San Diego traded linebacker Bob Babich and a 1975…
San Diego traded linebacker Bob Babich and a 1975 fourth-round pick to Cleveland for the 1974 first-round selection used on Don Goode and the 1975 second-round selection used on Louie Kelcher. Babich became a six-year Browns regular, so Cleveland received legitimate value. Kelcher, however, became a Chargers Hall of Famer and one of the franchise's best defensive linemen, giving San Diego the stronger return.
Cleveland Browns Received
- player Bob Babich
- pick 1975 fourth round pick (#86-Allen Carter)
Los Angeles Chargers Received
- pick 1974 first round pick (#15-Don Goode)
- pick 1975 second round pick (#30-Louie Kelcher)
Trade Analysis
What the Trade Actually Did
San Diego sent linebacker Bob Babich and a 1975 fourth-round pick to Cleveland on Sept. 5, 1973. Chargers trade history identifies the return as Cleveland's 1974 first-round pick, No. 15, and 1975 second-round pick, No. 30. San Diego selected linebacker Don Goode with the first and defensive tackle Louie Kelcher with the second.
Why Kelcher Became the Difference
Kelcher developed into one of the Chargers' defining defensive linemen. He played 100 games for the franchise from 1975 through 1983, became a first-team All-Pro, reached multiple Pro Bowls, and later entered the Chargers Hall of Fame. His presence on the “Bruise Brothers” front gave San Diego high-end value well beyond the ordinary expectation for a second-round choice.
What Cleveland Got From Babich
The Browns were not empty-handed. Babich became a regular member of their defense and remained in Cleveland through 1978. He played 83 games for the Browns and supplied years of starting-linebacker stability. That durability is why Cleveland deserves a solid grade even though the premium picks ultimately produced the best player in the deal.
Why San Diego Still Comes Out Ahead
Goode added further value from the first-round selection, while Kelcher became the transaction's standout performer. Cleveland's fourth-round pick helped offset the price and Babich was useful for six seasons, but San Diego received two high selections and converted one into a franchise-level defender.
Final Verdict
The Chargers earn a B+ and the win because Kelcher's peak and longevity create the strongest individual value in the exchange, with Goode adding another return. Cleveland receives a B- because Babich was a genuine long-term starter rather than a failed acquisition. San Diego wins, but the Browns' six useful seasons keep the margin moderate.