Indianapolis Colts
Trade grades, verdicts, asset movement, and historical context for Indianapolis Colts franchise trades.
Browse Trades by Era
Choose a decade to view the complete public trade record.
Select an era above.
The selected Indianapolis Colts public trade archive will appear here.
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis acquired center Sedrick Van Pran-Granger and a 2027 seventh-round pick from Buffalo on August 30, 2026 for a 2027 sixth-round selection. The 24-year-old center already has 31 NFL appearances and two starts, so the Colts gain experienced interior depth by moving down one late round. Buffalo still receives useful value for surplus depth, but Indianapolis gets the stronger current grade.
Pittsburgh moved from No. 53 to No. 47 in the 2026 second round and selected receiver Germie Bernard, also receiving pick No. 249. Indianapolis received Nos. 53, 135 and 237, using them on CJ Allen, Bryce Boettcher and Seth McGowan. The Steelers paid two later selections to secure their preferred receiver, while the Colts added volume without leaving the second round; that balance supports an Even Trade and C grades.
Indianapolis Colts acquired 2026 6th round pick (214th overall, Caden Curry) from Pittsburgh Steelers for Michael Pittman and 2026 7th round pick (230th overall, Eli Heidenreich). The overall result favors Pittsburgh Steelers over Indianapolis Colts.
Green Bay acquired veteran linebacker Zaire Franklin from Indianapolis in a straight player-for-player exchange for defensive lineman Colby Wooden. Franklin arrived with 132 games, 82 starts, a 2024 second-team All-Pro selection, and a Pro Bowl appearance, giving the Packers a proven middle-of-the-defense option. Wooden is younger and had become a starter, so the long-term result remains open, but Green Bay received the stronger established résumé at the time of the trade.
Indianapolis Colts acquired Sauce Gardner from New York Jets for Adonai Mitchell, 2026 1st round pick (16th overall, Kenyon Sadiq) and a 2027 1st round pick. Indianapolis Colts received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
Indianapolis acquired Mekhi Blackmon from Minnesota for a 2026 sixth-round pick shortly before roster cuts, betting on a corner returning from a torn ACL. Blackmon responded by playing all 17 games, starting 11 and recording 64 tackles, seven passes defensed, two interceptions and a sack. Minnesota moved the sixth-rounder again, leaving the Colts with the clearly stronger direct football return.
Philadelphia moved from No. 155 to No. 164 in the 2024 fifth round and sent Indianapolis an additional sixth-round pick, then selected linebacker Jeremiah Trotter Jr. The Colts used their two choices on Jaylin Simpson and Micah Abraham. Trotter has appeared in every regular-season game through two years and contributed on defense and special teams, giving Philadelphia the clearest realized value.
Carolina moved from No. 52 to No. 46 for Jonathon Brooks, sending Indianapolis two additional fifth-round picks at Nos. 142 and 155. Brooks entered the league recovering from an ACL tear and then tore the same ACL again in his third NFL game, sharply limiting the early return. The Colts collected three selections for six spots of movement, giving Indianapolis the stronger realized value so far.
Indianapolis moved up three spots in the 2024 third round for tackle Matt Goncalves, sending Arizona the selections used on tight end Tip Reiman and receiver Tejhaun Palmer. Goncalves appeared in every game as a rookie and started seven times across both tackle spots. Arizona received two players from one pick, but Indianapolis has realized the stronger early value from the deal's most important selection.
Minnesota acquired 2023 5th round pick (141st overall, Jaquelin Roy) from Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts for 2023 5th round pick (158th overall, Daniel Scott) and 2023 6th round pick (211th overall, Titus Leo). The deal grades as balanced. Neither side clearly separated after weighing player value, draft capital, roster impact, and what each team gave up.
Atlanta moved up six spots for Matthew Bergeron, who became an immediate fixture at left guard and started 49 games over his first three seasons. Indianapolis turned the move down into Julius Brents and Adetomiwa Adebawore; Adebawore developed into a useful rotational defender, but Brents' Colts tenure was limited by injuries. Bergeron's steady starting value gives Atlanta the clearer return.
Las Vegas sent picks 38 and 141 to Indianapolis to move three spots for tight end Michael Mayer. Mayer has started 32 games and produced 83 catches for 788 yards and three touchdowns through three seasons, useful production but below the expectations attached to the move. Indianapolis immediately traded No. 38 again and later moved No. 141, multiplying its draft capital. The Colts’ flexibility and Mayer’s modest output give Indianapolis the better side.
Dallas acquired veteran cornerback Stephon Gilmore from Indianapolis for a 2023 fifth-round pick that became running back Evan Hull. Gilmore immediately started all 17 regular-season games for a 12-win Cowboys team, intercepted two passes and strengthened a secondary that needed veteran stability. Indianapolis received little lasting production from Hull, making the one-year Gilmore rental easily worth the modest price.
Buffalo Bills acquired Nyheim Hines from Indianapolis Colts for Zack Moss and 2023 5th round pick (162nd overall, Will Mallory). The overall result favors Indianapolis Colts over Buffalo Bills.
Indianapolis acquired linebacker Grant Stuard and a 2023 seventh-round pick from Tampa Bay for a 2023 sixth-rounder. The Buccaneers used the sixth on defensive back Josh Hayes, while the Colts' seventh became Jake Witt. Stuard developed into a valuable special-teams player who also handled defensive starts, and Hayes supplied Tampa Bay with special-teams and secondary depth. Both clubs turned late-round value into useful roster pieces.
Indianapolis sent pick No. 179 and a 2023 third-rounder to Denver to move back into the 2022 third round for safety Nick Cross at No. 96. Cross grew from a young special-teams contributor into a productive starting safety, giving the Colts a durable defensive payoff. Denver later used the future third on Drew Sanders, but his early return did not match Cross's established role in Indianapolis.
Minnesota Vikings acquired 2022 2nd round pick (42nd overall, Andrew Booth) and 2022 4th round pick (122nd overall subsequently traded, Zamir White) from Indianapolis Colts for 2022 2nd round pick (53rd overall, Alec Pierce), 2022 3rd round pick (77th overall, Bernhard Raimann) and 2022 6th round pick (192nd overall, Andrew Ogletree). The stronger recorded return sits with Indianapolis Colts, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
Atlanta traded longtime quarterback Matt Ryan to Indianapolis for pick No. 82 in 2022, ending a 14-year era and beginning a roster reset. The Falcons used the pick on DeAngelo Malone, who became primarily a rotational defender and special-teams contributor. Ryan started 12 games for the Colts, throwing for 3,057 yards, 14 touchdowns and 13 interceptions before being released after one season. Atlanta won because Indianapolis received no lasting quarterback solution.
Las Vegas Raiders acquired Rock Ya-Sin from Indianapolis Colts for Yannick Ngakoue. Las Vegas Raiders received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Las Vegas Raiders Win verdict.
Indianapolis Colts acquired 2022 2nd round pick (42nd overall subsequently traded, Andrew Booth), 2022 3rd round pick (73rd overall, Jelani Woods) and 2023 3rd round pick (79th overall, Josh Downs) from Washington Commanders for Carson Wentz, 2022 2nd round pick (47th overall, Phidarian Mathis) and 2022 7th round pick (240th overall, Christian Holmes). Indianapolis Colts received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
Indianapolis acquired offensive lineman Matt Pryor and a 2022 seventh-round pick from Philadelphia for a 2022 sixth-round pick. Pryor immediately supplied useful, inexpensive depth, appearing in all 17 games with five starts in 2021 before earning another Colts contract. Philadelphia recovered a modest draft asset, but Indianapolis received the more substantial on-field return from a small late-round pick downgrade.
Indianapolis Colts acquired 2021 6th round pick (218th overall, Sam Ehlinger) and 2021 7th round pick (229th overall, Mike Strachan) from New Orleans Saints for 2021 6th round pick (206th overall, Landon Young). Indianapolis Colts received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
The Carson Wentz trade became a costly one-year quarterback swing for Indianapolis. The Colts sent a third-round pick and a conditional first-round pick to Philadelphia, hoping Wentz could stabilize a playoff-ready roster. Instead, the season ended with a collapse, Wentz was gone after one year, and the Eagles escaped a bad contract while gaining premium draft value. It remains a priority indexing page because the Wentz-Colts experiment is still a clean modern quarterback-trade search.
Indianapolis traded the 182nd pick to New England for selections 212 and 213, using them on Dezmon Patmon and Jordan Glasgow. The Patriots selected Michael Onwenu at No. 182. Patmon and Glasgow filled limited roles, while Onwenu became one of New England's best offensive linemen, starting at guard and tackle and eventually earning a multi-year contract to remain with the Patriots. New England won decisively.
New York Jets acquired Quincy Wilson from Indianapolis Colts for 2020 6th round pick (211th overall, Isaiah Rodgers). The overall result favors Indianapolis Colts/Baltimore Colts over New York Jets.
Indianapolis sent picks 44 and 160 to Cleveland to move up three spots for Jonathan Taylor. Taylor has become one of the defining running backs of his era, totaling 7,598 rushing yards and 69 rushing touchdowns through 2025, with a unanimous first-team All-Pro season and NFL rushing title in 2021. Cleveland landed long-term starting safety Grant Delpit and reserve lineman Nick Harris, giving the Browns a strong return but not enough to match Taylor.
Indianapolis moved down from No. 75 to No. 85 and received picks No. 149 and No. 182, selecting Julian Blackmon and Danny Pinter before later trading No. 182. Detroit used No. 75 on Jonah Jackson and No. 197 on John Penisini. Jackson became a Pro Bowl guard, while Blackmon developed into a multi-year starting safety. Both teams converted the swap into substantial starting value.
Indianapolis sent the 13th pick in the 2020 draft to San Francisco for DeForest Buckner and immediately signed him long term. Buckner became a first-team All-Pro in his first Colts season, added Pro Bowl selections and recorded 43 sacks for Indianapolis through 2025. San Francisco moved from No. 13 to No. 14 for Javon Kinlaw and gained another pick used in later movement. Kinlaw never approached Buckner's impact, making this a clear Colts win.
Indianapolis Colts
Miami acquired interior lineman Evan Boehm and a 2020 seventh-round pick from Indianapolis for a 2020 sixth-round pick just before the 2019 season. The Colts later moved the sixth-round selection, while Miami added an experienced center-guard to a rebuilding offensive line. The Miami Dolphins produced the stronger realized return, supporting the Miami Dolphins Win verdict.
Indianapolis sent cornerback Nate Hairston to New York for a conditional 2020 sixth-round pick. The condition was not satisfied, so the draft choice was never conveyed and the Colts ultimately received no draft asset from the transaction. The New York Jets produced the stronger realized return, supporting the New York Jets Win verdict.
Indianapolis Colts traded Hassan Ridgeway to Philadelphia for 2019 seventh-round pick Javon Patterson. Hindsight favors Philadelphia a slight edge. Ridgeway became usable defensive-line depth, while the pick gave Indianapolis minimal return.
Indianapolis sent picks No. 129 and No. 135 to Oakland to move up for safety Khari Willis at No. 109. Willis started regularly for three seasons and gave the Colts solid defensive value before retiring in 2022. Oakland's two picks ultimately produced Isaiah Johnson plus the trade capital that became Foster Moreau and Quinton Bell, keeping the overall return competitive.
Indianapolis traded the 26th pick in 2019 to Washington for No. 46 and a 2020 second-rounder. The Colts then moved No. 46 again, turning it into Ben Banogu and Marvell Tell, while the future choice became Michael Pittman Jr. Pittman developed into a long-term starting receiver and multiple-time 1,000-yard producer, giving Indianapolis the strongest piece of its eventual return despite Montez Sweat’s success in Washington.
Indianapolis acquired wide receiver Marcus Johnson from Seattle in exchange for tight end Darrell Daniels at the 2018 roster deadline. Johnson grew into useful receiver depth for the Colts, including 277 receiving yards and two touchdowns in 2019 and another 255 yards in 2020. Daniels gave Seattle only a brief role before moving on, so Indianapolis realized the stronger return.
Green Bay acquired linebacker Antonio Morrison from Indianapolis for cornerback Lenzy Pipkins just before the 2018 season. Morrison played all 16 games for the Packers, recorded 47 tackles and added a sack, giving Green Bay immediate defensive and special-teams utility. Pipkins did not establish a comparable Colts role, so the Packers received the more meaningful original-team return from the straight player swap.
