Player Trade Profile
Earl Morrall
Explore every recorded NFL trade involving Earl Morrall,
including the assets exchanged, team grades, final verdicts,
and TradeVerdicts analysis.
Trade Impact Summary
The TradeVerdicts database links Earl Morrall to 4 public trade records involving Indianapolis Colts, New York Giants, Detroit Lions, Pittsburgh Steelers, and San Francisco 49ers.
Each record below shows what the teams received, how each side
was graded, and the analysis behind the verdict. Grades and
verdicts follow the
TradeVerdicts methodology
.
Transaction Record
Related Trades
4 records Indianapolis Colts Win
Tier: major
Confidence: medium
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Earl Morrall from New York Giants for "high draft choice" (not exercised) (replaced by George Wilson / Butch Wilson on 09-02). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Assets Received
- Pick "high draft choice" (not exercised) (replaced by George Wilson / Butch Wilson on 09-02)
Trade Analysis
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Earl Morrall, while New York Giants received "high draft choice" (not exercised) (replaced by George Wilson / Butch Wilson on 09-02). The recorded results support the existing A/D grades and Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration, Charlie Johnson, Barry Brown and "high draft choice" (not exercised) (replaced by George Wilson / Butch Wilson on 09-02) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record), Henry Carr and Earl Morrall. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Assets Received
- Player undisclosed consideration
- Player Charlie Johnson
- Player Barry Brown
- Pick "high draft choice" (not exercised) (replaced by George Wilson / Butch Wilson on 09-02)
- Player undisclosed consideration
- Player undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record)
- Player Henry Carr
- Player Earl Morrall
Trade Analysis
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received undisclosed consideration, undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record), Henry Carr and Earl Morrall, while New York Giants received undisclosed consideration, Charlie Johnson, Barry Brown and "high draft choice" (not exercised) (replaced by George Wilson / Butch Wilson on 09-02). The recorded results support the existing C+/C grades and Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Pittsburgh Steelers Win
Tier: landmark
Confidence: high
Pittsburgh acquired Hall of Fame quarterback Bobby Layne from Detroit for Earl Morrall, a 1959 second-round pick, and a 1960 fourth-round pick. Layne gave the Steelers credibility, production, and a different competitive identity in the late 1950s and early 1960s. Detroit did receive value, including Roger Brown, but the Lions moved a franchise icon and watched Pittsburgh get the player who defined the trade's legacy.
Assets Received
- Player Earl Morrall
- Pick 1959 second round pick (#19-Mike Rabold)
- Pick 1960 fourth round pick (#42-Roger Brown)
Trade Analysis
Why the Steelers Made the Trade
Pittsburgh made this move because Bobby Layne gave the franchise something it badly needed: credibility at quarterback. The Steelers were not acquiring a random veteran passer. They were acquiring a proven championship-era quarterback with a Hall of Fame resume and enough left to change expectations.
That mattered because Pittsburgh had spent decades without sustained NFL relevance. Layne was not the long-term quarterback of the 1970s dynasty, but he helped pull the franchise toward respectability. For a team trying to escape the bottom tier, that kind of identity shift had real value.
What Detroit Actually Received
Detroit received Earl Morrall, a 1959 second-round pick that became Mike Rabold, and a 1960 fourth-round pick that became Roger Brown. That return was not worthless. Brown became a standout defensive tackle, and Morrall later had a meaningful career elsewhere.
That is why Detroit does not deserve a zero-value reading. The Lions did get pieces. The issue is that they moved Bobby Layne, a franchise icon and Hall of Fame quarterback, after his championship years. Even with Brown's success, Detroit surrendered the player who gave the trade its historical force.
Why the Trade Still Favors Pittsburgh
The trade still favors Pittsburgh because Layne gave the Steelers the best player and the clearest identity value. He made Pro Bowls with the franchise and helped Pittsburgh become more competitive than it had been.
Detroit's return softens the loss, but it does not erase it. Brown's development keeps the Lions from an F, but the broader story is still Pittsburgh acquiring a famous quarterback who mattered to the franchise's pre-dynasty history.
The Franchise Identity Factor
This trade is not only about box-score value. Pittsburgh needed legitimacy, and Layne supplied it. For a franchise with little winning tradition at the time, that mattered more than it would for a team already used to success.
Layne's arrival did not create the Steel Curtain, but it helped change how the Steelers were viewed. He became part of the bridge from old Pittsburgh futility toward a more serious football identity.
The Long-Term Legacy
Detroit's side is complicated by Roger Brown. If Brown had done nothing, the verdict would be harsher. Because he became a strong player, the Lions at least recovered meaningful value from the trade.
Still, the historical memory belongs to Pittsburgh. Layne is remembered as the star moved in the deal, and the Steelers got the more memorable side of the exchange.
Why This Trade Still Matters
This trade still matters because it is one of the most famous old-era quarterback moves in NFL history. The Bobby Layne name still carries weight, and the trade remains part of both Lions and Steelers lore.
It also belongs in the GSC priority group because Layne's move to Pittsburgh is a lasting search topic. It connects Hall of Fame quarterback movement, franchise identity, and one of the league's most repeated historical trade stories.
Final Verdict
This should stay as a Pittsburgh win, but not an A+ blowout because Detroit did get Roger Brown. Pittsburgh won the player and legacy arguments. Steelers grade: A-. Lions grade: D.
View the full trade verdict
→ San Francisco 49ers Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Pittsburgh Steelers received Earl Morrall and Mike Sandusky from San Francisco 49ers for Marv Matuszak, 1958 first round pick (#8-Jim Pace), and 1959 first round pick (#8-Dan James). The recorded outcome favors San Francisco 49ers.
Assets Received
- Player Earl Morrall
- Player Mike Sandusky
- Player Marv Matuszak
- Pick 1958 first round pick (#8-Jim Pace)
- Pick 1959 first round pick (#8-Dan James)
Trade Analysis
San Francisco 49ers received Marv Matuszak, 1958 first round pick (#8-Jim Pace), and 1959 first round pick (#8-Dan James), while Pittsburgh Steelers received Earl Morrall and Mike Sandusky. The recorded outcomes support the existing B+/D grades and San Francisco 49ers Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ 