New Orleans Saints
Trade grades, verdicts, asset movement, and historical context for New Orleans Saints franchise trades.
Browse Trades by Era
Choose a decade to view the complete public trade record.
Select an era above.
The selected New Orleans Saints public trade archive will appear here.
New Orleans Saints
The Deion Jones-Zamir White trade moved from a slight San Francisco win to an even result after both acquired players failed to make their new teams’ initial rosters. The 49ers released Jones on August 30, while the Saints terminated White’s contract the same day. Neither club surrendered draft capital, so the downside is limited, but neither side extracted regular-season roster value from the player it received.
New Orleans Saints acquired Tyree Wilson and 2026 7th round pick (219th overall, TJ Hall) from Las Vegas Raiders for 2026 5th round pick (150th overall, Dalton Johnson). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans Saints acquired a 2028 6th round pick from Houston Texans for Kai Kroeger and a 2028 7th round pick. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Los Angeles Chargers acquired Trevor Penning from New Orleans Saints for a 2027 6th round pick. The overall result favors Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers over Los Angeles Chargers.
New Orleans acquired Ja'Lynn Polk and a 2028 seventh-round pick from New England for a 2027 sixth. Polk was already unavailable for the 2025 season because of a shoulder injury and never played a regular-season snap for the Saints; he was placed on the Reserve/Retired list in August 2026. New England therefore improved from a future seventh to a sixth while moving a player who produced no Saints on-field return.
New Orleans Saints acquired Asim Richards and a 2028 7th round pick from Dallas Cowboys for a 2028 6th round pick. New Orleans Saints received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New Orleans Saints Win verdict.
Denver traded receiver Devaughn Vele to New Orleans for a 2026 fourth-round pick and a 2027 seventh-rounder. Vele caught 25 passes for 293 yards and two touchdowns in 13 games for the Saints in 2025, while Denver's fourth-round asset became pick No. 108 and Jonah Coleman. Turning a former seventh-round receiver into a fourth plus a future seventh gives Denver a B; New Orleans receives a C+.
New Orleans Saints acquired Davon Godchaux from New England Patriots for 2026 7th round pick (224th overall subsequently traded, Robert Spears-Jennings). The overall result favors New England Patriots over New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans sent Marshon Lattimore and a 2025 fifth-round pick to Washington for third-, fourth- and sixth-round selections. Those picks became Jonas Sanker, Quincy Riley and Devin Neal, and Sanker quickly emerged as a 16-game starting safety with two interceptions in 2025. Lattimore helped Washington during its 2024 NFC Championship run but played only 11 regular-season games for the Commanders through 2025. The younger, multi-player return now favors New Orleans.
New Orleans acquired defensive tackle John Ridgeway and Washington's 2025 seventh-round pick for the Saints' 2025 sixth-round pick, a modest pick-down used to add immediate line depth. Ridgeway played a rotational role for New Orleans, while Washington gained the better draft slot and later retained flexibility with that asset. Neither side created a large value gap, so an even result with slightly positive grades fits the exchange.
New Orleans moved up from No. 45 to No. 41 for Kool-Aid McKinstry, sending Green Bay additional picks at Nos. 168 and 190. McKinstry developed into a high-level starter with 17 pass breakups and three interceptions in 2025, while the Packers landed Edgerrin Cooper at No. 45 plus two extra assets. Both teams found substantial value, but Green Bay's larger return earns the narrow win.
Denver Broncos acquired Wil Lutz from New Orleans Saints for 2024 7th round pick (239th overall, Josiah Ezirim). The stronger recorded return sits with Denver Broncos, matching the Denver Broncos Win verdict.
Denver Broncos acquired Adam Trautman and 2023 7th round pick (257th overall, Alex Forsyth) from New Orleans Saints for 2023 6th round pick (195th overall, A.T. Perry). The stronger recorded return sits with Denver Broncos, matching the Denver Broncos Win verdict.
Jacksonville Jaguars acquired 2023 7th round pick (227th overall, Raymond Vohasek) and 2024 4th round pick (116th overall, Jordan Jefferson) from New Orleans Saints for 2023 4th round pick (127th overall, Jake Haener). Jacksonville Jaguars received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Jacksonville Jaguars Win verdict.
New Orleans moved up to pick No. 103 in the 2023 draft and selected guard Nick Saldiveri, sending Chicago picks No. 115 and No. 165. The Bears turned those selections into running back Roschon Johnson and cornerback Terell Smith. Both Chicago players supplied more sustained regular-season value than Saldiveri through the first three seasons, giving the Bears the stronger two-player return.
Denver sent New Orleans a 2023 first-round pick and a 2024 second for the rights to hire Sean Payton, receiving Payton and a 2024 third in return. After an 8-9 debut, Payton led Denver to consecutive playoff berths, a 14-3 record, the 2025 AFC West title and an AFC Championship Game appearance. New Orleans used the first-rounder on Bryan Bresee and leveraged the second-rounder in another trade. Both sides gained value, but Denver’s franchise turnaround now wins.
Philadelphia acquired C.J. Gardner-Johnson and a seventh-round pick for fifth- and sixth-round selections. Gardner-Johnson tied for the league lead with six interceptions despite missing time and helped the Eagles reach Super Bowl LVII. New Orleans recovered limited draft value while surrendering a versatile defender at the start of his prime.
New Orleans moved from No. 16 to No. 11 in 2022 for Chris Olave, sending Washington third- and fourth-round picks in the process. Olave has 291 catches for 3,728 yards and 19 touchdowns through four seasons, earned second-team All-Pro honors in 2025 and signed a new extension in 2026. Washington received meaningful value from Jahan Dotson and Brian Robinson Jr., but Olave became the best player in the transaction.
New Orleans acquired two 2022 first-round slots and used one on Trevor Penning, while Philadelphia received a future first, a future second, and additional selections. The 2023 first became the No. 10 pick that Philadelphia used in the move for Jalen Carter. The Eagles converted patience into premium, championship-level roster value.
New Orleans reacquired Mark Ingram from Houston for a future seventh-round pick, bringing back a franchise favorite at minimal cost. Ingram rushed for 260 yards and caught 20 passes for 138 yards in seven Saints games in 2021 while becoming the franchise's career rushing leader. Houston eventually used the 2024 pick on Solomon Byrd, who appeared in one game as a rookie. The Saints received more useful football value.
New Orleans acquired cornerback Bradley Roby from Houston in September 2021, sending the Texans a 2022 third-round pick and a 2023 sixth-rounder. Roby gave the Saints experienced secondary help, but the stay was relatively short. Houston recovered two future selections, including a day-two pick, for a veteran on a rebuilding roster. The amount and flexibility of that draft return give the Texans the edge.
Indianapolis Colts acquired 2021 6th round pick (218th overall, Sam Ehlinger) and 2021 7th round pick (229th overall, Mike Strachan) from New Orleans Saints for 2021 6th round pick (206th overall, Landon Young). Indianapolis Colts received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
Denver traded pick No. 76 to New Orleans for picks 98 and 105, selecting Quinn Meinerz and Baron Browning. Meinerz became a first-team All-Pro guard and signed a long-term extension, while Browning developed into a useful edge defender before Denver later traded him. New Orleans used No. 76 on Paulson Adebo, who started 51 games in four seasons and became a coveted free agent. Both teams hit, but Meinerz makes Denver's two-player return exceptional.
Jacksonville Jaguars acquired Malcom Brown from New Orleans Saints for 2021 7th round pick (229th overall subsequently traded, Mike Strachan). The overall result favors New Orleans Saints over Jacksonville Jaguars.
San Francisco traded Kwon Alexander to New Orleans for Kiko Alonso and a fifth-round pick that became Deommodore Lenoir. The Saints got linebacker help, but Lenoir became the best long-term asset. San Francisco wins the trade.
Houston acquired 2021 6th round pick (212th overall subsequently traded, Damar Hamlin) from New Orleans Saints for 2020 7th round pick (240th overall, Tommy Stevens).
Minnesota sent New Orleans pick No. 105, which became tight end Adam Trautman, and received four later selections that became James Lynch, Harrison Hand, Blake Brandel and Nate Stanley. Trautman developed into a useful Saints tight end, but Brandel became a long-term Vikings lineman and eventual starter, while Lynch and Hand added supporting snaps. Minnesota's broader return produced slightly more lasting value.
New Orleans moved up to No. 74 for linebacker Zack Baun and also received pick No. 244, while Cleveland acquired No. 88 and a 2021 third-rounder. Baun never became a full-time defensive centerpiece during four Saints seasons, and his later All-Pro breakthrough came after he left for Philadelphia. Cleveland received useful snaps from Jordan Elliott, but Anthony Schwartz added little, leaving the direct results close.
New Orleans Saints
Miami and New Orleans swapped linebackers immediately after the 2019 roster cutdown, with the Dolphins receiving Vince Biegel and the Saints acquiring veteran Kiko Alonso. The deal exchanged a younger reserve for a more established starter as both teams adjusted their linebacker rooms. The Miami Dolphins produced the stronger realized return, supporting the Miami Dolphins Win verdict.
New Orleans moved up from No. 116 to No. 105 in the fourth round of the 2019 draft, sending the Jets picks No. 116 and No. 168. The Saints selected defensive back C.J. Gardner-Johnson, while New York quickly used the incoming capital in another trade with Tennessee. The New Orleans Saints produced the stronger realized return, supporting the New Orleans Saints Win verdict.
Miami traded down from No. 48 and received No. 62, No. 202 and a 2020 second-rounder. The Dolphins later used No. 62 in the Josh Rosen deal, drafted Isaiah Prince at 202 and selected Raekwon Davis at No. 56 in 2020. Those returns produced some value, but they did not match New Orleans' long-term payoff from Erik McCoy.
