NFL Trade Verdict

The 2010 Dez Bryant-Devin McCourty Trade: Both Teams Found Franchise Players

Dallas moved from No. 27 to No. 24 for Dez Bryant, while New England dropped three spots for Devin McCourty and added a third-round pick. Both clubs landed players who defined the next decade.

Dallas Cowboys Received

  • pick 2010 1st round pick (24th overall, Dez Bryant )
  • pick 2010 4th round pick (119th overall subsequently traded, A.J. Edds )

New England Patriots Received

  • pick 2010 1st round pick (27th overall, Devin McCourty)
  • pick 2010 3rd round pick (90th overall, Taylor Price)

Trade Summary

Dallas moved from No. 27 to No. 24 and drafted Dez Bryant, who became the franchise's career leader in receiving touchdowns. New England moved down and selected Devin McCourty, a long-term captain and centerpiece of three Super Bowl champions, while also receiving a third-round pick. Both teams converted the exchange into a franchise-defining player.

Trade Analysis

What the Trade Actually Did

Dallas sent the 27th pick and a third-round selection, No. 90, to New England for picks No. 24 and No. 119. The Cowboys used No. 24 on wide receiver Dez Bryant. New England used No. 27 on defensive back Devin McCourty and No. 90 on receiver Taylor Price. Dallas later moved the fourth-rounder in another transaction.

Why Dallas Was Right to Move Up

Bryant became one of the most productive receivers in Cowboys history. He developed into a dominant red-zone target, earned All-Pro recognition and set the franchise career record for receiving touchdowns. Dallas gave up only three draft slots plus a third-rounder to secure a player who became an offensive centerpiece.

Why New England Was Also Right

McCourty became even more durable. He spent all 13 NFL seasons with New England, served as a team captain for 12 of them and was part of three Super Bowl championship teams. The Patriots drafted him after moving down and also gained an additional third-round selection, exactly the kind of asset-efficiency trade New England often sought.

The Transaction Is Better Than Its Winner Label

Most draft-day moves produce a clear regret for one side. This one did not. Bryant's peak as a receiver justified Dallas' aggression. McCourty's longevity, leadership and championship résumé justified New England's trade-down.

The Long-Term Legacy

The extra pieces did not determine the deal. The two first-round selections did, and both teams hit.

Final Verdict

An Even Trade is the most accurate interpretation. Dallas acquired a franchise receiver; New England acquired a 13-year defensive leader and extra capital. Each team executed its preferred strategy and received elite long-term value.

Sources