The Giants acquired defensive lineman Leonard Williams from…
The Giants acquired defensive lineman Leonard Williams from the Jets at the 2019 deadline for a 2020 third-round pick and a conditional 2021 fifth-rounder that became the 154th selection. The Jets later used the picks on Ashtyn Davis and running back Michael Carter. The New York Giants produced the stronger realized return, supporting the New York Giants Win verdict.
New York Giants Received
- player Leonard Williams
New York Jets Received
- pick 2020 3rd round pick (68th overall, Ashtyn Davis)
- pick 2021 5th round pick (154th overall, Michael Carter)
Trade Analysis
What Changed Hands
The Giants acquired defensive lineman Leonard Williams from the Jets at the 2019 deadline for a 2020 third-round pick and a conditional 2021 fifth-rounder that became the 154th selection. The Jets later used the picks on Ashtyn Davis and running back Michael Carter.
Why the Value Moved
Williams initially arrived without a long-term contract, which made the price controversial, but his Giants tenure soon justified the football bet. He broke out with 11.5 sacks in 2020, earned a lucrative extension and remained a major defensive-line presence for several seasons. Davis and Carter both contributed for the Jets, yet neither became an equivalent foundational player.
How the Trade Aged
The Jets did obtain two legitimate NFL contributors from a player they were unlikely to retain, so this was not a zero-return sale. Davis saw regular defensive and special-teams work, while Carter produced useful rushing and receiving seasons. Still, New York's NFC club received the best player in the deal and several years of high-end performance, including a peak season far above what either draft return supplied.
Why This Trade Still Matters
Veteran trades near roster cutdowns or during a competitive window often look small when they are announced, yet the realized snaps, contract timing and follow-on value can create clear separation. The key is what the acquiring club actually received before the player moved on, not the reputation attached to the name on transaction day. That lens keeps this verdict tied to football value rather than headline size.
Final Verdict
The Giants win and earn an A-. The Jets receive a C+ for turning an expiring asset into two players who contributed, but Leonard Williams' sustained production and 2020 breakout created the clearest long-term value.