Indianapolis sent defensive lineman Henry Anderson to the Jets for pick No. 235, then used that seventh-round selection on linebacker Zaire Franklin. Anderson immediately produced seven sacks in New York and earned a multi-year extension, so the Jets received legitimate value. Franklin nevertheless became the superior long-term asset, growing from special-teams contributor into Colts captain, tackle leader and 2024 second-team All-Pro linebacker.
Las Vegas Raiders acquired 2018 5th round pick (140th overall, Maurice Hurst) from Indianapolis Colts for 2018 5th round pick (159th overall, Daurice Fountain) and 2018 6th round pick (185th overall, Deon Cain). The overall result favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts over Las Vegas Raiders.
Cleveland Browns acquired 2018 3rd round pick (67th overall, Chad Thomas) and 2018 6th round pick (178th overall subsequently traded, Christian Sam) from Indianapolis Colts for 2018 2nd round pick (64th overall, Tyquan Lewis). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Philadelphia sent picks No. 52 and No. 169 to Indianapolis to move up three spots to No. 49 and select tight end Dallas Goedert. Philadelphia used No. 49 on Dallas Goedert, who developed into a long-term starting tight end and major postseason contributor. Indianapolis received Kemoko Turay and Jordan Wilkins; both supplied useful stretches, but neither approached Goedert's sustained impact. The Eagles paid a fifth-round pick to move only three spots, and the player they targeted justified the premium.
Indianapolis turned the third pick in the 2018 draft into a four-pick package that became Quenton Nelson, Braden Smith, additional 2018 draft capital and the 2019 selection used on Rock Ya-Sin. Nelson became one of the league’s defining guards and Smith a long-term starting tackle. New York used No. 3 on Sam Darnold, whose Jets tenure lasted three seasons before he was traded to Carolina.
Indianapolis and New England swapped former high draft picks at roster cuts in 2017, with Jacoby Brissett going to the Colts and Phillip Dorsett to the Patriots. Brissett became Indianapolis' emergency starter almost immediately and ultimately made 30 starts across four seasons. Dorsett contributed as a rotational receiver for three New England seasons and earned a Super Bowl LIII ring, but Brissett delivered the larger team-specific role.
Indianapolis chose Luke Rhodes as its long snapper and dealt Thomas Hennessy to New York for safety Ronald Martin. Martin was waived at final cuts, later returned to the Colts' practice squad and never became a meaningful Indianapolis regular. Hennessy, by contrast, won the Jets' snapping job and remained a fixture for years, turning a fringe-roster exchange into a quietly excellent New York acquisition.
The exchange of 2017 4th round pick (121st overall, Joe Williams) for 2017 4th round pick (143rd overall, Marlon Mack) and 2017 5th round pick (161st overall, Anthony Walker) stayed close enough in realized value to remain a true even verdict
New England acquired tight end Dwayne Allen and pick No. 200 from Indianapolis for the 137th pick in the 2017 draft. Allen spent two seasons with the Patriots, appearing in 29 regular-season games and serving primarily as a blocking tight end on teams that reached consecutive Super Bowls and won Super Bowl LIII. Indianapolis selected Zach Banner at No. 137 but waived him before he played a regular-season game for the Colts.
Green Bay sent Nos. 57, 125 and 248 to Indianapolis to move up nine spots for tackle Jason Spriggs at No. 48. Spriggs made nine starts in three Packers seasons. The Colts selected T.J. Green, Antonio Morrison and Austin Blythe; Green and Morrison contributed starts, while Blythe's best NFL work came after Indianapolis waived him. Neither club found the lasting impact needed to claim a clear win.
Indianapolis Colts and Las Vegas Raiders land in even-trade territory. The final grade profile (Indianapolis Colts C, Las Vegas Raiders C) shows useful value on both sides without enough separation for a clear winner.
The exchange of 2015 5th round pick (165th overall, Bradley Pinion) and 2015 7th round pick (244th overall, Trent Brown) for 2015 5th round pick (151st overall, David Parry) stayed close enough in realized value to remain a true even verdict
Tampa Bay moved from No. 65 to No. 61 and swapped fourth-round positions with Indianapolis to secure guard Ali Marpet. Marpet started all 101 games he played for the Buccaneers, became a Pro Bowler and helped anchor the offensive line for the Super Bowl LV champions. Indianapolis drafted D'Joun Smith and Clayton Geathers; Geathers became a useful safety, but Smith barely played. Tampa Bay landed the franchise-level player.
Seattle sent Indianapolis a 2015 sixth-round pick for cornerback Marcus Burley and received two seasons of useful secondary depth. Burley appeared in 26 regular-season games for the Seahawks and intercepted two passes. The Colts ultimately used the acquired selection at No. 207 on linebacker Amarlo Herrera, who appeared in only three NFL games. Seattle extracted the clearer on-field value from the modest exchange.
The Trent Richardson trade became a textbook sell-high win for Cleveland. The Browns moved a former No. 3 overall running back to Indianapolis for a first-round pick before Richardson's value fully collapsed. The Colts were chasing immediate help for Andrew Luck, but Richardson struggled badly and never justified the premium cost. It remains a priority indexing page because Richardson's collapse is one of the clearest modern running-back trade lessons.
Dallas Cowboys acquired Caesar Rayford from Indianapolis Colts for 2015 7th round pick (244th overall subsequently traded, Trent Brown). The overall result favors Indianapolis Colts over Dallas Cowboys.
Indianapolis and Baltimore exchanged two players on the edge of their respective rosters in August 2013: the Colts received receiver and returner David Reed, while the Ravens acquired running back Delone Carter. Neither side produced lasting value. Baltimore waived Carter before the regular season, and Indianapolis waived Reed in November after a limited special-teams role. With no draft capital involved and little meaningful production, an even grade fits.
Indianapolis traded center A.Q. Shipley to Baltimore for a conditional 2014 seventh-round pick that became No. 232, used on tackle Ulrick John. Shipley appeared in all 16 games for the Ravens in 2013 and started the final nine before being waived the next summer. John spent his rookie year on injured reserve and never played a regular-season snap for Indianapolis, leaving Baltimore with the better realized return.
Cleveland Browns acquired 2014 4th round pick (127th overall, Pierre Desir) from Indianapolis Colts for 2013 5th round pick (139th overall, Montori Hughes). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Indianapolis and Philadelphia made a straight player-for-player swap in March 2013, with fullback Stanley Havili going to the Colts and defensive lineman Clifton Geathers joining the Eagles. Each filled a one-season role. Havili appeared in 13 games with eight starts and added 128 receiving yards for Indianapolis, while Geathers played all 16 games as a reserve for Philadelphia. Neither became a long-term piece, making the exchange essentially even.
Indianapolis acquired cornerback Vontae Davis from Miami for a 2013 second-round pick, with a conditional late-round selection included in the terms but ultimately not conveyed. Davis became a centerpiece of the Colts secondary and earned consecutive Pro Bowl selections in 2014 and 2015. Miami used the second-rounder on Jamar Taylor, who never matched Davis's impact for the Dolphins. Indianapolis received the premium player and clearly won the exchange.
Los Angeles Rams acquired 2014 7th round pick (241st overall, C.B. Bryant) from Indianapolis Colts for Josh Gordy. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Indianapolis acquired linebackers Moise Fokou and Greg Lloyd from Philadelphia for cornerback Kevin Thomas and a conditional 2013 seventh-round pick that was not conveyed. Fokou became the only side of the exchange to provide meaningful regular-season value for his new club, appearing throughout the Colts' 2012 season. Thomas was waived by Philadelphia before the regular season, and the conditional pick never materialized.
Indianapolis and Philadelphia swapped fringe defensive prospects at the start of 2012 training camp, with cornerback D.J. Johnson going to the Colts and defensive tackle Ollie Ogbu going to the Eagles. Johnson was waived by Indianapolis before the regular season and moved to the practice squad. Ogbu was released by Philadelphia at final cuts. Because neither player produced meaningful regular-season value for his new team, the trade is a straightforward even result.
Denver Broncos received Chris Gronkowski. Indianapolis Colts received Cassius Vaughn. The final review keeps this as an even trade because the confirmed value stayed close.
San Francisco surrendered more long-term value than it recovered, with 2012 3rd round pick (92nd overall, T.Y. Hilton) proving more meaningful than 2012 4th round pick (97th overall subsequently traded, Lamar Miller) and 2013 5th round pick (157th overall, Qui
New York Jets acquired 2012 6th round pick (187th overall, Josh Bush) from Indianapolis Colts for Drew Stanton and 2012 7th round pick (214th overall, Tim Fugger). New York Jets received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New York Jets Win verdict.
Indianapolis acquired tackle Winston Justice and pick No. 187 for pick No. 172. Justice became a regular Colts starter in 2012, while Indianapolis later sent No. 187 to the Jets in the Drew Stanton trade. Philadelphia also extracted downstream value: No. 172 became part of the package used to move from No. 15 to No. 12 for Fletcher Cox. Both teams turned a small exchange into useful value.
Indianapolis moved up four spots for offensive lineman Ben Ijalana, sending Washington picks No. 53 and No. 152. Injuries prevented Ijalana from becoming a meaningful Colts contributor. Washington repeatedly recycled both acquired choices, turning them into portions of a broader 2011 draft-day chain that produced Leonard Hankerson, DeJon Gomes, Maurice Hurt, Roy Helu and Aldrick Robinson. The volume of usable downstream value clearly exceeded Indianapolis' return.
Indianapolis acquired cornerback Justin Tryon from Washington for a 2011 seventh-round pick. Tryon appeared in 12 games for the Colts in 2010, started six and recorded 44 tackles with seven passes defended before a short 2011 return. Washington used No. 224 on linebacker Markus White, who played only a handful of NFL games. Indianapolis received the more substantial contribution from a very small investment.
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis sent a future sixth-round pick to Philadelphia for No. 222 in 2009 and selected Pat McAfee. The seventh-rounder became one of the NFL's premier specialists, earning multiple Pro Bowls and first-team All-Pro recognition during eight Colts seasons. Philadelphia's 2010 sixth-round return became Charles Scott, who did not play a regular-season game for the Eagles, making this a massive Indianapolis win.
Miami moved down five spots in the second round and added a fifth-rounder, selecting Sean Smith at No. 61 and Chris Clemons at No. 165. Smith became a four-year starting corner for the Dolphins, while Clemons developed into a regular starter at safety. Indianapolis got useful defensive tackle Fili Moala at No. 56, but Miami created more total starting value from the two-player return.
Buffalo and Indianapolis announced a deadline deal on October 14, 2008 that would have sent defensive tackle John McCargo to the Colts for a conditional draft pick. The exchange never became effective: McCargo failed Indianapolis' physical, the trade was voided, and his rights returned to Buffalo. No player or draft choice ultimately changed clubs.
Indianapolis Colts acquired Conditional 2009 draft pick (did not convey) from Philadelphia Eagles for Luke Lawton. The overall result favors Philadelphia Eagles over Indianapolis Colts.
San Francisco traded the pick that became Tony Ugoh and received a package tied to Dashon Goldson and future first-round value. Goldson became the best realized player value, giving the 49ers the win.
Indianapolis acquired defensive tackle Anthony McFarland from Tampa Bay at the 2006 trade deadline for a 2007 second-round pick. McFarland stepped into the Colts defense and helped the club finish its run to a Super Bowl XLI championship. Tampa Bay used No. 64 on safety Sabby Piscitelli, who started 20 games for the Buccaneers, giving both sides real value.
Indianapolis acquired rookie defensive end Ryan LaCasse from Baltimore for a 2008 seventh-round pick shortly before the 2006 season, a low-cost exchange centered on depth and special teams. Neither side gained a cornerstone. Indianapolis received short-term depth on a title team, while Baltimore recouped a future late-round choice, making the exchange essentially balanced.
Baltimore reacquired safety Gerome Sapp from Indianapolis for a conditional 2007 seventh-round pick, adding an experienced special-teams player and reserve defensive back to a contending roster. The deal did not alter either franchise dramatically, but Baltimore obtained the more tangible on-field service from a player who already knew its system.
Indianapolis sent a 2007 sixth-round pick to Tennessee for No. 238 in the 2006 draft and selected return specialist T.J. Rushing. The future pick became No. 206, which Tennessee used on Ryan Smith. Rushing contributed on special teams for the Colts and scored on a punt return during his tenure, while Smith did not record an NFL regular-season appearance.
Indianapolis Colts acquired Rocky Calmus from Tennessee Titans for an undisclosed 2005 draft pick. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Indianapolis gave Philadelphia a 2006 fourth-round pick to acquire the 148th selection in 2005 and draft defensive end Jonathan Welsh. Welsh appeared in only six games for the Colts. Philadelphia carried the future fourth into the 2006 draft and used it in a sequence of trades that helped create more roster value, giving the Eagles the better return from a patient move.
Indianapolis Colts acquired Jamal Reynolds from Green Bay Packers for an undisclosed 2004 draft pick. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Atlanta sent second-, third- and fourth-round picks to Indianapolis for the 29th and 90th selections, drafting Michael Jenkins and Matt Schaub. Jenkins became a seven-year Falcons receiver with more than 3,000 yards for the club, while Schaub later generated two second-round picks when Atlanta traded him to Houston. The combined return gave the Falcons both production and valuable future trade capital.
Cleveland Browns acquired 2004 2nd round pick (59th overall, Sean Jones) and 2004 5th round pick (161st overall, Amon Gordon) from Indianapolis Colts for 2004 3rd round pick (68th overall, Ben Hartsock), 2004 5th round pick (141st overall, Jake Scott) and 2004 6th round pick (173rd overall, Von Hutchins). The overall result favors Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts over Cleveland Browns.
Pittsburgh traded up from No. 44 to No. 38 in the 2004 second round for cornerback Ricardo Colclough, sending Indianapolis the 44th and 107th picks. The Colts used No. 44 on Bob Sanders, who became a first-team All-Pro and the 2007 AP Defensive Player of the Year, while Kendyll Pope added depth from the fourth-round pick. Colclough never became a comparable starter, making Indianapolis the overwhelming winner.
Indianapolis traded safety Rich Coady to St. Louis at the end of the 2003 preseason for a 2004 seventh-round pick, which became kicker David Kimball at No. 229. The Rams received immediate depth and the Colts received a late selection, but neither return developed into meaningful long-term value. With limited football impact on both sides, matching C-plus grades and an Even Trade verdict fit the result.
Indianapolis acquired the 138th pick in the 2003 draft from Houston and used it on Robert Mathis, sending the Texans a 2004 fourth-rounder that became safety Glenn Earl at No. 122. Mathis developed into one of the greatest pass rushers in Colts history, finishing with 123 career sacks and 52 forced fumbles. Houston received a short-term starter, creating an enormous value gap.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired 2004 7th round pick (228th overall; Casey Cramer); 2004 7th round pick (228th overall, Casey Cramer) from Indianapolis Colts for David Gibson. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Indianapolis acquired running back Ricky Williams from New Orleans at the 2002 roster cutdown for a 2003 seventh-round pick. This was the former Texas Tech back, not the star running back with the same name. Williams gave the Colts modest depth over two seasons, totaling 190 rushing yards, 177 receiving yards and four touchdowns. New Orleans received a late pick that was later moved. Neither side generated enough value for a clear win.
Seattle sent quarterback Brock Huard to Indianapolis in 2002 and received the 146th pick, which became defensive tackle Rocky Bernard. Bernard developed into a long-term Seahawks contributor and eventually finished his career with 33 sacks across 160 games. Huard saw almost no action for Indianapolis, appearing in only two games in 2003 and attempting three passes. Seattle transformed a spare quarterback into years of defensive-line value.
Indianapolis sent return specialist Terrence Wilkins to the Rams for the 183rd pick in the 2002 draft, which the Colts used on safety James Lewis. Lewis did not become a regular-season contributor for Indianapolis. Wilkins, by contrast, immediately handled heavy kickoff- and punt-return work for St. Louis in 2002, including more than 1,000 kickoff-return yards. The Rams received the only substantial NFL value from the exchange.
Indianapolis moved from No. 52 to No. 37 in the 2001 second round and selected safety Idrees Bashir, sending Dallas Nos. 52 and 81. Bashir played 71 career games and recorded six interceptions. Dallas immediately recycled both acquired selections into later trades rather than drafting Chris Chambers or Kenny Smith itself. Those moves created useful downstream value, but Indianapolis receives a narrow edge for securing a multi-year defensive starter directly.
Indianapolis traded the 22nd pick in the 2001 draft to the Giants for picks 30, 91 and 193. New York selected cornerback Will Allen at No. 22, while the Colts used No. 30 on Reggie Wayne and the later choices on Cory Bird and Jason Doering. Allen became a long-term NFL starter, but Wayne's 1,006 catches, 13,566 yards and 80 touchdowns gave Indianapolis the decisive return.
New York moved up from No. 30 to No. 22 in the 2001 draft and selected cornerback Will Allen, sending Indianapolis picks No. 30, 91 and 193. Allen became a five-year Giants starter and delivered useful value. Indianapolis used No. 30 on Reggie Wayne, who became a franchise great and Super Bowl champion, making the Colts’ return decisively stronger.
St. Louis acquired punter John Baker from Indianapolis for a 2002 sixth-round pick. Baker became the Rams’ punter for the 2000 and 2001 seasons, appearing in 31 games and handling 86 punts, including the season that ended in Super Bowl XXXVI. Indianapolis used pick No. 204 on running back Brian Allen, who played only four NFL games. Two seasons of starting specialist value gives St. Louis the win.
Carolina sent running back Fred Lane to Indianapolis for linebacker Spencer Reid on April 21, 2000. Reid was a reserve-level player, but he at least appeared in NFL games after the exchange. Lane tragically died on July 6, before he could play a regular-season game for the Colts. Judged strictly by realized football return, Carolina received the only on-field value, though the circumstances make this unlike an ordinary trade outcome.
Indianapolis moved up 20 spots in the fifth round for guard Matt Johnson, sending New Orleans picks No. 158 and No. 195. Johnson never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. The Saints used No. 158 on tight end Austin Wheatley and No. 195 on defensive back Michael Hawthorne; Hawthorne played 63 career games and made 19 starts. That usable sixth-round return gives New Orleans the win.
Las Vegas Raiders acquired 2001 6th round pick (184th overall, Chris Cooper) from Indianapolis Colts for 2000 7th round pick (238th overall, Rodregis Brooks). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Indianapolis Colts
The exchange of 1999 4th round pick (99th overall, Anthony Parker) and 1999 6th round pick (171st overall, Tai Streets) for 1999 4th round pick (96th overall, Paul Miranda) stayed close enough in realized value to remain a true even verdict
The Rams' trade for Marshall Faulk became one of the greatest offensive acquisitions in NFL history. St. Louis paid a modest draft-pick price for a Hall of Fame running back who became the centerpiece of the Greatest Show on Turf. Indianapolis moved a star. The Rams acquired a championship engine. The deal became historic because Faulk did not merely improve the Rams; he helped unlock one of the most famous offenses the league has ever seen.
Indianapolis and New Orleans swapped linebacker Andre Royal for tight end Scott Slutzker at the end of the 1998 preseason. Royal stepped directly into the Colts defense, appearing in 13 games with nine starts that season and making 51 tackles. Slutzker played only three games for New Orleans in 1998 and 11 in 1999. Indianapolis received the more substantial immediate return.
Pittsburgh Steelers received 1999 5th round pick (136th overall, Jerame Tuman). Indianapolis Colts received Steve Conley. The final review favors Pittsburgh Steelers because that return produced stronger practical football value.
Carolina traded cornerback Tyrone Poole to Indianapolis for a 1999 second-round pick that became tackle Chris Terry at No. 34. Poole started 41 games over three Colts seasons and recorded five interceptions, giving Indianapolis dependable secondary play. Terry became an immediate Carolina starter and eventually started 88 NFL games. Both clubs turned the exchange into substantial multi-year value.
Indianapolis traded picks 104, 124 and 154 to Baltimore for the 93rd pick in the 1998 draft and selected offensive lineman Steve McKinney. McKinney started all 60 games he played for the Colts and finished a 10-year career with 143 games and 133 starts. Baltimore received three later selections and additional flexibility, but none of the direct return matched the long-term starting value Indianapolis found at No. 93.
Cincinnati acquired quarterback Paul Justin from Indianapolis for a fifth-round pick in March 1998. Justin appeared in five games with three starts for the Bengals, throwing for 426 yards with one touchdown and three interceptions. Indianapolis used the 135th pick on linebacker Antony Jordan, who played 27 NFL games and made three starts. Both sides received modest depth value without a lasting starter.
Baltimore acquired veteran quarterback Jim Harbaugh and the 93rd pick from Indianapolis on February 17, 1998, sending the Colts picks 71 and 104. Harbaugh started 12 games for the Ravens in 1998, while Indianapolis used No. 71 on receiver E.G. Green and later moved No. 104 in another trade. Neither side created major long-term value from the original exchange, making the deal a balanced veteran-for-draft-capital swap.
The exchange of 1997 3rd round pick (77th overall, Greg Clark) for 1997 3rd round pick (86th overall, Bertrand Berry) and 1997 5th round pick (156th overall, Carl Powell) stayed close enough in realized value to remain a true even verdict
Tampa Bay traded quarterback Craig Erickson to Indianapolis on April 27, 1995 for the Colts’ 1996 first-round pick. Erickson played only six games and made three starts for Indianapolis before moving on. The future pick landed at No. 22, where Tampa Bay selected defensive lineman Marcus Jones. Jones spent seven seasons with the Buccaneers and posted 13 sacks in 2000. Turning a short-term quarterback into a first-round starter gave Tampa Bay the clear advantage.
Indianapolis Colts and Los Angeles Rams completed this exchange on 1994-04-24. Indianapolis moved from No. The Rams' advantage comes from what they actually did with the acquired draft position, not from crediting Bryant Young to Los Angeles. The stronger overall return belongs to Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams. The grades reflect direct team value plus clearly traceable use of any acquired pick that was later traded.
Atlanta acquired quarterback Jeff George from Indianapolis for two 1994 picks and a conditional 1996 first-rounder. George produced several prolific passing seasons for the Falcons, but Indianapolis eventually converted the future first into No. 19 and selected Hall of Fame receiver Marvin Harrison. The Colts' return, especially Harrison, overwhelms Atlanta's shorter quarterback payoff.
Indianapolis moved from No. 100 to No. 92 in the 1993 fourth round, sending Chicago No. 100 and No. 156. The Colts selected defensive back Derwin Gray, while the Bears chose linebacker Myron Baker at No. 100 and later used No. 156 in another draft trade. Neither side found a star, but Chicago created two usable assets from moving down eight spots and gets the edge.
Indianapolis sent the 73rd and 127th picks to the Rams for No. 65 in the 1993 draft and selected cornerback Ray Buchanan. The Rams chose Russell White and Chuck Belin with the return. Buchanan became a long-term NFL starter and intercepted 16 passes during his Colts tenure before later starring in Atlanta, giving Indianapolis the best realized value from the exchange.
Pittsburgh moved from No. 49 to No. 44 in the 1993 second round, sending Indianapolis No. 49 and No. 107. The Steelers selected linebacker Chad Brown, who became a first-team All-Pro and Pro Bowler in Pittsburgh. Indianapolis landed running back Roosevelt Potts and linebacker Devon McDonald, both useful players. The Colts received real value, but Brown's peak and impact make Pittsburgh the clear winner.
Green Bay acquired defensive back Dave McCloughan from Indianapolis on August 19, 1992, for a 1993 sixth-round pick that became No. 156. McCloughan appeared in only five games for the Packers. Indianapolis later used No. 156 as part of a draft-day move that helped obtain No. 92, where the Colts selected Derwin Gray. The Colts receive a narrow win based on that longer team-specific return.
Indianapolis Colts and Los Angeles Raiders completed this exchange on 1992-04-26. Dickerson started 15 games for Los Angeles in 1992 and rushed for 729 yards with two touchdowns, giving the Raiders meaningful if unspectacular production. The Raiders were not wrong to take a relatively inexpensive chance on a Hall of Fame back and did receive one full season of starting work. Following the acquired picks only through moves actually made by the receiving clubs, the overall result is Indianapolis Colts Win.
Indianapolis acquired veteran tackle Irv Pankey from the Rams in September 1991 for third- and eleventh-round selections in the 1992 draft. Pankey's Colts stay was brief, while the Rams used the third-rounder on Marc Boutte, who started 31 of 32 games across his first two NFL seasons. Los Angeles received the more durable and useful return.
On 1991-08-20, Indianapolis Colts and Los Angeles Raiders completed a deal whose long-term value became clearer after the players and draft choices developed. Tyler also did not produce a regular-season contribution for Indianapolis. A conditional trade can still be rational even when it yields nothing. The result is Even Trade, with Indianapolis Colts graded C- and Los Angeles Raiders graded C-.
