The Chargers acquired defensive back and return specialist…
The Chargers acquired defensive back and return specialist Ron Smith from Chicago for the 1974 third-round pick used on Wayne Wheeler. Smith immediately led the NFL in punt-return average, scored two punt-return touchdowns, and started nine games for San Diego in 1973. The Chargers then traded him for two more picks in 1974, creating a decisive value advantage.
Chicago Bears Received
- pick 1974 third round pick (#54-Wayne Wheeler)
Los Angeles Chargers Received
- player Ron Smith (b. 1943-05-03)
Trade Analysis
What Changed Hands
On May 22, 1973, Chicago traded Ron Smith to the San Diego Chargers for a 1974 third-round selection. The Bears used that choice, No. 54 overall, on Wayne Wheeler. Smith was already an experienced defensive back and return specialist, so the Chargers were buying immediate veteran production rather than a developmental prospect.
Los Angeles Return
Smith delivered right away. He played all 14 games for San Diego in 1973 and started nine at strong safety. His largest impact came on special teams: 27 punt returns produced 352 yards and two touchdowns, while 36 kickoff returns produced 947 yards. His 13.0-yard punt-return average led the NFL. That alone represents strong one-year value for a third-round pick. San Diego then extended the return by trading Smith to Oakland in 1974 for additional fourth- and eighth-round choices, meaning the Chargers received both productive play and renewed draft capital.
Chicago Return
The Bears used the acquired third-rounder on Wheeler. He appeared in 12 games as a rookie and caught five passes for 59 yards and a touchdown, but he did not develop into a long-term Chicago contributor. The selection had legitimate value, yet the player chosen did not approach the immediate impact Smith delivered for San Diego.
Final Verdict
The Chargers win decisively. They received one of the league's most productive return specialists in 1973, nine defensive starts, and later turned Smith into two more draft choices. Chicago received a third-round pick but only modest realized production from Wheeler. An A- for the Chargers and C for the Bears captures the substantial difference in realized value.