Washington Commanders

San Francisco acquired Brian Robinson for a 2026 sixth-round pick and received immediate production in 2025. Robinson played all 17 games, carried 92 times for 400 yards and two touchdowns, then moved on to Atlanta for 2026. The 49ers received a useful one-season backfield return from a modest draft cost.

San Francisco agreed on March 1, 2025 to send Deebo Samuel to Washington for a fifth-round pick, and both clubs list the completed transaction on March 12. Washington received 16 games, 12 starts and 802 scrimmage yards with six touchdowns in 2025. San Francisco's No. 147 pick, Jordan James, produced only limited rookie action.

Washington acquired five-time Pro Bowl left tackle Laremy Tunsil and a 2025 fourth-round pick from Houston for a third, seventh, 2026 second and 2026 fourth. Tunsil immediately stabilized the left side, earning an 88.9 pass-blocking grade while allowing only a handful of pressures and later signing an extension. Houston received substantial draft capital, keeping the overall exchange close.

New Orleans sent Marshon Lattimore and a 2025 fifth-round pick to Washington for third-, fourth- and sixth-round selections. Those picks became Jonas Sanker, Quincy Riley and Devin Neal, and Sanker quickly emerged as a 16-game starting safety with two interceptions in 2025. Lattimore helped Washington during its 2024 NFC Championship run but played only 11 regular-season games for the Commanders through 2025. The younger, multi-player return now favors New Orleans.

New Orleans acquired defensive tackle John Ridgeway and Washington's 2025 seventh-round pick for the Saints' 2025 sixth-round selection. Ridgeway supplied rotational interior-line snaps, while the Saints retained a late-round draft asset. Washington improved by one round in draft order. The exchange gave New Orleans immediate depth at a modest draft cost without surrendering premium capital.

Cleveland traded kicker Cade York to Washington on August 22, 2024 for a conditional 2025 seventh-round pick. The condition required York to remain on Washington's 53-man roster for two games. He was released after Week 1, so the pick was not conveyed and Cleveland ultimately received no draft asset from the transaction.

Washington traded Jahan Dotson and a 2025 fifth-round pick to Philadelphia for a 2025 third-rounder and two 2025 seventh-rounders. Dotson helped the Eagles' championship run but remained a low-volume receiver, posting 216 regular-season yards in 2024 and 262 in 2025. Washington converted a player outside its plans into substantially stronger draft capital, giving the Commanders the long-term value edge.

Philadelphia moved from No. 50 to No. 40 by sending Washington picks No. 50, 53 and 161 for Nos. 40, 78 and 152. The Eagles selected Cooper DeJean, who became a Super Bowl playmaker and first-team All-Pro. Washington used No. 50 on Mike Sainristil and also added Ben Sinnott and Dominique Hampton, leaving both clubs with substantial young talent from the exchange.

Chicago acquired Montez Sweat for the 2024 second-round pick that became No. 40. Sweat produced 21.5 sacks in 42 regular-season games for the Bears from the trade through 2025 and signed a long-term extension. Washington later packaged No. 40 with two other picks to acquire Nos. 50, 53 and 161, so those three selections cannot be credited solely to the Sweat trade. Both sides created substantial value.

San Francisco 49ers received Chase Young. San Francisco received Chase Young, who immediately joined the pass rush during the club's run to Super Bowl LVIII. That result supports a B- for San Francisco 49ers. The overall comparison favors San Francisco 49ers, which produced the stronger realized return. The grade reflects the realized player service and draft value tied directly to this transaction, without assigning extra credit for outcomes that cannot be traced confidently to the exchanged assets.

Buffalo moved down in the 2023 fifth round and came away with No. 150 Justin Shorter plus No. 215. Shorter spent his rookie year on injured reserve and did not become an immediate Bills regular, but the additional sixth-round asset preserved value and was moved again. The two-piece return offsets Washington's quicker on-field contribution enough to keep Buffalo near even.

Pittsburgh acquired cornerback William Jackson III and a conditional 2025 seventh-round choice from Washington while sending back a conditional 2025 sixth-round choice. Jackson never appeared in a game for the Steelers because of a back injury and was released in March 2023. The playing-time conditions were not met, so neither conditional draft choice changed hands. Pittsburgh therefore received essentially no realized on-field value.

Carolina moved up for linebacker Brandon Smith at No. 120 and also received pick No. 189, used on edge defender Amare Barno. Washington received two fifth-rounders and selected Sam Howell and Cole Turner. Howell later started all 17 games for the Commanders in 2023 and was traded for additional draft value, while Carolina received only modest returns from Smith and Barno. Washington clearly created the stronger package.

New Orleans moved from No. 16 to No. 11 in 2022 for Chris Olave, sending Washington third- and fourth-round picks in the process. Olave has 291 catches for 3,728 yards and 19 touchdowns through four seasons, earned second-team All-Pro honors in 2025 and signed a new extension in 2026. Washington received meaningful value from Jahan Dotson and Brian Robinson Jr., but Olave became the best player in the transaction.

Indianapolis traded Carson Wentz plus picks No. 47 and No. 240 to Washington on March 16, 2022 for picks No. 42 and No. 73 plus a conditional 2023 third-round pick. The Colts later used No. 73 on Jelani Woods and the 2023 pick became No. 79 Josh Downs, while No. 42 was included in a trade-down that helped produce three additional selections. Downs alone had 207 catches for 2,249 yards and 11 touchdowns through Week 2 of 2026, giving Indianapolis the strongest direct long-term return.

Philadelphia sent 2021 picks No. 225 and No. 240 to Washington for a 2022 fifth-round selection. The Eagles preserved future draft flexibility and later moved that fifth-rounder in another sequence of transactions rather than making the selection themselves. That future asset had value, but Washington received multiple seasons from the specialist it targeted, leaving Philadelphia with the smaller realized return.

Miami sent guard Ereck Flowers and the 2021 seventh-round pick at No. 258 to Washington, receiving the No. 244 selection in return. The Dolphins gained modest draft position and moved Flowers' contract, but the pick used on Gerrid Doaks did not create value comparable to Flowers' immediate starting role in Washington. Miami's practical return was limited, supporting a C grade.

Las Vegas received Washington's 2021 sixth-round selection, No. 203, after sending David Sharpe and a seventh-rounder to Washington. The Raiders later moved that sixth in another transaction, so that later return is separate from this deal. The direct asset had value, but it did not create a clear Raiders contribution that outweighed Washington's immediate tackle depth plus the extra pick.

San Francisco acquired Trent Williams from Washington for a 2020 fifth-round pick and a 2021 third after the seven-time Pro Bowler had missed the entire 2019 season. Williams became even better with the 49ers, earning three straight first-team All-Pro selections from 2021 through 2023 and another All-Pro honor in 2025. Washington received Keith Ismael and Benjamin St-Juste, who supplied starting snaps but nowhere near Williams' value. San Francisco won decisively.

Carolina Panthers received 2020 5th round pick (148th overall subsequently traded, Alton Robinson) in the exchange with Washington. Carolina retained and redeployed the acquired fifth-round asset, preserving useful draft value rather than surrendering Kyle Allen without a return. Against Washington's return of Kyle Allen, that outcome supports a B grade. The transaction is judged as Carolina Panthers Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Seattle Seahawks received Quinton Dunbar in the exchange with Washington. Its C+ grade reflects the practical value of that return relative to the package surrendered and the hindsight result. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Buffalo sent two fourth-round picks to Washington to move up for tight end Dawson Knox at No. 96. Knox became a long-term starter in the Bills' Josh Allen offense and earned a multiyear extension after developing into a reliable receiving and red-zone option. Washington selected Bryce Love and Wes Martin, but neither produced comparable sustained value for the franchise.

Indianapolis traded the 26th pick in 2019 to Washington for No. 46 and a 2020 second-rounder. The Colts then moved No. 46 again, turning it into Ben Banogu and Marvell Tell, while the future choice became Michael Pittman Jr. Pittman developed into a long-term starting receiver and multiple-time 1,000-yard producer, giving Indianapolis the strongest piece of its eventual return despite Montez Sweat’s success in Washington.

Denver Broncos and Washington completed this transaction on 2019-03-13, with Denver Broncos receiving 2020 6th round pick (181st overall, Netane Muti) and Washington receiving Case Keenum and 2020 7th round pick (229th overall, James Smith-Williams). The cited historical sources support the basic exchange and its compensation. In hindsight, Washington gets the better grade because its return produced the clearer practical value from this modest exchange.

Green Bay Packers received 2019 4th round pick (118th overall subsequently traded, Hjalte Froholdt) in the deal with Washington Commanders. Green Bay later included pick 118 with pick 30 and another fourth-rounder to move up for Darnell Savage. The acquired pick therefore preserved meaningful draft-day leverage for the Packers. That outcome supports a B+ for Green Bay Packers. The Green Bay Packers Win verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Washington sent the Rams picks No. 205 and No. 231 for picks No. 197 and No. 256, selecting Shaun Dion Hamilton and Trey Quinn. Washington moved up for Shaun Dion Hamilton and Trey Quinn, receiving several seasons of linebacker and receiver depth. Los Angeles moved back for Trevon Young and Travin Howard. Howard developed into a useful linebacker and made a decisive interception during the Rams' 2021 NFC Championship run, giving the Rams the most consequential contribution from the four players involved.

San Francisco sent picks No. 59 and No. 74 to Washington for picks No. 44 and No. 142, then used them on Dante Pettis and D.J. Reed. Washington moved down and selected Derrius Guice and Geron Christian, but Guice's career was derailed before he could deliver meaningful value and Christian became a limited starter. San Francisco's Dante Pettis also failed to last, yet fifth-rounder D.J. Reed developed into a quality NFL corner after leaving the 49ers. San Francisco's side produced the stronger overall football value.

Denver Broncos received Su'a Cravens, the 2018 fourth-round pick used on DaeSean Hamilton, and an additional 2018 fifth-round selection from Washington Commanders. Cravens played only five Denver games, while Hamilton supplied some receiving value. The B- grade reflects a useful but limited return, with the final Washington Commanders Win call based on the broader value Washington created from its package.

Kansas City traded Alex Smith to Washington for cornerback Kendall Fuller and the 78th pick in the 2018 draft. Fuller gave the Chiefs two seasons of secondary play and was part of the Super Bowl LIV roster, while the draft capital added another valuable asset. The move also cleared the starting job for Patrick Mahomes, making Kansas City's return unusually strong even before considering the quarterback succession.

Los Angeles Rams received Derek Carrier from Washington Commanders. The Rams received Derek Carrier and used him in a modest tight end role for one season. He provided real but limited short-term service after the exchange. That outcome supports a C grade for Los Angeles Rams. The final verdict is Even Trade, based on the football value the club actually realized from the assets it controlled after the exchange.

Pittsburgh Steelers received Dashaun Phillips in the exchange with Washington. Its C grade reflects the practical value of that return relative to the package surrendered and the hindsight result. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Minnesota moved down two spots late in the 2017 sixth round and also changed seventh-round positions, landing Bucky Hodges at No. 201 and Ifeadi Odenigbo at No. 220. Washington used No. 199 on center Chase Roullier and No. 230 on Josh Harvey-Clemons. Roullier’s long run as a starting center gives Washington the stronger return.

New York gave Washington a 2017 fourth-round pick to acquire No. 158 in 2016 and drafted tackle Brandon Shell. Shell became a four-year Jets contributor with 40 starts. Washington used the future pick on Samaje Perine, who rushed for 603 yards as a rookie but had a much smaller role the next season. Perine had value, but New York received more sustained starting production.

New Orleans sent No. 152 and a 2017 fifth-rounder to Washington for No. 120 and selected David Onyemata. He became a seven-season Saints defensive-line fixture with more than 100 appearances. Washington used the incoming picks on Matthew Ioannidis and Jeremy Sprinkle; Ioannidis developed into a productive interior pass rusher and Sprinkle supplied several years of tight-end depth. Both teams turned modest capital into real contributors.

Houston moved up one spot in the 2016 first round for receiver Will Fuller, giving Washington pick 22 plus a 2017 sixth-rounder. Fuller became a dangerous vertical threat and produced five productive Texans seasons when healthy. Washington selected Josh Doctson at No. 22 and later Robert Davis with the extra pick; neither matched Fuller's impact. Houston clearly won despite Fuller's recurring injuries limiting the ceiling of the move.

Washington sent pick No. 167 to New Orleans for pick No. 187 and a 2016 sixth-round selection. Washington used those assets on Evan Spencer and Nate Sudfeld, but neither became a substantial contributor for the club. The move down created two opportunities instead of one, yet the added draft volume did not develop into meaningful long-term Washington production.

Washington traded pick No. 69 to Seattle for four later selections and used them on Matt Jones, Arie Kouandjio, a pick later moved to New Orleans, and Kyshoen Jarrett. Seattle used No. 69 on Tyler Lockett. Lockett became a franchise-level returner and receiver with a decade of Seahawks production, dwarfing Washington's combined return. The volume looked attractive on draft night, but Seattle found the one player who defined the trade.

Tampa Bay sent safety Dashon Goldson and a 2016 seventh-round pick, No. 232, to Washington for a 2016 sixth-round pick, No. 197. The Buccaneers turned No. 197 into Danny Vitale, gaining younger draft capital and salary flexibility. Goldson nevertheless gave Washington the more useful immediate football return, so Tampa Bay's side grades as respectable but weaker in hindsight.

Tennessee traded up eight spots in the sixth round for quarterback Zach Mettenberger, sending Washington picks that became Lache Seastrunk and Zach Hocker. Mettenberger never developed into a long-term answer, but he did start 10 games and threw for 2,347 yards as a Titan. Neither Washington selection produced regular-season value for Washington, giving Tennessee the modest but clear hindsight edge.

Dallas sent second- and third-round selections to Washington to move up for DeMarcus Lawrence. Lawrence became a four-time Pro Bowler and a decade-long defensive cornerstone for the Cowboys. Washington used the return on Trent Murphy and Spencer Long, both of whom became legitimate NFL starters. The two-player return was useful, but Lawrence developed into the transaction's most accomplished team-specific contributor.

Detroit acquired cornerback Kevin Barnes from Washington for an undisclosed conditional 2013 draft pick. Barnes appeared in only two games for the Lions, logged 14 defensive snaps and was released in September. The conditional pick was not exercised, so Washington ultimately received no draft asset from the deal. With almost no realized football value on either side, the C/C Even Trade result fits the realized outcome.

Buffalo gave Washington pick No. 71 and seventh-rounder No. 217 to move up two spots for receiver T.J. Graham at No. 69. Graham started 17 games across two Bills seasons but finished that stint with only 54 catches for 683 yards and three touchdowns. Washington selected guard Josh LeRibeus and safety Jordan Bernstine. LeRibeus supplied reserve-line value, while Bernstine's career was derailed immediately by injury, leaving neither side with a major return.

The Robert Griffin III trade remains one of the most famous quarterback gambles of the modern draft era. Washington moved a massive package to select Griffin, who delivered a spectacular rookie season but not long-term stability. The Rams turned the pick into a haul of premium assets, giving St. Louis the stronger long-term result. The deal remains a priority evergreen page because RGIII's rookie season, injury arc, and the Rams' asset haul still draw major trade-history interest.

Chicago/St. Louis Cardinals received Vonnie Holliday; 2012 6th round pick (177th overall, Justin Bethel) from Washington, giving up Tim Hightower. Arizona received veteran defensive lineman Vonnie Holliday plus the future sixth-rounder used on Justin Bethel. Getting both an immediate player and a realized draft asset supports a B. That return supports a B grade for Chicago/St. Louis Cardinals. The final verdict is Arizona/St. Louis Cardinals Win.

New England Patriots acquired Albert Haynesworth from Washington for the 2013 fifth-round pick that became No. 162, Brandon Jenkins. Haynesworth's stay in New England was short and unproductive, so the Patriots did not receive the hoped-for rebound from the veteran defensive lineman. Because they surrendered a real draft asset for little return, New England receives a D+.

Minnesota acquired Donovan McNabb from Washington in 2011 for a 2012 sixth-round pick and a conditional 2013 sixth that was not ultimately conveyed. McNabb started only six games before rookie Christian Ponder replaced him, and Minnesota released him during the season. Washington used the conveyed pick on Alfred Morris, who rushed for 1,613 yards as a rookie and became a multi-year starter. The Commanders received vastly more value.

