NFL Trade Verdict

Pittsburgh Steelers Win

Summary: Pittsburgh acquired veteran pass rusher Preston Smith from Green Bay for a seventh-round pick. Smith provided experienced edge depth for Pittsburgh's defensive line. Analysis: Preston Smith, a veteran with double-digit sack seasons on his resume, came at the cost of a seventh-round pick — minimal draft capital for a legitimate edge presence. Even in a depth role, Smith's experience and pass-rush knowledge justify the cost. Original "Green Bay Packers Win" overstates Green Bay's gain (a late seventh) versus Pittsburgh receiving a veteran contributor. Upgrading to slight Steelers edge.

November 5, 2024 Pittsburgh SteelersGreen Bay Packers Confidence: medium Tier: major

Green Bay Packers Received

Trade Summary

Summary: Pittsburgh acquired veteran pass rusher Preston Smith from Green Bay for a seventh-round pick. Smith provided experienced edge depth for Pittsburgh's defensive line. Analysis: Preston Smith, a veteran with double-digit sack seasons on his resume, came at the cost of a seventh-round pick — minimal draft capital for a legitimate edge presence. Even in a depth role, Smith's experience and pass-rush knowledge justify the cost. Original "Green Bay Packers Win" overstates Green Bay's gain (a late seventh) versus Pittsburgh receiving a veteran contributor. Upgrading to slight Steelers edge.

Trade Analysis

Summary: Pittsburgh acquired veteran pass rusher Preston Smith from Green Bay for a seventh-round pick. Smith provided experienced edge depth for Pittsburgh's defensive line. Analysis: Preston Smith, a veteran with double-digit sack seasons on his resume, came at the cost of a seventh-round pick — minimal draft capital for a legitimate edge presence. Even in a depth role, Smith's experience and pass-rush knowledge justify the cost. Original "Green Bay Packers Win" overstates Green Bay's gain (a late seventh) versus Pittsburgh receiving a veteran contributor. Upgrading to slight Steelers edge. Green Bay Packers received 2025 7th round pick (237th overall, Micah Robinson) and gave up Preston Smith. The partner grade reflects the same value curve from the opposite side of the transaction.