New Orleans Saints acquired Eli Apple from New York Giants for 2019 4th round pick (132nd overall subsequently traded, Ugo Amadi) and 2020 7th round pick (238th overall, T.J. Brunson). The overall result favors New York Giants over New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints acquired 2019 7th round pick (231st overall, Alize Mack) from Cleveland Browns for Devaroe Lawrence. New Orleans Saints received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New Orleans Saints Win verdict.
New Orleans acquired Teddy Bridgewater and a 2019 sixth-round pick from the Jets for a 2019 third-rounder. Bridgewater became Drew Brees' backup and delivered the trade's defining value in 2019, going 5-0 as the starter while Brees recovered from a thumb injury. The Saints also retained the sixth-round selection, while New York later used the incoming third-round capital in another draft-day move.
New Orleans paid picks No. 27 and 147 plus its 2019 first-rounder to jump to No. 14 for Marcus Davenport. Davenport flashed high-end ability and totaled 21.5 sacks in five Saints seasons, including nine in 2021, but injuries repeatedly limited his availability. Green Bay used the return as flexible capital in moves that helped produce Jaire Alexander in 2018 and Darnell Savage in 2019, giving the Packers the stronger long-term value.
New Orleans moved Adrian Peterson after four games in a crowded backfield and received a conditional 2018 sixth-round pick that became No. 189, used on Kamrin Moore. Arizona needed a runner after David Johnson's injury and got six starts, 448 rushing yards and two touchdowns from Peterson. The Cardinals received the more useful direct return, although the short stay keeps the margin modest.
Philadelphia acquired 2019 7th round pick (draft pick voluntarily returned by Eagles after Dorenbos failed his physical due to a pre-existing condition) from New Orleans Saints for Jon Dorenbos.
New Orleans sent pick No. 229 and a 2018 second-rounder to San Francisco for pick No. 67, then selected Alvin Kamara. Kamara became one of the defining players of the Saints' modern era, earning five straight Pro Bowls to begin his career and setting major franchise rushing marks. San Francisco found some value in Adrian Colbert and later draft maneuvering, but nothing close to Kamara's impact.
New Orleans sent Brandin Cooks and a fourth-round pick to New England for the final first-round pick and a third-rounder. The Saints drafted Ryan Ramczyk and Trey Hendrickson, landing an All-Pro right tackle and a pass rusher who broke out with 13.5 sacks in 2020. New England still received 1,082 yards from Cooks and later flipped him for a first-round pick, making this a strong transaction for both clubs.
Miami Dolphins acquired a conditional 2017 pick (7th round; did not convey) from New Orleans Saints for Chris McCain. The overall result favors New Orleans Saints over Miami Dolphins.
New Orleans sent No. 152 and a 2017 fifth-rounder to Washington for No. 120 and selected David Onyemata. He became a seven-season Saints defensive-line fixture with more than 100 appearances. Washington used the incoming picks on Matthew Ioannidis and Jeremy Sprinkle; Ioannidis developed into a productive interior pass rusher and Sprinkle supplied several years of tight-end depth. Both teams turned modest capital into real contributors.
New Orleans traded picks No. 78 and 112 to New England for No. 61 and selected safety Vonn Bell. Bell immediately became a major defensive contributor, appearing in 61 games with 45 starts over four Saints seasons. The move worked. It simply ran into an exceptional Patriots return, because New England turned the two selections into Joe Thuney and Malcolm Mitchell.
Washington sent pick No. 167 to New Orleans for pick No. 187 and a 2016 sixth-rounder. The Saints selected cornerback Damian Swann, whose promising rookie year was interrupted by concussions and whose NFL career lasted only seven games. Washington used the immediate pick on Evan Spencer and the future pick on Nate Sudfeld, but neither became a meaningful contributor for the club. With little lasting return on either side, the trade grades out even.
Miami acquired young receiver Kenny Stills from New Orleans for linebacker Dannell Ellerbe and the 78th pick in the 2015 draft. Stills gave the Dolphins four productive seasons and was a legitimate deep threat. The Saints received useful linebacker play from Ellerbe and used No. 78 on defensive back P.J. Williams, who remained with New Orleans for years. Both sides gained value, but the two-piece Saints return lasted longer.
New Orleans turned Jimmy Graham and a fourth-round pick into center Max Unger and the No. 31 selection, used on Stephone Anthony. Seattle still got three productive seasons from Graham, including two double-digit or near-double-digit touchdown campaigns, and the acquired fourth-rounder became part of the package used to move up for Tyler Lockett. Unger's four seasons anchoring the Saints' line give New Orleans the stronger long-term return.
Philadelphia acquired Darren Sproles for a fifth-round pick and received six seasons of multidimensional value. Sproles became an elite punt returner for the Eagles, contributed as a runner and receiver, and earned three Pro Bowl selections during his Philadelphia tenure. New Orleans used pick No. 169 on linebacker Ronald Powell, whose Saints career lasted only one season. The return gap makes this a clear Eagles win.
San Francisco 49ers acquired 2014 7th round pick (242nd overall subsequently traded, Corey Nelson) from New Orleans Saints for Parys Haralson. The overall result favors New Orleans Saints over San Francisco 49ers.
The Jets acquired running back Chris Ivory from New Orleans for the 106th pick in the 2013 draft. Ivory became New York’s primary runner, surpassed 800 rushing yards in each of his first two seasons and broke 1,000 yards in 2015. The Saints combined pick No. 106 with No. 109 to move up for defensive tackle John Jenkins, so their return had value, but Ivory’s three productive Jets seasons were stronger.
Miami acquired Reggie Bush and a later sixth-round pick from New Orleans for safety Jonathon Amaya and a sixth-round pick. Bush immediately delivered the first 1,000-yard rushing season of his career and produced more than 2,600 yards from scrimmage across two Dolphins seasons. Amaya played only briefly for New Orleans, leaving Miami with a strong return for a very modest package.
New Orleans traded its 2011 second-round pick and 2012 first-round pick to New England for No. 28, using it on running back Mark Ingram. Ingram became the Saints' all-time rushing leader and a three-time Pro Bowler. New England got productive back Shane Vereen and later used the future first as part of the move up for pass rusher Chandler Jones. Both teams created substantial value, making this a rare trade that aged well for each side.
Washington sent New Orleans the 72nd pick in the 2011 draft for tackle Jammal Brown and the 155th selection. Brown started 26 games over two seasons, while the fifth-round choice became Niles Paul, who spent six years in Washington and developed into a useful tight end and special-teams player. New Orleans selected Martez Wilson at No. 72, but his impact never matched Washington's combined return.
Jacksonville Jaguars acquired 2011 4th round pick (121st overall, Chris Prosinski) from New Orleans Saints for 2010 5th round pick (158th overall, Matt Tennant). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans Saints
New Orleans acquired tight end David Thomas from New England for a conditional 2011 draft choice that ultimately became the 189th pick in the sixth round. Thomas played 48 games with 25 starts for the Saints and contributed as a versatile receiver and in-line tight end on the Super Bowl XLIV champion. New England later reused the pick, but Thomas' four useful Saints seasons create the stronger return.
New Orleans traded a 2009 seventh-round pick and a 2010 fifth-rounder to Philadelphia for No. 164 and selected punter Thomas Morstead. Morstead spent 12 seasons with the Saints, earned Pro Bowl and second-team All-Pro honors, and became a central special-teams figure on the Super Bowl XLIV champion. Philadelphia retained useful draft capital, but nothing from the return approached Morstead's longevity and franchise impact.
New Orleans acquired Jeremy Shockey from the Giants in 2008 for second- and fifth-round selections in the 2009 draft. Shockey never regained his peak Giants production, but he started on the Saints' 2009 championship team and caught a touchdown in Super Bowl XLIV. New York used the picks on Clint Sintim and Rhett Bomar, neither of whom became a meaningful long-term contributor.
New Orleans acquired pick No. 237 from Green Bay in 2008 and selected wide receiver Adrian Arrington, sending the Packers a 2009 sixth-round choice that became No. 187. Arrington appeared in only five regular-season games for the Saints and caught nine passes for 110 yards. Green Bay used the future pick on defensive back Brandon Underwood, who also had a limited NFL impact, but he gave the Packers more usable roster time than Arrington gave New Orleans.
New Orleans traded picks 10 and 78 to New England for picks 7 and 164, selecting Sedrick Ellis and Carl Nicks. Ellis became a five-year starting defensive tackle, while Nicks developed into a first-team All-Pro guard and Super Bowl champion. New England drafted Jerod Mayo, a Defensive Rookie of the Year and All-Pro linebacker, plus Shawn Crable. Both clubs found premium starters, making this a genuine win-win.
New Orleans acquired linebacker Jonathan Vilma from the Jets in 2008 and later sent New York a 2009 third-round pick after the trade's conditions were met; the Saints also received a 2009 fourth-rounder. Vilma became a defensive captain, made the 2009 Pro Bowl and helped lead the Saints to their Super Bowl XLIV championship. New York gained useful draft value, but New Orleans secured the centerpiece.
New Orleans traded picks 123 and 163 to Houston to move up to No. 107 for running back Antonio Pittman. Pittman did not survive final cuts, leaving the Saints with no regular-season return from the move. Houston used No. 123 on Fred Bennett, who started eight games and intercepted three passes as a rookie, giving the Texans the clear advantage.
New Orleans moved down from No. 58 in the 2007 draft and received picks 66 and 145, selecting safety Usama Young and cornerback David Jones. Detroit used the higher choice on defensive lineman Ikaika Alama-Francis. Young became a useful multi-year Saints defensive back and special-teams player, while Alama-Francis produced limited starting value for Detroit.
Miami sent veteran kicker Olindo Mare to New Orleans for the 199th pick in the 2007 draft, which became guard Drew Mormino. Mare lasted only the 2007 season with the Saints and made 10 of 17 field-goal attempts, while Mormino never appeared in a regular-season game for Miami. Neither club turned the exchange into lasting value.