Tampa Bay acquired quarterback Chris Chandler from Indianapolis in July 1990 and surrendered its 1992 first-round pick. The choice became No. 2 overall, where the Colts selected linebacker Quentin Coryatt. Chandler's Buccaneers stint was brief and unsuccessful, while Coryatt became a six-year Indianapolis starter, creating a severe value gap in the Colts' favor.
Atlanta turned the No. 1 overall pick into Chris Hinton, Andre Rison, a fifth-round pick, and a future first-rounder that became Mike Pritchard. Indianapolis used the pick on Jeff George, whose arm talent never produced the franchise-changing quarterback outcome the Colts needed. The Falcons received multiple useful building blocks, including a star receiver, while Indianapolis absorbed the cost and instability of a miss at the top of the draft.
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis acquired linebacker Chip Banks from San Diego on October 17, 1989 for a conditional pick that became the 67th selection in 1990, wide receiver Walter Wilson. Banks started 51 games for the Colts across four seasons and finished his Indianapolis tenure with a nine-sack 1992 season. Wilson played 14 games with five starts and 87 receiving yards for the Chargers, leaving Indianapolis clearly ahead.
Dallas Cowboys acquired 1990 tenth round pick (#259-Jim Szymanski); Chuck Ehin from Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts for Zefross Moss; 1990 conditional tenth round pick (not exercised). The final grade stays even because neither side created a clear long-term value gap from the recorded return.
Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts acquired Bill Contz from Denver Broncos for 1990 conditional eleventh round pick (not exercised). The final grade stays even because neither side created a clear long-term value gap from the recorded return.
Indianapolis sent Washington the 129th pick in the 1989 draft, used on Tim Smiley, for two 1990 choices that became Alan Grant at No. 103 and Harvey Wilson at No. 213. Grant immediately gave the Colts two full seasons, appearing in 32 games with eight starts and returning kicks. Smiley did not become an NFL regular-season contributor, giving Indianapolis the better return.
Indianapolis traded Pro Bowl guard Ron Solt to Philadelphia for a 1989 first-round pick and a 1990 fourth-rounder. The first became Andre Rison, who produced 820 receiving yards as a Colts rookie before becoming one of the league's premier receivers later in his career. Turning an established lineman into a first-round skill player plus another selection gave Indianapolis the stronger long-term asset return.
Seattle traded linebacker Fredd Young to Indianapolis for first-round selections in both 1989 and 1990. The 1989 pick became tackle Andy Heck, while the 1990 first-rounder later became part of Seattle's trade-up for Cortez Kennedy rather than a direct Ray Agnew selection. Turning one veteran into two premium assets created enormous flexibility and helped shape the Seahawks for years.
Indianapolis acquired linebacker Anthony Griggs from Cleveland on August 30, 1988 for a conditional 1989 twelfth-round pick. The condition was not exercised, so Cleveland received no drafted player from the deal. Griggs had been a productive starter earlier in his career, but his official NFL record ends with five Browns games in 1988 and shows no regular-season Colts appearance, leaving little realized value either way.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and Tim Sherwin from Indianapolis Colts for undisclosed consideration and 1989 seventh round pick (#185-Charles Washington (Edwin)). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis Colts.
Indianapolis sent defensive back Leonard Coleman to San Diego on July 8, 1988 for a 1990 twelfth-round pick. That selection became No. 311, Gene Benhart, who did not establish an NFL career. Coleman gave the Chargers immediate veteran depth and appeared during the 1988 season. The return was modest on both sides, but San Diego received the more useful direct value.
The May 25, 1988 entry reflects the reversal of Indianapolis' earlier deal for Ken Woodard. The Colts had agreed to send Pittsburgh a conditional 1989 twelfth-round pick, but Woodard failed his physical and the transaction was negated. Woodard returned to the Steelers and the conditional pick was never exercised, leaving neither franchise with meaningful lasting value from the aborted exchange.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers received Joe Ferguson from Indianapolis Colts for 1989 twelfth round pick (#314-William DuBose). The recorded outcome favors Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Indianapolis acquired veteran receiver Charlie Brown from Atlanta on April 27, 1988 for a conditional 1989 twelfth-round pick. Brown had been a former Pro Bowl-level target earlier in the decade, but the Colts released him on July 26 before the regular season. The conditional pick was not exercised, so neither Indianapolis nor Atlanta converted the move into meaningful lasting value.
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers received 1989 conditional eleventh-round pick (not exercised) from Indianapolis Colts for Mark Herrmann. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis Colts.
Indianapolis acquired Clarence Verdin from Washington on March 29, 1988 for a sixth-round pick, No. 159, later used on quarterback Stan Humphries. Verdin became a multi-year Colts receiver and return specialist, producing 437 receiving yards and four touchdowns in his first Indianapolis season. Humphries later had a strong NFL career, but Washington realized little of that success before he left the franchise.
Buffalo obtained the rights to linebacker Cornelius Bennett on October 31, 1987, surrendering Greg Bell plus first-round picks in 1988 and 1989 and a 1989 second-rounder. Bennett became a centerpiece of the Bills defense during the franchise's Super Bowl run, making the premium package worthwhile despite the substantial price Buffalo paid.
In the three-team Eric Dickerson/Cornelius Bennett trade, Indianapolis received Eric Dickerson, Buffalo received rights to Cornelius Bennett, and Los Angeles received Greg Bell, Owen Gill, 1988 1st round pick from Bills, 14th overall, Gaston Green, 1988 2nd round pick from Colts, 47th overall, Fred Strickland, 1989 1st round pick from Bills, 26th overall, Cleveland Gary, and 1989 2nd round pick from Colts, 45th overall, Frank Stams. The existing Indianapolis Colts Win verdict and A/A-/D grades are preserved.
Pittsburgh Steelers acquired cash / future considerations from Indianapolis Colts for Mark Smythe. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and 1988 seventh round pick (#186-Danta Whitaker) from Indianapolis Colts for undisclosed consideration and Jerome Sally. The recorded outcome favors New York Giants.
Detroit Lions received Derrick Ramsey from Indianapolis Colts for 1988 twelfth round pick (#308-Aaron Kenney). The recorded outcome favors Detroit Lions.
Indianapolis conditionally acquired defensive back Demetrious Johnson from Detroit for a 1989 twelfth-round pick, but Colts records mark the selection as tied to an unmet condition. The pick was therefore not exercised, and Johnson did not appear in a regular-season game for Indianapolis before playing three games for Miami in 1987. With no durable value transferred, the result is even.
Buffalo Bills acquired 1988 eighth round pick (#213-Jeff Wright (Dee)) (in place of Roger Caron when he retired) from Indianapolis Colts for 1987 eighth round pick (#200-Chuckie Miller). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Indianapolis acquired defensive back and returner Kirk Springs from the Jets on April 1, 1987 for a conditional 1988 twelfth-round pick. Springs did not make the Colts' regular-season roster and was released in August. Because the trade condition failed, the twelfth-round choice reverted to Indianapolis, leaving the Colts with no regular-season production and the Jets with no lasting draft return.
Indianapolis acquired the rights to receiver Walter Murray from Washington on October 7, 1986, sending a 1987 second-round pick that became No. 30. Murray contributed modestly during two Colts seasons, while Washington used No. 30 on defensive back Brian Davis, who also failed to become a major long-term piece. Neither side created enough separation to claim a meaningful victory.
New York Giants acquired undisclosed consideration; 1987 ninth round pick (#225-Stan Parker) from Indianapolis Colts for undisclosed consideration; Kenny Daniel. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired 1987 eighth round pick (#197-Stan Mataele) from Indianapolis Colts for John Holt. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Cleveland Browns received Mike Pagel from Indianapolis Colts for 1987 ninth round pick (#247-Bob Ontko). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis Colts.
Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts acquired 1987 conditional tenth round pick (not exercised) from Denver Broncos for Jim Mills (Anthony). The final grade stays even because neither side created a clear long-term value gap from the recorded return.
Detroit Lions acquired 1986 conditional tenth round pick (not exercised) from Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts for Roosevelt Barnes. The final verdict remains Indianapolis Colts Win, with the grades reflecting the recorded asset value and the available historical return.
Indianapolis sent the 144th pick to the Rams in the 1986 draft for picks No. 172, No. 190 and No. 326. The Colts selected Chris White, Tommy Sims and Isaac Williams; Sims appeared in one NFL game, while White and Williams did not become regular-season Colts contributors. The Rams used No. 144 on Robert Cox, later Robert Jenkins, who developed into a multi-year NFL linebacker, giving Los Angeles the better return.
Dallas traded quarterback Gary Hogeboom to Indianapolis on April 28, 1986, moving from No. 47 to No. 33 in the next day's second round and receiving a conditional 1987 fifth-round pick that was not exercised. Dallas selected Darryl Clack at No. 33. Indianapolis received Hogeboom and used No. 47 on Jack Trudeau, whose long Colts tenure gave Indianapolis the stronger overall return despite mixed quarterback results.
Indianapolis moved from No. 6 to No. 4 before the 1986 draft and selected defensive lineman Jon Hand, sending New Orleans No. 6 and No. 60. Hand became a nine-year Colt with 35.5 sacks, so Indianapolis received a good player. New Orleans, however, drafted Jim Dombrowski and Pat Swilling; Swilling became Defensive Player of the Year and a five-time Pro Bowler, giving the Saints the superior return.
Indianapolis acquired linebacker Dave Ahrens from St. Louis on August 27, 1985, for a 1986 tenth-round pick. Ahrens appeared in 44 regular-season games for the Colts over three seasons and started 10 games in 1986. St. Louis used the No. 255 selection on receiver Wes Smith, who played only one NFL game. Indianapolis converted a late pick into substantially more usable roster value and wins the exchange.
Buffalo Bills acquired 1986 eleventh round pick (#282-Billy Witt) from Indianapolis Colts for Matt Kofler. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Indianapolis Colts received Tim Golden from New England Patriots for 1986 conditional tenth round pick (not exercised). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis Colts.
Indianapolis traded linebacker Vernon Maxwell to San Diego on August 1, 1985 for a 1986 fifth-round pick. The Colts later used that selection, No. 124 overall, on center Gary Walker. Walker never became a contributor for Indianapolis, but the Colts at least converted an expendable player into meaningful draft capital. That matters because Maxwell did not survive San Diego’s final preseason cuts.
Detroit and Indianapolis exchanged Alvin Moore and Robbie Martin on July 25, 1985. Moore gave the Lions useful backfield production, including 221 rushing yards, four rushing touchdowns and one receiving score in 1985. Martin contributed as a receiver and return option for Indianapolis but did not become a major long-term piece. Neither club created a large enough advantage to separate the deal decisively.
The Cardinals sent Eddie McGill to Indianapolis on July 23, 1985 for a conditional 1986 twelfth-round pick. The condition was not exercised, leaving St. Louis without a realized draft selection, while McGill did not produce meaningful regular-season value for the Colts. With neither side converting the transaction into a lasting contribution, the practical outcome was essentially neutral.
Indianapolis Colts received 1986 conditional twelfth round pick (not exercised) from Cleveland Browns for Victor Oatis. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
Indianapolis sent quarterback Mark Herrmann to San Diego on March 27, 1985, for a 1986 tenth-round pick that became No. 266 and guard Pete Anderson. Herrmann gave the Chargers three seasons of backup quarterback value, including 1,537 passing yards and 10 touchdowns in 1985. Anderson never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. San Diego clearly received the stronger realized return from a low-cost exchange.
Indianapolis acquired George Radachowsky from the Rams on August 27, 1984 for a 1985 eleventh-round pick. Radachowsky played all 16 games as a Colts rookie and three more in 1985, giving Indianapolis immediate depth. Los Angeles used the pick on Doug Flutie, who never played for the Rams but whose rights were later traded to Chicago for future draft value. Both teams extracted something useful.
Indianapolis Colts acquired Mark Reed (b)? from Los Angeles Rams for Mark Jerue. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Dallas traded kicker Raul Allegre to Baltimore for a 1984 ninth-round pick after Allegre lost a training-camp competition. The Cowboys eventually used No. 232 on John Hunt, who played only a handful of NFL games. Allegre immediately became one of the league's most productive kickers, making 30 of 35 field goals in 1983 and scoring 112 points for the Colts, then remaining with the franchise through 1985.
