NFL Trade Verdict

Even Trade

New York acquired undisclosed consideration; Dorne Dibble from Detroit Lions for undisclosed consideration; 1959 draft pick (undisclosed pick).

March 19, 1958 Detroit Lions ↔ New York Giants Confidence: medium Tier: minor

Detroit Lions Received

player undisclosed consideration
pick 1959 draft pick (?-?)
pick 1959 fourth round pick (#46- Bob Grottkau )

New York Giants Received

player undisclosed consideration
player Dorne Dibble
player Carl Karilivacz

Trade Analysis

Detroit Lions received undisclosed consideration; 1959 draft pick (undisclosed pick) and gave up undisclosed consideration; Dorne Dibble. The trade is judged based on long-term player value, draft return, and historical certainty.