Denver sent wide receiver Jabar Gaffney to Washington for defensive lineman Jeremy Jarmon in a straight player swap on July 27, 2011. Jarmon had only a brief Denver tenure and did not match the immediate production Gaffney delivered in Washington. With no additional consideration involved, the Broncos clearly received the weaker realized return from the exchange.

Washington sent picks No. 127, No. 144 and No. 152 to Houston for Nos. 105 and 178. Washington selected Roy Helu and Aldrick Robinson, receiving productive offensive seasons from both. Houston drafted Roc Carmichael, Shiloh Keo and T.J. Yates, with Yates delivering a rookie playoff victory during the franchise's first postseason appearance.

Chicago moved up to No. 53 and selected Stephen Paea, who became a multi-year Bears defensive tackle and regular starter. That direct player value is the strongest realized result in the trade. The cost was Nos. 62 and 127, but Washington moved both selections again, so later players tied to those pick numbers are not counted as direct Washington returns here.

Indianapolis moved up four spots for offensive lineman Ben Ijalana, sending Washington picks No. 53 and No. 152. Injuries prevented Ijalana from becoming a meaningful Colts contributor. Washington repeatedly recycled both acquired choices, turning them into portions of a broader 2011 draft-day chain that produced Leonard Hankerson, DeJon Gomes, Maurice Hurt, Roy Helu and Aldrick Robinson. The volume of usable downstream value clearly exceeded Indianapolis' return.

Miami sent picks No. 79, No. 146 and No. 217 to Washington to move up to No. 62 for running back Daniel Thomas. Thomas spent four seasons with the Dolphins as a rotational contributor. Washington used the three incoming selections on Leonard Hankerson, DeJon Gomes and Maurice Hurt, creating useful receiving, defensive and offensive-line contributions across several roster spots.

Jacksonville sent the 16th and 49th picks to Washington in 2011 to move to No. 10 for quarterback Blaine Gabbert. Gabbert went 5-22 as a Jaguars starter and was traded after three seasons. Washington selected Ryan Kerrigan at No. 16, landing a four-time Pro Bowler and franchise sack leader, while also controlling the second-round asset. The value gap makes this one of Washington's strongest draft-day wins.

Indianapolis acquired cornerback Justin Tryon from Washington for a 2011 seventh-round pick. Tryon appeared in 12 games for the Colts in 2010, started six and recorded 44 tackles with seven passes defended before a short 2011 return. Washington used No. 224 on linebacker Markus White, who played only a handful of NFL games. Indianapolis received the more substantial contribution from a very small investment.

Washington and St. Louis swapped 2010 draft picks Hall Davis and Dennis Morris late in the preseason. The exchange produced virtually no regular-season value for either receiving club. Davis never appeared in a Washington game and later surfaced with Tennessee, while Morris did not make the Rams' final roster. With both sides trading developmental players who failed to contribute for their new teams, the fairest hindsight result is a low-value even trade.

Baltimore Ravens received Doug Dutch in the exchange with Washington. Its C grade reflects the practical value of that return relative to the package surrendered and the hindsight result. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Washington sent New Orleans the 72nd pick in the 2011 draft for tackle Jammal Brown and the 155th selection. Brown started 26 games over two seasons, while the fifth-round choice became Niles Paul, who spent six years in Washington and developed into a useful tight end and special-teams player. New Orleans selected Martez Wilson at No. 72, but his impact never matched Washington's combined return.

Miami traded sixth- and seventh-round choices to Washington for pick No. 163 and selected safety Reshad Jones. Jones became a ten-year Dolphin, a two-time Pro Bowler and one of the franchise’s most productive defensive backs of the decade. Washington selected Dennis Morris and Terrence Austin; Morris was traded before the season and Austin had a limited receiving role. The hindsight gap is enormous.

Oakland acquired Jason Campbell from Washington for a 2012 fourth-round pick. Campbell gave the Raiders two seasons, appeared in 19 games and posted an 11-7 starting record with 3,557 passing yards, 19 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. Washington eventually received pick No. 109 and moved it again, but the Raiders obtained credible starting-quarterback play for a modest future selection and clearly won the exchange.

Washington sent pick No. 208 to New England for selections No. 229 and No. 231 in the 2010 draft. The Commanders selected Erik Cook and Selvish Capers, while the Patriots used No. 208 on Thomas Welch. None of the three linemen became a durable starter for the club that drafted him, leaving the direct football returns similarly limited.

Washington acquired Adam Carriker while moving down 28 spots in the fifth round and up three spots in the seventh. Carriker started 33 games and recorded seven sacks for Washington. St. Louis later traded the incoming fifth-rounder and used part of the return on Eugene Sims, who played seven seasons for the Rams and recorded 12 sacks. Both clubs found meaningful defensive value, making this a genuine draw.

Philadelphia traded Donovan McNabb within the division for pick No. 37 in 2010 and a conditional 2011 selection that became No. 104. The Eagles drafted safety Nate Allen with the second-rounder and later traded No. 104 for Casey Matthews plus a 2012 fourth-round pick. McNabb started only 13 games for Washington before the relationship collapsed. Philadelphia extracted multiple years of value from a quarterback it was ready to replace.

Minnesota moved up eight spots in the fifth round for linebacker Jasper Brinkley, sending Washington picks 158 and 221. Brinkley became a useful Vikings defender and eventual starting middle linebacker, appearing across six seasons in Minnesota. Washington selected Cody Glenn and Eddie Williams with the return, but neither produced comparable NFL value, leaving the Vikings with the clear advantage from a modest draft-day move.

Miami Dolphins received 2009 second-round pick (44th overall, Pat White); 2010 sixth-round pick (174th overall, later traded). Miami used Washington's 2009 second-round selection at No. 44 on Pat White. The acquired sixth-rounder became No. 174, but Miami did not use it on Dennis Morris. Those receiving-team outcomes support a B+ grade. Washington held the counterparty return, and the transaction-level verdict is Miami Dolphins Win.

Minnesota traded defensive end Erasmus James to Washington on May 27, 2008, for a conditional 2009 seventh-round pick that became No. 221. The Vikings later used that selection as part of the move up for Jasper Brinkley, while James appeared in only five games for Washington before being released. Minnesota's recovered draft value clearly exceeded Washington's brief return.

Tennessee moved up to No. 103 for William Hayes, who played 48 Titans games, started 12 and recorded eight sacks from 2008-11. Washington got Justin Tryon at No. 124, who played 29 games with two starts, then paired No. 157 with another seventh-rounder to obtain Durant Brooks and Kareem Moore. Moore became the best Washington downstream result with 42 games and 13 starts, but No. 157 was only half of that move. The concrete returns balance at B/B.

Washington sent picks No. 157 and No. 228 to St. Louis for Nos. 168 and 180. Washington selected punter Durant Brooks and safety Kareem Moore; Moore played 42 games with 13 starts, while Brooks lasted six games. The Rams selected Roy Schuening and Chris Chamberlain. Schuening contributed almost nothing, but Chamberlain became a four-year Ram with 59 games and 19 starts, giving St. Louis the stronger return.

Atlanta moved from No. 34 to No. 21 in the 2008 draft and received picks 84 and 154, turning the package into Sam Baker, Harry Douglas and Kroy Biermann. Washington received picks 34, 48 and 103, highlighted by tight end Fred Davis but undermined by the miss on Devin Thomas. Atlanta landed three meaningful contributors and clearly extracted more long-term value.

Washington acquired veteran guard Pete Kendall from the New York Jets on August 23, 2007. The conditional compensation escalated to a 2009 fourth-round pick, No. 115 overall, after Kendall met the playing-time trigger; he started all 32 regular-season games for Washington across 2007 and 2008.

Chicago Bears received Adam Archuleta in the exchange with Washington Commanders. Archuleta played 15 games with 10 starts for Chicago in 2007, totaling 61 tackles, two sacks and an interception. The Bears received a meaningful season of defensive snaps from the veteran. The B- grade reflects the direct value Chicago Bears realized from the deal, while the Chicago Bears Win call weighs actual regular-season service and clearly connected draft value rather than name recognition alone.

Atlanta turned surplus running back T.J. Duckett into wide receiver Ashley Lelie in a three-team deal with Washington and Denver. Lelie gave the Falcons a full season of receiver depth, while Duckett was used sparingly in Washington and left after one year. Because Washington also sent Denver meaningful draft capital to complete the transaction, Atlanta extracted the stronger value from its outgoing asset.

In a three-team deal, Washington received running back T.J. Duckett from Atlanta, Denver received Washington's 2007 third-round and 2008 fourth-round choices, and Atlanta received wide receiver Ashley Lelie from Denver. Although Atlanta completed the player bridge, the Washington-Denver value exchange is stark: two useful draft assets went to Denver while Washington received only a small amount of one-season production.

Washington and San Francisco exchanged Mike Rumph and Taylor Jacobs in August 2006. Rumph appeared in seven games for Washington, recording 11 combined tackles and four passes defensed. Jacobs lasted into a second 49ers season but remained a minor receiving option, totaling seven catches for 69 yards and one touchdown across 12 games with San Francisco. Both clubs obtained some short-term depth, but neither return created enough value to separate the deal.

Washington moved up to No. 35 in the 2006 draft for linebacker Rocky McIntosh, sending the Jets picks 53 and 189 plus a 2007 second-rounder. New York later used those pieces in multiple moves: No. 53 helped facilitate the Kellen Clemens trade-up, No. 189 became Drew Coleman after more movement, and the 2007 pick helped bring Thomas Jones.

New York Jets received Patrick Ramsey. New York received Patrick Ramsey, who attempted only one pass for the Jets before leaving after the 2006 season. That result supports a D for New York Jets. The overall comparison favors Washington Commanders, leaving New York Jets on the weaker side of the exchange. The grade reflects the realized player service and draft value tied directly to this transaction, without assigning extra credit for outcomes that cannot be traced confidently to the exchanged assets.

Washington acquired wide receiver Brandon Lloyd from San Francisco for a 2006 third-round pick and a 2007 fourth-round pick, a two-choice price that was larger than the old record showed. The 49ers' return was not a home run, yet Washington paid meaningful capital for very little production, making San Francisco the clear winner on cost and outcome.

Carolina Panthers received Rod Gardner in the exchange with Washington Commanders. Gardner produced nine receptions for 84 yards and one touchdown in 11 Panthers games before leaving. Carolina received only a short and modest contribution from the veteran receiver. The D grade reflects the direct value Carolina Panthers realized from the deal, while the Washington Commanders Win call weighs actual regular-season service and clearly connected draft value rather than name recognition alone.

Minnesota moved up eight spots in the fourth round of the 2005 draft, sending Washington picks No. 120 and No. 154 for No. 112. The Vikings selected running back Ciatrick Fason; Washington chose Manuel White and Robert McCune. Fason scored five rushing touchdowns, but none of the three developed into a substantial long-term starter.

Washington paid a 2005 third-rounder plus its 2006 first- and fourth-round selections to obtain Denver's No. 25 pick and draft quarterback Jason Campbell. Campbell became a multi-year starter, so the move was not empty. Denver nevertheless received a premium package, including the pick used on Brandon Marshall and a future first-rounder, making the Broncos the clear value winner despite Washington getting meaningful quarterback play.

The Jets reacquired Laveranues Coles by sending Santana Moss to Washington in a straight receiver swap. Coles immediately returned to a productive role in New York and remained a dependable starter for four seasons. Moss, however, delivered a franchise-record 1,483-yard debut season, became a Pro Bowler and stayed in Washington for a decade, creating substantially more long-term value.

Washington moved up in the 2004 third round for tight end Chris Cooley and also received a fifth-round pick, while New Orleans acquired a fifth-rounder that became Rodney Leisle plus Washington's 2005 second-round pick, used on Josh Bullocks. Bullocks became a multi-year starter, so the Saints received real value. Cooley developed into a two-time Pro Bowler and one of Washington's most productive tight ends, giving Washington the better return.

Philadelphia Eagles and Washington completed this exchange on 2004-03-31. Philadelphia Eagles received 2005 5th round pick (146th overall, Trent Cole), while Washington received James Thrash. The historical sources agree on the core package and transaction identity. In hindsight, The deal is a classic example of a modest draft asset turning into premium value. Thrash gave Washington functional depth, while Cole produced years of high-end defensive play, creating a decisive gap. The final grades are A+ for Philadelphia Eagles and D for Washington, producing a Philadelphia Eagles Win verdict.

Chicago Bears received Bryan Johnson in the exchange with Washington Commanders. Johnson appeared in 19 Bears games over 2004 and 2005 and scored two receiving touchdowns in his first Chicago season. He gave the Bears usable fullback depth across parts of two years. The B- grade reflects the direct value Chicago Bears realized from the deal, while the Chicago Bears Win call weighs actual regular-season service and clearly connected draft value rather than name recognition alone.

Denver traded Clinton Portis to Washington and received Champ Bailey plus the 41st pick in the 2004 draft, which became Tatum Bell. Portis produced several excellent seasons in Washington, including three 1,200-yard campaigns, so the deal was not a failure for Washington. Bailey became a Hall of Fame cornerback and perennial Pro Bowler in Denver, however, while the Broncos also received meaningful draft capital.

Washington acquired veteran quarterback Mark Brunell from Jacksonville for the 72nd pick in the 2004 draft. Brunell struggled in his first season but rebounded in 2005, starting 15 games for a 10-6 playoff team and throwing 23 touchdowns against 10 interceptions. Jacksonville later moved pick No. 72 for Jorge Cordova and Anthony Maddox, neither of whom became a major contributor. Washington received the more consequential return.

Washington acquired defensive tackle Lional Dalton from Denver in 2003 for a conditional 2004 pick. The original terms called for a fifth-rounder if Dalton played at least 40 percent of defensive snaps and a seventh otherwise; the final compensation became a conditional sixth-round pick, No. 171 Triandos Luke. Dalton started nine games for Washington, giving the Commanders the better immediate return.

New Orleans Saints received 2004 7th round pick (206th overall subsequently traded, Mark Jones) in the 2003-08-20 exchange with Washington. Washington acquired defensive tackle Martin Chase from New Orleans on August 20, 2003 for a 2004 seventh-round choice that would have escalated if Chase met a playing-time threshold. The condition did not trigger, leaving the Saints with pick No. 206. The documented result supports a C grade for New Orleans Saints. The overall verdict is Even Trade, based on realized value rather than hypothetical upside.

Washington traded guard David Brandt to Green Bay for a conditional 2004 seventh-round pick that would convey only if Brandt made the Packers' roster. Green Bay waived Brandt before the 2003 regular season, and the pick was not exercised. Washington therefore received no draft asset, while Green Bay received no regular-season contribution. The realized result was effectively zero value on both sides.

Washington and New England exchanged third-round positions in March 2003, with Washington receiving picks 81 and 140 for pick 75 and a 2004 fourth-rounder. Washington used No. 81 on Derrick Dockery, who became a durable multi-year starting guard. New England later used pick 75 in its move for Eugene Wilson and traded the 2004 fourth for veteran nose tackle Ted Washington.

Washington obtained running back Trung Canidate from St. Louis for guard David Loverne and a 2003 fourth-round pick, later used on DeJuan Groce. Canidate led Washington in rushing in 2003 with 600 yards across 11 games, while the Rams received line depth and a defensive back. St. Louis collected multiple pieces, but Washington got the strongest immediate on-field production from the exchange.

Detroit received the 144th pick in the 2003 draft and selected James Davis. Detroit received the 144th pick in the 2003 draft and used it on James Davis. Davis went on to play forty games and make thirty starts for the Lions, turning a fifth-round return into a substantial amount of lineup value. For a modest veteran trade, that is a notably successful draft conversion. In hindsight, that result supports a B+ grade for Detroit Lions in a deal ultimately judged as Detroit Lions Win.

Miami acquired quarterback Sage Rosenfels from Washington in August 2002 for a 2003 seventh-round pick. Rosenfels served primarily as a reserve for the Dolphins and did not produce major statistics there, but he remained with the club for four seasons before later becoming a more experienced NFL backup and spot starter. Washington used the acquired late pick on Gibran Hamdan, who did not record meaningful NFL playing time. Miami gets the modest edge.

