NFL Trade Verdict

Cleveland Browns received Lew Carpenter and 1958 fifth round…

Cleveland Browns received Lew Carpenter and 1958 fifth round pick (#61-Jim Gibbons) from Detroit Lions for Roger Zatkoff. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.

September 5, 1957 Cleveland Browns - Detroit Lions Record confidence: Medium

Cleveland Browns Received

  • player Lew Carpenter
  • pick 1958 fifth round pick (#61-Jim Gibbons)

Detroit Lions Received

  • player Roger Zatkoff

Cleveland Browns

C+

Detroit Lions

C+

Trade Analysis

Cleveland Browns received Lew Carpenter and 1958 fifth round pick (#61-Jim Gibbons), while Detroit Lions received Roger Zatkoff. The available outcome record supports the existing C+/C+ grades and Even Trade verdict.