NFL Trade Verdict
New York Giants Win
New York acquired Charlie Conerly / Charley Conerly / Chuck Conerly from Washington for Howie Livingston and undisclosed consideration. Conerly became a major franchise quarterback for the Giants, making New York the clear hindsight winner.
New York Giants Received
Washington Commanders Received
- player undisclosed consideration
- player Howie Livingston
Trade Analysis
New York acquired undisclosed consideration; Charlie Conerly / Charley Conerly / Chuck Conerly from Washington Redskins/Commanders for undisclosed consideration; Howie Livingston. Washington Redskins/Commanders received undisclosed consideration; Howie Livingston and gave up undisclosed consideration; Charlie Conerly / Charley Conerly / Chuck Conerly. The trade is judged based on long-term player value, draft return, and historical certainty.