Los Angeles sent Andy Robustelli to the Giants in July 1956…
Los Angeles sent Andy Robustelli to the Giants in July 1956 for New York's 1957 first-round pick, later used on Del Shofner. Robustelli immediately helped New York win the 1956 NFL championship and became a Hall of Fame defensive leader. Los Angeles still received major value because Shofner developed into an elite receiver during his Rams tenure.
Los Angeles Rams Received
- pick 1957 first round pick (#11- Del Shofner )
New York Giants Received
- player Andy Robustelli
Trade Analysis
What the Trade Did
The Rams traded Andy Robustelli to New York in July 1956 for the Giants' first-round selection in the 1957 draft. Los Angeles used that choice at No. 11 on Del Shofner. The basic exchange therefore paired a proven elite defensive end with a premium pick that produced a high-level receiver, making this one of the rare historical trades in which both sides can point to major realized value.
Why the Giants Still Won
Robustelli's impact in New York was immediate and sustained. The Giants won the 1956 NFL championship in his first season, and he became a leader of the defense for nine years. The Hall of Fame credits him with seven Pro Bowls, seven All-NFL selections and appearances in eight NFL title games over his full career. New York was acquiring an established star at exactly the right point in its competitive cycle.
How the Rams Recovered Value
The old D+ grade ignored what the pick became. Shofner developed into one of the league's best receivers, including a 1,097-yard season in 1958, and his production gave Los Angeles genuine star-level return. That does not erase Robustelli's championship influence, but it means the Rams were not merely the team that gave away a Hall of Famer. They converted him into an elite first-round talent.
Final Verdict
New York receives an A+ because Robustelli became a championship centerpiece and franchise legend. Los Angeles rises to A- because the first-rounder became Del Shofner, a premier receiver rather than a failed pick. The Giants still win on longevity, leadership and championship impact, but this should be remembered as a productive trade for both organizations.
Robustelli became a Hall of Fame Giants leader and immediate champion, while Shofner also developed into an elite receiver and major Rams return, overall in the seasons that followed.