Even Trade
Miami acquired Evan Boehm and 2020 7th round pick (227th overall subsequently traded, Lachavious Simmons) from Colts for 2020 6th round pick (197th overall subsequently traded, John Penisini). Josh Rosen failed to become Miami’s quarterback answer, making the second-round investment a major miss. The grade still accounts for era, role, uncertainty in conditional picks or cash terms, and whether the traded asset produced meaningful on-field value after the move
Indianapolis Colts Received
- pick 2020 6th round pick (197th overall subsequently traded, John Penisini )
Miami Dolphins Received
- pick Evan Boehm and 2020 7th round pick (227th overall subsequently traded, Lachavious Simmons )
Trade Analysis
Colts received 2020 6th round pick (197th overall subsequently traded, John Penisini) and gave up Evan Boehm and 2020 7th round pick (227th overall subsequently traded, Lachavious Simmons). From the partner side, this becomes A+ because Miami's revised outcome carries the opposite value judgment. The partner assessment mirrors the same second-pass logic: actual player utility, draft capital converted into real contributors, opportunity cost, and whether the trade created lasting roster value beyond the transaction itself