NFL Trade Verdict

Washington Redskins/Commanders Win

Washington acquired Sam Huff from the New York Giants for Dick James. Huff gave Washington a major defensive name and immediate veteran value, making Washington the hindsight winner.

January 1, 1964 New York Giants ↔ Washington Commanders Confidence: medium Tier: minor

New York Giants Received

player Dick James
player Andy Stynchula
pick 1965 fifth round pick (probably #62- Frank Lambert )

Washington Commanders Received

player Sam Huff
player George Seals

New York Giants

C-

Washington Commanders

B+

Trade Analysis

The Giants received Dick James, but Washington landed the more durable star value in Sam Huff. The partner side grades down because the premium name and impact moved to Washington.