Green Bay Packers received Randy Dean in the deal with New…

The Exchange

On 1980-08-04, Green Bay acquired quarterback Randy Dean from the Giants for a 1981 sixth-round pick. The result is best measured through the service each club actually received afterward, including games, starts, production and draft value that can be connected directly to the exchanged assets. That approach keeps a smaller transaction proportional to what it ultimately produced. Green Bay Packers Return Dean was released later in August 1980 and never appeared in a Packers regular-season game. Green Bay received no direct game value from the acquisition. The F grade reflects that outcome against the price Green Bay Packers surrendered. Longer tenure, starting work and productive downstream draft use raise the return, while brief service or little direct contribution keeps the grade lower. New York Giants Return New York used the sixth-round selection on Mel Hoover, who went on to play 32 NFL games with 16 receptions, 364 yards and two touchdowns. The pick produced the only meaningful football contribution. The B grade applies the same standard to New York Giants. The focus stays on value tied to this transaction rather than later accomplishments that cannot be connected confidently to the assets exchanged here. Value in Hindsight Green Bay received no regular-season service, while the Giants' sixth-round selection became an NFL contributor. The return was not star-level, but the contrast is clear enough to make New York the decisive winner. The comparison remains centered on duration, starts, production and useful draft outcomes. A modest trade does not need a dramatic grade spread unless the documented returns clearly moved in opposite directions. Final Verdict The final call is New York Giants Win. Green Bay Packers receives F, and New York Giants receives B. The decision follows the contribution each side received and the downstream value that remained connected to the original package. Those grades keep the result grounded in realized football value and appropriately scaled to the size of the deal.