Detroit traded wide receiver Tracy Porter to Baltimore on August 29, 1983 for a 1984 late-round choice that became No. 259, William Frizzell. Porter immediately caught 28 passes for 384 yards in 1983, then added 39 receptions for 590 yards in 1984. Frizzell played 24 games for Detroit without a start before building more of his career elsewhere, giving the Colts the better team-specific return.
Dallas traded offensive lineman Steve Wright to Baltimore in August 1983 for a 1985 sixth-round pick. Wright immediately started 10 games for the Colts in 1983 and nine more in 1984, giving Baltimore two seasons of useful line play. Dallas used No. 144 on Kurt Ploeger, whose NFL career totaled only five games and one start, leaving the Colts with the stronger direct return.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers received Reese McCall from Indianapolis Colts for 1984 conditional seventh round pick (not exercised). The recorded outcome favors Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Indianapolis Colts received Calvin Close from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis Colts.
Detroit traded tackle Karl Baldischwiler to Baltimore during 1983 training camp for a 1984 seventh-round choice. The Lions used No. 178 on Jimmie Carter, whose NFL career amounted to one game and did not create value for Detroit. Baldischwiler immediately started all 14 games he played for the Colts in 1983 and later returned to start additional games for Indianapolis, giving the Colts the clear advantage.
Denver acquired the rights to No. 1 overall pick John Elway from the Colts for Chris Hinton, Mark Herrmann and a 1984 first-round selection that became Ron Solt. Elway became Denver's Hall of Fame franchise quarterback, leading five Super Bowl appearances and two championships. Hinton and Solt gave the Colts substantial value, but no return could match Elway's transformative career.
Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts acquired Glenn Hyde from Denver Broncos for 1983 eighth round pick (#197-Gary Kubiak). The final verdict remains Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts Win, with the grades reflecting the recorded asset value and the available historical return.
Seattle acquired veteran receiver Roger Carr from Baltimore for a 1984 fourth-round pick in September 1982. Carr caught 15 passes for 265 yards and two touchdowns in nine Seahawks games before leaving after the season. The Colts used No. 103 on running back George Wonsley, who played five seasons for Indianapolis and rushed for 716 yards with six touchdowns in 1985 alone. Indianapolis received the stronger return.
Atlanta Falcons acquired Dave Smigelsky from Indianapolis Colts for 1983 ninth round pick (#242-Chris Rose). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Pittsburgh Steelers acquired 1983 conditional twelfth round pick (not exercised) from Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts for Zack Valentine. The final verdict remains Indianapolis Colts Win, with the grades reflecting the recorded asset value and the available historical return.
Seattle sent a 1984 fifth-round pick to Baltimore for veteran guard Robert Pratt in July 1982. Pratt became a four-year Seattle fixture, starting every game he played for the Seahawks. Baltimore later used No. 130 on tackle Kevin Call, who spent ten seasons with the Colts and started 87 games. Both clubs converted modest assets into long-term offensive-line starters, making this one of the strongest even trades in the group.
Baltimore traded veteran safety Bruce Laird to San Diego in May 1982 for a 1983 sixth-round pick. Laird gave the Chargers 23 games over two seasons and started six times in the strike-shortened 1982 season. The Colts used No. 161 on center Grant Feasel, who appeared in 17 games for Baltimore and Indianapolis without a start before continuing his career elsewhere. San Diego received the better direct return.
Los Angeles paid the fourth and 34th selections in the 1982 draft for veteran quarterback Bert Jones, hoping the former MVP-caliber passer could stabilize the position. Jones started only four games for the Rams before a serious neck injury ended his career. The short return made the price costly even though Baltimore's first-round choice, Art Schlichter, became a major disappointment.
Baltimore acquired kicker Mike Wood from San Diego on August 31, 1981 for a 1983 sixth-round pick. Wood handled the Colts' kicking job for all 16 games in 1981 and six more in 1982. The Chargers used No. 141 in 1983 on receiver Trumaine Johnson, who later played two seasons for San Diego and caught 34 passes for 450 yards and two touchdowns. Both received value, with the Chargers holding the edge.
Washington acquired veteran defensive end Fred Cook from Baltimore in July 1981 under conditional draft terms reported as a 1982 ninth-round pick and a possible 1983 sixth-rounder. Cook was released in August before making the regular-season roster, and Washington reclaimed the ninth-round choice; the playing-time condition for the later pick was not met. With no games for Washington and no realized draft return for Baltimore, the direct outcome is even.
New York Giants acquired Lyle Blackwood from Indianapolis Colts for a 1982 conditional twelfth round pick tied to Blackwood making the Giants roster. The pick was not exercised, and the overall result favors New York Giants.
Baltimore traded running back Joe Washington to Washington for the 52nd pick in the 1981 draft. The Colts did not use that selection on Jarvis Redwine; they immediately included No. 52 in their move-up with Minnesota for No. 18. Joe Washington, meanwhile, became an immediate dual-threat contributor in Washington and gave his new team the stronger realized return.
Minnesota traded the 18th pick in the 1981 draft to Baltimore for two second-rounders and a fifth-rounder, selecting Mardye McDole, Jarvis Redwine, and Wendell Ray. The quantity did not translate into comparable NFL value. Baltimore used No. 18 on Donnell Thompson, who became an 11-year Colt, started 143 games, and provided the durable return that decides the trade.
Baltimore traded defensive tackle Jim Krahl to San Francisco on September 23, 1980 for a 1981 tenth-round pick. Krahl appeared in two games for the 49ers without a start, so the return was small. The Colts used No. 256 on linebacker Greg Gerken, who did not play an NFL regular-season game. San Francisco gets a narrow win because it received the only measurable NFL contribution.
Baltimore traded guard Ron Baker to Philadelphia on August 26, 1980 for the 1981 eighth-round pick used on defensive end Hosea Taylor. Taylor gave the Colts 20 games and seven starts across two seasons, including six starts and two sacks as a rookie. Baker became a Philadelphia line fixture, starting 106 games for the Eagles from 1980 through 1988. The long-term gap strongly favors Philadelphia.
Atlanta Falcons acquired 1981 tenth round pick (not exercised) from Indianapolis Colts for Brian Cabral. The overall result favors Indianapolis Colts.
Denver Broncos acquired Don Hardeman from Indianapolis Colts for 1980 twelfth round pick (#324-Marvin Sims). Denver Broncos received the stronger recorded football value.
Detroit Lions acquired Stan White (Ray) from Indianapolis Colts for 1980 eighth round pick (#195-Ken Walter (Gene)). Detroit Lions received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Detroit Lions Win verdict.
The Colts acquired Mark Bailey from Kansas City for a 1980 fifth-round pick, No. 114. Kansas City used that selection on wide receiver Carlos Carson, who became a two-time Pro Bowler, produced 6,360 receiving yards for the Chiefs and later entered the club's Hall of Honor. Bailey did not provide Indianapolis with anything close to that level of service. Turning a fifth-round return into a long-term featured receiver gives Kansas City a decisive win.
Indianapolis Colts
Dallas acquired defensive lineman John Dutton for its first- and second-round picks in 1980. Dutton became a long-term piece of the Cowboys defense and remained with the club through 1987, giving Dallas years of starting value from an established player. That sustained contribution outweighed the two draft choices Baltimore ultimately used on Derrick Hatchett and Tim Foley.
Denver Broncos acquired 1980 eighth round pick (#197-Don Coleman (c)) from Indianapolis Colts for Bucky Dilts. Indianapolis Colts received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired Calvin O'Neal from Indianapolis Colts for 1980 twelfth round pick (not exercised?). Tampa Bay Buccaneers received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Tampa Bay Buccaneers Win verdict.
Indianapolis moved from No. 72 to No. 69 in the 1979 third round, sending Houston the No. 72 selection plus No. 171 in the seventh round. The Colts used No. 69 on Kim Anderson, who played 56 NFL games with 12 starts for Indianapolis. Houston used No. 72 on Kenny King, who later became valuable enough to headline a significant trade with the Raiders, while No. 171 Tim Ries added little. The Oilers hold a narrow edge.
Detroit traded veteran quarterback Greg Landry for three draft choices: a 1979 fourth, a 1979 fifth and a 1980 third. The most useful return became tight end Ulysses Norris, who spent five seasons with the Lions and eventually started 15 games in 1983. The package produced roster value, but not enough star power to create a clear win.
Buffalo Bills acquired 1979 sixth round pick (#141-Mike Burrow); cash from Indianapolis Colts for Dwight Harrison. Buffalo Bills received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Buffalo Bills Win verdict.
Baltimore received Joe Washington and a 1979 fifth-round pick. Washington immediately rushed for a career-high 958 yards in 1978, then led the NFL with 82 receptions in 1979 while adding 884 rushing yards. The fifth-round asset later helped Baltimore acquire quarterback Greg Landry. The hindsight grade is A-, with the overall verdict recorded as Indianapolis Colts Win.
Baltimore received Washington's 1979 sixth-round pick, No. 150, and used it on Jimmy Moore. Moore did not appear in a regular-season NFL game, leaving the Colts without meaningful realized player value from the selection. The longer view produces a D+ grade for Baltimore Colts. Washington receives a B+ and Baltimore a D+.
Minnesota Vikings acquired Frank Myers from Indianapolis Colts for 1979 eighth round pick (#207-Nesby Glasgow). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
The Colts acquired Don Hardeman, who gave Baltimore two seasons of backfield work. He rushed for 244 yards in 1978 and 292 in 1979, useful production but a much smaller return than the multi-year workload Tampa Bay received from Eckwood. The hindsight grade is C+, with the overall verdict recorded as Tampa Bay Buccaneers Win.
Baltimore acquired wide receiver Mike Siani and a 1979 third-round pick for Raymond Chester and a 1979 second-rounder. Siani gave the Colts three seasons, and the draft choice retained value before being moved to Houston. The Colts received legitimate pieces, but neither matched Chester’s impact after his return to Oakland.
Detroit received wide receiver Freddie Scott and Baltimore's 1978 fourth-round pick at No. 107. The Lions used the pick on guard Homer Elias, who played seven seasons for Detroit, appeared in 96 games, and started 87, becoming the defining long-term asset in the exchange. The hindsight grade is A-, with the overall verdict recorded as Detroit Lions Win.
Baltimore acquired Hall of Fame linebacker Willie Lanier, but Lanier never played a regular-season game for the Colts. He announced his retirement in July 1978, three months after the trade, so Baltimore received no on-field return from the veteran acquisition. The hindsight grade is C, with the overall verdict recorded as Even Trade.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Alden Roche from Green Bay Packers for 1978 seventh round pick (selection not identified). The unidentified seventh-round selection and the limited documented return leave the exchange even.
Baltimore sent quarterback Marty Domres to San Francisco for cash and a future fifth-round pick that became No. 117 Frank Myers in 1978. Myers did not become a Colts fixture, but Baltimore later moved him to Minnesota for another draft choice. The Colts preserved useful asset value while Domres made only five appearances for San Francisco.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers received Rod Garcia from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for cash. The recorded outcome favors Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Philadelphia Eagles received Ed George from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for cash. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Bill Troup from Philadelphia Eagles for Dennis Nelson and undisclosed draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore sent defensive back Mike Washington to expansion Tampa Bay for a 1976 third-round choice and cash. The Colts used the selection on Ron Lee, but Washington became a foundational Buccaneer, playing 100 games with 97 starts and intercepting 28 passes. Baltimore received legitimate consideration, yet Tampa Bay obtained the far more valuable long-term contributor.
Baltimore acquired veteran center Forrest Blue plus the return of its 1976 15th- and 16th-round choices. Contemporary team records describe San Francisco's compensation as a 1978 third-round pick, later used on Ernie Hughes; a later Colts listing also mentions a 1977 second, but its conditional status is unresolved. Blue gave Baltimore veteran line help, while Hughes became a useful 49ers starter. The returns were comparable.
Baltimore acquired Howard Stevens from New Orleans for a 1977 fifth-round pick and received three seasons of useful return work. Stevens handled 109 punt returns for 1,012 yards with the Colts and added substantial kickoff-return production, especially in 1976. New Orleans used the No. 136 selection on Dave Hubbard, whose NFL career lasted only five games. Baltimore received the clearly stronger result.
