Jacksonville sent Tank Bigsby to Philadelphia in September…

The Exchange

Philadelphia acquired Tank Bigsby from Jacksonville after Week 1 of the 2025 season and sent a 2026 fifth-round pick plus a 2026 sixth-round pick in return. The move gave the Eagles another experienced runner and return option. Jacksonville, meanwhile, chose draft flexibility over keeping a third-year back whose role had become less central to its long-term plan.

Jacksonville Jaguars Return

Jacksonville sent Tank Bigsby to Philadelphia in September 2025 for a 2026 fifth-round pick and a 2026 sixth-round pick. The Eagles added a proven young runner and kick-return option behind Saquon Barkley, while the Jaguars converted a crowded backfield asset into two future selections that later carried identifiable draft value.

Philadelphia Eagles Return

Philadelphia acquired Tank Bigsby for 2026 fifth- and sixth-round choices, adding experienced depth to a championship-caliber roster. Bigsby remained useful enough to stay in the Eagles' plans, but paying two selections for a reserve running back created a demanding value threshold. Jacksonville's ability to turn him into two picks gives the Jaguars the stronger return.

Value in Hindsight

The Eagles could justify the deal because their roster was built to contend immediately and depth mattered more than hoarding every late-round selection. Jacksonville was operating from a different position and extracted unusually good capital for a player it could replace internally. That asymmetry is why both sides can defend the move while the value grade still leans clearly toward the Jaguars.

Final Verdict

Jacksonville Jaguars Win. Jacksonville earns a B+ for turning a non-core running back into two future draft choices without carrying the risk of a diminished role. Philadelphia receives a C+ because Bigsby was a useful and credible addition, but the combined fifth- and sixth-round cost was rich for depth. The Jaguars captured the cleaner surplus value.