NFL Trade Verdict

Green Bay Packers Win

New York acquired undisclosed consideration; Bill Quinlan / Billy Quinlan; John Symank from Green Bay Packers for undisclosed consideration; 1964 third round pick (#40-Joe O'Donnell (a)). The standard designation reflects the available asset quality, career impact, and certainty of the historical record.

April 25, 1963 Green Bay Packers ↔ New York Giants Confidence: high Tier: standard

Green Bay Packers Received

player undisclosed consideration
pick 1964 third round pick (#40- Joe O'Donnell (a ))

New York Giants Received

player undisclosed consideration
player Bill Quinlan / Billy Quinlan
player John Symank

Green Bay Packers

New York Giants

C+

Trade Analysis

Green Bay Packers received undisclosed consideration; 1964 third round pick (#40-Joe O'Donnell (a)) and gave up undisclosed consideration; Bill Quinlan / Billy Quinlan; John Symank. The trade is judged based on long-term player value, draft return, and historical certainty.