Baltimore agreed in August 1975 to send tackle Dennis Nelson to Washington for a multi-pick package, but Nelson never reported to the Redskins. Contemporary Philadelphia material and later transaction records show that the deal was negated, Nelson's rights returned to the Colts, and he sat out the 1975 season. The listed draft choices therefore were not completed trade proceeds.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1976 fourth round pick (probably not exercised?) from Green Bay Packers for Paul Linford. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Minnesota Vikings received Dave Hazel from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1976 eighth round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore sent tight end Ron Mayo to San Diego on July 29, 1975, and received a sixth-round selection in the 1976 draft. Chargers club records consistently identify the compensation as a sixth-round pick, resolving the earlier round uncertainty. Mayo did not appear in a regular-season game for San Diego, while the exact player ultimately produced by Baltimore’s pick remains unidentified, leaving little demonstrated value on either side.
Buffalo Bills received 1976 sixth round pick (#175-Darnell Powell) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Jim Cheyunski. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Al Cowlings from Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans for 1976 third round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome favors Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans.
Baltimore acquired return specialist Herb Mul-Key from Washington for a 1977 fourth-round choice, but Mul-Key did not make the Colts' regular-season roster. Washington later moved that fourth-round asset, along with Charley Harraway's rights, to Miami for tight end Marv Fleming, who also failed to make Washington's roster. Neither club converted the exchange into lasting on-field value.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and Larry Christoff from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration and rights to Jim Sims. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore acquired the NFL rights to tackle Ed George from Pittsburgh for 1976 second- and fourth-round selections. George gave the Colts 12 games and two starts in 1975, so Baltimore received real short-term help. Pittsburgh used the premium pick on quarterback Mike Kruczek, who went 6-0 as a rookie starter, making the Steelers’ return stronger overall.
Baltimore and San Francisco swapped late-round draft capital on January 29, 1975. The Colts received the 1975 choices used on Mike Evavold at No. 399 and Mike Bengard at No. 426, while the 49ers received 1976 15th- and 16th-round selections, including No. 449 Mike Fuhrman. None of the identified selections produced meaningful NFL value, leaving this as a low-impact even exchange.
Baltimore sent Cotton Speyrer and Glenn Ressler to Washington for a 1975 twelfth-round choice used on Brad Storm and a 1976 sixteenth-round choice used on Mike Fuhrman. Neither side turned the exchange into lasting direct value: Ressler’s NFL career had already ended, Speyrer did not become a Washington regular, and neither Colts pick produced an NFL career.
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received 1976 13th round pick (#367-Craig Crnick) and 1976 17th round pick (#478-Buddy Tate) from Indianapolis Colts for 1975 16th round pick (#416-Robert Smith (b)) and 1975 17th round pick (#440-Frank Russell). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore traded defensive lineman Jim Bailey to the New York Jets on January 28, 1975, for a fourth-round selection in that spring’s draft. The Colts used the pick at No. 93 on Paul Linford, who did not produce regular-season value for Baltimore. Bailey, by contrast, appeared in all 14 games for the Jets in 1975 and started eight, giving New York the clearly better immediate return.
Chicago acquired the NFL rights to Greg Latta and Noah Jackson in two same-day deals with Baltimore, while also receiving the Colts’ 1976 seventh-round selection. Latta played five seasons for Chicago and Jackson became a long-term starting guard. Baltimore received four selections that produced Dave Pear, Steve Joachim, Derrel Luce and Sanders Shiver, making this a productive exchange for both clubs but a slight Bears win.
Atlanta moved George Kunz and the No. 3 pick to Baltimore for the No. 1 selection and a sixth-rounder, then drafted Steve Bartkowski first overall and Fulton Kuykendall later in the draft. Bartkowski became the Falcons' long-term quarterback, while Kuykendall also became a durable starter. Baltimore received an elite tackle in Kunz plus Ken Huff at No. 3. Both franchises converted the deal into major value.
Baltimore acquired tight end Ron Mayo from Houston on September 12, 1974, for the 1975 tenth-round pick at No. 246. Mayo appeared in nine games for the Colts that season without a start and contributed mainly on special teams. Houston used the returned selection on Alan Pringle, who did not produce a significant NFL career, leaving the exchange close to neutral.
Denver Broncos received Tom Drougas from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1975 eighth round pick (#187-Greg Denboer / Greg den Boer). The recorded outcome favors Denver Broncos.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Tom Drougas from New Orleans Saints for 1975 fourth round pick (AP) / 1976 fourth round pick (selection not identified) and 1975 fourth round pick (AP). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Baltimore sent Ted Hendricks and a 1975 second-round choice to Green Bay for linebacker Tom MacLeod and the 1975 eighth-round pick that became Mario Cage. Hendricks gave the Packers only one season before leaving for Oakland, but that season was exceptional: he earned first-team All-Pro and Pro Bowl honors. Baltimore's return did not approach that peak value, leaving Green Bay ahead despite the short tenure.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Mike Kaczmarek from Denver Broncos for cash. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Houston acquired veteran center Fred Hoaglin, who appeared in 28 games across the next two seasons for the Oilers. Baltimore received the 1975 tenth-round pick used on Alan Pringle, whose NFL career consisted of one game with Detroit rather than meaningful Colts production. The Oilers received usable offensive-line depth for two seasons, while the draft return produced essentially no direct value for Baltimore. That modest but clear production edge decides the trade.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1975 third round pick (#53-Mike Washington) and 1976 seventh round pick (possibly #201-Ed Bauer) from San Francisco 49ers for Tom Mitchell. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and Roy Hilton from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, Joe Orduna and 1975 sixth round pick (#131-Don Westbrook (a)). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Mike Simpson from San Francisco 49ers for 1976 seventh round pick (#201-Ed Bauer). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis received a sixth-round choice that became Danny Rhodes plus cash, while New England acquired quarterback Jack Mildren. Rhodes appeared in 14 games as a rookie, and Mildren never developed into a long-term answer for the Patriots. Neither return became a franchise-changing piece, but the Colts extracted both draft capital and cash from a player who provided New England limited on-field value.
Washington received Cornelius Johnson / Corny Johnson, 1975 17th round pick (undisclosed) and Ed Mooney from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for George Nock, 1974 17th round pick (#436-Buzzy Lewis) and 1974 twelfth round pick (#307-Bob Bobrowski). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Denver acquired linebacker Ray May from Baltimore on October 3, 1973 for 1974 third- and eighth-round picks. May became a useful Broncos starter for three seasons, but Baltimore used the third-rounder on guard Robert Pratt, who developed into a long-term Colts lineman with 170 career games. Denver received solid value; Pratt's sustained impact gives Baltimore the stronger return.
Miami acquired Don Nottingham and a 1974 sixth-round pick from Baltimore for Hubert Ginn on October 2, 1973. Nottingham became a five-season Dolphins contributor and scored 25 rushing touchdowns from 1974 through 1977, while the pick became Randy Crowder. Ginn played only nine games for Baltimore before returning to Miami, producing a decisive Dolphins win.
Baltimore acquired Ed Mooney from Detroit for its 1974 fifth-round selection, No. 109. Mooney appeared in 13 games and started three for the Colts before being traded again the next January. Detroit flipped the pick to Atlanta for Willie Germany, who appeared in six Lions games. Both sides received short-term value, but Baltimore’s player contribution and later return give it the edge.
Denver Broncos received Bill Laskey from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1974 seventh round pick (#170-Dan Dickel). The recorded outcome favors Denver Broncos.
Baltimore acquired defensive tackle John Gordon from Detroit on August 1, 1973 for the Colts' 1974 tenth-round draft choice. Gordon had appeared in only two NFL games for Detroit in 1972 and never played another NFL regular-season game. Detroit at least recovered a future selection, so the Lions receive a narrow edge despite the modest value of the return.
Detroit Lions received Jim O'Brien (b) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1974 fourth round pick (#84-Tony Bell). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Minnesota Vikings received Charles Stukes / Charlie Stukes from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1974 fifth round pick (#129-Doug Nettles). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Buffalo Bills received John Mosier from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1974 seventh round pick (#174-Freddie Scott). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received Charles Smith / Bubba Smith from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Raymond Chester / Ray Chester. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore acquired veteran guard Elmer Collett from San Francisco in June 1973 for a 1975 third-round draft choice. Collett immediately started every game for the Colts in 1973 and gave a rebuilding offense a dependable veteran presence. The 49ers received future draft value, but the transaction was essentially a straightforward veteran-for-pick exchange.
Baltimore acquired veteran lineman Joe Schmiesing from Detroit on June 14, 1973 for a future fourth-round choice. Schmiesing started 11 games for the Colts that season, while Detroit later returned the trade consideration to Baltimore in the Jim O'Brien transaction. Both clubs extracted useful value from the same asset chain, supporting an even B/B result.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1974 14th round pick (selection not identified) (pick may have been conditional and not exercised) from Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans for Tom Nowatzke. The recorded outcome favors Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1974 tenth round pick (selection not identified) (pick may have been conditional and not exercised) from Washington for Fred Miller (David). The recorded outcome favors Washington.
Baltimore sent veteran lineman Dan Sullivan to Oakland for a future draft choice on February 7, 1973. Sullivan retired before playing for the Raiders, and Colts historical records state that the transaction was negated. Because Oakland received no regular-season contribution and Baltimore did not realize the draft compensation, the fairest hindsight result is an even trade with neutral grades.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1974 tenth round pick (#257-Glen Ellis / Glenn Ellis) from Los Angeles Rams for Jerry Logan. The recorded outcome favors Los Angeles Rams.
Baltimore acquired kicker George Hunt from Cleveland on January 30, 1973 for the fourth-round pick used on Andy Dorris. Hunt handled the Colts' kicking job for all 14 games in 1973. Cleveland drafted Dorris but traded him before the regular season, later receiving a 1974 seventh-round pick. Baltimore gained the stronger immediate football return.
Baltimore acquired the No. 2 pick in the 1973 draft from New Orleans and used it on quarterback Bert Jones, sending defensive lineman Billy Newsome and the No. 86 selection, Jim Merlo, to the Saints. Jones became the 1976 NFL MVP and Offensive Player of the Year and led Baltimore's resurgence. The Saints received useful pieces, but nothing close to a franchise quarterback at his peak.
Baltimore sent center Bill Curry to Houston for guard Tom Regner and the 1973 third-round pick used on fullback Bill Olds. Curry's Oilers stint ended after only four games in 1973, while Olds developed into a useful Colts starter and offensive contributor, including 14 starts in 1975. Regner added little in Baltimore, but the pick outcome created enough value for a clear Colts win.
Baltimore traded running back Norm Bulaich to Philadelphia for the 1973 fourth-round pick used on Gery Palmer and the 1974 second-round pick used on Ed Shuttlesworth. Bulaich immediately gave the Eagles substantial rushing and receiving work, while the Colts' return produced little realized value; Shuttlesworth never played for Baltimore. The original Colts-win direction therefore needs to be reversed in Philadelphia's favor.
Baltimore acquired center Fred Hoaglin from Cleveland on January 25, 1973, for Kansas City’s third-round pick, No. 67 overall, which the Browns used on defensive end Bob Crum. Hoaglin appeared in all 14 games for the Colts that season, while Crum never played a regular-season game for Cleveland. The deal produced modest value, but Baltimore realized more of it.
Baltimore acquired San Diego's 1973 eighth-round pick, No. 189, and used it on defensive back Ray Oldham in exchange for veteran Tom Matte. Oldham became a multi-season Colts contributor with meaningful starting time, while Matte did not provide San Diego regular-season value after the transaction. The conversion of a retiring veteran into years of defensive depth makes this a clear Colts win.
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers received John Unitas / Johnny Unitas from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for future considerations unspecified consideration / $150K cash and future considerations (details not identified) / $150K cash. The recorded outcome favors Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers.
Cincinnati acquired guard John Shinners from Baltimore on October 24, 1972 for a 1973 fourth-round pick, No. 93 overall. Shinners became a useful five-season Bengal, appearing in 66 games and starting 32. Baltimore later sent the pick to Cleveland for kicker George Hunt, who scored 70 points for the Colts in 1973. Cincinnati received the stronger long-term return.
Denver Broncos received 1973 seventh round pick (#166-John Grant) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for John Mosier. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Baltimore acquired defensive tackle Chuck Hinton from the Jets on September 7, 1972 for a 1973 tenth-round choice. Hinton played 13 games and started six for the Colts that season. New York used pick No. 243 on linebacker Joe Carbone, who was released before playing a regular-season game for the Jets. Baltimore therefore received the only meaningful NFL contribution from the exchange.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1973 fourth round pick (#85-Ollie Smith) from Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers for Leonard Dunlap. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Cleveland Browns received Lynn Larson / Lynn Larsen from Indianapolis Colts for 1973 sixth round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received cash from Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans for Craig Robinson. The recorded outcome favors Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans.