Washington moved down from No. 18 to No. 21 in the 2002 first round and received Oakland's third-round pick at No. 89. Oakland immediately used No. 18 as part of another move to No. 17 for Phillip Buchanon. Washington later moved both acquired choices again while reshaping its draft board. Because neither club directly turned this exchange into a lasting cornerstone, the trade grades remain close.

Washington sent the 21st pick in the 2002 draft to New England for picks 32, 96 and 234. Washington selected quarterback Patrick Ramsey at No. 32 and later moved No. 96 in another deal, while New England used No. 21 on tight end Daniel Graham. Ramsey showed flashes but never became a long-term starter; Graham became a dependable run-game contributor on championship teams, giving New England a narrow edge.

Washington moved from pick 52 to 56 in the 2002 second round, sending Baltimore selections 52 and 96 for picks 56, 87 and 159. The Ravens selected defensive lineman Anthony Weaver at 52 and later moved pick 96, while Washington drafted Ladell Betts, Cliff Russell and Andre Lott. Betts became a productive multi-year back in Washington, giving that larger three-pick return the advantage.

New York used the acquired fifth-round selection on offensive lineman Jonathan Goodwin. Goodwin gave the Jets four seasons of useful interior-line service and later built a long NFL career. His Jets contribution made the pick a solid return, but the trade sent Washington two separate assets that each generated meaningful playing time, which keeps New York on the losing side of a productive exchange.

Houston Texans received Jerry DeLoach. Washington acquired Danny Wuerffel as quarterback depth in a system familiar to him, but the move produced only limited lasting value. Its C+ grade reflects the value of that return relative to what Washington received. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Washington acquired running back Robert Arnaud from New Orleans on July 20, 2001 for a conditional 2002 seventh-round pick. Washington released Arnaud in August, which prevented the condition from triggering, so the pick was not surrendered.

The Rams moved from No. 145 to No. 154 and added No. 186, while Washington used No. 145 on cornerback Jerametrius Butler. Washington selected receiver Darnerien McCants at No. 154 and Mario Monds at No. 186. McCants contributed 58 receptions and eight touchdowns, but Butler produced the strongest career in the deal, appearing in 71 games and intercepting nine passes. That gives the Rams the better return.

San Francisco 49ers received 2001 7th round pick (224th overall, Eric Johnson) from Washington Commanders. San Francisco received the future seventh-round choice later used on Eric Johnson. Johnson developed into a productive multi-year 49er and posted a major receiving season in 2004, creating substantial value from a late pick. That outcome supports a B+ grade for San Francisco 49ers. The final verdict is San Francisco 49ers Win, based on the football value the club actually realized from the assets it controlled after the exchange.

Miami acquired veteran punter Matt Turk from Washington for a 2001 seventh-round pick. Turk immediately handled all 16 games for the Dolphins in 2000, averaging 42.1 yards on 92 punts, and returned for several more Miami seasons. Washington received only late-round draft capital. Getting a proven starting specialist for such a small price makes Miami the clear winner, even though Turk’s Pro Bowl peak came earlier in Washington.

San Francisco sent the No. 3 pick in the 2000 draft to Washington on February 26 for first-round selections Nos. 12 and 24 plus fourth- and fifth-round choices that ultimately slotted at Nos. 119 and 154. Washington used No. 3 on Chris Samuels, while San Francisco spread its return across several draft assets. The long-term value supports an even result.

Miami traded defensive tackle Barron Tanner to Washington on September 4, 1999 for a 2001 sixth-round pick that became Josh Heupel. Tanner had played 29 games for Miami but did not appear in a regular-season game for Washington. Heupel also never became an NFL regular-season contributor, yet Miami still gained a draft asset for a player Washington did not use, giving the Dolphins the better side.

Washington acquired cornerback Tito Paul from Denver for seventh-round selections in 2000 and 2001. Paul was a short-term depth addition rather than a long-running starter, while Denver later moved both late-round assets before the selections were made. The trade therefore produced little durable franchise value on either side. Washington received immediate roster help, and Denver preserved two small pieces of future flexibility, making the outcome essentially even.

Washington traded tackle Shar Pourdanesh to Pittsburgh in August 1999 for a conditional 2000 seventh-round pick that would transfer if he made the Steelers' roster. The condition was satisfied, and the pick became No. 216, Delbert Cowsette. Pittsburgh obtained immediate tackle depth at a low price, while Washington recovered a late selection. The useful short-term fit gives Pittsburgh a slight edge.

Philadelphia Eagles and Washington completed this exchange on 1999-04-28. Philadelphia Eagles received 2000 6th round pick (192nd overall, John Romero), while Washington received Rodney Peete. The historical sources agree on the core package and transaction identity. In hindsight, For a minor transaction, usable quarterback depth carried more realized value than the eventual draft outcome. Washington therefore deserves a modest edge rather than an inflated grade. The final grades are C for Philadelphia Eagles and B- for Washington, producing a Washington Commanders Win verdict.

Denver Broncos received 1999 6th round pick (179th overall, Desmond Clark) and 1999 7th round pick (218th overall, Billy Miller) from Washington in the 1999-04-18 exchange. Denver turned the two acquired picks into Desmond Clark and Billy Miller; Clark produced 905 receiving yards and nine touchdowns for Denver in 2000-01, while Washington's Derek Smith never played an NFL regular-season game. Measured by what Denver Broncos actually realized after the deal, the return supports a A grade and represents the stronger realized return. The overall judgment is Denver Broncos Win.

Washington turned the No. 5 pick in the 1999 draft into the Saints' remaining 1999 draft class plus first- and third-round selections in 2000. The future first landed at No. 2 overall and became LaVar Arrington, while the rest of the package created extraordinary flexibility across two drafts. Washington did not maximize every individual piece, but controlling eight incoming selections for one move down created a massive roster-building advantage.

Washington moved up to No. 7 in the 1999 draft and selected Champ Bailey, while Chicago received No. 12 plus four additional picks. The Bears turned that volume into Cade McNown, D'Wayne Bates, Warrick Holdman, Jerry Wisne and Dustin Lyman. Bailey became a Hall of Fame cornerback, giving Washington overwhelming star value despite Chicago's much larger collection of selections.

Minnesota traded Brad Johnson to Washington for the 11th and 73rd picks in the 1999 draft. The Vikings used No. 11 on Daunte Culpepper, who became a three-time Pro Bowl quarterback and threw for more than 24,000 career yards. Washington received a capable veteran who helped the 1999 team reach the playoffs, but Minnesota landed a younger franchise quarterback plus another premium asset.

Oakland moved from No. 113 to No. 109 in the 1998 draft, sending Washington the 113th pick and No. 191. The Raiders selected guard-center Gennaro DiNapoli, who played 39 career games and only 11 for Oakland. Washington used No. 113 on linebacker Shawn Barber, who played 111 career games and started 34 times for Washington. That substantial difference in career and team value gives Washington the edge.

Cincinnati traded defensive tackle Dan Wilkinson to Washington in February 1998 for the 17th and 78th picks. The Bengals selected linebacker Brian Simmons and guard Mike Goff, both long-term starters, while Wilkinson gave Washington several solid seasons in the middle of its defensive line. Washington received a useful veteran, but Cincinnati turned one player into two durable building blocks and wins the trade in hindsight.

Atlanta traded the 140th pick in the 1997 draft to Washington and received picks 180 and 222. Washington selected defensive back Keith Thibodeaux, while Atlanta chose guard Calvin Collins and defensive back Chris Bayne. Collins alone played 68 NFL games and developed into a multi-year starter, with Bayne adding further depth. That two-player return gives the Falcons a clear hindsight advantage over Washington's single selection.

Washington moved on from former No. 3 overall pick Heath Shuler and received a 1997 fifth-rounder plus a 1998 third-rounder. The later pick became running back Skip Hicks, who scored 13 rushing touchdowns in 38 NFL games. Shuler's New Orleans stint was brief and unsuccessful. Recovering two draft choices from a quarterback who was already trending toward bust status made this a strong Washington exit.

Washington traded picks 37 and 67 to Dallas in 1996 to move into the first round at No. 30 and select Penn State tackle Andre Johnson. Johnson never played a regular-season game for Washington and appeared in only three NFL games. Dallas drafted defensive end Kavika Pittman and center Clay Shiver, both multi-year contributors, making the Cowboys the overwhelming winner despite neither becoming a star.

Washington acquired defensive tackle Sean Gilbert from the Rams for the sixth pick in the 1996 draft and received immediate high-level defensive production. Gilbert recorded 10.5 sacks in his first Washington season and gave the club an established interior force during a competitive stretch. The relationship later became complicated by a contract dispute, but the football return still compared favorably with what St. Louis ultimately received from the premium pick.

Las Vegas Raiders received 1995 5th round pick (138th overall, Matt Dyson) in the 1995-04-23 exchange with Washington Commanders. Matt Dyson appeared in only a handful of NFL games, leaving Oakland with very little realized return from the higher selection. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Las Vegas Raiders surrendered, the result supports Washington Commanders Win and a D grade for Las Vegas Raiders.

Arizona Cardinals received 1995 7th round pick (212th overall, Billy Williams) in the exchange with Washington Commanders. The seventh-round selection did not become a comparable Cardinals contributor. Arizona received draft capital, but the direct football value tied to Williams was minimal. The D grade reflects the direct value Arizona Cardinals realized from the deal, while the Washington Commanders Win call weighs actual regular-season service and clearly connected draft value rather than name recognition alone.

Washington acquired Rich Gannon from Minnesota in August 1993 for conditional draft compensation that ultimately included the 1994 fifth-round pick used on Shelly Hammonds. Gannon started only four games for Washington and missed the following season with a shoulder injury. Minnesota's pick produced little, so Washington still won the immediate exchange, although Gannon's later MVP years came elsewhere and should not inflate this return.

Pittsburgh Steelers received 1993 seventh round pick (#185-Jeff Zgonina) from Washington Commanders, sending Huey Richardson the other way. Pittsburgh won this trade decisively in hindsight. That outcome supports a B+ grade for Pittsburgh Steelers, and the overall verdict is Pittsburgh Steelers Win. The grade stays proportional to the size of the exchange and the direct value created for the original club.

Minnesota acquired defensive end George Hinkle and wide receiver Joe Johnson from Washington for a conditional 1993 sixth-round pick. The condition did not elevate the selection, and Washington used No. 160 on tight end Frank Wycheck. Johnson contributed 21 catches for 211 yards in 1992, while Hinkle offered short-term depth. Wycheck's greatest years came after Washington, but becoming a long NFL starter gives the pick the stronger hindsight value.

Los Angeles Chargers received Stan Humphries from Washington Commanders in the 1992-08-13 trade. The Chargers acquired Stan Humphries, who immediately became their starting quarterback. Washington Commanders's return was 1993 conditional fourth round pick (later increased to third) (#80-Ed Bunn). Washington's conditional pick escalated to a third-rounder and became punter Ed Bunn at No. 80. Those realized outcomes, rather than the labels on the assets alone, drive the hindsight grade.

Cincinnati traded picks No. 4 and No. 58 to Washington for Nos. 6, 28 and 84 in the 1992 draft. The Bengals selected David Klingler, Darryl Williams and Leonard Wheeler, while Washington took Desmond Howard at No. 4 and quickly moved No. 58 to Dallas. Klingler's failure as Cincinnati's hoped-for franchise quarterback outweighed the useful Williams selection, leaving Washington with the better side.

Dallas sent the newly acquired Nos. 47 and 74 picks to Washington for Nos. 56 and 58 during the 1992 draft. Washington selected Shane Collins and Paul Siever. Dallas selected Clayton Holmes at No. 58 and traded No. 56 to Detroit for three later choices. The Cowboys win because their two incoming assets created more useful team-specific value, not because Jason Hanson's Detroit career belongs to Dallas.

San Diego sent Washington a 1992 first-round pick that became No. 6 overall and received No. 47 Eric Moten plus a 1992 fifth-round selection. Moten became a durable Chargers starter, while Washington turned the premium pick into leverage for another move up the 1992 board. Both clubs created meaningful value, even though Washington's later conversion carried mixed results.

Washington moved up from No. 20 to No. 17 in the 1991 first round and selected defensive tackle Bobby Wilson, sending Dallas No. 20 and fifth-round pick No. 132. Wilson gave Washington useful starting and rotational work, but Dallas immediately turned the 20th selection into another trade that helped produce Dixon Edwards and additional draft capital.

Washington acquired defensive tackle Eric Williams from Detroit for running back James Wilder and a 1991 fourth-round pick, No. 108 Tony Hill. Williams immediately became an important interior defender and started throughout Washington's 1991 championship season, posting a career-high 64 tackles and 17 quarterback hurries. Detroit received a veteran back and a mid-round choice, but neither matched Williams' impact on an elite Super Bowl defense.

Washington Commanders received Tim Johnson. Washington acquired defensive lineman Tim Johnson. He spent six seasons with the club, started 67 games, and recorded 20.5 sacks, creating a durable defensive return from the transaction. Both clubs received contributors, but Johnson's six seasons and 67 starts produced substantially more value for Washington than Cooper produced for Pittsburgh. That outcome supports an A- grade for Washington Commanders.

Miami moved into the 1990 fifth round at No. 137 and selected Leroy Holt. Holt's path to an NFL role was derailed by a neck injury before he could produce meaningful regular-season value. Because Miami consolidated its return into one selection that did not become a durable contributor, the Dolphins finished with little realized benefit from the exchange.

New England Patriots received 1990 fifth round pick (#110-Junior Robinson), 1990 fifth round pick (#111-Jeff Davidson) in the 1990-04-22 exchange with Washington. Washington moved two fifth-round choices, Nos. 110 and 111, to New England to obtain the fourth-round slot No. The documented result supports a C+ grade for New England Patriots. The overall verdict is New England Patriots Win, based on realized value rather than hypothetical upside.

Washington acquired punter Ralf Mojsiejenko from San Diego for a 1990 seventh-round pick that became No. 187, Nate Lewis. Contemporary reporting supports an August 29 agreement, while the league transaction log shows August 30. Washington solved a specialist need cheaply, but the Chargers converted the move into a future selection and receive the slight value edge.

Dallas acquired defensive tackle Dean Hamel from Washington on August 29, 1989 for a conditional 1990 draft choice that ultimately became the fifth-round No. 110 pick. Hamel stepped into the Cowboys lineup and supplied immediate defensive value. Washington later moved No. 110 in a separate draft-day deal, so the most tangible direct return from the original transaction belonged to Dallas.

New England acquired punter Monte Robbins from Washington for a 1990 fourth-round selection that historical records identify as No. 86. The pick later returned to Washington through a separate 1990 draft-day trade and should not be conflated with the Robbins transaction. With neither direct return creating a major durable advantage, the original exchange grades close to even.

San Diego sent Washington its 1989 twelfth-round selection, No. 316, which became Jimmie Johnson, and received Washington's 1990 twelfth-round choice, No. 326, later used on Elliott Searcy. The trade was essentially a one-year shift of very late draft capital. Washington received the earlier opportunity and extracted the slightly better practical value, while San Diego's deferred selection did not create a stronger NFL return.

Cleveland sent running back Earnest Byner to Washington in a straight player-for-player exchange for Mike Oliphant. Oliphant contributed mainly on special teams and carried only 15 times for 97 yards in his lone Browns season, while Byner went on to become a two-time Pro Bowler and championship back in Washington. The disparity makes this a costly Cleveland decision in hindsight.

Indianapolis sent Washington the 129th pick in the 1989 draft, used on Tim Smiley, for two 1990 choices that became Alan Grant at No. 103 and Harvey Wilson at No. 213. Grant immediately gave the Colts two full seasons, appearing in 32 games with eight starts and returning kicks. Smiley did not become an NFL regular-season contributor, giving Indianapolis the better return.

Washington acquired veteran running back Gerald Riggs and a 1990 fifth-round pick from Atlanta for a 1989 second-rounder and a 1990 first-rounder. The price was substantial, but Riggs became a short-yardage and goal-line weapon on Washington's 1991 championship team, scoring 11 regular-season rushing touchdowns and six more during the postseason run.

