NFL Trade Verdict

New York Giants Win

New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and George Shaw from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, 1960 second round pick (#24-Marvin Terrel) and 1961 first round pick (probably #11-Bill Kilmer / Billy Kilmer. The recorded outcome favors New York Giants.

July 30, 1959 Indianapolis Colts - New York Giants Confidence: high Tier: major

Indianapolis Colts Received

player undisclosed consideration
pick 1960 second round pick (#24-Marvin Terrel)
pick 1961 first round pick (probably #11- Bill Kilmer / Billy Kilmer

New York Giants Received

player undisclosed consideration
player George Shaw

Indianapolis Colts

C+

New York Giants

Trade Analysis

New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and George Shaw, while Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received undisclosed consideration, 1960 second round pick (#24-Marvin Terrel) and 1961 first round pick (probably #11-Bill Kilmer / Billy Kilmer. The recorded results support the existing B/C+ grades and New York Giants Win verdict.