Baltimore acquired quarterback Marty Domres from San Diego in August 1972 for tight end John Andrews and the 1973 first-round pick Baltimore had obtained from Washington. San Diego used that selection at No. 25 on Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Rodgers, while Domres became the Colts’ primary starter during a turbulent 1972 season.
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received Lloyd Edwards, William West and William West / Bill West (b) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for cash. The recorded outcome favors Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders.
Indianapolis Colts received Lloyd Edwards and William West / Bill West (b) from New York Jets for cash. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1972 eighth round pick (#191-Al Qualls), 1973 fourth round pick (#85-Ollie Smith), 1973 eighth round pick (#189-Ray Oldham) and other compensation (details not specified in source record) from Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers for George Wright. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1973 seventh round pick (selection not identified) from Los Angeles Rams for Tom Curtis. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore sent offensive lineman John Williams to the Los Angeles Rams before the 1972 season and received the Rams’ 1974 first-round draft choice. Baltimore eventually used that pick at No. 24 on wide receiver Roger Carr, creating a long-term offensive return from a veteran lineman who had played out his option.
Baltimore sent Eldridge Dickey to Kansas City on July 23, 1972, for the Chiefs' 1973 third-round pick, later No. 67 overall. The Colts then sent that selection to Cleveland for center Fred Hoaglin; Cleveland used No. 67 on Bob Crum. Dickey never appeared in another NFL game, while Hoaglin played all 14 games for Baltimore in 1973, giving the Colts the better return.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1972 fourth round pick (#104-Eric Allen (B.)), 1972 eighth round pick (#191-Al Qualls), 1973 fourth round pick (#85-Ollie Smith), consolidated pick package and conflicting sources list combinations including 1972 fourth-round, 1972 eighth-round, 1973 fourth-round, and 1973 eighth-round compensation from Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers for George Wright. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received John Shinners from New Orleans Saints for Jim Duncan (b), 1972 fifth round pick (#126-Bob Davies) and 1973 sixth round pick (#139) [later traded with 1974 fourth round pick (#86-Mike Townsend) to Minnesota Vikings for Bob Brown (Earl)]. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Baltimore acquired Eldridge Dickey from Oakland on January 28, 1972 for the Colts' third-round pick, No. 74. Dickey never appeared in another NFL regular-season game, while Oakland quickly used the pick as part of a draft-day move with New Orleans. The Raiders therefore converted a player leaving their plans into useful draft capital, giving Oakland a clear advantage.
Baltimore sent defensive back and returner Ron Gardin to New England for the fifth-round choice that became No. 115 in the 1972 draft, where the Colts selected Don Croft. Gardin supplied the Patriots with immediate 1971 playing time, while Croft never produced regular-season value for Baltimore. That modest but real contribution gives New England the better side of a small trade.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Marty Schottenheimer from Pittsburgh Steelers for 1972 tenth round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Green Bay kept defensive tackle Jim DeLisle after Baltimore withdrew its claim in exchange for a 1972 ninth-round selection, No. 215 overall. The Colts used that pick on Gary Hambell, but it did not produce meaningful Baltimore regular-season value. DeLisle appeared in nine games for the 1971 Packers, giving Green Bay the clearer return from an unusual waiver-rights transaction.
Washington acquired proven receiver Roy Jefferson plus ninth-round selections in 1973 and 1974, sending Baltimore rookie Cotton Speyrer and its 1973 first-round choice. Jefferson immediately became Washington’s leading receiver and remained productive for six seasons, including the 1972 Super Bowl run. Baltimore received flashes from Speyrer and converted the first-rounder into later trade value, but never matched Jefferson’s sustained impact.
Baltimore traded linebacker Bob Grant to Washington in July 1971 and received Washington’s second- and seventh-round selections in the 1972 draft. The Colts used those picks on wide receiver Glenn Doughty at No. 47 and defensive end John Sykes at No. 169. The historical result remains meaningful when measured against the cost and the careers that followed.
Oakland acquired Tom Maxwell plus Baltimore’s 1972 fourth- and seventh-round selections, sending Bill Laskey and a 1972 second-round pick to the Colts. The fourth-rounder became Dave Dalby, who spent 14 seasons with the Raiders, started more than 120 games and won three Super Bowls. Baltimore used its second-rounder on Jack Mildren, but that return could not match Dalby’s extraordinary longevity and championship value.
Cleveland Browns received 1972 ninth round pick (#230-Billy LeFear) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Tom Beutler. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
Pittsburgh sent star receiver Roy Jefferson to Baltimore for Willie Richardson and a 1971 fourth-round pick. Richardson never played a regular-season game for the Steelers and was soon moved again, but the fourth-rounder became Dwight White, a founding member of the Steel Curtain and four-time Super Bowl champion. Jefferson helped Baltimore win Super Bowl V, so the Colts received real championship value even though Pittsburgh won the longer arc.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Ray May and 1971 twelfth round pick (#294-Bob Wuensch / Bobby Wuensch) from Pittsburgh Steelers for Preston Pearson and Ocie Austin. The recorded outcome favors Pittsburgh Steelers.
Baltimore sent linebacker Dennis Gaubatz to Washington for defensive lineman Frank Bosch and the 1970 fourth-round pick used on Steve Smear. Bosch did not survive the Colts’ final cuts and returned to Washington on waivers, while Smear chose the CFL and never played for Baltimore. Gaubatz retired before providing Washington regular-season value. The Colts acquired two assets, but neither produced an NFL return, leaving the deal effectively even.
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received John Campbell from Pittsburgh Steelers for cash. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Baltimore traded linebacker Ron Porter to Philadelphia for the 1970 third-round pick used on Ara Person. Person never played a regular-season game for the Colts and later appeared in only four NFL games with St. Louis. Porter, meanwhile, remained with Philadelphia through 1972 and contributed as a regular defender. The pick was real value in theory, but Baltimore failed to convert it into production.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Dan Berry from Philadelphia Eagles for cash. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Minnesota Vikings received cash from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Jim Maylan. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Green Bay traded longtime defensive tackle Ron Kostelnik to Baltimore for a 1970 fourth-round pick, No. 96 overall, later used on kicker Skip Butler. Kostelnik played only 10 games for the Colts before retiring in 1970, while the Packers converted a veteran nearing retirement into mid-round draft capital. Butler never became Green Bay’s kicker, but obtaining the selection still gave the Packers the better asset-management result.
Atlanta Falcons received Gail Cogdill and 1970 sixth round pick (selection not identified) from Indianapolis Colts for Perry Lee Dunn. The recorded outcome favors Atlanta Falcons.
Minnesota Vikings received Jim Dillard from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1970 sixth round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Atlanta Falcons received 1969 fourth round pick (#103-Dickie Lyons) and 1969 fifth round pick (#127-Tony Pleviak) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Dan Grimm. The recorded outcome favors Atlanta Falcons.
Baltimore traded veteran defensive lineman Andy Stynchula to Dallas on December 18, 1968, for receiver Sims Stokes and a 1969 fifth-round pick, No. 127. Stokes never played a regular-season game for the Colts, but Baltimore later packaged the acquired pick with another selection to obtain guard Dan Grimm from Atlanta. Dallas received only a brief Stynchula tenure, so the Colts' reusable draft capital gives them the edge.
Atlanta Falcons received Phil Sobocinski from Indianapolis Colts for 1969 ninth round pick (#210-George Wright). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore sent running back Tony Lorick to New Orleans for the Saints' 1969 second-round pick. The choice became Ted Hendricks at No. 33, a future Hall of Fame linebacker who played 215 consecutive games, reached eight Pro Bowls and helped the Colts win Super Bowl V. Lorick's Saints career lasted two seasons and produced only limited offensive value, creating a massive imbalance.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Jim Kelly (Harry) from Philadelphia Eagles for cash. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Detroit Lions received James Welch / Jim Welch from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for cash. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Philadelphia Eagles received George Harold from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for cash. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore acquired Earl Morrall from the Giants in August 1968, with tight end Butch Wilson becoming the final return to New York. Morrall immediately replaced an injured Johnny Unitas, led the Colts to a 13-1 record and won NFL MVP honors before helping the franchise win Super Bowl V two years later. Wilson never approached that impact, making Baltimore the overwhelming winner.
Baltimore sent linebacker/tight end Barry Brown to the Giants for defensive back and Olympic sprint champion Henry Carr on June 12, 1968. Brown appeared in 12 games for New York that season before later continuing his career in Boston. Carr did not produce a regular-season appearance for Baltimore. The return was modest for the Giants, but it was still more tangible than what the Colts realized from Carr.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1969 conditional draft pick (if Wade makes Steelers roster) (selection not identified) from Pittsburgh Steelers for Bob Wade. The recorded outcome favors Pittsburgh Steelers.
Baltimore and Philadelphia exchanged veteran multipurpose players before the 1968 season, with Timmy Brown going to the Colts and Alvin Haymond to the Eagles. Brown played 11 games as a reserve for a Baltimore team that reached Super Bowl III. Haymond started nine games for Philadelphia, intercepted a pass and scored on both punt and kickoff returns before later bringing the Eagles additional trade value. Philadelphia gets the slight edge.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration, Charlie Johnson, Barry Brown and "high draft choice" (not exercised) (replaced by George Wilson / Butch Wilson on 09-02) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record), Henry Carr and Earl Morrall. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Pittsburgh Steelers received Bob Wade from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Ed Brown (b) and 1969 conditional draft pick (if Wade makes Steelers roster) (undisclosed overall/player). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Detroit Lions received 1968 sixth round pick (selection not identified) from Indianapolis Colts for Jim Todd. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and Bob Lurtsema from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration and 1968 fifth round pick (#126-Paul Elzey). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Baltimore sent running back Jerry Allen to Washington in August 1967 for a 1968 tenth-round pick and a 1969 fourth-round pick. The first became defensive back Ocie Austin, who played 28 games for the Colts over two seasons; the later choice became Jacky Stewart. Baltimore received usable depth and two selections, but Allen immediately became a Washington starter and generated the stronger direct production.
Atlanta Falcons received 1968 sixth round pick (#162-Rick Eber) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Alex Hawkins. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
New Orleans sent Bill Curry, the No. 1 overall pick, a 1967 third-round pick and a 1969 seventh-rounder to Baltimore for quarterback Gary Cuozzo, Buford Allison and a 1967 seventeenth-round pick. Baltimore used No. 1 on Bubba Smith and also gained Curry, both future All-Pro-level starters on Super Bowl teams. Cuozzo lasted one Saints season before being traded again.
St. Louis Cardinals received linebacker Mike Strofolino from Baltimore Colts for 1967 eighth round pick (#202-Lee Anderson). Strofolino gave St. Louis 23 regular-season games across 1966 through 1968 and started five in 1968, while Anderson never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. The modest but tangible defensive return outweighs a draft choice that did not reach the field, supporting an Arizona Cardinals Win with conservative grades.
Atlanta Falcons received Lou Kirouac from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1967 sixth round pick (#137-Terry Southall). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Detroit Lions received John McGuire from Indianapolis Colts for 1967 sixth round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Atlanta Falcons received 1967 sixth round pick (#151-Martine Bircher / Marine Bircher) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Dale Memmelaar. The recorded outcome favors Atlanta Falcons.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1967 ninth round pick (selection not identified) and Bill Hunter / Billy Hunter (a) from Washington for Tom Carr, Ken Duke, Roland Rogers and Dave Hayes. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore Colts received punter David Lee from Cleveland Browns for the 1968 fifth round pick that became No. 134 Jackie Jackson. Lee became Baltimore’s punter for 13 seasons, played 184 games, accumulated 838 punts for 34,019 yards and contributed to championship teams. Jackson never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. That enormous realized-value gap makes this an Indianapolis Colts Win.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Earl Hawkins from Detroit Lions for cash. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and Wendell Harris from Indianapolis Colts for undisclosed consideration and Andy Stynchula. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Pittsburgh Steelers received Jim Carter (a) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for 1967 twelfth round pick (#298-Preston Pearson). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Pittsburgh acquired linebacker John Campbell from Baltimore on September 29, 1965, for veteran center Buzz Nutter. Campbell immediately started all 14 games for the Steelers and remained a substantial starter through 1968, while Nutter played 13 games with six starts in his final NFL season. The longevity gap gives Pittsburgh the stronger return from a straightforward veteran swap.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Billy Lothridge and 1966 fourth round pick (#54-Rod Sherman) from Dallas Cowboys for Ralph Neely. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1965 tenth round pick (selection not identified) from Pittsburgh Steelers for Jimmy Maples / Butch Maples. The recorded outcome favors Pittsburgh Steelers.