Green Bay sent Washington the rights to quarterback Jeff Graham and received the rights to Erik Affholter, pick No. 124 and pick No. 206. Those selections became Jeff Query and Brian Shulman. Washington's acquisition did not develop into a major quarterback payoff, while Green Bay collected multiple assets and found some usable depth. The Packers therefore earned the better return from an otherwise modest rights-and-picks transaction.

Washington traded Tim Morrison to Seattle for a conditional draft selection, but the conditions were not fulfilled. That outcome leaves Washington without an exercised pick to credit from the exchange. Seattle obtained the opportunity to evaluate Morrison, while neither side established a substantial return. An even grade reflects the limited realized value and the conditional nature of the price.

Los Angeles received the 1988 twelfth-round selection associated with Jeff Beathard plus a 1989 eleventh-round choice tied to Willie Griffin. Those late-round assets did not turn into meaningful direct Rams production. The package gave Los Angeles extra draft opportunities, but the eventual football return was too small to create a clear advantage in a deal built entirely around late selections.

New England Patriots received 1989 fourth round pick (#96-Maurice Hurst (Sr.) (Roy)). New England received the 1989 fourth-round choice used on Maurice Hurst. Hurst became a seven-year Patriots defensive back, appeared in 105 games, and intercepted 27 passes. That sustained production from a mid-round asset created the dominant return in the transaction and comfortably outweighs the value Washington obtained from the 1988 fifth-round selection it received. That result supports a A- grade for New England Patriots.

Washington traded picks No. 82, No. 137 and No. 165 to the Rams in the 1988 draft for No. 66, used on running back Mike Oliphant. Los Angeles found a useful defensive lineman in Mike Piel, who played 50 Rams games with 13 sacks. Washington's value became larger one year later when it traded Oliphant straight up for Earnest Byner, turning the acquired asset into a major multi-year contributor.

Indianapolis acquired Clarence Verdin from Washington on March 29, 1988 for a sixth-round pick, No. 159, later used on quarterback Stan Humphries. Verdin became a multi-year Colts receiver and return specialist, producing 437 receiving yards and four touchdowns in his first Indianapolis season. Humphries later had a strong NFL career, but Washington realized little of that success before he left the franchise.

On 1987-08-20, New England Patriots received undisclosed draft pick (undisclosed), while Washington received Glenn Dennison. The hindsight verdict is Even Trade, with New England Patriots graded C and Washington graded C. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and the football value that can be traced from it, while keeping unverified downstream pick identities or conditional outcomes out of the final judgment.

Washington acquired veteran tight end Chris Dressel from Houston in June 1987 for an undisclosed 1988 draft choice. Contemporary reports support a future pick but do not support the current conditional, not-exercised wording. Dressel was cut by Washington before the regular season, leaving the Redskins without game value from the acquisition. Houston therefore gets a narrow C+ to D+ win despite the unidentified downstream pick.

Buffalo moved up in the 1987 draft and used the acquired fourth-round selection on defensive lineman Leon Seals, who became a multi-year Bills contributor and finished his career with 14.5 sacks. Washington received two later picks, most notably the fifth-round choice used on Timmy Smith. Smith's regular-season career was brief, but his postseason peak helped make the return far more meaningful than his career totals alone suggest.

Washington moved up four spots in the second round of the 1987 draft for tackle Wally Kleine, giving the Raiders No. 52 and a fifth-round choice. Los Angeles used No. 52 on Bruce Wilkerson, who became a long-term starting tackle and appeared in 147 NFL games. Kleine did not provide Washington comparable staying power, so the Raiders won despite making only a modest move down.

Indianapolis acquired the rights to receiver Walter Murray from Washington on October 7, 1986, sending a 1987 second-round pick that became No. 30. Murray contributed modestly during two Colts seasons, while Washington used No. 30 on defensive back Brian Davis, who also failed to become a major long-term piece. Neither side created enough separation to claim a meaningful victory.

Washington traded punter Jeff Hayes to Cincinnati on August 19, 1986. Contemporary reporting called the return future considerations, while Bengals historical material describes undisclosed cash. Cincinnati received the only clearly measurable football asset, but the limited scale and unknown cash amount keep the hindsight verdict modest: Bengals win, C+ to C.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers received 1987 fifth round pick (#137-Tony Mayes) from Washington Commanders, sending rights to Doug Williams the other way. The current '(Lee)' suffix is unsupported and should be removed. That outcome supports a D grade for Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and the overall verdict is Washington Commanders Win.

New England traded the NFL rights to USFL receiver Ricky Sanders to Washington in August 1986 for Washington’s 1987 third-round pick, No. 81 overall. The Patriots retained useful draft value and later moved the choice in another deal. Washington, however, obtained a receiver who became a major part of its offense, topped 1,100 yards twice and scored 12 touchdowns in 1988.

Kansas City acquired center Rick Donnalley from Washington on April 29, 1986 and surrendered the sixth-round choice at No. 146. Donnalley gave the Chiefs useful immediate line help, including a starting role in 1986, so Kansas City received legitimate value. The problem is what Washington did with the pick: Mark Rypien became a two-time Pro Bowler and the quarterback of a Super Bowl champion.

Washington moved up from No. 128 to No. 113 in the 1986 draft and added No. 159 to complete the trade with Atlanta. The move produced linebacker Ravin Caldwell, who spent six seasons with Washington and appeared in 79 games, including on the 1987 and 1991 championship teams. Atlanta's two selections, Dan McMillen and Keith Williams, did not provide comparable staying power. Washington paid extra volume but found the useful long-term player.

Washington paid a 1986 tenth-round pick and its 1987 first-rounder to San Francisco for the 45th selection in 1986, using that pick on receiver Walter Murray. Murray never signed with Washington and was later moved to Indianapolis. San Francisco secured valuable future first-round capital without surrendering a proven player, giving the 49ers the clear advantage.

San Francisco 49ers received Tory Nixon in the 1985-09-03 exchange with Washington, giving up 1986 sixth round pick (#156-Jim Huddleston). San Francisco acquired Tory Nixon, who appeared in 50 regular-season games for the 49ers and made three interceptions, including an 88-yard touchdown return. That return supports a B grade for San Francisco 49ers. The final verdict is San Francisco 49ers Win, based on the football value tied directly to the assets in this deal.

Houston acquired kicker Tony Zendejas, who became a productive multi-season specialist for the Oilers. His sustained scoring contribution gave the franchise the clearest realized value in the deal and outweighed the future fifth-round asset that moved to Washington. That outcome supports a B grade for Tennessee Titans within the final Houston Oilers Win verdict.

The Raiders sent Malcolm Barnwell to Washington on August 26, 1985 for a 1986 second-round pick, No. 48 overall. Barnwell’s Washington stint produced only seven games, two starts and three receptions for 28 yards. Converting a player who barely contributed for his new club into a premium second-round selection gave the Raiders the clearly stronger side of the exchange.

Atlanta Falcons received Charlie Brown (d), while Washington Commanders received R.C. Thielemann. Washington and contemporary wire reports directly document the August 26, 1985 Charlie Brown-for-R.C. That return earns a B grade for Atlanta Falcons, and the overall verdict is Even Trade. The grade stays proportional to the direct value each club realized from this exchange.

Washington acquired tackle Dan McQuaid from the Los Angeles Rams on August 24, 1985 for its 1986 fourth-round choice, which became No. 101. McQuaid played 30 regular-season games with three starts for Washington from 1985 through 1987.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers received Anthony Washington, while Washington Commanders received Kelly Thomas. Tampa Bay and Washington evidence supports the August 2, 1985 swap of tackle Kelly Thomas for defensive back Anthony Washington. That return earns a C- grade for Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and the overall verdict is Even Trade.

Atlanta acquired Joe Washington plus the selections that became Scott Bergold and first-round defensive end Tim Green, while sending Washington the picks that produced Tory Nixon, Markus Koch and Kent Hagood. Joe Washington contributed for one Falcons season, but Green became the most durable Atlanta piece. The combined return gives the Falcons a modest but meaningful edge.

Kansas City sent Washington the 185th pick in the 1985 draft and received Washington’s 1986 sixth-round selection, which became No. 141 and Kent Hagood. The Chiefs gained a future pick one round earlier than the choice they surrendered, but Hagood did not develop into meaningful NFL production. The paper value of moving into a future sixth round was not matched by a useful player outcome.

Washington acquired former rushing champion George Rogers plus three 1985 draft picks from New Orleans for the 24th overall selection. Rogers immediately became a major part of the offense, surpassed 1,000 rushing yards in 1985 and later contributed to Washington’s Super Bowl XXII championship season. The additional picks also produced useful roster pieces, giving Washington both immediate backfield help and extra depth from a single first-round investment.

Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received 1985 fourth round pick (#107-Jamie Kimmel) in the exchange with Washington Redskins. The fourth-round choice became No. 107 Jamie Kimmel, but that downstream return did not outweigh Muhammad's contribution in Washington. Against the other side's return of Calvin Muhammad, that outcome supports a C+ grade. The transaction is ultimately judged as Washington Redskins Win, with the grade reflecting realized football value rather than the name or nominal value of the asset on the trade date.

New England Patriots received 1985 seventh round pick (#192-Nick Haden), while Washington Commanders received Ricky Smith (b). The September 11, 1984 Ricky Smith trade and the resulting 1985 seventh-round No. 192, used on Nick Haden. That return earns a C grade for New England Patriots, and the overall verdict is Even Trade.

Los Angeles received Washington's 1985 tenth-round pick No. 275 and used it on Reggie McKenzie. McKenzie played 58 games with 40 starts for the Raiders from 1985 through 1988, turning a very late selection into a substantial multi-year return. That outcome supports a B grade for Las Vegas Raiders within the final Los Angeles Raiders Win verdict.

Pittsburgh Steelers received 1985 fifth round pick (#136-Cam Jacobs), while Washington Commanders received Rick Donnalley. Washington acquired offensive lineman Rick Donnalley, who played 28 games with 20 starts for Washington in 1984 and 1985. Pittsburgh received the 1985 fifth-round pick used on linebacker Cam Jacobs, but Jacobs did not provide regular-season service to the Steelers. That outcome supports a C grade for Pittsburgh Steelers, a B for Washington Commanders, and a Washington Commanders Win verdict.

Philadelphia acquired Bob Holly from Washington for a 1985 seventh-round pick, later identified as No. 177 Jamie Harris. The Eagles did not receive meaningful regular-season value from Holly. Washington at least converted a surplus quarterback into draft capital, but Harris was among the team’s August 1985 cuts and did not become a regular-season contributor. With both acquired assets producing little, the fairest hindsight result is an even trade at a low grade.

New York moved from No. 31 to No. 27 in the 1984 draft by sending Washington the second-rounder plus No. 125. The Giants selected offensive lineman William Roberts, who became a 10-year Giant, made the 1990 Pro Bowl and played on two Super Bowl championship teams. Washington's two acquired choices never generated a comparable centerpiece.

Washington acquired the 1984 fourth-round pick at No. 102 from Houston and used it on running back Jimmy Smith, sending the Oilers a 1985 third-round choice that became No. 80. Smith appeared in only one game for Washington and produced two kickoff returns before being released. Houston secured the stronger draft asset, giving the Oilers the clear edge.

Pittsburgh traded cornerback Anthony Washington to Washington on August 17, 1983 for Washington's 1984 fourth-round pick, No. 111 overall. Pittsburgh used that selection on guard Terry Long, who played 105 games and started 89 over eight Steelers seasons. Washington received two full seasons from Anthony Washington, including five starts and five interceptions.

Pittsburgh Steelers received 1985 draft pick (undisclosed) from Washington Redskins/Commanders, while Washington Redskins/Commanders received Bo Metcalf in the 1983-08-09 deal. Bo Metcalf did not produce on-field value for Washington, while Pittsburgh received a future 1985 draft choice, so hindsight favors the Steelers despite the pick's undisclosed identity. The final grades are B- for Pittsburgh Steelers and D+ for Washington Redskins/Commanders, producing a verdict of Pittsburgh Steelers Win.

The Raiders received Washington's 1984 fifth-round choice, No. 139, in exchange for a 1983 sixth-round pick. Rather than simply using No. 139, the Raiders later included it in the move up to No. 51 for Sean Jones. Jones developed into a durable NFL starter, giving the Raiders substantially more realized value than Washington created from its return.

New England Patriots received 1984 ninth round pick (#251-David Windham), while Washington Commanders received Tony McGee (Eugene). Washington's September 1982 acquisition of Tony McGee for a 1984 ninth-round choice is supported by contemporary reporting and the draft history. That return earns a D grade for New England Patriots, and the overall verdict is Washington Commanders Win.

Washington swapped young quarterback Tom Flick for veteran Tom Owen during the 1982 preseason, seeking experienced depth behind Joe Theismann. Owen filled that reserve role on the eventual Super Bowl champion, while Flick appeared in three games for New England and went 0-for-5 passing. Neither quarterback generated major statistical value, but Washington received the clearer roster fit and more useful insurance at the position.

New Orleans received Washington's 1983 fourth-round pick after sending five late 1982 selections to Washington. The Saints later moved that fourth-rounder to Buffalo for a 1984 third-round choice and used the resulting asset on Terry Hoage, who started 13 games with four interceptions in 1985. That downstream value balanced Washington's useful haul led by Ken Coffey and Don Laster.

Buffalo acquired veteran cornerback Lemar Parrish from Washington for a fifth-round pick. Parrish arrived with an accomplished career and gave the Bills an experienced secondary option, but the transaction came late in his playing years. The approved hindsight evaluation gives Buffalo a C+ grade, recognizing real veteran value without treating the acquisition as more durable than the draft asset sent away.

The Giants received Washington's 1983 twelfth-round pick and used No. 335 on John Tuggle. Tuggle made the 1983 roster, appeared in all 16 games and started five, giving New York real value from the final pick of that draft. His career was tragically cut short by illness, but the contribution he did make supports a C+ and the Giants win.

On 1981-08-17, Detroit Lions received 1982 conditional twelfth-round pick (exercise not documented), while Washington Commanders received Lee Spivey. The final verdict is Even Trade, with Detroit Lions graded C and Washington Commanders graded C. The hindsight view follows the documented consideration and later traceable value without treating every named pick outcome as if it had been directly exchanged on trade day. Any conditional, undisclosed, or unidentified component is credited only to the extent that the surviving evidence establishes it.

Washington acquired veteran defensive end Fred Cook from Baltimore in July 1981 under conditional draft terms reported as a 1982 ninth-round pick and a possible 1983 sixth-rounder. Cook was released in August before making the regular-season roster, and Washington reclaimed the ninth-round choice; the playing-time condition for the later pick was not met. With no games for Washington and no realized draft return for Baltimore, the direct outcome is even.

The Chargers acquired Jeff Williams from Washington in exchange for Wilbur Young on May 15, 1981. The verified package was a clean two-player swap, not a deal involving extra consideration. Los Angeles received the stronger realized return, while Washington's side produced less lasting value. The Chargers therefore deserve the win once the transaction identifiers are cleaned up around the correct package.

Washington moved Henry Childs to the Rams only days after acquiring him and received Los Angeles’ 1982 third-round pick at No. 61 plus a seventh-round choice at No. 172. Childs gave the Rams seven starts, 12 catches, 145 yards and one touchdown in 1981. Washington’s third-round selection became Carl Powell, who never appeared in an NFL regular-season game, but the two-pick return still favored Washington’s asset management.

Arizona Cardinals received 1982 fifth round pick (#125-Earl Ferrell). Arizona received the 1982 fifth-round choice identified as No. 125, Earl Ferrell. Ferrell became a multi-year Cardinals contributor, giving the franchise lasting value from a relatively modest future pick. Compared with Washington Commanders' return, the result supports a A- grade and fits the Arizona Cardinals Win verdict.

Washington acquired Henry Childs from New Orleans for the 1982 third-round pick that became No. 68, Kenny Duckett. Six days later, Washington moved Childs to the Rams for a better third-round choice at No. 61 plus a seventh-round pick. New Orleans still received useful value from Duckett, who produced 34 catches for 503 yards and four touchdowns as a Saint, but Washington’s immediate asset flip created the stronger return.

Baltimore traded running back Joe Washington to Washington for the 52nd pick in the 1981 draft. The Colts did not use that selection on Jarvis Redwine; they immediately included No. 52 in their move-up with Minnesota for No. 18. Joe Washington, meanwhile, became an immediate dual-threat contributor in Washington and gave his new team the stronger realized return.

