NFL Trade Verdict

Even Trade

Pittsburgh acquired the rights to Pat McCarty and Lou Midler from Green Bay for Buckets Goldenberg and Swede Johnston. The known record does not show a meaningful long-term value gap, so this is best treated as an even historical exchange.

July 20, 1938 Green Bay Packers - Pittsburgh Steelers Confidence: high Tier: standard

Green Bay Packers Received

player Charles Goldenberg / Buckets Goldenberg
player Chester Johnston / Swede Johnston

Pittsburgh Steelers Received

other rights to Pat McCarty
other rights to Lou Midler / Lew Midler

Green Bay Packers

Pittsburgh Steelers

Trade Analysis

The available information points to a low-certainty, balanced pre-modern transaction. Neither side has a clearly superior realized outcome in the current record, so Even Trade is the fairest verdict.