The Chargers moved running back Duane Thomas to Washington…
The Chargers moved running back Duane Thomas to Washington and received a 1975 first-round pick plus a 1976 second-round pick. The first-rounder became Mike Williams at No. 22 in 1975. Thomas had already been a prominent but volatile back, so San Diego converted a short-term asset into two future chances to replenish the roster.
Los Angeles Chargers Received
- pick 1975 first round pick (#22- Mike Williams (Herman))
- pick 1976 second round pick
Washington Commanders Received
- player Duane Thomas
Trade Analysis
What the Trade Actually Did
The Chargers moved running back Duane Thomas to Washington and received a 1975 first-round pick plus a 1976 second-round pick. The first-rounder became Mike Williams at No. 22 in 1975. Thomas had already been a prominent but volatile back, so San Diego converted a short-term asset into two future chances to replenish the roster.
Why the Deal Made Sense
The package matters more than Thomas’s name recognition. San Diego received two future premium selections rather than a single late pick, giving the franchise flexibility across multiple drafts. Washington was pursuing immediate help under George Allen, whose veteran-heavy approach often accepted future-pick costs. Thomas fit that philosophy, but his contribution was too brief to justify the price in hindsight.
What the Return Became
The 1975 first-round choice became Mike Williams, while the 1976 second-rounder retained additional trade or draft value. Even without a superstar outcome from both selections, two premium assets gave San Diego more durable optionality.
Why the Value Separated
Thomas had talent and had already played on a championship team in Dallas, but his Washington stay did not become a long-term solution. The mismatch between acquisition cost and realized tenure drives the grade separation.
Final Verdict
Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers Win. The final grades reflect realized production, longevity, acquisition cost and the value of the draft capital that changed hands. Los Angeles Chargers receives A- and Washington Commanders receives D+.
How the Hindsight Standard Applies
This verdict does not assume that every draft choice should have produced a star. It compares what each club surrendered with the actual careers, roster roles and flexibility created by the exchange. That keeps the judgment centered on historical value rather than reputation alone.