NFL Trade Verdict

Miami Dolphins Win

Miami acquired Pat McQuistan from Cowboys for a conditional 2010 pick (not conveyed). The available record indicates a conditional, voided, or low-impact transaction, so the fairest public grade is near even unless later evidence shows real value changed hands. This grade weighs both process and hindsight: the draft capital or player value Miami surrendered, the value it received, and whether the trade created durable roster impact rather than just short-term depth. Where records are incomplete, conditional, voided, or future-dated, the grade is intentionally conservative

September 4, 2010 Dallas CowboysMiami Dolphins Confidence: medium Tier: minor

Dallas Cowboys Received

Trade Analysis

Cowboys received a conditional 2010 pick (not conveyed) and gave up Pat McQuistan. Miami Dolphins receives the edge because the recorded return carries stronger long-term football value than the package credited to Dallas Cowboys.