Oakland sent Cleveland a third-round pick for linebacker…
Oakland sent Cleveland a third-round pick for linebacker Kamerion Wimbley and immediately received two productive starting seasons. Wimbley recorded nine sacks in 2010 and seven more in 2011 before leaving after a contract dispute. Cleveland used the 85th pick on quarterback Colt McCoy, who started 21 games for the Browns and remained in the NFL for years. Oakland still gained the stronger peak value, but Cleveland's return deserves credit.
Cleveland Browns Received
- pick 2010 3rd round pick (85th overall, Colt McCoy)
Las Vegas Raiders Received
- player Kamerion Wimbley
Trade Analysis
Why Oakland Targeted Wimbley
The Raiders acquired Kamerion Wimbley from Cleveland in March 2010 for a third-round pick. Wimbley had already shown pass-rush ability after being selected in the first round in 2006, and Oakland saw a chance to add a proven edge presence without surrendering an early-round premium.
What Wimbley Gave the Raiders
Wimbley became an immediate starter and produced one of the best seasons of his career in 2010, recording nine sacks. He followed with seven sacks in 2011, giving Oakland 16 sacks across two seasons and dependable edge play. His Raiders tenure ended after two years amid contract considerations, which keeps the acquisition from receiving an elite grade, but the on-field return was substantial.
What Cleveland Received
The Browns used the 85th pick on Texas quarterback Colt McCoy. McCoy started eight games as a rookie and 13 more in 2011, finishing with 21 Cleveland starts. He never became the long-term franchise quarterback the Browns needed, but he remained in the NFL for many years as a reserve. That makes Cleveland's side considerably more useful than a typical failed third-round selection.
Why This Trade Still Matters
Both teams received legitimate NFL value. Cleveland converted a defender into a quarterback who started games and sustained a long professional career. Oakland obtained the stronger short-term player, especially because pass-rush production is difficult to find cheaply.
Final Verdict
Oakland Raiders Win. The Raiders earn a B+ for two starting seasons and 16 sacks from Wimbley. Cleveland receives a C+ because McCoy provided 21 starts and lasting league value, narrowing what otherwise might look like a one-sided trade.