New Orleans Saints acquired Mark Simoneau and 2007 4th round pick (125th overall, Jermon Bushrod) from Philadelphia Eagles for Donte' Stallworth. New Orleans Saints received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New Orleans Saints Win verdict.
New Orleans acquired linebacker Scott Shanle from Dallas for a 2007 seventh-round pick, which the Cowboys used at No. 237 on defensive back Alan Ball. Both players outperformed the typical expectations of their acquisition cost, but Shanle's long run as a New Orleans starter and championship contributor gives the Saints the stronger result.
Kansas City Chiefs acquired Michael Bennett from New Orleans Saints for 2007 4th round pick (123rd overall subsequently traded, Fred Bennett). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Buffalo Bills acquired Courtney Watson from New Orleans Saints for Tim Euhus. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans and New England swapped two former high draft picks who had fallen out of favor, with wide receiver Bethel Johnson going to the Saints and defensive tackle Johnathan Sullivan going to the Patriots. Because neither acquired player produced regular-season value for his new club, the fairest judgment is an even trade with poor grades on both sides.
New Orleans sent the 99th pick to Philadelphia for veteran defensive tackle Hollis Thomas and No. 108, then used that fourth-round selection on guard Jahri Evans. Thomas became an immediate defensive-line contributor, while Evans started every game as a rookie and grew into a six-time Pro Bowler, four-time first-team All-Pro and Super Bowl XLIV champion. Philadelphia selected Max Jean-Gilles at No. 99, producing nowhere near the same value.
New Orleans sent the 34th pick to Cleveland and received center Jeff Faine and No. 43, which became safety Roman Harper. Faine immediately stabilized the Saints' offensive line, while Harper became a two-time Pro Bowler, Super Bowl XLIV champion and long-time defensive leader. Cleveland used No. 34 on linebacker D'Qwell Jackson, who developed into a tackling machine and franchise cornerstone, making this a genuine win-win exchange.
Atlanta Falcons acquired Wayne Gandy from New Orleans Saints for Bryan Scott. Atlanta Falcons received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Atlanta Falcons Win verdict.
Miami Dolphins acquired an undisclosed 2005 draft pick from New Orleans Saints for Jesse Chatman. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans moved from pick 16 to 13 for tackle Jammal Brown, sending Houston a future third-rounder in addition to the lower first. Brown became a two-time Pro Bowler and first-team All-Pro for the Saints. Houston selected Travis Johnson at 16 and later Eric Winston at 66; Winston became a durable starting tackle. Both clubs created substantial value, making the exchange unusually balanced in hindsight.
Green Bay Packers acquired J.T. O'Sullivan and 2005 2nd round pick (51st overall, Nick Collins) from New Orleans Saints for Mike McKenzie and an undisclosed 2004 draft pick. Green Bay Packers received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Green Bay Packers Win verdict.
New Orleans moved up for fullback Mike Karney at pick 156 in 2004, sending Dallas picks 182 and 206. Karney became a five-year Saint and an important lead-blocking fullback, so New Orleans received solid value. Dallas then flipped both acquired picks in separate trades, eventually adding Nate Jones, Jacques Reeves, Darian Barnes and Patrick Crayton. Crayton became a productive long-term receiver, giving the Cowboys a narrow overall edge.
Minnesota moved up two spots in the 2004 second round for linebacker Dontarrious Thomas, sending New Orleans picks 50 and 151 for No. 48. Thomas became a useful multi-year Viking, but the Saints selected Devery Henderson at 50 and later used pick 151 in another trade that helped add 2005 second-round capital. Henderson’s long tenure and championship-era production give New Orleans the stronger return.
Washington moved up in the 2004 third round for tight end Chris Cooley and also received a fifth-round pick, while New Orleans acquired a fifth-rounder that became Rodney Leisle plus Washington's 2005 second-round pick, used on Josh Bullocks. Bullocks became a multi-year starter, so the Saints received real value. Cooley developed into a two-time Pro Bowler and one of Washington's most productive tight ends, giving Washington the better return.
Jacksonville Jaguars acquired 2004 5th round pick (150th overall, Chris Thompson) from New Orleans Saints for Jason Craft. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Washington Commanders acquired Martin Chase from New Orleans Saints for 2004 7th round pick (206th overall subsequently traded, Mark Jones). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans acquired linebacker Derrick Rodgers from Miami in May 2003 for a 2004 seventh-round pick. Miami gained a future late-round asset and the Saints added an experienced defender at a very low acquisition cost. Neither side created a major long-term advantage, but New Orleans received usable veteran depth for a pick with limited expected value, giving the Saints a narrow edge rather than a decisive win.
New Orleans paid an enormous package to move from picks 17 and 18 to No. 6 in 2003, also exchanging second- and fourth-round value with Arizona. The Saints selected defensive tackle Johnathan Sullivan, while Arizona's return produced Bryant Johnson, Calvin Pace and Anquan Boldin. Sullivan became a major first-round disappointment and Boldin became a franchise star, creating one of the widest draft-trade gaps of the era.
New Orleans acquired safety Tebucky Jones from New England in April 2003 for third- and seventh-round picks that year plus a 2004 fourth-rounder. The Patriots expanded an already deep draft portfolio and ultimately tied the returned choices to Wade Smith, Tully Banta-Cain and Dexter Reid. Jones became a Saints starter, but New England's three-pick return created more roster flexibility and depth, giving the Patriots a narrow win.
St. Louis acquired right tackle Kyle Turley from New Orleans in March 2003 for a 2004 second-round pick. Turley started all 16 games for the 12-4 Rams in his first season, but serious back problems prevented him from playing again for St. Louis. New Orleans used the 60th overall pick on linebacker Courtney Watson, whose Saints tenure was also limited. The Saints win because they converted Turley into premium draft capital before his availability collapsed.
New Orleans acquired quarterback Todd Bouman from Minnesota in March 2003 for a sixth-round pick. Minnesota used the 190th overall selection on linebacker Mike Nattiel, while Bouman served as veteran quarterback depth for the Saints. Neither side landed a long-term centerpiece, but the Vikings turned a reserve passer into a draft choice that became a roster contributor, giving Minnesota the modest edge in the deal.
Indianapolis acquired running back Ricky Williams from New Orleans at the 2002 roster cutdown for a 2003 seventh-round pick. This was the former Texas Tech back, not the star running back with the same name. Williams gave the Colts modest depth over two seasons, totaling 190 rushing yards, 177 receiving yards and four touchdowns. New Orleans received a late pick that was later moved. Neither side generated enough value for a clear win.
Cincinnati traded running back Curtis Keaton to New Orleans in 2002 and received a 2003 fourth-round pick that became fullback Jeremi Johnson at No. 118. Keaton appeared in six games for the Saints and carried only 12 times for 19 yards. Johnson became a durable Bengals regular, playing 96 games over seven seasons. Cincinnati converted a fringe player into years of useful starting-caliber backfield work and clearly won the exchange.
Kansas City acquired future Hall of Fame tackle Willie Roaf from New Orleans in March 2002 for a 2003 third-round pick. Roaf became a centerpiece of one of the NFL’s best offensive lines, earning four straight Pro Bowl selections with the Chiefs and multiple All-Pro honors. New Orleans did receive meaningful third-round capital and later used that asset in another transaction, so its return was not worthless. Kansas City nevertheless landed transformational value.
Miami acquired Ricky Williams and moved up 11 spots in the fourth round, while New Orleans received Miami's 2002 first-rounder, the lower fourth-round pick and a conditional 2003 selection that became a first-rounder. Williams immediately led the NFL with 1,853 rushing yards in 2002 and remained highly productive in 2003. New Orleans turned the premium picks into Charles Grant and part of the package used to draft Johnathan Sullivan.
New Orleans Saints acquired Earthwind Moreland and 2002 6th round pick (196th overall, John Gilmore) from New York Jets for Chad Morton. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Washington Commanders acquired Robert Arnaud from New Orleans Saints for a conditional 2002 pick. The overall result favors Washington Redskins over Washington Commanders.
Dallas sent the 70th and 81st selections to New Orleans to move up to No. 53 for quarterback Quincy Carter. Carter started 31 games for the Cowboys, including all 16 in 2003, and finished his career with 6,337 passing yards. New Orleans selected linebacker Sedrick Hodge and defensive lineman Kenny Smith. Hodge became a 43-start contributor and Smith played 36 games, making the deal competitive but giving Dallas a slight positional-value edge.
New Orleans sent K.D. Williams and a 2001 third-round pick to Green Bay for Lamont Hall and quarterback Aaron Brooks. Brooks became the centerpiece, starting late in 2000 and helping deliver the first playoff victory in Saints history. He ultimately threw for 20,261 career yards and 123 touchdowns. Green Bay’s return never approached that franchise-level impact, making this an overwhelming Saints win.
New Orleans swapped linebacker Chris Bordano for defensive back Kevin Mathis on April 26, 2000. Mathis went on to play 115 NFL games and intercepted 11 passes, while Bordano’s career ended after 33 games and he did not become a Dallas regular. The Saints gained the more durable and productive player without adding draft capital, giving New Orleans the clear edge.
Indianapolis moved up 20 spots in the fifth round for guard Matt Johnson, sending New Orleans picks No. 158 and No. 195. Johnson never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. The Saints used No. 158 on tight end Austin Wheatley and No. 195 on defensive back Michael Hawthorne; Hawthorne played 63 career games and made 19 starts. That usable sixth-round return gives New Orleans the win.
Chicago acquired Eddie Kennison from New Orleans for the 138th pick in the 2000 draft. Kennison started 10 games for the Bears that season and caught 55 passes for 549 yards and two touchdowns. New Orleans later traded the pick to Indianapolis and turned it into two later choices, including Michael Hawthorne. The Saints recovered some value, but Chicago received the strongest immediate production from the original exchange.
Kansas City Chiefs acquired 2000 7th round pick (208th overall, Desmond Kitchings) from New Orleans Saints for 2000 7th round pick (228th overall, Kevin Houser). The overall result favors New Orleans Saints over Kansas City Chiefs.
