NFL Trade Verdict

Cleveland Browns Win

Baltimore Colts (franchise now Indianapolis Colts) acquired Harry Agganis; Dick Batten; Gern Nagler; Bert Rechichar; Ed Sharkey; Stu Sheetz; Don Shula; Art Spinney; Carl Taseff; Elmer Willhoite from Cleveland Browns for Tom Catlin; Don Colo; Herschel Forester / Herschel Forrester; Mike McCormack; John Petitbon. Cleveland Browns gets the edge because the Colts surrendered the stronger long-term asset or received limited return.

March 25, 1953 Cleveland Browns ↔ Indianapolis Colts Confidence: high Tier: standard

Cleveland Browns Received

player Tom Catlin
player Don Colo
player Herschel Forester / Herschel Forrester
player Mike McCormack
player John Petitbon

Indianapolis Colts Received

player Harry Agganis
player Dick Batten
player Gern Nagler
player Bert Rechichar
player Ed Sharkey
player Stu Sheetz
player Don Shula
player Art Spinney
player Carl Taseff
player Elmer Willhoite

Cleveland Browns

B+

Indianapolis Colts

C+

Trade Analysis

Cleveland Browns received Tom Catlin; Don Colo; Herschel Forester / Herschel Forrester; Mike McCormack; John Petitbon and gave up Harry Agganis; Dick Batten; Gern Nagler; Bert Rechichar; Ed Sharkey; Stu Sheetz; Don Shula; Art Spinney; Carl Taseff; Elmer Willhoite.