New Orleans traded running back Tony Baker to Philadelphia on…
New Orleans traded running back Tony Baker to Philadelphia on October 27, 1971 for the 1972 fourth-round pick that became linebacker Joe Federspiel. Federspiel became one of the most durable defenders in early Saints history, starting 111 games for New Orleans from 1972 through 1980. Baker gave Philadelphia 18 games and six starts across two seasons, making the long-term value overwhelmingly favor the Saints.
New Orleans Saints Received
- pick 1972 4th round pick (99th overall, Joe Federspiel)
Philadelphia Eagles Received
- player Tony Baker
Trade Analysis
The Midseason Exchange
Philadelphia acquired veteran running back Tony Baker from New Orleans on October 27, 1971. The Saints received the Eagles' 1972 fourth-round draft choice, which became No. 99 overall. New Orleans used that selection on Kentucky linebacker Joe Federspiel, creating one of the strongest long-term returns in this group of historical trades.
Baker's Eagles Tenure
Baker joined Philadelphia during the 1971 season and appeared in five games, carrying 17 times for 49 yards and catching four passes for 36 yards. In 1972 he played 13 games with six starts, rushing 90 times for 322 yards and adding 16 catches for 114 yards. He was a useful backfield piece, but his Eagles tenure ended after that second season.
Federspiel's Longevity
Federspiel immediately became part of the Saints' defense. He started 10 games as a rookie in 1972 and remained a regular starter through 1980. Saints historical records credit him with 130 games and 111 starts for New Orleans over nine seasons; his NFL career continued for one final year with Baltimore. He also recorded multiple interceptions and became a durable centerpiece during a difficult era for the franchise.
Why the Pick Dominates
Philadelphia received a short-term runner who contributed, so its side was not empty. New Orleans, however, converted one fourth-round selection into nearly a decade of starting linebacker play. The difference in games, starts and organizational longevity is enormous.
Final Verdict
New Orleans Saints Win. The Saints earn an A-plus for turning a fourth-rounder into a nine-season defensive fixture. Philadelphia earns a C-plus because Baker supplied meaningful 1972 production, but 18 games of backfield work cannot approach Federspiel's sustained starting value.
Joe Federspiel became a nine-season Saints fixture with 111 starts, vastly exceeding Tony Baker's 18 Philadelphia games and six starts across two seasons after the transaction for New Orleans.