New Orleans Saints
The Ricky Williams trade became the defining cautionary tale of Mike Ditka's Saints tenure. New Orleans sent an enormous draft package to Washington for the right to select Williams fifth overall. Williams was talented, but the cost was overwhelming. Washington turned one pick into a roster-building haul and won the value side decisively. This is a priority indexing page because the Ricky Williams-Mike Ditka trade is one of the most famous draft overpays in NFL history.
St. Louis traded wide receiver Eddie Kennison to New Orleans for the 41st pick in the 1999 draft and used it on cornerback Dre’ Bly. Bly played 167 NFL games, intercepted 43 passes, made two Pro Bowls and won a Super Bowl as a rookie. Kennison remained a productive NFL receiver, but his Saints stay was brief, giving the Rams the stronger long-term return.
Indianapolis and New Orleans swapped linebacker Andre Royal for tight end Scott Slutzker at the end of the 1998 preseason. Royal stepped directly into the Colts defense, appearing in 13 games with nine starts that season and making 51 tackles. Slutzker played only three games for New Orleans in 1998 and 11 in 1999. Indianapolis received the more substantial immediate return.
Oakland acquired veteran cornerback Eric Allen from New Orleans for the 97th pick in the 1998 draft. Allen intercepted 15 passes in four Raiders seasons and later entered the Pro Football Hall of Fame, giving Oakland a high-impact veteran secondary piece. New Orleans used the fourth-rounder on Fred Weary, who became a useful defensive back, so the Saints still received legitimate value.
New Orleans Saints acquired 1997 4th round pick (116th overall, Keith Poole) and 1997 6th round pick (165th overall, Nick Savoie) from Tennessee Titans for 1997 4th round pick (107th overall, Pratt Lyons). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Washington moved on from former No. 3 overall pick Heath Shuler and received a 1997 fifth-rounder plus a 1998 third-rounder. The later pick became running back Skip Hicks, who scored 13 rushing touchdowns in 38 NFL games. Shuler's New Orleans stint was brief and unsuccessful. Recovering two draft choices from a quarterback who was already trending toward bust status made this a strong Washington exit.
Oakland moved from No. 10 to No. 2 in the 1997 draft, also receiving a sixth-rounder, and selected defensive tackle Darrell Russell. New Orleans received Daryl Hobbs plus picks 10, 39 and 107, using the first on guard Chris Naeole. Russell reached a higher peak with two Pro Bowls, while Naeole delivered much greater career longevity. The trade was productive for both sides and finishes close to even.
Las Vegas Raiders acquired 1997 7th round pick (203rd overall subsequently traded, Hudhaifa Ismaeli) from New Orleans Saints for Austin Robbins. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Las Vegas Raiders acquired 1996 7th round pick (220th overall, Sedric Clark) from New Orleans Saints for Willie Broughton. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans Saints acquired 1996 5th round pick (136th overall, Mercury Hayes) from Cleveland Browns for Reggie Jones. New Orleans Saints received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New Orleans Saints Win verdict.
The Jets moved up one spot in the 1994 first round, sending New Orleans picks No. 13 and No. 143 for No. 12. New York selected cornerback Aaron Glenn, while the Saints drafted defensive end Joe Johnson at No. 13 and Craig Novitsky later. Glenn and Johnson both became high-level NFL starters, so this is a close trade; Glenn's long Jets tenure gives New York the edge.
Los Angeles Rams and New Orleans Saints completed this exchange on 1994-03-18. The Rams traded veteran quarterback Jim Everett to New Orleans in March 1994 for a 1995 seventh-round pick. Context matters because Everett was no longer the Rams' long-term answer, so Los Angeles did not surrender a player it intended to build around. The stronger overall return belongs to New Orleans Saints. The grades reflect direct team value plus clearly traceable use of any acquired pick that was later traded.
New Orleans sent star linebacker Pat Swilling to Detroit for the eighth and 89th picks in the 1993 draft. The Saints selected Willie Roaf at No. 8 and Lorenzo Neal at No. 89. Roaf became a Hall of Fame left tackle and one of the greatest players in franchise history, while Swilling's Detroit stay was short. New Orleans turned one veteran into two exceptional long-term NFL talents.
New Orleans moved up from No. 79 to No. 72 in the 1992 draft, sending Tampa Bay an additional fifth-round pick at No. 118. The Saints selected Tyrone Legette, while the Buccaneers took Tyji Armstrong and Rogerick Green. Legette became useful depth, but Armstrong supplied more sustained Tampa Bay production, giving the Buccaneers a narrow win rather than an even result.
New Orleans Saints received Allen Pinkett from Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans for 1992 fifth round pick (#133-Joe Bowden). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
On 1991-08-21, Detroit Lions and New Orleans Saints completed a deal whose long-term value became clearer after the players and draft choices developed. Perriman became a six-year fixture in Detroit, starting 91 games and catching 428 passes for 5,244 yards and 25 touchdowns as a Lion. Detroit still created the larger return because Perriman immediately became a major part of the offense and remained highly productive through 1996. The result is Detroit Lions Win, with Detroit Lions graded A+ and New Orleans Saints graded B.
On 1991-08-19, Phoenix Cardinals and New Orleans Saints completed a deal whose long-term value became clearer after the players and draft choices developed. Kennard became a regular starter for New Orleans, including all 16 games in both 1992 and 1993, and the Saints also controlled pick No. The outcomes are unusually balanced. The result is Even Trade, with Phoenix Cardinals graded B and New Orleans Saints graded B.
Las Vegas Raiders acquired 1992 seventh round pick (#191-Dave Moore) from New Orleans Saints for Vencie Glenn. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Dallas traded backup quarterback Steve Walsh to New Orleans for first-, third-, and second-round picks across two drafts. Walsh supplied some starting value for the Saints, but Dallas used the package to add Erik Williams and more roster-building capital. Williams became an All-Pro cornerstone of the offensive line that powered three Super Bowl champions.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers received 1991 tenth round pick (#265-Hyland Hickson) from New Orleans Saints for Robert Goff / Pig Goff. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans sent five late 1990 draft choices to the Raiders for a 1991 fourth-round pick that became No. 98. The Saints used their incoming choices on James Williams, Gerry Gdowski, Broderick Graves, Gary Cooper and Webbie Burnett. The Raiders later used No. 98 with pick No. 51 to acquire Seattle's No. 43 selection. Neither side turned the exchange into major lasting value, keeping it even.
New Orleans Saints
New Orleans acquired return specialist Bobby Morse from Philadelphia on April 24, 1989 for an 11th-round pick in the 1990 draft. Morse played 27 games for the Saints and delivered a 99-yard kickoff-return touchdown in 1989. Philadelphia used the future pick, No. 294, on center John Hudson, who went on to play 67 games for the Eagles. Hudson's longer tenure gives Philadelphia a narrow win.
Denver Broncos acquired Shawn Knight from New Orleans Saints for Ted Gregory. The final verdict remains New Orleans Saints Win, with the grades reflecting the recorded asset value and the available historical return.
New Orleans Saints received undisclosed draft pick from New England Patriots for Tony Stephens. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Denver moved up two spots in the third round of the 1988 draft, sending New Orleans picks No. 81 and No. 276 for No. 79. The Broncos used the higher choice on defensive back Kevin Guidry, who appeared in 14 games for Denver as a rookie. Neither Saints selection became an NFL contributor, giving Denver a small but real edge in an otherwise low-impact exchange.
New Orleans Saints acquired Kirk Jones; Robert Brannon from Cleveland Browns for undisclosed pick; draft pick (undisclosed). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired Jon Sutton from New Orleans Saints for Not specified in source record. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Kansas City acquired linebacker Jack Del Rio from New Orleans on August 17, 1987 for a 1988 fifth-round pick that became No. 112, Greg Scales. Del Rio immediately played 10 games with seven starts for the Chiefs and returned for 15 games with 10 starts in 1988. That two-year defensive role gave Kansas City more direct value than the Saints received from Scales.
Minnesota traded wide receiver Mike Jones to New Orleans on September 2, 1986 for running back Wayne Wilson. Wilson had been productive earlier in his career, but his Minnesota stay produced only eight carries for 14 yards in seven games. The Vikings gained veteran depth, yet the return was brief and modest, leaving Minnesota with little direct football value from the exchange.
Indianapolis moved from No. 6 to No. 4 before the 1986 draft and selected defensive lineman Jon Hand, sending New Orleans No. 6 and No. 60. Hand became a nine-year Colt with 35.5 sacks, so Indianapolis received a good player. New Orleans, however, drafted Jim Dombrowski and Pat Swilling; Swilling became Defensive Player of the Year and a five-time Pro Bowler, giving the Saints the superior return.
New Orleans moved defensive back David Greenwood to Tampa Bay on August 30, 1985 and received a 1986 third-round pick, No. 57 overall. That pick became Rueben Mayes, who won Offensive Rookie of the Year, made two Pro Bowls and rushed for 3,484 yards as a Saint. The long-term return clearly outweighed Greenwood’s useful but brief Tampa Bay stint.
Washington acquired George Rogers and multiple picks from New Orleans for a 1985 first-round pick, adding a proven power back and useful draft depth to a contender. Rogers gave Washington major rushing value and later contributed to a Super Bowl-winning roster. The Saints received a real first-round return, so their side was not empty, but Washington got the better realized football value.
Houston moved Earl Campbell to New Orleans for a 1985 first-round pick that became Richard Johnson, turning a declining franchise legend into a useful starting cornerback. The Saints reunited Campbell with Bum Phillips, but the move chased nostalgia more than remaining value. Campbell was no longer the dominant back from his Oilers peak, and New Orleans burned premium draft capital for a short, limited return.
