NFL Trade Verdict

Carolina Panthers Win

Carolina Panthers received Perry Phenix. Tennessee Titans received 2002 7th round pick not exercised. The final review favors Carolina Panthers because that return produced stronger practical football value.

September 2, 2001 Carolina Panthers - Tennessee Titans Confidence: high Tier: minor

Carolina Panthers Received

Tennessee Titans Received

  • pick 2002 7th round pick not exercised

Carolina Panthers

B

Tennessee Titans

C

Trade Analysis

Carolina Panthers earns the stronger review after comparing actual player outcomes, draft-slot cost, roster usefulness, and retained value from the exchange. The final TradeVerdicts outcome is Carolina Panthers Win.