Indianapolis and Philadelphia made a straight…
Indianapolis and Philadelphia made a straight player-for-player swap in March 2013, with fullback Stanley Havili going to the Colts and defensive lineman Clifton Geathers joining the Eagles. Each filled a one-season role. Havili appeared in 13 games with eight starts and added 128 receiving yards for Indianapolis, while Geathers played all 16 games as a reserve for Philadelphia. Neither became a long-term piece, making the exchange essentially even.
Indianapolis Colts Received
- player Stanley Havili
Philadelphia Eagles Received
- player Clifton Geathers
Trade Analysis
Why the Deal Happened
The Eagles were transitioning to Chip Kelly’s offense, where a traditional fullback was expected to have a reduced role. Indianapolis, by contrast, wanted a true fullback for its evolving run game. The teams matched needs in a direct swap: Stanley Havili went to the Colts, and defensive lineman Clifton Geathers went to Philadelphia.
What Each Side Received
Havili appeared in 13 games and started eight for Indianapolis in 2013. He carried only seven times but caught 18 passes for 128 yards and a touchdown, while also handling blocking duties. Geathers appeared in all 16 games for Philadelphia as a reserve, recording 26 tackles and contributing rotational snaps along the defensive front.
How the Return Aged
Neither player developed into a long-term piece for the acquiring team. Havili’s 2013 season was his only regular-season campaign with Indianapolis. Geathers became a free agent after the year and signed with Washington. The useful value on each side was therefore concentrated in a single season.
Why the Margin Matters
The roles were different but comparable in scale. Indianapolis filled a specific schematic need and received eight starts. Philadelphia acquired a large defensive lineman who stayed available all season and supplied depth without requiring draft capital. There is not enough separation in playing time, impact or longevity to reward one team over the other.
Final Verdict
Even Trade. Indianapolis and Philadelphia each receive a C+. Both front offices converted a player who no longer fit perfectly into a useful one-year contributor at another position. The swap worked as a practical roster adjustment, but neither side created the sustained value necessary for a higher grade or directional verdict.