Atlanta Falcons received 1985 sixth round pick (#152-Reggie Pleasant) from New Orleans Saints for Junior Miller. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans acquired quarterback Richard Todd from the Jets for the 1984 first-round selection that became linebacker Ron Faurot at No. 15. Todd started 14 games for the Saints in 1984 but struggled with 11 touchdown passes and 19 interceptions. Faurot played only 20 games for New York, so the Saints receive a narrow win despite modest results.
Buffalo Bills received Tom Myers (b) / Tommy Myers (b) from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1984 #68-Terry Hoage). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Miami Dolphins received Ed Simonini from New Orleans Saints for future considerations (details not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis Colts received Calvin Close from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick. The recorded outcome favors Indianapolis Colts.
New England sent New Orleans a 1984 fourth-round pick in exchange for four late selections in the 1983 draft: Nos. 233, 265, 292 and 319. The Patriots found some useful depth, especially defensive lineman Toby Williams, but the Saints used the future pick on center Joel Hilgenberg. He spent 10 seasons with New Orleans, started 97 games and became a Pro Bowler and Saints Hall of Famer.
Buffalo moved a future third-round pick to New Orleans for the 1983 fourth-round choice used on defensive end Jimmy Payne. Payne spent his rookie year on injured reserve and never developed into an NFL contributor. The cost became meaningful when the Saints used Buffalo's 1984 third-rounder on safety Terry Hoage, who started 13 games with four interceptions for New Orleans in 1985.
New Orleans ended the Archie Manning era by sending its longtime quarterback to Houston for offensive tackle Leon Gray. Gray was already an accomplished offensive lineman and quickly gave the Saints a Pro Bowl season in 1983, while Manning's Oilers stay lasted only two games. The combination of immediate line quality and greater staying power makes New Orleans the clear winner.
Denver Broncos acquired 1984 fourth round pick (#96-Rickey Bolden) from New Orleans Saints for Kelvin Clark. The final verdict remains Denver Broncos Win, with the grades reflecting the recorded asset value and the available historical return.
Cincinnati sent veteran tight end Don Bass to New Orleans in August 1982 and received the Saints' 1983 sixth-round choice. New Orleans got only three regular-season games from Bass. Cincinnati used No. 152 on linebacker Kiki DeAyala, who later played 28 games with two starts for the Bengals. The return was modest, but it clearly exceeded the Saints' brief payoff from Bass.
Arizona acquired veteran defensive end Elois Grooms from New Orleans for a 1983 third-round pick that became running back Cliff Austin at No. 66. Grooms started 26 games for the Cardinals from 1982 through 1984 and recorded 7.5 sacks in those three seasons. Austin spent only his 1983 rookie year with the Saints and produced 41 yards from scrimmage, giving Arizona the much stronger direct return.
Kansas City Chiefs received 1983 seventh round pick (#179-Daryl Posey) from New Orleans Saints for Whitney Paul. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans acquired the NFL rights to defensive lineman Bruce Clark from Green Bay on June 10, 1982, giving up its 1983 first-round pick. Clark then spent seven seasons with the Saints, produced 39.5 sacks, and reached the 1984 Pro Bowl. That sustained defensive production gave New Orleans the stronger return from a costly but successful rights acquisition.
New Orleans received Washington's 1983 fourth-round pick after sending five late 1982 selections to Washington. The Saints later moved that fourth-rounder to Buffalo for a 1984 third-round choice and used the resulting asset on Terry Hoage, who started 13 games with four interceptions in 1985. That downstream value balanced Washington's useful haul led by Ken Coffey and Don Laster.
New Orleans acquired linebacker Dennis Winston from Pittsburgh during the 1982 draft for the sixth-round pick used on Craig Bingham. Winston became an immediate Saints starter, making 42 starts in 43 games from 1982 through early 1985 and intercepting seven passes during that span. Bingham appeared in 29 games for Pittsburgh from 1982 through 1984 with one start. The Saints received substantially more impact from the exchange.
San Diego quickly used part of the John Jefferson return to acquire Wes Chandler from New Orleans, sending Aundra Thompson plus 1982 first- and third-round picks. Chandler became a premier Chargers receiver and a central piece of the Air Coryell offense. New Orleans did not receive comparable production from the package, giving San Diego a clear and lasting win.
Denver Broncos acquired 1983 fifth round pick (#125-Bruce Baldwin) from New Orleans Saints for Rob Nairne. The final grade stays even because neither side created a clear long-term value gap from the recorded return.
Minnesota acquired Tony Galbreath from New Orleans on August 31, 1981 for the 1982 third-round pick that became Eugene Goodlow. Galbreath gave the Vikings three useful seasons, totaling 788 rushing yards and 645 receiving yards while starting 11 games. Goodlow later became a productive Saints receiver with 1,677 yards and 10 touchdowns. Both teams turned the exchange into legitimate multi-year production.
San Francisco 49ers acquired Guy Benjamin from New Orleans Saints for 1982 sixth round pick (#167-Craig Bingham). San Francisco 49ers received the stronger recorded football value, matching the San Francisco 49ers Win verdict.
Washington acquired Henry Childs from New Orleans for the 1982 third-round pick that became No. 68, Kenny Duckett. Six days later, Washington moved Childs to the Rams for a better third-round choice at No. 61 plus a seventh-round pick. New Orleans still received useful value from Duckett, who produced 34 catches for 503 yards and four touchdowns as a Saint, but Washington’s immediate asset flip created the stronger return.
New England sent veteran guard Sam Adams to New Orleans on April 23, 1981 for the Saints' eighth-round selection, No. 194. The Patriots used the pick on Ken Naber, who did not become an NFL regular-season contributor. Adams, meanwhile, started all 16 games for New Orleans in 1981. Turning a late-round choice into a full season of starting line play gives the Saints the clear edge.
New Orleans Saints acquired draft pick (possibly 1981 #166-Glen Redd) from Las Vegas Raiders for Joe Campbell (Patrick). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
San Diego acquired Chuck Muncie during the 1980 season for a 1981 second-round pick. Muncie became an important part of the Air Coryell offense, topped 1,100 rushing yards in 1981 and scored 19 rushing touchdowns that season. The Chargers paid a historic price in hindsight, but they still received several seasons of high-level production from the player they targeted.
Los Angeles Chargers acquired Rich Partridge from New Orleans Saints for 1981 eighth round pick (#215-Kevin Evans). The overall result favors New Orleans Saints over Los Angeles Chargers.
Miami traded quarterback Guy Benjamin to New Orleans on August 28, 1980 for a 1981 fourth-round pick and a 1982 seventh-rounder. Benjamin played only two games for the Saints before they moved him again. Miami's fourth-rounder, Sam Greene, did not stick, but seventh-rounder Dan Johnson became a productive Dolphins tight end with 66 games, 34 starts, 1,012 receiving yards and 16 touchdowns. Miami won the exchange.
New Orleans Saints acquired Tommy Hart from Chicago Bears for past considerations. New Orleans Saints received the stronger recorded football value.
Buffalo Bills acquired Conrad Dobler from New Orleans Saints for 1981 draft pick (possibly #214-Gene Gladys). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
The June 1980 Steve Riley entry reflects the resolution of an earlier Vikings-Saints transaction after Riley failed New Orleans' physical and remained with Minnesota. The Saints ultimately received 1981 third- and fifth-round selections, Nos. 71 and 128, while Minnesota retained Riley, who continued as a regular offensive tackle for several seasons. Both sides obtained real value, but the two future selections give New Orleans the stronger return and preserve a narrow Saints win.
Minnesota agreed to send tackle Steve Riley to New Orleans on April 18, 1980 for third- and fifth-round picks used on Brent Boyd and Paul Jones. Riley later failed the Saints' physical, and the transaction was unwound with Minnesota sending 1981 third- and fifth-round selections to New Orleans while retaining Riley. Boyd became a useful Vikings lineman, and Riley continued starting in Minnesota, giving the Vikings the stronger overall chain.
New Orleans Saints
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired Tom Blanchard from New Orleans Saints for 1981 sixth round pick (#144-Johnnie Poe). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans Saints acquired Roger Finnie from Arizona Cardinals for 1979 undisclosed draft pick; 1980 conditional pick based on Roger Finnie's playing time. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans Saints acquired Barry Darrow from Cleveland Browns for 1980 conditional draft pick (not exercised). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Las Vegas Raiders acquired 1979 tenth round pick (#259-Ricky Smith) from New Orleans Saints for Floyd Rice. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
St. Louis/Arizona Cardinals received Jim Thaxton (James Ivory Thaxton) from New Orleans Saints for 1979 seventh round pick (selection not identified). The recorded returns remain too close to establish a clear long-term winner.
San Francisco 49ers received Chuck Crist (Charles Crist) from New Orleans Saints for Skip Vanderbundt. New Orleans received the more useful player return, preserving its modest advantage.
Kansas City Chiefs acquired 1979 ninth round pick (#229-Joe Robinson (b)) from New Orleans Saints for Keith Simons. Kansas City Chiefs received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Kansas City Chiefs Win verdict.
Atlanta Falcons acquired Ernie Jackson (b. 1950-04-11) from New Orleans Saints for Ray Brown (Madison). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
San Francisco 49ers acquired Greg Boykin from New Orleans Saints for Ralph McGill. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
New Orleans reacquired Richard Neal for a seventh-round pick. Neal appeared in two games and made one start, providing a small realized return.
St. Louis received defensive end Bob Pollard and guard Terry Stieve. Stieve arrived as a young lineman with starting experience, while Pollard added veteran defensive help. Together they gave the Cardinals two usable roster pieces in exchange for players whose contract situations had become difficult. The hindsight grade is B+, with the overall verdict recorded as Arizona Cardinals / St. Louis Cardinals Win.
New Orleans Saints received draft pick (possibly 1978 #157-Francis Chesley) from Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans for Cliff Parsley. The possible draft return and Cliff Parsley's limited documented value leave the transaction even.
San Francisco acquired Paul Seal from New Orleans for John Watson. Seal gave the 49ers the stronger football value, while the Saints did not receive a matching return.
