NFL Trade Verdict

New York acquired running back Allen Jacobs from Green Bay on…

New York acquired running back Allen Jacobs from Green Bay on September 6, 1966 for the Giants' 1967 seventh-round draft choice. Jacobs appeared in all 14 games for New York that season and carried 77 times for 273 yards and one touchdown while catching 10 passes for 69 yards. He added six games in 1967, giving the Giants 20 regular-season appearances and useful backfield depth for a seventh-round price.

Green Bay Packers Received

  • pick 1967 seventh round pick (#161-Bob Ziolkowski)

Trade Analysis

The trade chain is directly documented. Green Bay transaction history records that the Packers traded running back Allen Jacobs to the New York Giants on September 6, 1966 for a 1967 seventh-round choice. Pro Sports Transactions traces that selection to No. 161 overall, where Green Bay drafted Iowa tackle Bob Ziolkowski. The Packers' own 1967 media guide independently lists Ziolkowski as a seventh-round selection made with a choice from New York. The legacy row's extra undisclosed-consideration placeholders are unsupported and should be removed; the defensible exchange is Jacobs for the Giants' 1967 seventh-round pick.

Jacobs gave New York immediate offensive depth. NFL records show him appearing in all 14 Giants games in 1966, carrying 77 times for 273 yards and one touchdown while catching 10 passes for 69 yards. He was not credited with a start, but he received enough backfield work to be a real part of the offense rather than a roster-only acquisition. Jacobs returned for six games in 1967, adding 11 carries for 23 yards. Across his Giants tenure he therefore played 20 regular-season games and produced 296 rushing yards, one rushing touchdown and 69 receiving yards.

Green Bay's return was a legitimate future draft asset. The 1967 common draft ledger shows the Giants' seventh-round choice as No. 161, and the Packers selected Ziolkowski, a 6-foot-5, 270-pound tackle from Iowa. Green Bay's contemporary media guide explicitly marks the pick as coming from New York, matching the transaction ledger. The choice therefore should be recorded precisely rather than as generic or undisclosed compensation.

The selected player did not create regular-season NFL value. Pro Football Reference's Green Bay draft history lists Ziolkowski at No. 161 without an NFL games or starts line, and the Packers' 1967 draft class records show no regular-season career for him. That does not mean the trade was unreasonable when made; Green Bay moved a lightly used back for a future selection and took a developmental tackle. In hindsight, however, the pick did not produce game-day return.

New York owns the stronger realized outcome. A seventh-round selection bought the Giants 20 appearances and one season of meaningful reserve rushing work from Jacobs, while Green Bay's resulting pick never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. A B- for New York and D+ for Green Bay reflects useful low-cost production on the Giants' side without overstating Jacobs as a long-term starter.

Sources