Los Angeles moved up to No. 9 in the 1981 draft and selected linebacker Mel Owens, who spent nine seasons with the Rams, played 122 games, started 91 and recorded 26.5 sacks. Washington received selections No. 20, No. 52 and No. 105, led by guard Mark May, a long-term starter on championship teams. Both clubs converted the exchange into major multi-year value through foundational contributors.

Los Angeles acquired Washington's 1982 first-round pick, which became running back Barry Redden at No. 14. Washington received four selections, headlined by 1981 third-round guard Russ Grimm and the 1982 second-round pick used on cornerback Vernon Dean. Grimm became a Hall of Famer and three-time Super Bowl champion, while Dean intercepted 22 career passes. Redden was useful, but Washington's return was historically superior.

Green Bay received the fourth-round choice used on Richard Turner and the fifth-round choice used on Byron Braggs. The combined return produced more professional value, with Braggs in particular giving the Packers meaningful contribution after the draft. That result supports a B grade within the Green Bay Packers Win verdict.

On 1981-01-01, Cleveland Browns received 1982 eighth round pick (#211-Bill Jackson), while Washington Commanders received 1981 tenth round pick (probably #257-Phil Kessel) and 1981 tenth round pick (#267-Allan Kennedy). The final verdict is Even Trade, with Cleveland Browns graded C and Washington Commanders graded C. The hindsight view follows the documented consideration and later traceable value without treating every named pick outcome as if it had been directly exchanged on trade day. Any conditional, undisclosed, or unidentified component is credited only to the extent that the surviving evidence establishes it.

San Francisco sent fullback Wilbur Jackson to Washington for second-round picks in 1981 and 1982. The first became John Harty; the second was later packaged with another choice to acquire the pick used on Bubba Paris. Jackson immediately produced more than 1,100 yards from scrimmage for Washington in 1980, but San Francisco's two premium selections created the stronger long-term asset value.

Pittsburgh sent quarterback Mike Kruczek to Washington and received two future draft choices: the 1982 seventh-round pick used on Edmund Nelson and the 1983 fifth-round pick used on Gregg Garrity. The delayed compensation eventually gave the Steelers more durable roster value than the player they moved. That two-pick return supports a B- grade for Pittsburgh.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers received Danny Buggs and 1980 fourth round pick (#102-Larry Flowers). Tampa Bay received Danny Buggs and the fourth-round choice that became Larry Flowers at No. 102. Neither asset produced a level of Buccaneers value comparable to the player Tampa Bay sent away. White's sustained Washington contribution comfortably exceeded the value Tampa Bay realized from Buggs and Flowers, making Washington the clear winner. That outcome supports a D+ grade for Tampa Bay Buccaneers.

On 1980-03-13, Tampa Bay Buccaneers received several 1981 draft picks, while Washington received Darryl Carlton, Morris Owens. The hindsight verdict is Tampa Bay Buccaneers Win, with Tampa Bay Buccaneers graded B- and Washington graded C+. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and the football value that can be traced from it, while keeping unverified downstream pick identities or conditional outcomes out of the final judgment.

Cleveland sent safety Tony Peters to Washington on August 17, 1979 for three draft choices: the 1980 fifth-rounder used on Laval Short, the 1981 fourth-rounder used on Mike Robinson, and Washington's 1981 tenth-rounder, probably Phil Kessel. Peters became a Pro Bowl safety and Super Bowl champion in Washington, while Cleveland's return produced only modest value. Washington earns an A- to Cleveland's C.

New York sent Neil Hutton and Randy Sidler to Washington for a conditional 1980 draft choice, believed to be a tenth-rounder if either player made Washington's roster. The available record does not establish whether that condition ultimately produced a pick, and neither acquired player created major lasting value. With the downstream outcome unresolved, the fairest hindsight result is even.

Los Angeles Chargers received Mike Thomas in the exchange with Washington Commanders. Thomas played 24 Chargers games with 14 starts over two seasons, producing 837 rushing yards, 606 receiving yards and four rushing touchdowns. San Diego received substantial offensive production from the veteran. The B+ grade reflects the direct value Los Angeles Chargers realized from the deal, while the Los Angeles Chargers Win call weighs actual regular-season service and clearly connected draft value rather than name recognition alone.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers received 1980 undisclosed draft choice, while Washington received Louis Carter. Washington acquired Louis Carter on May 15, 1979 for an undisclosed 1980 draft choice, according to the Redskins media guide. Carter was released before the season, so Tampa Bay converted a veteran back into draft value while Washington received only a brief offseason look. The hindsight grades are C- for Tampa Bay Buccaneers and B- for Washington, producing a Tampa Bay Buccaneers Win verdict.

Seattle received the 1979 seventh-round choice used on Larry Polowski and a 1980 fifth-round selection that became Daniel Jacobs. Neither return approached the sustained NFL contribution Washington received from Rich Milot. The C grade reflects a real two-pick package that produced modest value, leaving Seattle on the lighter side of a trade Washington ultimately won.

Cleveland Browns received 1979 twelfth round pick (#315-Dewitt Methvin / Dee Methvin) from Washington Commanders, sending Joe Jones (Turkey) the other way. Methvin did not deliver meaningful NFL value, while Washington obtained a veteran defensive end, so Washington receives the better hindsight grade after correcting Jones's nickname. That outcome supports a C- grade for Cleveland Browns, and the overall verdict is Washington Commanders Win.

On 1978-10-10, Buffalo Bills received undisclosed draft pick, while Washington Commanders received Jim Braxton. The hindsight verdict is Even Trade, with Buffalo Bills graded C+ and Washington Commanders graded C+. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and traceable football value, while leaving unresolved downstream pick identities out of the judgment.

Tampa Bay acquired receiver Frank Grant from Washington on October 10, 1978 for a 1979 seventh-round pick, No. 169. The later Seattle trade involving that selection is separate downstream history and does not belong in the direct package. Grant gave the Buccaneers an immediate player, while Washington gained a late pick, producing little long-term separation between the sides.

Miami acquired fullback Jim Braxton and Washington's 1979 third-round pick, No. 80. Braxton's Dolphins stay was brief, but the draft asset retained meaningful value and was later used in the March 1979 deal for safety Neal Colzie. That gave Miami a useful path from the original transaction even after Braxton himself failed to become a lasting contributor.

Kansas City received Washington's 1979 tenth-round pick, No. 260, and selected Gerald Jackson. Jackson played 16 games for the Chiefs in 1979, made three starts and recorded one interception, but his Kansas City tenure ended after that season. Washington received wide receiver John McDaniel, who immediately produced 577 receiving yards and four touchdowns and remained productive into 1980.

Baltimore acquired Washington's 1979 sixth-round selection, No. 150, and used it on Jimmy Moore. Moore did not appear in an NFL regular-season game, leaving the Colts without meaningful realized player value from the pick. Washington received wide receiver Ricky Thompson, who remained with the club for four seasons and supplied the transaction's only sustained roster contribution.

On 1978-08-22, Atlanta Falcons received 1980 sixth round pick, while Washington Commanders received Greg McCrary. The hindsight verdict is Atlanta Falcons Win, with Atlanta Falcons graded B and Washington Commanders graded D-. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and traceable football value, while leaving unresolved downstream pick identities out of the judgment.

Green Bay obtained tackle Tim Stokes from Washington for the 1979 fourth-round pick that became Don Warren. Stokes was a useful Packers starter, appearing in 63 games with 39 starts. Washington nevertheless landed the larger return: Warren played 14 seasons for the franchise, appearing in 193 games and starting 181. Both sides gained value, but Washington gained a cornerstone.

Miami traded rookie quarterback Bill Kenney to Washington on August 1, 1978 for a conditional 1979 sixth-round draft choice. Washington released Kenney three weeks later before the regular season, and contemporaneous reporting states that the sixth-round pick reverted to Washington. Miami therefore retained no exercised draft return from the deal.

Los Angeles received defensive back Eddie Brown and a 1981 seventh-round pick in a broad July 1978 exchange. Brown gave the Rams useful immediate value, including a productive 1979 season and postseason contributions, but the Rams surrendered several players and premium future choices. The return was real, yet not large enough to match Washington’s deeper package.

Cincinnati sent Lemar Parrish and Coy Bacon to Washington for a 1979 first-round pick, which became No. 12 overall and running back Charles Alexander. Alexander spent seven seasons with the Bengals and accumulated more than 2,600 rushing yards, giving Cincinnati meaningful value. The return still fell short of the immediate two-veteran impact Washington received.

Miami traded tight end Jim Mandich to Washington and received two eighth-round selections, including the 1980 pick used on quarterback David Woodley. Woodley became a multi-year Dolphins starter and started Super Bowl XVII, creating exceptional value from a very late selection. Washington did not receive comparable regular-season production from Mandich after the transaction, leaving Miami with the much stronger realized return.

Washington traded linebacker Joe Harris to San Francisco on May 3, 1978 for the eighth-round choice used on North Carolina receiver Walker Lee at No. 202. Contemporary Washington coverage ties Lee directly to the Harris trade; Tony Green belonged to a separate Larry Jones transaction. Lee was waived during training camp, while San Francisco received the veteran player, giving the 49ers the modest hindsight edge.

San Francisco 49ers San Francisco received Larry Jones in the transaction. The return did not produce enough lasting value to offset what Washington obtained from the corrected sixth-round choice. The supported hindsight grade is D+. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against Washington Commanders, the final verdict is Washington Commanders Win.

Washington acquired running back Harold Hart from New England on August 22, 1977 in a conditional-pick transaction. Hart was waived eight days later without playing a regular-season game for Washington; the resulting Patriots-to-Washington conditional pick became No. 300 in 1979, used on Tony Hall, who also failed to make the regular-season roster.

Washington acquired running back Harold Hart from New England on August 22, 1977 in a conditional-pick exchange. Hart did not make Washington's regular-season roster, triggering New England's 1979 No. 300 pick to Washington, which the club used on receiver Tony Hall.

Washington sent a future 1981 third-round pick to the Rams for three draft choices spanning 1977 and 1978. The transaction record associates the future third, with a probability qualifier, with No. 66 Robert Cobb, who played only six games for the Rams. Washington's package included the choice connected to Don Hover, who later played 32 NFL games, producing the stronger return.

Los Angeles sent guard Dan Nugent to Washington for future second- and third-round selections in the 1980 draft. The second-rounder became No. 50 Irv Pankey, who played 144 games and started 117 for the Rams. With another third-round asset also included, Los Angeles turned one useful lineman into far greater long-term roster value.

Washington Redskins/Commanders received Ted Fritsch Jr., while Atlanta Falcons received 1977 sixth- and ninth-round picks that became Keith Jenkins and Robert Speer. Fritsch played all 60 Washington regular-season games from 1976-79 as a reserve center and long snapper, providing sustained specialist value. The hindsight grades are B+ for Washington Redskins/Commanders and C for Atlanta Falcons, producing a Washington Commanders Win verdict.

Miami Dolphins received Bryant Salter from Washington, giving up Jake Scott; 1977 fourth round pick (#97-Duncan McColl). Miami received Bryant Salter. The Dolphins obtained a player, but the package did not match Washington's combined veteran-and-pick return, so Miami lands at C. That return supports a C grade for Miami Dolphins. The final verdict is Washington Redskins Win.

Washington acquired John Matuszak from Kansas City on August 24, 1976 for its 1977 eighth-round pick and 1978 seventh-round pick. Matuszak lasted roughly ten days in Washington and never played a regular-season game for the club before being released and joining Oakland.

Washington acquired veteran guard Ron Saul from Houston for three future draft choices, one each in the seventh round of 1977, sixth round of 1978, and third round of 1979. Saul became a durable Washington starter, appearing in 81 games with 77 starts over six seasons. That sustained line value outweighed Houston’s diffuse return from the future-pick package.

Philadelphia sent cornerback Joe Lavender to Washington in 1976 and received defensive lineman Manny Sistrunk plus three future picks: 1977 No. 158, 1978 No. 130 and 1979 No. 94. The package gave the Eagles several chances to recover value, but none matched Lavender's sustained impact in Washington. In hindsight, the quantity on Philadelphia's side did not overcome the quality of the player it surrendered.

Houston received the rights to running back Duane Thomas. Thomas had been a productive NFL player earlier in his career, but those rights did not produce meaningful Oilers regular-season value. He later attempted comebacks with other clubs instead. With no durable Houston contribution emerging from the acquired rights, the Oilers' side of the exchange finished below neutral.

Chicago acquired Ted Vactor from Washington for a 1976 tenth-round selection. Vactor appeared in four regular-season games for the Bears in 1975, providing modest veteran secondary depth. Washington used No. 272 on Paul Strohmeier, but the pick did not become an NFL regular-season contributor. The scale of the trade was tiny, yet Chicago received the only measurable post-trade football value, producing a narrow Bears win rather than a major success.

Washington acquired tackle Tim Stokes plus two 1976 draft choices from the Rams for four future picks. Stokes started 33 games for Washington from 1975 through 1977, providing meaningful line value. The Rams' return eventually included 1978 Pro Bowl kicker Frank Corral and additional draft capital that was moved in later deals. Los Angeles gets the edge, but Washington's useful starter prevents a poor grade.

Washington's signing of Dave Butz triggered a compensation settlement with St. Louis that sent the Cardinals first-round picks in 1977 and 1978 plus a 1979 second-rounder. Washington retained Butz and received lower selections in return. Butz then played 14 seasons, appeared in 203 games and became a defensive pillar on two Washington Super Bowl championship teams.

Baltimore agreed in August 1975 to send tackle Dennis Nelson to Washington for a multi-pick package, but Nelson never reported to the Redskins. Contemporary Philadelphia material and later transaction records show that the deal was negated, Nelson's rights returned to the Colts, and he sat out the 1975 season. The listed draft choices therefore were not completed trade proceeds.

On 1975-08-21, Miami Dolphins received Cotton Speyrer, while Washington received undisclosed draft pick (selection not identified). The hindsight verdict is Even Trade, with Miami Dolphins graded C and Washington graded C. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and the football value that can be traced from it, while treating conditional terms and later draft outcomes as context rather than as assets exchanged directly on trade day.

Washington acquired veteran tight end Marv Fleming from Miami for the NFL rights to Charley Harraway and a 1977 fourth-round pick, No. 110. The deal unraveled quickly: Harraway did not report to Miami, but Fleming was waived before the 1975 season and never gave Washington regular-season value. Miami still retained the future draft asset and later moved it, so the Dolphins escaped with usable compensation while Washington received essentially nothing.

Baltimore acquired return specialist Herb Mul-Key from Washington for a 1977 fourth-round selection, but Mul-Key never produced a regular-season contribution for the Colts. Washington later packaged that pick with Charley Harraway's rights for tight end Marv Fleming, who also failed to make Washington's roster. Neither branch of the exchange generated durable team-specific football value.

Washington acquired the rights to defensive tackle Glenn Hyde from Atlanta in March 1975 for two draft choices. Atlanta historical material confirms the two-pick price, with later ledgers identifying a 1978 eighth-round selection and tentatively linking the other to a 1976 eighth. Hyde did not become a regular-season contributor for Washington, so the Falcons win C+ to D+ by extracting draft value from an asset that did not pay off.

Baltimore sent Cotton Speyrer and Glenn Ressler to Washington for a 1975 twelfth-round choice used on Brad Storm and a 1976 sixteenth-round choice used on Mike Fuhrman. Neither side turned the exchange into lasting direct value: Ressler’s NFL career had already ended, Speyrer did not become a Washington regular, and neither Colts pick produced an NFL career.

New England Patriots received 1975 twelfth round pick (#306-Conredge Holloway). New England received the 1975 twelfth-round choice used at No. 306 on Conredge Holloway. Holloway did not play in the NFL, so the Patriots did not realize meaningful professional production from the selection. The draft asset had some theoretical value, but the actual football outcome was minimal. The balanced outcome supports a C grade for New England Patriots.

Washington acquired Karl Lorch's rights from Miami for a 1976 10th-round pick. Lorch eventually joined the team and played six Washington seasons, appearing in 90 games with 52 starts and providing substantial defensive-line value. Miami used pick No. 281 on Gary Fencik, who never played for the Dolphins before becoming a star elsewhere. Washington won this exchange by a wide margin.