Atlanta acquired Ernie Jackson from New Orleans for Ray Brown. New Orleans received the slightly stronger realized return.
New Orleans acquired Pat Hughes from the New York Giants for the 1978 tenth-round pick used on Greg Jorgensen. Hughes supplied the more useful realized return, giving the Saints a narrow win.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired cash from New Orleans Saints for Ed McAleney. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers received 1977 ninth round pick (#241UNKNOWN) from New Orleans Saints for Halvor Hagen. The recorded outcome favors Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers.
Los Angeles Rams received Bivian Lee from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1977 #162-Tom Schick). The recorded outcome favors Los Angeles Rams.
New Orleans Saints received Stephen George and Stephen George / Steve George from Arizona Cardinals for 1977 undisclosed pick and 1977 draft pick (not disclosed). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Los Angeles traded linebacker Ken Bordelon to New Orleans for a 1977 fourth-round pick and used No. 91 on quarterback Vince Ferragamo. Ferragamo eventually became a multi-year Rams starter and took over the 1979 team during its run to Super Bowl XIV, giving Los Angeles exceptional value from a fourth-round selection.
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers received unspecified draft pick and undisclosed pick from New Orleans Saints for Terry Owens. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers received Larry Cipa from New Orleans Saints for draft pick (selection not identified) and undisclosed pick. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers received John Fuller / Johnny Fuller and John Fuller from New Orleans Saints for Jim Kearney. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans Saints received Bob Stein from Minnesota Vikings for 1977 draft pick (selection not identified) and 1977 undisclosed pick. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
San Diego sent quarterback Bobby Douglass and a 1976 third-round choice to New Orleans for linebacker Rick Middleton. Middleton spent multiple seasons with the Chargers but was primarily depth, starting only twice across his San Diego tenure. The return was serviceable, yet it did not match the immediate quarterback value New Orleans received.
Baltimore acquired Howard Stevens from New Orleans for a 1977 fifth-round pick and received three seasons of useful return work. Stevens handled 109 punt returns for 1,012 yards with the Colts and added substantial kickoff-return production, especially in 1976. New Orleans used the No. 136 selection on Dave Hubbard, whose NFL career lasted only five games. Baltimore received the clearly stronger result.
Miami sent wide receiver Melvin Baker to New Orleans for a 1976 seventh-round choice used on Joe Ingersoll. Baker appeared in two games with one start for the Saints before moving on, while Ingersoll never logged an NFL regular-season career. Neither return was substantial, but New Orleans at least received brief on-field production, giving the Saints a narrow edge.
New Orleans Saints received Lawrence Williams from New England Patriots for 1976 eighth round pick (-). The recorded outcome favors New England Patriots.
Chicago obtained veteran center John Didion, while New Orleans received the 1976 seventh-round choice that became Ed Bauer. Didion's NFL career had effectively reached its end by the time of the exchange, and Bauer did not produce an NFL career from pick No. 201. The deal was a low-cost depth transaction with little lasting value on either side. Chicago took the immediate veteran option, while New Orleans deferred its return to the bottom of the next draft.
New Orleans Saints received Josh Ashton from New England Patriots for 1976 seventh round pick (-). The recorded outcome favors New England Patriots.
New Orleans Saints received 1976 draft pick (possibly #201-Ed Bauer) from Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders for Jess Phillips. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received undisclosed pick and draft pick (not disclosed) from Arizona Cardinals for Bill Butler. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans acquired the No. 12 pick in the 1975 draft and selected offensive lineman Kurt Schumacher, while the Jets received defensive lineman Billy Newsome. Newsome started all 14 games for New York in 1975 and recorded eight sacks. Schumacher had the longer Saints tenure, appearing in 45 games with 20 starts. Neither return became a franchise cornerstone, but both teams received useful value.
Minnesota acquired offensive lineman Andy Maurer and received useful immediate line help. New Orleans received the 1975 third-round pick used on defensive end Elois Grooms, who played 99 games for the Saints and recorded 42.5 sacks for the franchise. Maurer made the Vikings' side respectable, but Grooms became a far more durable and productive asset in New Orleans. The third-round pick produced the best player value in the exchange.
St. Louis acquired veteran defensive back Ken Reaves from New Orleans on October 17, 1974 for the 1975 fourth-round choice that became Charlie Hall at No. 99. Reaves immediately joined the Cardinals and remained there through 1977, intercepting eight passes for St. Louis over those seasons. New Orleans converted the pick into Hall, but the selected player did not match the multi-season defensive contribution Reaves supplied the Cardinals. That balance of realized value gives the edge to Arizona Cardinals / St. Louis Cardinals.
New Orleans acquired veteran receiver Fair Hooker from Cleveland for Jubilee Dunbar, also listed as Allen Dunbar. Dunbar appeared in five games for the Browns in 1974 and caught six passes for 74 yards. Hooker did not produce a Saints regular-season appearance after the move, so Cleveland receives a narrow edge from the limited direct value.
New Orleans Saints received Vince Clements, undisclosed consideration and Vince Clements / Vin Clements from New York Giants for 1975 conditional pick not exercised, undisclosed consideration and 1975 draft pick (not exercised?). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received Tom Drougas from New Orleans Saints for 1975 fourth round pick (AP) / 1976 fourth round pick (selection not identified) and 1975 fourth round pick (AP). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Atlanta Falcons received Royce Smith and Dick Palmer from New Orleans Saints for Ken Reaves and Andy Maurer. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Arizona Cardinals received Ray Hester from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick (not exercised?). The recorded outcome favors Arizona Cardinals.
Detroit moved center Dave Thompson and the No. 13 pick to New Orleans for the No. 8 pick and a 1975 sixth-round choice. The Lions used No. 8 on linebacker Ed O'Neil, who played six seasons for Detroit and started 60 games; the later sixth-rounder became Fred Cooper, who did not play in the NFL. New Orleans selected Rick Middleton at No. 13, and both Middleton and Thompson lasted only two seasons with the Saints. That balance of realized value gives the edge to Detroit Lions.
Atlanta Falcons received undisclosed 1974 draft pick (possibly #71-Maurice Spencer) from New Orleans Saints for Joe Profit. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans acquired defensive end Andy Dorris from St. Louis for the 1975 eighth-round pick used on John Adams. Dorris became a meaningful Saints contributor, playing 42 games from 1974 through 1976 and starting 21 of them. Adams never appeared in an NFL regular-season game, so the Saints received far more realized football value from the exchange.
New Orleans acquired tight end Len Garrett from Green Bay for the 1974 eighth-round choice used on safety Ned Guillet. Garrett appeared in 27 Saints games across 1973 and 1974 and remained with the club into 1975, while Guillet never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. That clear difference in realized value gives New Orleans the win.
San Francisco 49ers received Danny Abramowicz from New Orleans Saints for 1974 fourth round pick (#88-Rod McNeill) and 1974 fifth round pick (#113-Joel Parker). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received Jerry Moore (Porter) from Chicago Bears for 1975 fifth round pick (#110-Revie Sorey). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Cincinnati traded running back Jess Phillips to New Orleans for 1974 third- and fifth-round picks. The third-rounder became Dave Lapham, who played 140 Bengals games and started on Cincinnati's first Super Bowl team; the fifth became Haskel Stanback. Phillips gave the Saints two productive rushing seasons, so New Orleans received real value, but Lapham's decade in Cincinnati makes the Bengals the clear winner.
San Francisco 49ers received 1974 undisclosed draft pick (possibly #83-Clint Haslerig) from New Orleans Saints for Allen Dunbar / Jubilee Dunbar. The recorded outcome favors San Francisco 49ers.
Buffalo Bills received Dave Long from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1975 #149-Mike Lemon). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Miami sent Jeff White to New Orleans for the 1974 seventh-round pick later used on Carl Swierc. White did not record a Saints regular-season contribution, and Swierc did not produce an NFL regular-season career for Miami. With neither acquired asset creating meaningful direct value for its new club, the exchange finishes as an even trade with matching C grades.
New Orleans acquired Henry Matthews from New England for a future fifth-round choice, most plausibly the 1974 selection that became Charlie Battle at No. 124. Matthews appeared for the Saints in 1973 but did not create a long-term impact. Because the exact pick lineage is not perfectly explicit, New England receives only a narrow edge rather than a strong grade.
New Orleans Saints received Leo Brooks from Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans for Bob Gresham. The recorded outcome favors Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans.
New Orleans traded running back James Ford to Houston on August 1, 1973 for sixth- and tenth-round choices in the 1974 draft. Houston released Ford before the regular season, while the Saints retained two future selections. Because the Oilers received no regular-season contribution and New Orleans recovered two draft assets, the Saints hold a straightforward but still modest hindsight win.
Arizona Cardinals received Doug Mooers from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick (not disclosed). The recorded outcome favors Arizona Cardinals.
New Orleans Saints received draft pick (possibly 1974 #71-Maurice Spencer) from Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders for Jim Strong (Harold). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
San Francisco 49ers received undisclosed draft pick (probably 1976 #63-Keith Simons) (possibly 1974 #83-Clint Haslerig) from New Orleans Saints for John Fuller / Johnny Fuller. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans Saints received draft pick (possibly 1974 #71-Maurice Spencer) from Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders for Mike Crangle. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans acquired Bob Davis, punter Steve O'Neal and a 1974 fourth-round choice from the Jets for Julian Fagan, Margene Adkins and a 1974 eighth-round selection on June 5, 1973. O'Neal immediately became the Saints' punter, and the higher draft choice gave New Orleans the stronger asset package. The Saints earn the edge even though neither side created a major long-term centerpiece.
Atlanta Falcons received Al Dodd and Tom Roussel from New Orleans Saints for draft pick (possibly 1974 #121-Terry Schmidt). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
San Francisco 49ers received 1975 fourth round pick (#85-Cleveland Elam) from New Orleans Saints for Preston Riley. The recorded outcome favors San Francisco 49ers.