San Francisco acquired defensive lineman Dan LaRose from Baltimore for the 1966 seventh-round choice that became No. 105 Dave Ellis. LaRose appeared in five games for the 49ers in 1965, while Ellis never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. The return was small, but San Francisco received the only on-field NFL value created by the exchange, giving the 49ers a narrow historical edge.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1966 fifth round pick (selection not identified) from Los Angeles Rams for Tom Gilburg. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Minnesota Vikings received rights to Larry Kramer from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for John Campbell and 1966 eighth round pick (#120-Jerry Allen). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Detroit Lions received Joe Don Looney and 1966 fifth round pick (selection not identified) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Dennis Gaubatz / Denny Gaubatz. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore acquired kicker-defensive end Lou Michaels and Pittsburgh's 1965 third-round pick for linebacker Bill Saul and defensive back Marv Woodson. Player transaction records place the completed trade on September 8, 1964, after Michaels missed Pittsburgh's final preseason game. Michaels became Baltimore's kicker for six seasons and the draft choice became Glenn Ressler, while Saul developed into a useful Steelers starter. The Colts received the stronger combined return.
Washington acquired veteran Jim Martin from Baltimore on September 8, 1964, sending the Colts a 1965 20th-round choice that became No. 273 Ray Johnson. Martin handled Washington's kicking duties for all 14 games in 1964 and scored 71 points, while Johnson never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. The return was short-lived but clearly tangible, supporting Washington's existing win with conservative grades.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration, Andy Nelson and R.C. Owens from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, Joe Don Looney, Lou Kirouac and 1965 sixth round pick (#71-Bob Felts / Bobby Felts). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis Colts received 1965 ninth round pick (selection not identified) from Philadelphia Eagles for Herm McKee. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Cleveland Browns received 1964 sixth round pick (undisclosed) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Jim McCusker. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
Indianapolis Colts received Guy Reese from Dallas Cowboys for Jim Colvin / Rocky Colvin. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Minnesota Vikings received Palmer Pyle from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Steve Stonebreaker. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1965 fourth round pick (#49-Marty Schottenheimer) from Washington for J.W. Lockett. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Baltimore acquired veteran kicker Jim Martin from Detroit on September 3, 1963, for the 1964 tenth-round choice that became No. 134 Glenn Holton. Martin immediately scored 104 points for the Colts, making 24 field goals in 39 attempts and leading the NFL in field goals made. Holton was drafted by Detroit but never appeared in an NFL regular-season game, creating a decisive one-season value advantage for the Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Raymond Berry from San Francisco 49ers for 1965 third round pick (#42-Jack Chapple). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Baltimore sent its 1964 third-round pick to Dallas for running back J.W. Lockett. Colts materials confirm the third-rounder went to the Cowboys and note that Dallas later dealt the selection, but the surviving draft histories do not cleanly establish which player should be credited to this exact transaction. Lockett gave Baltimore one season of modest production, making the realized value on both sides fairly limited.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Dick Bielski from Cardinals Cowboys for 1963 third round pick (#33-Mike Fracchia). The recorded outcome favors Cardinals Cowboys.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1962 fifth round pick (#61-Jerry Croft) from Pittsburgh Steelers for undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Gary Glick from Washington for 1962 sixth round pick (probably #79-John Sutro). The recorded outcome favors Washington.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Lenny Lyles from San Francisco 49ers for cash. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1962 high draft pick (selection not identified) from Pittsburgh Steelers for John Sample / Johnny Sample. The recorded outcome favors Pittsburgh Steelers.
Baltimore traded defensive back Johnny Sample to Pittsburgh for the future second-round choice that became No. 24 overall in 1963, Butch Wilson. Sample immediately started all 14 games for the Steelers in 1961 and intercepted eight passes, then started six more games in 1962. Wilson gave Baltimore five seasons of role-player service, but Pittsburgh received the more impactful peak return.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1962 undisclosed draft pick (selection not identified) from Philadelphia Eagles for Jerry Richardson (Johnson). The recorded outcome favors Philadelphia Eagles.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Jerry Richardson (Johnson) from New York Giants for draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration, Jerry Richardson (Johnson) and draft pick (selection not identified) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, John Guzik and Jerry Richardson (Johnson). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Pittsburgh Steelers received Madison Nutter/ Buzz Nutter and Gene Lipscomb from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Jim Orr / Jimmy Orr, Joe Lewis and Dick Campbell. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis Colts received Tom Gunderman from Washington for Vince Scott. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Green Bay sent quarterback Lamar McHan to Baltimore for the Colts' 1962 fifth-round selection, No. 65 overall, which became Chuck Morris. Packers draft histories tie that pick directly to McHan; the additional 1964 third-rounder previously attached to the deal is not supported by the stronger team materials. McHan served as Johnny Unitas' backup for parts of three seasons, while Morris never played a regular-season NFL game for Green Bay.
Baltimore acquired Hall of Fame fullback Joe Perry from San Francisco in February 1961 for a conditional 1962 20th-round selection. Perry immediately became the Colts' leading rusher, gaining 675 yards in 1961 and adding 359 more in 1962. The 49ers surrendered an aging legend, but the extremely late conditional return never approached the two useful seasons Baltimore received.
Baltimore acquired defensive lineman Billy Ray Smith Sr. from Pittsburgh for defensive back Jackie Simpson on January 25, 1961. Smith became a long-term Colts mainstay, appearing in 124 regular-season games for Baltimore and starting 75, with a career that extended through the Super Bowl V championship season. Simpson gave Pittsburgh 21 games and five starts across two seasons. The longevity gap makes Baltimore the decisive winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received E.A. Sims from Pittsburgh Steelers for undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Baltimore sent its 1961 first-round selection to San Francisco for tight end Dee Mackey, and the 49ers used the No. 11 pick on UCLA quarterback Billy Kilmer. Mackey never produced a regular-season receiving line for the Colts, while Kilmer became a useful multi-position 49er and later a long-term NFL starting quarterback. The first-round return gives San Francisco the decisive advantage.
Baltimore converted aging veteran Bert Rechichar into Pittsburgh’s 1961 fifth-round selection and used No. 62 on Auburn’s Ed Dyas. The pick carried developmental upside, but Dyas never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. Rechichar’s Steelers tenure was also short—six games and three starts in 1960—so this was a low-value exchange overall. Pittsburgh’s limited on-field service is enough to give the Steelers the edge.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1962 ninth round pick (#116-Roy Walker) from Dallas Cowboys for Don Perkins (Anthony). The recorded outcome favors Dallas Cowboys.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1960 tenth round pick (#112-Ernie Barnes) from Washington for Hanson Churchwell. The recorded outcome favors Washington.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Alex Hawkins from Green Bay Packers for cash. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1960 ninth round pick (#106-Don Perkins (Anthony)) (awarded 1962 ninth round pick (#116-Roy Walker) after Perkins was ruled property of Cowboys) from Philadelphia Eagles for Jimmy Carr. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and George Shaw from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, 1960 second round pick (#24-Marvin Terrel) and 1961 first round pick (probably #11-Bill Kilmer / Billy Kilmer. The recorded outcome favors New York Giants.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Marv Matuszak from Green Bay Packers for Fred Thurston / Fuzzy Thurston. The recorded outcome favors Green Bay Packers.
Indianapolis Colts received Leo Sanford from Arizona Cardinals for Dale Meinert. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Baltimore acquired defensive lineman Ray Krouse from Detroit on July 17, 1958 for a 1959 third-round pick, No. 36 overall Ron Luciano. Krouse immediately joined a Colts defense that won back-to-back NFL championships in 1958 and 1959 and remained with Baltimore through 1959. Luciano never produced comparable NFL value for Detroit, flipping the original assessment decisively toward the Colts.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration and Dick Yelverton. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and 1958 fifth round pick (#58-Bobby Joe Conrad) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration and Henry Moore (a). The recorded outcome favors New York Giants.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1958 seventh round pick (#79-John Sample / Johnny Sample) from Pittsburgh Steelers for Dick Young. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1958 fifth round pick (#50-Ray Brown (Lloyd)) from Arizona Cardinals for Tom Finnin. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received 1957 16th round pick (#185-Joe Cannavino) from Pittsburgh Steelers for Charles Shepard / Charley Shephard / Charlie Shephard. The recorded outcome favors Pittsburgh Steelers.
Indianapolis Colts received Dick Young from Arizona Cardinals for Tom Keane. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record) from Los Angeles Rams for 1955 fourth round pick (selection not identified) and 1955 tenth round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis Colts received Don Joyce (b. 1929-10-08) from Arizona Cardinals for Bill Lange and draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Gary Kerkorian from Los Angeles Rams for 1955 tenth round pick (#112-Jesse Arnelle). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Jim Winkler and undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record) from Los Angeles Rams for James Kincaid and Tom Feamster. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record) from Green Bay Packers for Tom Allman / Tommy Allman. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for undisclosed consideration, 1955 fourth round pick (#44-Jack Patera) and 1955 ninth round pick (#104-Bill Evans (a)). The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and Ray Pelfrey from Indianapolis Colts for undisclosed consideration and Tom Finnin. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Los Angeles Rams received rights to Jim Sears from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for draft pick (not exercised). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Fred Enke Jr. from Philadelphia Eagles for George Musacco. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Dick Barwegan / Dick Barwegen, Bob Williams (a) and Paul Nestor from Chicago Bears for Andy Hillhouse and "high" draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Bobby Williams (a), Dick Barwegen and Paul Nestor from Chicago Bears for 1954 draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Tom Cosgrove from Cleveland Browns for 1954 sixth round pick (#64-Jim Ray Smith). The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Harry Agganis, Dick Batten, Gern Nagler, Bert Rechichar, Ed Sharkey, Stu Sheetz, Don Shula, Art Spinney, Carl Taseff and Elmer Willhoite from Cleveland Browns for Tom Catlin, Don Colo, Herschel Forester / Herschel Forrester, Mike McCormack and John Petitbon. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
Detroit Lions received Dick Hoerner from Indianapolis Colts for Tom Dublinski. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Bill Lange and Tom Kalmanir / Tommy Kalmanir from Los Angeles Rams for undisclosed terms (details not specified in source record). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Chicago reacquired George Blanda from Baltimore on September 20, 1950, for a reported $500 after the Colts had placed him on waivers. Contemporary Green Bay reporting says Baltimore withdrew the waiver claim process and Halas bought Blanda back; Pro Football Archives records Blanda's return to Chicago on September 20. He then remained with the Bears for years, making the small cash return a poor long-term exchange for Baltimore.
Chicago sent George Blanda, Bob Perina, Ernie Zalejski, Jim Crawford and Bob Jensen to Baltimore in September 1950. The Bears subsequently received standout guard Dick Barwegan and the rights to retired tackle Dub Garrett. Barwegan became a first-team All-Pro for Chicago, while Blanda was back with the Bears within weeks and the other Baltimore arrivals did not create comparable lasting value, leaving Chicago ahead.
Baltimore acquired fullback Jim Spavital from Chicago on August 27, 1950, sending the Bears its 1951 first-round choice. Spavital started nine games for the Colts and produced 484 yards from scrimmage with three touchdowns. Chicago then used the No. 2 overall pick on quarterback Bob Williams, whose NFL career totaled 981 passing yards and 10 touchdowns. The realized returns were much closer than the premium draft slot suggests.
Cleveland Browns received 1951 ninth round pick (undisclosed) from Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts for Jim Brasher. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
Cleveland signed rookie quarterback Y.A. Tittle before the 1948 AAFC season, but league commissioner Jonas Ingram shifted him to Baltimore as part of a talent-balancing program. Transaction histories date Tittle's move to April 14, 1948. This was not a normal negotiated trade for Cleveland compensation, and Charley O'Rourke came to Baltimore from the Los Angeles Dons rather than from Cleveland.
Cleveland Browns acquired player(s) to be named later (undisclosed) from Baltimore/Indianapolis Colts for Ernie Blandin. Cleveland Browns received the stronger long-term football value, matching the Cleveland Browns Win verdict.