Arizona/St. Louis Cardinals received Washington's 1976 fifteenth-round selection at No. 420 for the rights to Ray Parson and used it on Lee Nelson. Nelson became a ten-season defensive back for the franchise, appearing in 135 games with 64 starts. Turning a distant late-round pick into that much sustained service is exceptional value and earns the Cardinals an A.

Washington acquired veteran tackle Jim Tyrer for the 1974 stretch run. Kansas City received three future selections: Wayne Hoffman in 1975, Calvin Harper in 1976 and Eric Harris in 1977. Harris became the most consequential return, playing 71 NFL games and intercepting 21 passes. Tyrer gave Washington only a short final NFL stop, while Kansas City converted an aging star into a multi-year package that ultimately yielded a productive defensive back.

Washington acquired Howard Kindig, but he did not become a lasting piece for the club. Miami received the 1975 tenth-round selection used on Joe Jackson, who did not produce an NFL career. The transaction moved a veteran for a late pick, but neither side converted its return into durable on-field value. The cleanest hindsight judgment is an even result at a low grade.

Detroit Lions received Sam Wyche in the exchange with Washington. The return is graded C+ after weighing the transaction cost and the practical value visible in hindsight. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

On 1974-08-12, Los Angeles Chargers received 1977 third round pick (#77-Keith King), while Washington Commanders received Deacon Jones and 1975 eighth round pick (#189-Wayne Hoffman). The final verdict is Washington Redskins/Commanders Win, with Los Angeles Chargers graded C and Washington Commanders graded B. The hindsight view follows the documented consideration and later traceable value without treating every named pick outcome as if it had been directly exchanged on trade day. Both sides have identifiable consideration, allowing the hindsight grade to focus on what those assets actually became.

Washington acquired veteran running back Larry Smith from the Rams in May 1974 for the 1977 fifth-round pick that became No. 130 Donnie Hickman. Smith offered Washington immediate experienced depth, while the later selection did not develop into a return strong enough to outweigh that practical roster value. Washington holds a modest hindsight edge.

Washington received safety Bryant Salter plus the 1975 eighth-round choice that became Wayne Hoffman. San Diego ultimately received a 1976 third-round pick, a 1977 second-round pick and a 1977 third-round pick after the conditional terms were settled. Salter started 13 games for Washington in 1975. Washington got a useful starter and an additional pick, but San Diego accumulated three higher future selections and later used or moved those assets in subsequent transactions. The Chargers hold a narrow value edge rather than the lopsided result the old record implied.

Washington acquired veteran Fred Sturt from St. Louis for Jimmie Jones plus two draft selections: 1975 No. 178 Earl Douthitt and 1976 No. 141 Wayne Morris. The No. 178 pick later moved again, but that separate Cardinals-Bears deal was not part of Washington's payment. The Cardinals received the broader package and retain the slight value edge.

Denver acquired the rights to running back Jon Keyworth from Washington on February 18, 1974 for 1975 picks No. 147 and No. 277. Keyworth became a seven-season Bronco, started 69 games, and contributed to the 1977 AFC championship team. That sustained production easily surpassed Washington's draft return and makes Denver the clear winner.

Washington acquired guard Cornelius Johnson and a 1975 seventeenth-round selection from Baltimore for running back George Nock and 1974 seventeenth-round No. 436 Buzzy Lewis. Nock never became a Colts contributor, while the late-round assets and Johnson produced little durable separation. The modest, low-leverage returns support an even grade once the distinct Ed Mooney transaction is kept separate.

Los Angeles Rams received 1974 ninth round pick (#213-Don Hutt / Donnie Hutt) from Washington Commanders, sending Joe Sweet the other way. Neither side ultimately received meaningful direct NFL value from the exchange: Sweet's 1974 NFL appearances came with New England, while Hutt pursued the WFL rather than becoming a Rams contributor. That makes a low-impact even verdict the most defensible hindsight result. That outcome supports a C- grade for Los Angeles Rams, and the overall verdict is Even Trade.

The Chargers traded veteran guard Walt Sweeney to Washington for a 1974 fifth-rounder, a 1975 sixth-rounder, and a 1976 fourth-rounder. The 1976 selection is correctly No. 115 Artie Owens, not No. 110 Herb McMath. Turning one veteran into three draft assets gave the Chargers the broader long-term return and a modest hindsight edge.

Washington acquired the NFL rights to Joe Theismann. Miami received Washington's 1976 first-round selection and used No. 17 on linebacker Larry Gordon, who became a productive long-term Dolphin. Theismann eventually became Washington's franchise quarterback and led the club to a Super Bowl championship. Miami received genuine first-round value and drafted a good starter, so this was not a bad deal for the Dolphins. Theismann's quarterback value, longevity and championship impact nevertheless made Washington's side more consequential.

Washington acquired Willie Holman plus Chicago's 1975 fifth-round pick while sending the Bears a 1974 third-rounder. That fifth-round choice became running back Mike Thomas, the 1975 AP Offensive Rookie of the Year and a 1976 Pro Bowler who rushed for more than 4,000 career yards. Chicago's pick became Cliff Taylor, whose NFL impact was minimal, making Washington the decisive winner.

Washington acquired linebacker Brad Dusek and a 1974 third-round pick from New England for Donnel Smith and a 1974 seventh-round pick. Dusek became an eight-season Washington fixture, while the third-round choice retained additional trade value. New England's seventh-rounder became Maury Damkroger, whose Patriots career lasted 13 games, creating a clear Washington advantage.

New England Patriots received Charlie Richards in the 1973-08-29 exchange with Washington, giving up 1974 ninth round pick (#218-Mark Sens). New England acquired running back Charlie Richards for a ninth-round draft choice. That return supports a B grade for New England Patriots. The final verdict is New England Patriots Win, based on the football value tied directly to the assets in this deal.

New England Patriots received Mel Lunsford, while Washington Commanders received 1974 fifth round pick (undisclosed). Mel Lunsford became a long-term New England defensive lineman, playing 92 games with 74 starts for the Patriots through 1980. Washington received a 1974 fifth-round choice, but the documented return does not approach the sustained starting service New England extracted from Lunsford. That outcome supports a A- grade for New England Patriots, a C- for Washington Commanders, and a New England Patriots Win verdict.

The Chargers moved running back Duane Thomas to Washington and received a 1975 first-round pick plus a 1976 second-round pick. The first-rounder became Mike Williams at No. 22 in 1975. Thomas had already been a prominent but volatile back, so San Diego converted a short-term asset into two future chances to replenish the roster.

Cleveland Browns received 1975 sixth round pick (#150-Charles Miller / Charlie Miller), while Washington received Paul Staroba. Cleveland sent Paul Staroba to Washington for the 1975 sixth-round choice used at No. 150 on Charles Miller, also known as Charlie Miller. The supported history provides enough detail to judge the exchange without overstating uncertain downstream information. Cleveland Browns earns a C grade, and the overall verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Washington acquired veteran tight end Alvin Reed from Houston on May 28, 1973 for a future draft choice whose exact 1974 round and pick cannot be established from the surviving record. Reed played 33 games for Washington over three seasons, starting five in 1973 and totaling 15 receptions for 165 yards and three touchdowns. He supplied real but limited depth before his 1976 release.

Washington acquired Hall of Fame safety Ken Houston from the Houston Oilers in 1973 for five veterans: Jim Snowden, Mack Alston, Clifton McNeil, Mike Fanucci and Jeff Severson. Houston immediately became a cornerstone of George Allen’s defense and continued a remarkable run of Pro Bowl and All-Pro recognition.

The Houston franchise received veteran defensive back Al Haymond from Washington. The available career and transaction record does not establish a large long-term advantage from Haymond's side of the exchange, particularly when compared with Washington's fifth-round selection. The C grade reflects a legitimate veteran return but not enough sustained separation to move the deal away from an Even Trade conclusion.

Baltimore sent veteran defensive tackle Fred Miller to Washington in February 1973 and received a 1974 tenth-round draft choice. Colts history supports the round and year of the return, but the eventual player tied to that selection cannot be established confidently. Miller retired before appearing in a regular-season game for Washington, leaving Baltimore with a future draft asset from a veteran whose playing career had effectively ended.

The Rams moved veteran defensive back Clancy Williams to Washington and received the late 1973 selection used on Kurt Matter. Matter did not appear in an NFL regular-season game, while Williams' eight-season Rams career had effectively reached its end before the trade produced value for Washington. Both clubs exchanged assets with recognizable résumé or draft value, but neither side gained a meaningful post-trade football return.

Washington acquired Hall of Fame linebacker Dave Robinson from Green Bay for a 1975 second-round pick. Robinson started all 28 games across his two Washington seasons and intercepted six passes, including a touchdown. Green Bay used the pick on Bill Bain, who played one Packers season before being traded again. Both sides preserved value, but Washington received the stronger direct return.

Detroit Lions received John Hilton. John Hilton gave Detroit two seasons of service at tight end, providing the Lions with identifiable regular-season value from the transaction. That outcome supports a B- grade because the return is measured by the direct football value Detroit Lions actually received after the deal, compared with the asset sent the other way.

Atlanta Falcons received Willie Germany. Willie Germany appeared in 12 games for Atlanta in 1972 and intercepted two passes, giving the Falcons useful immediate production from the defensive back. That outcome supports a B- grade because the return is measured by the direct football value Atlanta Falcons actually received after the deal, compared with the asset sent the other way.

Cleveland acquired the Saints' 1973 third-round selection, No. 54, a meaningfully stronger piece of draft capital than the assets it sent away. The pick later became part of the Rich Jackson transaction, illustrating the flexibility of the asset without turning Jackson into direct consideration here. Cleveland's incoming third-round value gives it the stronger side of this exchange.

On 1972-07-19, Los Angeles Rams received draft pick (possibly 1973 #129-Cody Jones), while Washington received Alvin Haymond / Al Haymond. The hindsight verdict is Washington Redskins Win, with Los Angeles Rams graded C+ and Washington graded B. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and the football value that can be traced from it, while treating conditional terms and later draft outcomes as context rather than as assets exchanged directly on trade day.

New England Patriots received 1973 ninth round pick (Baltimore) from Washington Commanders. New England received Baltimore's 1973 ninth-round choice, retaining future draft value even though the exact later player assignment is not secure enough to attribute here. That realized return supports a B- grade for New England Patriots. The final verdict is New England Patriots Win, based on the regular-season service and draft value each club actually received after the exchange.

Washington sent linebacker Bob Grant and its 1973 eighth-round pick, No. 207, to New Orleans on June 16, 1972 for the Saints' 1973 third-round choice, No. 54. Washington later moved No. 54 to Cleveland for tackle Mitch Johnson and a 1974 eighth-round pick, No. 196 Darwin Robinson. Neither Johnson nor Robinson produced a Washington regular-season appearance.

Buffalo Bills received conditional draft pick (if Wilson makes Redskins roster) (probably 1973 #259-John LeHeup) in the exchange with Washington. Buffalo retained a conditional draft asset, likely the choice that became John LeHeup, although LeHeup never appeared in an NFL game for the Bills. The supported hindsight grade is C+. That mark reflects realized value tied directly to this transaction, with the overall result recorded as Buffalo Bills Win.

Washington acquired Rosey Taylor plus San Francisco's 1973 third- and fourth-round picks, while the 49ers received Washington's 1974 second-rounder and 1975 third-rounder. Taylor helped Washington reach Super Bowl VII. San Francisco later turned its incoming picks into Delvin Williams and Steve Mike-Mayer, with Williams becoming a Pro Bowl runner who topped 1,200 rushing yards in 1976.

Washington acquired veteran receiver Clifton McNeil from the Giants in October 1971 for a package built around 1972 fifth-, sixth- and seventh-round assets. Richmond Flowers was later substituted for the sixth-rounder because Washington did not own that selection. McNeil gave Washington only a short receiving return, while New York collected multiple pieces and useful Flowers snaps, supporting a B to C- Giants win.

Chicago sent running back Mike Hull to Washington for tackle Steve Wright and running back Danny Pierce on August 31, 1971. Wright immediately started all 14 games at right tackle for the Bears; Pierce did not play for Chicago. Hull spent four seasons with Washington but never started and had only four rushing attempts. Chicago received the more meaningful post-trade role.

Los Angeles sent veteran safety Richie Petitbon to Washington in August 1971. The return was a 1973 sixth-round selection plus a 1974 first-round pick, with the premium choice revised from a 1973 second-rounder after Washington discovered that selection had already been traded. The first-rounder later became part of another Rams transaction.

Washington acquired running back Tom Barrington from New Orleans on August 4, 1971 in exchange for defensive end Bruce Anderson. Barrington did not appear in a regular-season game after returning to Washington; Pro Football Archives records his release on September 11. The 1973 draft ledger later suggests possible draft-choice movement around the deal, but those pick links are explicitly unresolved and are not included in the verified package.

Washington acquired proven receiver Roy Jefferson plus ninth-round selections in 1973 and 1974, sending Baltimore rookie Cotton Speyrer and its 1973 first-round choice. Jefferson immediately became Washington’s leading receiver and remained productive for six seasons, including the 1972 Super Bowl run. Baltimore received flashes from Speyrer and converted the first-rounder into later trade value, but never matched Jefferson’s sustained impact.

Washington acquired veteran safety Mike Gaechter from Dallas on July 20, 1971 for conditional draft compensation. Gaechter had missed the 1970 season after an Achilles injury and was released by Washington on August 11 before appearing in a regular-season game. The conditional pick was not exercised, leaving neither club with realized regular-season value.

Los Angeles sent center George Burman to Washington in July 1971 for two draft choices, one of which is traceable as the 1974 fourth-round pick that became No. 99 and Norris Weese. Burman appeared only briefly for Washington, while the Rams at least recovered multiple future assets. Because one selection remains unidentified and Weese did not become a Rams regular, Los Angeles earns only a narrow edge.

Baltimore traded linebacker Bob Grant to Washington in July 1971 and received second- and seventh-round selections in the 1972 draft. The Colts used those picks on wide receiver Glenn Doughty at No. 47 and defensive end John Sykes at No. 169. Doughty developed into a useful receiver and returner, giving Baltimore the most durable team-specific contribution from the exchange.

This entry records the draft compensation tied to Verlon Biggs signing with Washington in 1971. Washington sent its 1972 first-round pick and 1973 second-round pick to New York while receiving the Jets' 1972 seventh-rounder. Biggs then started 55 games for Washington and helped reach Super Bowl VII, while first-rounder Mike Taylor played only 22 NFL games.

Buffalo sent veteran defensive lineman Ron McDole to Washington for three 1973 draft choices, eventually Nos. 77, 103 and 181. The Bills gained useful draft volume, but McDole became a durable Washington starter and remained a fixture on the defense through the 1970s. His seven-plus seasons of direct value outweigh the scattered return created by Buffalo's package, giving Washington the stronger result.

Cincinnati acquired Henry Dyer, but his NFL regular-season record ends with Washington in 1970. The available evidence therefore does not show meaningful Bengals game production after the trade. Cincinnati received the player, but not a durable on-field return, which keeps its grade near the bottom of the scale.

New York Jets received 1973 sixth round pick (#155-Rick Harrell) in the exchange with Washington Redskins. The sixth-round choice became No. 155 Rick Harrell, whose NFL career was brief and did not provide a return comparable to Washington's player acquisition. Against Washington Redskins' return of Jimmie Jones, that result supports a D grade. The transaction is judged as Washington Redskins Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

On 1971-03-31, Los Angeles Rams received 1973 fifth-round draft pick, while Washington Commanders received Tommy Mason. The hindsight verdict is Washington Redskins Win, with Los Angeles Rams graded C+ and Washington Commanders graded B. The evaluation credits only the consideration that can be traced confidently and keeps uncertain pick details out of the final judgment.

New Orleans received defensive end Leo Carroll plus the seventeenth-round choice at No. 428, used on Hermann Eben. The Saints gained two pieces, but the later football payoff was modest and did not create a clear advantage. That result supports a C grade and fits an even overall verdict.