Cincinnati sent tight end Mike Kelly to New Orleans for a future 1974 sixth-round pick, which became No. 153 and was used on William 'Bill' Bryant. Kelly appeared in only one Saints game in 1973, while Bryant did not become a Bengals regular-season contributor. Neither club extracted meaningful direct value, so the transaction is best graded as even.
New Orleans acquired linebacker Adrian Young from Detroit on April 9, 1973, for the Saints’ 1974 sixth-round pick, No. 139, later used on Willie Burden. Young was released before the season and never played a regular-season game for New Orleans. Burden also never appeared in an NFL regular-season game for Detroit. Neither side turned the trade into meaningful NFL value.
New Orleans acquired quarterback Kent Nix and defensive tackle Ron Billingsley from Houston for Edd Hargett, Dave Parks and Tom Stincic in March 1973. Neither Nix nor Billingsley played a regular-season game for the Saints, while Parks made five appearances for Houston. The Oilers therefore receive a slight edge, though the transaction produced little lasting value for either club.
Baltimore acquired the No. 2 pick in the 1973 draft from New Orleans and used it on quarterback Bert Jones, sending defensive lineman Billy Newsome and the No. 86 selection, Jim Merlo, to the Saints. Jones became the 1976 NFL MVP and Offensive Player of the Year and led Baltimore's resurgence. The Saints received useful pieces, but nothing close to a franchise quarterback at his peak.
New Orleans sent Richard Neal and Delles Howell to the Jets for 1973 second- and third-round picks. Steve Baumgartner became a useful Saints defender, but the Jets received the better combined player return: Neal developed into a multi-year starter and Howell added three productive seasons in New York. That sustained two-player contribution gives the Jets the hindsight edge.
New Orleans Saints received Mitch Johnson and 1974 eighth round pick (selection not identified) from Cleveland Browns for 1973 third round pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Philadelphia acquired linebacker Dick Absher from New Orleans on September 15, 1972 for the 1975 fourth-round choice later used on John Starkebaum at No. 92. Absher played eight games for the Eagles and recorded an interception. Starkebaum suffered a major knee injury in his first Saints training camp and never played an NFL regular-season game, giving Philadelphia the slight hindsight advantage.
New Orleans Saints received Bob Brown (Earl) from Minnesota Vikings for 1973 sixth round pick (#139-Doug Kingsriter) and 1974 fourth round pick (#86-Mike Townsend). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Los Angeles Rams received Lawrence Estes / Larry Estes from New Orleans Saints for 1973 draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome favors Los Angeles Rams.
Kansas City sent its 1972 fourth-round pick, No. 101, to New Orleans for Charles “Donnie” Williams. The Chiefs waived Williams later that August, while the Saints used the pick on defensive end Mike Coleman, who was also released without becoming a regular-season contributor. The older row duplicated Williams as two players; after correcting that structure, the realized returns are essentially equal and support an even verdict.
New Orleans acquired linebacker Tom Stincic from Dallas in July 1972, and the Cowboys received the 1973 third-round pick used on Harvey Martin at No. 53. Martin became one of the defining defenders in Cowboys history, earning four Pro Bowls and sharing Super Bowl XII MVP honors. That extraordinary conversion overwhelms the Saints’ modest return and makes this a decisive Dallas victory.
New Orleans sent Jim Flanigan to New England on June 29, 1972 and received the 1973 sixth-round choice later used on Marty Shuford at No. 134. Flanigan did not make a regular-season impact for the Patriots, while Shuford also failed to become a meaningful NFL contributor. The Saints at least recovered a draft asset, giving them a slight edge in an otherwise low-value exchange.
Washington received 1973 "high" draft pick (probably 1973 #54-Paul Howard) from New Orleans Saints for Bob Grant and undisclosed draft pick (probably 1974 #124) [later traded to New England Patriots for Henry Matthews]. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Atlanta Falcons received 1972 sixth round pick (#146-Fred Riley) from New Orleans Saints for John Mallory. The recorded outcome favors Atlanta Falcons.
New Orleans acquired Margene Adkins from Dallas on February 1, 1972, and the Cowboys received the second-round pick used on linebacker John Babinecz at No. 39. Adkins offered the Saints veteran receiving depth, but Dallas turned the exchange into a player who appeared in 26 games over two Cowboys seasons. That stronger and more durable return gives Dallas the clear hindsight edge.
Oakland moved into the No. 33 slot of the 1972 draft and selected defensive tackle Kelvin Korver. New Orleans received the No. 39 selection, used on linebacker John Babinecz, plus the No. 74 choice, used on defensive back Tom Myers. The exchange was a classic trade-down in which both clubs converted draft position into players.
New Orleans acquired Joe Williams from Dallas on January 31, 1972, while the Cowboys received the fourth-round choice that became linebacker Tim Kearney at No. 83. Williams appeared for the Saints that season, but Dallas converted the outgoing player into useful draft value. Kearney did not stick with the Cowboys long term, so the advantage is real but appropriately modest.
Indianapolis/Baltimore Colts received John Shinners from New Orleans Saints for Jim Duncan (b), 1972 fifth round pick (#126-Bob Davies) and 1973 sixth round pick (#139) [later traded with 1974 fourth round pick (#86-Mike Townsend) to Minnesota Vikings for Bob Brown (Earl)]. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received 1972 fourth round pick (#99-Joe Federspiel) from Philadelphia Eagles for Tony Baker (a). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
On 1971-08-23, New Orleans Saints and Philadelphia Eagles completed a deal that sent Richard Harvey to New Orleans Saints and Jim Ward (Edgar Harold) to Philadelphia Eagles. Neither player became a significant long-term contributor for his new club. Harvey appeared only briefly for New Orleans, while Ward's Eagles regular-season production was similarly slight, leaving little durable separation between the sides. That realized value supports a Even Trade verdict, with New Orleans Saints graded C and Philadelphia Eagles graded C.
On 1971-08-20, Green Bay Packers and New Orleans Saints completed a deal that sent Richard Winther to Green Bay Packers and 1972 fifth round pick (#111-Bill Butler) to New Orleans Saints. Winther's Packers stay was brief and produced limited playing value. Butler, by contrast, spent three seasons with New Orleans, appeared in 41 games and started 21, creating a much stronger realized return from a modest pick. That realized value supports a New Orleans Saints Win verdict, with Green Bay Packers graded C and New Orleans Saints graded B+.
On 1971-08-16, Detroit Lions and New Orleans Saints completed a deal that sent 1973 fourth round pick (#81-Mike Hennigan) to Detroit Lions and Carl Cunningham to New Orleans Saints. Cunningham started for New Orleans in 1971, so the Saints received real short-term help. Hennigan later appeared for Detroit, giving the Lions a modest but tangible return from a player they moved. That realized value supports a Detroit Lions Win verdict, with Detroit Lions graded B and New Orleans Saints graded C+.
Minnesota acquired defensive lineman Doug Sutherland from New Orleans for running back Bill Harris in August 1971. The transaction involved one Harris, not two duplicate player entries. Sutherland went on to play 138 regular-season games for Minnesota, start 90 and appear in three Super Bowls. Harris played only one game for New Orleans and gained one rushing yard, producing an overwhelming Vikings advantage.
Washington received Tom Barrington and undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1973 #106-Dave Reavis) from New Orleans Saints for Bruce Anderson (Albert) and undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1973 #207-Doug Winslow). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Atlanta Falcons received Ray Poage from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1972 #146-Fred Riley). The recorded outcome favors Atlanta Falcons.
New Orleans sent offensive lineman Don Talbert to Dallas for running back Doug Mooers and a 1972 fourth-round pick, No. 104. The Saints later moved that pick onward, so Eric Allen should be treated as the eventual player tied to the selection rather than a New Orleans draftee. Mooers became a 14-game Saints starter in 1972, while Talbert had a smaller Dallas role, giving New Orleans the edge.
Washington received 1973 draft pick (possibly #177-Jim Peterson) from New Orleans Saints for Jim Ward (Edgar Harold). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints and Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans completed this trade on 1971-06-14. Tilleman immediately became an every-game Oilers starter and delivered an outstanding 1972 season. New Orleans also received real value through Hines and draft capital, leaving both teams with meaningful returns rather than a clear loser. The post-trade results provide the clearest measure of what each club gained from the exchange. The historical return supports a Even Trade verdict, with New Orleans Saints graded B and Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans graded B.
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received Elijah Nevett from New Orleans Saints for draft pick (probably 1972 #150-Curt Watson). The recorded outcome favors Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders.
Denver Broncos received Steve Ramsey from New Orleans Saints for 1972 fourth round pick (#83-Tim Kearney). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans Saints received 1972 undisclosed pick and 1972 draft pick (selection not identified) from Philadelphia Eagles for Andy Livingston (a). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Denver Broncos received 1973 fifth round pick (#106-Dave Reavis) from New Orleans Saints for John Huard. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
On 1971-03-26, Minnesota Vikings and New Orleans Saints completed a deal that sent Bill Cody to Minnesota Vikings and undisclosed conditional future draft choice to New Orleans Saints. Cody did not become a meaningful Vikings regular-season contributor before moving on. Because the Saints' conditional return cannot be tied confidently to a productive selection, neither side produced enough verified value for a win. That realized value supports a Even Trade verdict, with Minnesota Vikings graded C and New Orleans Saints graded C.
Washington received Mike Taylor (Ray) from New Orleans Saints for Leo Carroll and 1971 17th round pick (#428-Hermann Eben). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Kansas City Chiefs received Jim Otis from New Orleans Saints for 1971 seventh round pick (#172-Bob Newland). The recorded outcome favors Kansas City Chiefs.
New Orleans Saints and Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans completed this trade on 1971-01-25. Burrough became the defining asset, spending eleven seasons with Houston, reaching the Pro Bowl and leading NFL wide receivers with 1,063 yards in 1975. New Orleans received volume, but no comparable long-term centerpiece. The post-trade results provide the clearest measure of what each club gained from the exchange. The historical return supports a Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans Win verdict, with New Orleans Saints graded C+ and Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans graded A.
