Baltimore acquired quarterback Marty Domres from San Diego in…
Baltimore acquired quarterback Marty Domres from San Diego in August 1972 for tight end John Andrews and the 1973 first-round pick Baltimore had obtained from Washington. San Diego used that selection at No. 25 on Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Rodgers, while Domres became the Colts’ primary starter during a turbulent 1972 season.
Indianapolis Colts Received
- player Marty Domres
Los Angeles Chargers Received
- player John Andrews (Milton)
- pick 1973 first round pick (#25-Johnny Rodgers)
Trade Analysis
What the Trade Actually Did
Baltimore acquired quarterback Marty Domres from San Diego in August 1972 for tight end John Andrews and the 1973 first-round pick Baltimore had obtained from Washington. San Diego used that selection at No. 25 on Heisman Trophy winner Johnny Rodgers, while Domres became the Colts’ primary starter during a turbulent 1972 season.
Why the Deal Made Sense
Baltimore needed a succession option behind Johnny Unitas, and Domres did start nine games in 1972. That immediate role gives the Colts tangible value rather than making the trade a pure draft-pick loss. San Diego extracted a first-round pick plus Andrews from a quarterback who was blocked by John Hadl. From an asset-management perspective, that was an excellent return.
What the Return Became
Rodgers did not become an immediate NFL star, which narrows the hindsight margin considerably. The theoretical value of a first-round pick was stronger than the eventual on-field payoff.
Why the Value Separated
San Diego still holds the edge because it converted a surplus quarterback into premium capital and a veteran player. Baltimore received needed quarterback snaps, but the organizational instability of the period limited the long-term return.
Final Verdict
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers Win. The final grades reflect realized production, longevity, acquisition cost and the value of the draft capital that changed hands. Indianapolis Colts receives C and Los Angeles Chargers receives B+.
How the Hindsight Standard Applies
This verdict does not assume that every draft choice should have produced a star. It compares what each club surrendered with the actual careers, roster roles and flexibility created by the exchange. That keeps the judgment centered on historical value rather than reputation alone.