George Allen’s first major Washington move sent Marlin McKeever and seven premium-to-midround selections to Los Angeles for six veteran players and a fifth-round pick. Washington immediately gained experienced starters and became a playoff team, but the Rams converted the package into Isiah Robertson, Dave Elmendorf and additional draft assets. The long-term star power favors Los Angeles, though Washington’s immediate return was genuinely valuable.

Green Bay Packers received 1971 fifth round pick (#124-Jim Stillwagon) in the exchange with Washington Commanders. The historical record shows how the player service and draft value developed after the deal, with the comparison favoring Washington Commanders. That result supports a D for Green Bay Packers. The grade reflects the less valuable realized return and keeps the judgment proportional to the documented value produced by this transaction.

Washington acquired quarterback Billy Kilmer from New Orleans in January 1971 for linebacker Tom Roussel plus 1971 picks No. 88 Richard 'Wimpy' Winther and No. 194 James Elder. Kilmer became a central starter, led Washington to consecutive playoff appearances and started the franchise's first Super Bowl. That impact overwhelms the Saints' three-asset return and makes this a clear Washington win.

New York Giants received Jim Norton, while Washington Commanders received Bruce Anderson. Jim Norton did not match the immediate contribution Anderson supplied in Washington. New York therefore received the less productive side of the exchange. In hindsight, that direct return supports a D+ grade for New York Giants. The grade reflects realized football value from this exchange rather than reputation alone.

Baltimore sent linebacker Dennis Gaubatz to Washington for defensive lineman Frank Bosch and the 1970 fourth-round pick used on Steve Smear. Bosch did not survive the Colts’ final cuts and returned to Washington on waivers, while Smear chose the CFL and never played for Baltimore. Gaubatz retired before providing Washington regular-season value. The Colts acquired two assets, but neither produced an NFL return, leaving the deal effectively even.

On 1969-09-09, Los Angeles Rams received Mitch Johnson, while Washington received draft pick. The hindsight verdict is Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams Win, with Los Angeles Rams graded B and Washington graded C+. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and the football value that can be traced from it, while keeping unverified downstream pick identities or conditional outcomes out of the final judgment.

Detroit Lions received 1970 sixth round pick (#149-Tony Terry), while Washington Commanders received Dave Kopay. Washington acquired veteran running back Dave Kopay, while Detroit received the 1970 sixth-round selection that became Tony Terry. Kopay supplied short-term backfield service in Washington, whereas the draft return did not produce enough NFL value to swing the deal toward Detroit. That outcome supports a C+ grade for Detroit Lions, a B- for Washington Commanders, and a Washington Commanders Win verdict.

On 1969-08-30, Green Bay Packers received 1970 tenth round pick (#251-Frank Patrick (b)), while Washington Commanders received Leo Carroll. The hindsight verdict is Washington Commanders Win, with Green Bay Packers graded D+ and Washington Commanders graded B-. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and traceable football value, while leaving unresolved downstream pick identities out of the judgment.

Washington purchased defensive back Bob Wade from Pittsburgh on August 28, 1969. Wade appeared in 13 games for Washington that season, while the Steelers received cash rather than a football asset that can be traced forward. The contribution was modest and short-lived, but Washington did receive usable depth for the purchase price, supporting a narrow Redskins win rather than a dramatic result.

New Orleans Saints received Mike Morgan, while Washington Commanders received Dennis Hale. Mike Morgan joined New Orleans during the 1969 preseason, but the move did not produce enough durable value to make the Saints a clear winner. In hindsight, that direct return supports a D+ grade for New Orleans Saints. The grade reflects realized football value from this exchange rather than reputation alone.

On 1969-08-19, Atlanta Falcons received 1970 sixth-round draft pick, while Washington Commanders received Bob Long (Andrew). The hindsight verdict is Washington Redskins Win, with Atlanta Falcons graded C+ and Washington Commanders graded B-. The evaluation credits only the consideration that can be traced confidently and keeps uncertain pick details out of the final judgment.

Detroit Lions received Ken Barefoot from Washington Commanders. Barefoot never appeared in a Lions regular-season game, so Detroit received no direct game contribution from the player it acquired. The D grade reflects the direct value Detroit Lions realized from the transaction, with the final Washington Commanders Win call based on actual service and clearly traceable draft outcomes rather than projected value.

New Orleans Saints received Jim Ninowski from Washington, giving up Randy Schultz; 1970 fifth round pick (#114-Manny Sistrunk). New Orleans received quarterback Jim Ninowski. The Saints added an experienced player, but the return did not outweigh Washington's combined player-and-pick package, leaving New Orleans at C+. That return supports a C+ grade for New Orleans Saints. The final verdict is Washington Redskins Win.

On 1969-07-01, Kansas City Chiefs received Walter Barnes / Walt Barnes (C.), while Washington received draft pick (undisclosed). The hindsight verdict is Kansas City Chiefs Win, with Kansas City Chiefs graded B and Washington graded D+. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and the football value that can be traced from it, while keeping unverified downstream pick identities or conditional outcomes out of the final judgment.

Washington acquired Jim Norton from Philadelphia for Jim Carroll in June 1969. Norton appeared in five games and started four for Washington, giving the club a short but concrete return. Carroll did not provide Philadelphia with comparable regular-season value after the exchange, so Washington wins the deal, although Norton's limited tenure keeps the grades modest.

Green Bay Packers received 1971 fifth round pick (#116-Donnell Smith), while Washington Commanders received Tom Brown. Green Bay sent Tom Brown to Washington for a fifth-round choice that became No. 116, Donnell Smith. Brown played only one additional game for Washington, giving Green Bay the stronger asset outcome even though the return was modest. Green Bay Packers earns a C+ grade, and the overall verdict is Green Bay Packers Win.

Philadelphia sent Mike Morgan to Washington and received two 1969 picks, No. 218 Lynn Buss and No. 243 Donnie Shanklin. Two selections gave the Eagles more optionality than a single late pick, but neither return produced enough value to outweigh Washington’s immediate player acquisition. The difference is modest, leaving Philadelphia with a fair but slightly weaker result.

Washington acquired Pro Bowl tackle Walter Rock from San Francisco for its 1970 first-round pick. The 49ers used No. 17 on Bruce Taylor, who won NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year, made a Pro Bowl and spent eight seasons in San Francisco. Rock also became a multi-year Washington starter and reached Super Bowl VII, leaving both clubs with substantial value from opposite sides of the exchange.

On 1968-09-01, Cleveland Browns received Ron Snidow, while Washington received 1969 second round pick (#46-Eugene Epps), draft pick (undisclosed). The hindsight verdict is Washington Redskins/Commanders Win, with Cleveland Browns graded C and Washington graded C+. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and the football value that can be traced from it, while treating conditional terms and later draft outcomes as context rather than as assets exchanged directly on trade day.

Pittsburgh acquired linebacker Steve Jackson from Washington for cash on August 16, 1968. Jackson had played 25 games for Washington in 1966-67 and recorded no regular-season service for Pittsburgh after the move. In hindsight, the grades are D+ for Pittsburgh Steelers and C+ for Washington, producing a Washington Win verdict. The modest scoring reflects the limited scale of the transaction.

Minnesota acquired safety Paul Krause from Washington for Marlin McKeever and a seventh-round pick, one of the defining trades in Vikings history. Krause played 12 seasons in Minnesota, started on all four Vikings Super Bowl teams and retired as the NFL's career interceptions leader with 81, a record he still holds. Washington received legitimate assets, but nothing close to the Hall of Fame value Minnesota captured.

Los Angeles traded the contract rights to Heisman Trophy quarterback Gary Beban to Washington for a 1969 first-round pick. The Rams used the No. 10 selection on receiver Jim Seymour. Seymour had only a modest three-year NFL career, but Beban appeared in just five games and never became Washington's quarterback of the future, leaving Los Angeles with the superior realized value.

Washington traded tackle George Patton to Atlanta on January 31, 1968 for the Falcons' fifth-round pick at No. 113 overall, which Washington used on Virginia Tech tight end Ken Barefoot.

Atlanta Falcons received George Patton from Washington Commanders. Patton supplied Atlanta with one NFL season of service, giving the Falcons a modest but tangible return from the exchange. The C+ grade reflects the direct value Atlanta Falcons realized from the transaction, with the final Atlanta Falcons Win call based on actual service and clearly traceable draft outcomes rather than projected value.

St. Louis acquired Lonnie Sanders from Washington for defensive back Jim Burson, whose historical references also use James and Jimmy Burson. Sanders immediately played 13 games, started 11, and intercepted three passes for the Cardinals in 1968. Burson was moved again and spent that season starting for Atlanta, leaving St. Louis with the clearer direct value from the original player-for-player exchange.

Washington acquired Dick Absher from Philadelphia on October 19, 1967, with the stored return to Philadelphia listed as cash. Absher appeared in one game for Washington before being released, so neither side realized much football value from the move. In hindsight, the grades are C for Philadelphia Eagles and C for Washington, producing a Push verdict. The modest scoring reflects the limited scale of the transaction.

Washington received Sid Williams; New York received cash. Transaction records confirm Washington acquired linebacker Sid Williams for cash on August 27, 1967. Williams then appeared in 10 games for Washington that season, giving the club actual roster service for a simple cash outlay. The hindsight grades are C+ for New York Giants and B- for Washington Redskins/Commanders, producing a Washington Commanders Win verdict.

Baltimore sent running back Jerry Allen to Washington in August 1967 for a 1968 tenth-round pick and a 1969 fourth-round pick. The first became defensive back Ocie Austin, who played 28 games for the Colts over two seasons; the later choice became Jacky Stewart. Baltimore received usable depth and two selections, but Allen immediately became a Washington starter and generated the stronger direct production.

Cleveland Browns received Dick Shiner and 1968 third round pick (#66-Reece Morrison) from Washington Commanders, sending Jim Ninowski the other way. Shiner was only a brief Browns contributor, but Morrison supplied several seasons of useful depth, while Ninowski had limited Washington impact, leaving Cleveland modestly ahead. That outcome supports a B grade for Cleveland Browns, and the overall verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Minnesota acquired the rights to Bob Breitenstein from Washington in 1967 and sent back a 1968 fifth-round pick, No. 117. Breitenstein played 11 games with six starts for the Vikings, but Washington used the pick on Mike Bragg, who became the franchise's long-term punter. Bragg's 12 seasons in Washington and 172 games make this a clear Washington win.

Dallas Cowboys received cash in the exchange with Washington. The return is graded C after weighing the transaction cost and the practical value visible in hindsight. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Jim Prestel moved from the New York Giants to Washington in 1967, with the surviving record supporting a cash transaction even though exact consideration detail is thin. Prestel appeared in eight games for Washington and supplied immediate defensive-line depth. That usable service gives Washington the better hindsight return, but the limited scale and source detail keep the grades restrained.

On 1966-10-02, Detroit Lions received 1967 sixth-round draft pick (#144-John McCambridge), while Washington Commanders received Joe Don Looney. The hindsight verdict is Washington Redskins Win, with Detroit Lions graded C+ and Washington Commanders graded B-. The evaluation credits only the consideration that can be traced confidently and keeps uncertain pick details out of the final judgment.

The Giants reacquired veteran guard Darrell Dess and kept him through the end of his playing career. New York received the most stable single asset in the trade: an experienced lineman who returned to a familiar role and remained with the club. That durability gives the Giants the stronger hindsight return.

Washington acquired offensive lineman Bill Briggs from Minnesota on August 31, 1966, sending the Vikings the draft choice that became 1967 eighth-round pick No. 197. Minnesota used it on tight end John Beasley, who played 75 games and started 48 for the Vikings. That multi-year contribution gives Minnesota the better return.

Washington completed a multi-player trade with Dallas on August 30, 1966, acquiring Brig Owens, Mitch Johnson and Jake Kupp for veteran defensive back Jim Steffen and Washington's 1967 fifth-round pick. Owens became the centerpiece: he played 12 seasons for Washington, intercepted 36 passes and started 124 games. Johnson also started all 14 games in 1966, while Kupp appeared in all 14 before the 1967 expansion draft.

Philadelphia sent the rights to Joe Kantor to Washington and received the 1968 fifth-round choice that became No. 122 Mike Dirks. Dirks played 43 games for the Eagles from 1968 through 1971, giving Philadelphia several seasons of roster value. Kantor appeared in only four games for Washington, so the Eagles clearly converted the draft consideration into the more productive return.

Green Bay Packers received 1967 fourth round pick (#93-Travis Williams) in the exchange with Washington Commanders. The historical record shows how the player service and draft value developed after the deal, with the comparison favoring Green Bay Packers. That result supports a A for Green Bay Packers. The grade reflects the stronger realized return and keeps the judgment proportional to the documented value produced by this transaction.

Chicago Bears received John Paluck in the exchange with Washington. The return is graded C after weighing the transaction cost and the practical value visible in hindsight. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Washington's 1966 deal with Dallas ultimately brought Brig Owens, Mitch Johnson and Jake Kupp in exchange for Jim Steffen and a 1967 fifth-round pick used on Willie Parker. Owens became the defining piece, spending 12 seasons in Washington and recording 36 interceptions. Dallas received legitimate consideration, but nothing in its return approached Owens' sustained impact, leaving Washington with the clear advantage in hindsight.

Chicago Bears received Johnny Sample, while Washington Commanders received 1967 tenth round pick (#247-Tim Houlton). Washington sent Johnny Sample to Chicago for its 1967 tenth-round choice, later No. 247 Tim Houlton. Historical sources differ by one day on the transaction date, but neither Sample in Chicago nor Houlton from the pick created meaningful regular-season value. Chicago Bears earns a D grade, and the overall verdict is Even Trade.

Baltimore received Bill Hunter and a 1967 ninth-round pick from Washington in exchange for Tom Carr, Ken Duke, Roland Rogers, and Dave Hayes. The exact ninth-round selection is not securely identified in the surviving record, and no downstream outcome clearly separates the clubs. Baltimore gained a player plus late draft capital, but the available evidence supports only a modest return.

Detroit Lions received quarterback George Izo and guard Ted Karras; Izo went 2-1 in three 1965 starts, while Karras started 10 of 12 games for Detroit that season. The team earns a C+, compared with C for Washington Commanders, and the hindsight verdict is Detroit Lions Win. That judgment reflects the concrete team-specific production, role and tenure created by the assets in this deal.

Pittsburgh acquired linebacker Rod Breedlove from Washington and received three seasons of useful service. Breedlove appeared in 39 games for the Steelers from 1965 through 1967, giving the defense dependable depth and meaningful playing time. Washington's seventh-round return did not create comparable regular-season value, so Pittsburgh turned a low-cost move into the stronger football outcome and merits a B grade.

Chicago Bears received George Seals in the exchange with Washington. George Seals became a long-term Chicago lineman, staying seven seasons, appearing in 98 games and earning second-team All-Pro recognition in 1968. That durability and peak performance gave the Bears clear realized value from a modest veteran exchange. In hindsight, that direct outcome supports a B+ grade for Chicago Bears. The judgment focuses on what this transaction itself produced rather than unrelated later moves.

Green Bay acquired Bill Anderson from Washington for the 1966 sixth-round selection that became No. 94 Earl Yates. Anderson played 24 regular-season games for the Packers across the 1965 and 1966 championship seasons, giving Green Bay useful depth and experience during a title run. Yates never recorded an NFL regular-season appearance, so the Packers received substantially more realized value.

Chicago received Riley Mattson and Fred Hageman in the four-player swap. Neither acquisition produced a comparable post-trade return to what Bob Jencks supplied Washington, leaving the Bears with the weaker realized side of an otherwise straightforward veteran exchange. That outcome supports a D+ grade for Chicago Bears within the final Washington Redskins Win verdict.

Chicago Bears received 1966 sixth round pick (#85-Dennis Brewster), while Washington Commanders received Steve Barnett. Washington received tackle Steve Barnett and Chicago received the 1966 sixth-round pick used on Dennis Brewster. Barnett gave Washington immediate line help in 1964, while the later draft selection did not generate a stronger documented professional return for Chicago. That outcome supports a C+ grade for Chicago Bears, a B- for Washington Commanders, and a Washington Commanders Win verdict.

Washington acquired veteran Jim Martin from Baltimore on September 8, 1964, sending the Colts a 1965 20th-round choice that became No. 273 Ray Johnson. Martin handled Washington's kicking duties for all 14 games in 1964 and scored 71 points, while Johnson never appeared in an NFL regular-season game. The return was short-lived but clearly tangible, supporting Washington's existing win with conservative grades.

