NFL Trade Verdict

Carolina Panthers Win

Carolina moved up in the 2004 draft for Chris Gamble, while San Francisco received Rashaun Woods and Richard Seigler value. Gamble became the best long-term player in the exchange, giving Carolina the win.

April 24, 2004 Carolina Panthers - San Francisco 49ers Confidence: high Tier: major

Carolina Panthers Received

pick 2004 1st round pick (28th overall, Chris Gamble )

San Francisco 49ers Received

pick 2004 1st round pick (31st overall, Rashaun Woods )
pick 2004 4th round pick (127th overall, Richard Seigler )

Carolina Panthers

B+

San Francisco 49ers

C+

Trade Analysis

Gamble started 99 games, recorded 24 interceptions, and became a long-tenured Panthers defensive back. Woods and Seigler did not produce comparable value for San Francisco. Carolina received the clear best player in the trade.