San Diego traded linebacker Thomas Benson to New England for…
San Diego traded linebacker Thomas Benson to New England for a 1989 seventh-round pick, then used No. 183 on running back Marion Butts. Benson appeared in 12 games for the Patriots in 1988, but Butts became a two-time Pro Bowler and rushed for 5,185 career yards, including 1,225 in 1990. Turning a departing veteran into a multiyear featured back made this an outstanding piece of late-round value for the Chargers.
Los Angeles Chargers Received
- pick 1989 7th round pick (183rd overall, Marion Butts )
New England Patriots Received
- player Thomas Benson
Trade Analysis
The Exchange
San Diego sent linebacker Thomas Benson to New England in August 1988. The Patriots gave the Chargers a 1989 seventh-round pick, No. 183. San Diego used that selection on Florida State running back Marion Butts, turning a veteran defensive player into one of the best late-round returns in this portion of the trade history.
San Diego Chargers Return
Butts immediately became a major part of the offense. He rushed for 683 yards and nine touchdowns as a rookie, then exploded for 1,225 yards in 1990. He earned Pro Bowl honors in both 1990 and 1991 and remained San Diego's leading rushing presence for several seasons. His power-running style gave the Chargers a dependable featured option from a pick that normally carries very low expectations.
New England Patriots Return
Benson was an established linebacker with starting experience in San Diego. In New England, however, he appeared in 12 games in 1988 without becoming a long-term fixture. He moved on after that season and later returned to a larger role with the Raiders. The Patriots received immediate veteran depth, but only for a short window.
Value in Hindsight
The price and payoff are what make the deal lopsided. Seventh-round picks rarely become two-time Pro Bowl starters, and San Diego did not need years of development before receiving value. Butts produced from his rookie season onward and eventually finished with 5,185 career rushing yards. Benson was a legitimate NFL player, so New England's decision was not irrational, but the opportunity cost became substantial.
Final Verdict
San Diego earns an A and New England a C-. The Patriots got one season from a useful veteran. The Chargers turned the corresponding late pick into a multiyear featured back and two-time Pro Bowler. That is a decisive San Diego victory.