NFL Trade Verdict

Atlanta acquired veteran offensive lineman Guy Bingham from…

Atlanta acquired veteran offensive lineman Guy Bingham from the Jets in September 1989 for a 1990 seventh-round pick, No. 167. Bingham spent three seasons with Atlanta and provided veteran line depth, but the Jets turned the late selection into Dwayne White. The longer downstream value attached to White gives New York the stronger hindsight return.

New York Jets Received

  • pick 1990 seventh round pick (#167-Dwayne White)

Trade Analysis

The Exchange

Atlanta acquired offensive lineman Guy Bingham from the New York Jets on September 4, 1989. The Jets received Atlanta's 1990 seventh-round choice, later identified as No. 167, Dwayne White. The transaction was a classic veteran-for-late-pick move, with Atlanta prioritizing immediate depth and New York taking future draft value. Atlanta Falcons Return Bingham gave Atlanta useful veteran service across three seasons. For a seventh-round price, that is a reasonable outcome because the Falcons received a player capable of contributing immediately rather than waiting on a long-shot selection. The return was functional, but it did not become a major long-term building block or create enough surplus value to dominate the trade. New York Jets Return New York converted an older lineman into a draft choice and used the selection on Dwayne White. Even though seventh-round picks are uncertain, the Jets extracted a future asset from a player they were willing to move. White's longer career gives the selection more lasting value than a typical late-round return and provides the stronger hindsight case on the Jets side. Value in Hindsight Both teams received something useful. Atlanta bought three seasons of veteran line help at a low price, while New York secured a late pick that became a player with a longer runway. The distinction is not large enough for an extreme grade spread, but the Jets achieved more durable value from an asset that otherwise might have produced little future return. Final Verdict New York earns a B- and Atlanta a C. The Falcons received fair short-term service from Bingham, while the Jets turned him into a selection with better long-term value. This is a modest Jets win built on durability rather than a lopsided exchange.

Sources