Washington received Bill Kilmer / Billy Kilmer and Bill Kilmer from New Orleans Saints for Tom Roussel, 1971 fourth round pick (#88-Richard Winther / Wimpy Winther) and 1971 eighth round pick (#194-James Elder / Jim Elder). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Los Angeles Rams received undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1971 #418-Randy Vataha) from New Orleans Saints for Elijah Pitts. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received Bill Dusenbery from Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans for no separately listed compensation. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
San Francisco 49ers received undisclosed draft pick (possibly 1971 #236-Ron Cardo) from New Orleans Saints for Gary Lewis. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans acquired defensive end Willie Townes from Dallas on September 9, 1970 for a 1971 fourth-round pick that became Joe Carter at No. 80. Townes’ Saints tenure was brief, but he appeared in six games and started four. Carter never appeared in an NFL regular-season game for Dallas. Neither return was large, yet New Orleans received actual playing value while the Cowboys’ draft conversion produced none, giving the Saints a narrow win.
New Orleans Saints received Mike Pyle from Chicago Bears for 1971 undisclosed pick and 1971 draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received Jackie Burkett from Dallas Cowboys for Dave Whitsell and Tom Broadhead. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers received Bob Miller (b) from New Orleans Saints for Jim Fetherston. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans acquired veteran safety Joe Scarpati and the 1971 tenth-round selection used on Rocky Pamplin for Norman Davis and Bo Burris. Scarpati immediately started 11 games for the Saints in 1970 and intercepted a pass, giving New Orleans useful short-term value from the veteran. Pamplin did not add meaningful NFL production, but Scarpati’s starting role gives the Saints the better realized return.
New Orleans Saints received Sam Walton from New York Jets for undisclosed pick and draft pick (selection not identified). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers received Joe Owens from New Orleans Saints for 1971 fourth round pick (#91-D'Artagnan Martin). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received Ted Davis from New Orleans Saints for 1971 eighth round pick (#201-Bob Gresham). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans Saints received undisclosed pick from Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders for Jerry Jones. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Buffalo acquired center Frank Marchlewski from New Orleans for a 1971 fourth-round pick that became Carlos Bell at No. 82. Marchlewski immediately started all 13 games he played for the Bills in 1970, giving Buffalo a full season of dependable offensive-line value. Bell reached the Saints but appeared in only one NFL game. Turning a future fourth-rounder into an immediate starting center gives Buffalo the clear advantage.
New Orleans Saints received Loyd Phillips from Chicago Bears for Jim Hester and undisclosed pick. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received Frank Marchlewski from Los Angeles Rams for draft pick (possibly 1971 #418-Randy Vataha). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans Saints
Chicago acquired defensive back George Youngblood from New Orleans for a 1970 fifth-round selection. Youngblood started all 14 games for the Bears in 1969, intercepted three passes, and returned one for a touchdown, so Chicago received immediate defensive production. New Orleans used the acquired No. 106 pick on Glenn Cannon, but that selection did not create comparable long-term value. The short duration of Youngblood’s career keeps the deal roughly even.
New Orleans Saints received Don Shy and Ken Kortas from Pittsburgh Steelers for Don McCall, 1971 fifth round pick (probably #106-Larry Brown) and 1971 eighth round pick (#184-Larry Crowe). The recorded outcome favors Pittsburgh Steelers.
Washington received Dennis Hale from New Orleans Saints for Mike Morgan (Lee). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans Saints received draft pick (selection not identified) from Detroit Lions for Jim Boeke. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Washington received Randy Schultz and 1970 fifth round pick (#114-Manny Sistrunk) from New Orleans Saints for Jim Ninowski. The recorded outcome favors Washington.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and cash from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed consideration and Gary Lane. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received Andy Livingston (a) from Chicago Bears for 1971 second round pick (#28-Jim Harrison). The recorded outcome favors Chicago Bears.
Atlanta Falcons received Jerry Jones, Roy Schmidt and Jim Ferguson from New Orleans Saints for Errol Linden and Don Talbert. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Washington received Dave Long and draft pick (possibly 1970 #103-Paul Laaveg) from New Orleans Saints for Jim Ninowski. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Los Angeles acquired quarterback Karl Sweetan from New Orleans for the 1971 fourth-round pick later used on Don Morrison. Sweetan served as a reserve for two Rams seasons, appearing in 11 games and throwing only 26 regular-season passes. Morrison became a long-term Saints starting tackle, starting 92 games for New Orleans from 1971 through 1977. The Rams received modest backup value while surrendering the asset that produced a foundational lineman.
Cleveland Browns received cash from New Orleans Saints for Ralph Smith / Catfish Smith. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
St. Louis acquired John Gilliam from New Orleans and immediately unlocked a major offensive season: 52 catches, 997 yards, and nine touchdowns in 1969. The Cardinals paid Dave Long, Dick Kasperek, Brady Keys, and the second-round pick that became Richard Neal. Gilliam was clearly the best individual performer in the deal, but surrendering three veterans plus a second-rounder made the acquisition expensive.
Baltimore sent running back Tony Lorick to New Orleans for the Saints' 1969 second-round pick. The choice became Ted Hendricks at No. 33, a future Hall of Fame linebacker who played 215 consecutive games, reached eight Pro Bowls and helped the Colts win Super Bowl V. Lorick's Saints career lasted two seasons and produced only limited offensive value, creating a massive imbalance.
New Orleans Saints received Jim Boeke from Dallas Cowboys for Jackie Burkett. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Los Angeles Rams received Kent Kramer from New Orleans Saints for 1970 fifth round pick (#126-Steve Ramsey). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans traded linebacker Dave Simmons to Dallas for a 1969 fourth-round pick, No. 102, later used on tackle Bob Hudspeth. Simmons played 13 games for the Cowboys in 1968 and intercepted a pass before being released the next year. Hudspeth did not establish an NFL career. The return was short-lived on both sides, but Dallas received actual regular-season contribution and therefore gets the narrow win.
New Orleans Saints received draft pick (possibly 1969 #117-Keith Christensen), undisclosed pick and undisclosed consideration from New York Giants for Gary Wood and undisclosed consideration. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans Saints received Karl Sweetan from Detroit Lions for Walter Roberts, 1969 "high" draft pick (possibly 1969 #59-Larry Walton) and Walter Roberts / Walt Roberts. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Cleveland converted veteran linebacker Johnny Brewer into a 1970 second-round pick, No. 36 overall, that became defensive end Joe “Turkey” Jones. Brewer still gave New Orleans 37 games and 31 starts from 1968 through 1970, so the Saints received real short-term value. Jones, however, developed into a 134-game NFL defender, giving Cleveland the stronger long-range return and the win.
Atlanta Falcons received William Clay / Bill Clay? / Billy Clay? from New Orleans Saints for cash. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Los Angeles Rams received Jim Garcia from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed draft pick (not exercised?). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
San Francisco 49ers received George Rose from New Orleans Saints for Monte Stickles / Monty Stickles. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Atlanta Falcons received cash from New Orleans Saints for Jake Kupp. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
San Francisco 49ers received Jim Jordan from New Orleans Saints for Daniel Colchico / Dan Colchico. The recorded outcome favors San Francisco 49ers.
New Orleans Saints received Archie Sutton from Minnesota Vikings for Tom Hall (Francis). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Minnesota acquired quarterback Gary Cuozzo from New Orleans for the Vikings' first-round picks in 1968 and 1969. Those selections became Kevin Hardy at No. 7 and John Shinners at No. 17. Neither became a star for the Saints, but two first-round assets still outweighed Cuozzo's uneven Minnesota tenure, giving New Orleans the better return without making the trade a franchise-changing victory.
Atlanta Falcons received Ray Ogden from New Orleans Saints for Ernie Wheelwright (Lamour). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Atlanta Falcons received Jerry Simmons from New Orleans Saints for cash. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Atlanta Falcons received Charles Wood (a) from New Orleans Saints for cash. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Dallas Cowboys received Larry Stephens from New Orleans Saints for 1968 fourth round pick (#103-Dan Sartin). Stephens remained with Dallas during its 1967 championship-game season, giving the Cowboys the only meaningful team-specific return. Across the complete player and draft outcomes, the exchange supports the Dallas Cowboys Win verdict while still crediting the other club for the useful value it realized.
San Francisco 49ers received draft pick (possibly 1968 #141-Leo Johnson / Lee Johnson) from New Orleans Saints for David McCormick / Dave McCormick. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Cleveland Browns received cash from New Orleans Saints for Randy Schultz. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
New Orleans Saints received Eli Stroud from Pittsburgh Steelers for cash. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
Chicago Bears received Don Croftcheck from New Orleans Saints for Doug Atkins and Herman Lee. Croftcheck played only nine games with two starts for Chicago. Across the complete player and draft outcomes, the exchange supports the New Orleans Saints Win verdict while still crediting the other club for the useful value it realized.
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration and cash from New Orleans Saints for undisclosed consideration and Jim Colvin / Rocky Colvin. The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received Hershel Turner and Hershel Turner / Herchel Turner from Arizona Cardinals for undisclosed pick and draft pick (not disclosed). The recorded outcome favors New Orleans Saints.
New Orleans Saints received Bruce McLenna from Detroit Lions for Charles Bradshaw and Charles Bradshaw / Charlie Bradshaw. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
New Orleans sent Bill Curry, the No. 1 overall pick, a 1967 third-round pick and a 1969 seventh-rounder to Baltimore for quarterback Gary Cuozzo, Buford Allison and a 1967 seventeenth-round pick. Baltimore used No. 1 on Bubba Smith and also gained Curry, both future All-Pro-level starters on Super Bowl teams. Cuozzo lasted one Saints season before being traded again.