Pittsburgh received what contemporary reporting and transaction ledgers describe as a 1964 sixth-round draft choice. Because the transaction occurred on August 28, after the 1964 NFL draft, the wording is chronologically unusual, and the exact selection or rights mechanism has not been identified. No downstream player outcome can be assigned without inventing evidence that the surviving record does not supply.

On July 1, 1964, the Chicago Bears sent defensive back Tommy Neck to the Washington Redskins for exactly $1. Neck had appeared in one NFL game for Chicago in 1962 and did not record another NFL appearance after the deal. Washington bought a virtually cost-free look, while Chicago received only nominal consideration, leaving little hindsight separation between the clubs.

Washington acquired receiver Angelo Coia and defensive tackle Fred Williams from Chicago for its 1965 first-round pick, which became No. 6 overall Steve DeLong. Coia immediately started 13 games and posted 500 receiving yards with five touchdowns in 1964, while Williams joined the defensive rotation. DeLong signed with the rival AFL Chargers and did not play for Chicago until 1972. Washington therefore realized the stronger immediate and team-specific return.

Washington received Hall of Fame linebacker Sam Huff and rookie lineman George Seals. Huff played 66 regular-season games for Washington across 1964-67 and 1969, intercepted 12 passes, and earned a Pro Bowl selection in his first Washington season. Seals added 12 games in 1964 before continuing his career with Chicago. The package gave Washington immediate star-level defensive value plus one season of depth.

Washington acquired quarterback Sonny Jurgensen and defensive back Jimmy Carr from Philadelphia for quarterback Norm Snead and defensive back Claude Crabb on March 31, 1964. Jurgensen became one of Washington's defining quarterbacks, repeatedly led the league in major passing categories and ultimately entered the Pro Football Hall of Fame. His star-level longevity created the largest individual return from a trade that also sent Philadelphia a legitimate long-term starter.

Baltimore Colts received 1965 fourth round pick (#49-Marty Schottenheimer), while Washington Redskins received J.W. Lockett. Baltimore sent J.W. Lockett to Washington for the 1965 fourth-round choice that became No. 49 Marty Schottenheimer. Lockett played all 14 games for Washington in 1964, producing 175 rushing yards, 204 receiving yards and three touchdowns, while Schottenheimer signed with Buffalo rather than Baltimore. Washington received the clearer realized football value. From Baltimore Colts perspective, the grade is based on realized player or draft value that can actually be documented, not on an

Washington acquired linebacker and defensive end Carl Kammerer from San Francisco on September 12, 1963 for an eighth-round pick in the 1964 draft. Kammerer became a seven-year Washington contributor, appearing in 95 games with 58 starts and producing 30 Approximate Value. The low acquisition cost and long starting run make this an excellent Washington return.

Philadelphia Eagles received 1963 eighth round pick (#106-Gene Sykes) in the 1962-09-05 exchange, while Washington Redskins received Ed Khayat / Eddie Khayat. Philadelphia converted Khayat into the 1963 eighth-round choice at No. 106, used on Gene Sykes. Sykes supplied only modest value, so the pick return did not create a decisive long-term advantage.

On 1962-09-04, Los Angeles Rams received 1964 high draft pick, while Washington Commanders received Bob Pellegrini. The hindsight verdict is Washington Commanders Win, with Los Angeles Rams graded C and Washington Commanders graded B. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and traceable football value, while leaving unresolved downstream pick identities out of the judgment.

Green Bay Packers received 1963 fifth round pick (#63-Jack Cverko) in the exchange with Washington Redskins. Green Bay turned the deal into the No. 63 selection, Jack Cverko, but the downstream pick did not produce comparable Packers value. Against Washington Redskins' return of Ben Davidson, that outcome supports a C grade. The transaction is judged as Washington Redskins Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

On 1962-06-11, San Francisco 49ers received 1963 high draft pick, while Washington Commanders received Gorden Kelley. The hindsight verdict is Washington Commanders Win, with San Francisco 49ers graded C and Washington Commanders graded B. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and traceable football value, while leaving unresolved downstream pick identities out of the judgment.

Pittsburgh Steelers received Ray Lemek from Washington, giving up John Nisby. Pittsburgh received Ray Lemek in a direct veteran-for-veteran exchange. The available record supports a legitimate roster move but not a pronounced long-term advantage, leaving the Steelers at C. That return supports a C grade for Pittsburgh Steelers. The final verdict is Even Trade.

Philadelphia received Jim Schrader and Ben Scotti, two veterans who provided more than a one-game return and gave the Eagles useful roster value. Neither transformed the franchise, so the gain should not be exaggerated, but the combined service of two incoming players gives Philadelphia a slight edge over Washington's package in a close, veteran-for-veteran exchange.

Cleveland acquired the rights to No. 1 overall pick Ernie Davis from Washington for star back Bobby Mitchell and the rights to Leroy Jackson. Davis was diagnosed with leukemia and tragically never played an NFL regular-season game. Mitchell became a Hall of Fame receiver in Washington, immediately leading the league in receiving yards in 1962 and remaining one of the franchise's defining stars of the decade.

The legacy record lists Baltimore Colts receiving Gary Glick and Washington Redskins receiving 1962 sixth round pick (probably #79-John Sutro), but part of that date, identity, or downstream attribution remains disputed in the surviving historical record. The Colts historical ledger records Baltimore sending a 1962 sixth-round choice to Washington for defensive back Gary Glick. Glick then appeared in 11 games for Baltimore in 1961 and intercepted four passes. The exact downstream identity of Washington draft asset remains conflicted, so Baltimore receives a modest edge for the player value

Minnesota acquired Jerry Reichow from Washington in September 1961 for draft-choice compensation, later identified in Vikings historical material as a seventh-round choice. Reichow immediately became one of the expansion club's best offensive players, catching 50 passes for 859 yards and 11 touchdowns in 1961 and remaining with Minnesota through 1964. That production makes the Vikings the clear winner.

Arizona Cardinals and Washington completed this transaction on 1961-09-12, with Arizona Cardinals receiving Ralph Guglielmi and Washington receiving George Izo. The cited historical sources support the basic exchange and its compensation. The long-term value remained modest on both sides, leaving the exchange best graded as an even result.

Detroit Lions received Johnny Olszewski in the deal with Washington Commanders. Olszewski appeared in all 14 Detroit games in 1961, but his offensive production was modest at 109 rushing yards and 14 receiving yards. The Lions received availability and veteran depth rather than a major offensive return. That outcome supports a C+ for Detroit Lions. The Washington Commanders Win verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Baltimore's historical ledger records the Colts acquiring linebacker Tom Gunderman from Washington in exchange for Vince Scott. The substance of that player swap is supportable, but surviving contemporary records leave the exact execution date and parts of Scott's identity uncertain. No securely documented long-term contribution creates a clear value separation, so Baltimore's return should be described without adding precision the surviving record does not provide.

Washington acquired center-linebacker Fred Hageman from the New York Giants on December 31, 1960 for the Redskins' 1961 second-round choice. New York used the acquired selection at No. 17 on Bobby Gaiters. Washington earns the stronger grade because Hageman became a multi-year starter and important two-way roster piece. The Giants received a premium draft choice, so their side retained value, but the realized production favored Washington.

San Francisco 49ers received 1962 sixth round pick (#71-Keith Luhnow) from Washington Commanders, sending Rodney Breedlove / Rod Breedlove the other way. Breedlove became a multi-season Washington regular and earned Pro Bowl recognition, giving Washington far more realized NFL value than San Francisco received from the late-round return. That outcome supports a D+ grade for San Francisco 49ers, and the overall verdict is Washington Commanders Win.

Los Angeles Rams received 1961 fourth round pick (#45-Charlie Cowan) in the 1960-09-06 exchange, while Washington Redskins received Roy Wilkins. Los Angeles received Washington’s 1961 fourth-round choice, No. 45, and used it on Charlie Cowan. Cowan became the strongest long-term NFL asset connected to the exchange, giving the Rams the clearer enduring return.

Cleveland traded defensive back Jim Wulff to Washington for a 1961 tenth-round draft choice. Cleveland used the acquired No. 129 selection on Wake Forest guard Wayne Wolff, who never appeared in a Browns regular-season game.

Washington traded veteran offensive lineman Don Boll to the New York Giants for the Giants' 1961 third-round draft choice. Washington used the acquired No. 39 selection on Pittsburgh fullback Jim Cunningham, who played three NFL seasons for the club.

Dallas acquired the rights to veteran quarterback Eddie LeBaron from Washington for its 1961 first- and sixth-round picks. The first became No. 2 overall quarterback Norm Snead, while the sixth became Joe Krakoski. LeBaron gave the expansion Cowboys needed stability and a 1962 Pro Bowl season, but Washington received premium draft capital and a long-term starting quarterback, producing the stronger overall return.

Pittsburgh Steelers received Will Renfro and 1961 fifth round pick (#59-Fred Mautino). Pittsburgh received Will Renfro and the 1961 fifth-round choice used on Fred Mautino. Renfro's Steelers stay was brief, and Mautino did not appear in an NFL regular-season game. The package gave Pittsburgh two possible paths to value, but neither developed into a durable return, leaving the Steelers with a limited result from the exchange. That result supports a C- grade for Pittsburgh Steelers.

Cleveland Browns received Sam Baker in the deal with Washington Commanders. Baker gave Cleveland two useful seasons handling kicking and punting duties. The Browns received legitimate special-teams value rather than a throwaway return. That outcome supports a B for Cleveland Browns. The Washington Commanders Win verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Chicago sent linebacker Bill Roehnelt to Washington on January 1, 1960 for a 1962 fifth-round choice that became No. 57, Mac Burton. Roehnelt immediately gave Washington 12 games and nine starts in 1960. Chicago used the acquired pick on Burton, but he never played an NFL regular-season game and instead continued his career in Canada. Washington therefore received the clear direct return and keeps the historical win.

Baltimore sent guard Hanson Churchwell to Washington for a future draft choice that became the 1960 tenth-round selection at No. 112, used on Ernie Barnes. Barnes did not provide on-field value for the Colts, while Churchwell played 10 games with two starts for Washington before being released. Surviving sources disagree on whether the transaction occurred September 18 or September 22, so that date conflict remains explicit.

Washington received Chicago’s 1960 second-round choice for Larry Morris and selected VMI back Sam Horner at No. 21. Horner contributed as a runner, defensive back, returner and punter in 1960-61, so the return was useful rather than wasted. Morris, however, became a long-term Bears linebacker, a key member of the 1963 championship defense and a second-team All-Pro. Chicago’s sustained defensive impact makes it the clear winner.

Washington acquired defensive back Richie McCabe from Pittsburgh on May 27, 1959 for fullback Billy Hicks. McCabe played 10 regular-season games with four starts for Washington that season and recorded one interception.

Washington acquired defensive lineman Bob Toneff from San Francisco on May 12, 1959, for a 1960 second-round pick, No. 16 overall. Toneff became a six-year Washington mainstay, playing 80 games with 76 starts and earning three consecutive Pro Bowls from 1959 through 1961. San Francisco used the pick on guard Mike Magac, who played five seasons and 56 games for the 49ers. Both sides did well, but Toneff delivered the greater peak value.

Philadelphia Eagles and Washington completed this transaction on 1958-07-17, with Philadelphia Eagles receiving Don Owens and Washington receiving Jim Weatherall. The cited historical sources support the basic exchange and its compensation. The long-term value remained modest on both sides, leaving the exchange best graded as an even result.

The Cardinals received Ben Preston plus the 1959 No. 52 pick used on Ted Bates. Bates supplied one useful season for the club, giving the return some genuine value, but the package did not generate the same sustained production Washington received from Johnny Olszewski. Arizona therefore lands slightly below average rather than failing completely in this historical exchange.

Pittsburgh acquired linebacker Ralph Felton from Washington in 1958, but the Steelers released him before the season was complete. Felton therefore provided only a short-lived return before Washington signed him back. The Steelers did not secure lasting value from the acquisition, while Washington regained Felton and also held the seventh-round pick received in the trade, supporting a D+ grade for Pittsburgh.

Washington acquired John Petitbon, Doyle Nix and a conditional fifth-round pick, while Green Bay received J.D. Kimmel and Steve Meilinger. Petitbon retired, activating the extra selection, but Nix contributed on defense. Kimmel started all 12 games for Green Bay in 1958 and Meilinger also played regularly. The exchange produced comparable short-term value on both sides rather than a decisive winner.

Philadelphia received Volney Peters; Washington received Menil Mavraides. Washington's 1958 guide and contemporary reporting confirm the Peters-for-Mavraides swap. Peters played 10 games for Philadelphia in 1958, while Mavraides' documented NFL career ended before he produced regular-season service for Washington. The hindsight grades are B for Philadelphia Eagles and D+ for Washington Redskins/Commanders, producing a Philadelphia Eagles Win verdict.

Pittsburgh acquired Billy Wells from Washington for a 1960 seventh-round pick probably used on Lenard Wilson. The exact downstream pick carries historical uncertainty, but Wells immediately played 11 games with nine starts for the Steelers in 1957. Pittsburgh therefore received meaningful short-term service, while Washington's probable draft return did not produce comparable documented value.

Washington moved quarterback Al Dorow to Philadelphia for a 1958 third-round pick and selected Tennessee end Bill Anderson at No. 31. Dorow appeared in six games with one start for the Eagles. Anderson became a six-year Washington receiving fixture, made two Pro Bowls, topped 700 receiving yards in 1959, and ultimately produced more than 3,000 NFL receiving yards.

Washington acquired Don Owens from Pittsburgh for Dale Atkeson in September 1957. Owens immediately became a regular, starting ten games for Washington that season. Atkeson's Pittsburgh opportunity was derailed and did not produce comparable regular-season value. The exchange therefore favors Washington clearly, though the limited scale of the player swap keeps the grade below elite territory.

Los Angeles sent quarterback Rudy Bukich to Washington in September 1957 and received two premium draft choices: Washington's 1958 first-rounder and 1959 second-rounder. Those selections became Lou Michaels at No. 4 overall and Buddy Humphrey at No. 16. Bukich gave Washington only a short stay, while Los Angeles converted one expendable quarterback into two significant shots at young talent.

Los Angeles Rams received fourth round pick (undisclosed). Los Angeles received a fourth-round draft choice, but the exact selection has not been identified. The Rams therefore acquired real draft capital, yet its downstream player value cannot be measured without inventing a pick identity. The return should stay explicitly unresolved.

Pittsburgh Steelers received Jack Scarbath. Pittsburgh acquired Jack Scarbath, but his 1956 Steelers production was limited: 12 completions on 41 attempts for 208 yards, two touchdowns, and five interceptions. That gave Pittsburgh short-term quarterback depth without creating sustained or high-level value. The return was measurable, but it did not develop into a major long-term advantage for the acquiring club.

Detroit traded star guard Dick Stanfel to Washington for defensive back Dick Alban in April 1956. Stanfel remained an elite lineman, earning first-team All-Pro honors in all three Washington seasons and later reaching the Pro Football Hall of Fame. Alban never played for Detroit, but the Lions quickly flipped him to Pittsburgh for Dick Modzelewski, preserving some indirect value from the original return.

Detroit acquired Harry Gilmer from Washington in June 1955, but the complete return was Bert Zagers and Bob Trout, not Zagers alone. Gilmer provided Detroit with two seasons of veteran quarterback depth, while Zagers became a multi-year Washington contributor. Restoring Trout to the package strengthens an already favorable Washington result and supports a clear Redskins/Commanders win.

Pittsburgh Steelers received Dick Modzelewski. Pittsburgh received Dick Modzelewski, but his Steelers stay lasted only through the 1955 season before he was traded again. He provided legitimate short-term line value, yet Pittsburgh did not keep the player long enough to match the multi-season return Washington received from the outgoing package.

Detroit received Jim Ricca and Walt Yowarsky, but neither became a meaningful Lions return. Ricca appeared in only six Detroit games with one start in 1955, while Yowarsky played only two games for the club before his release. The package gave Detroit little durable lineup value, especially compared with the immediate starting impact Washington received from LaVern Torgeson.

Cleveland acquired Don Paul from Washington for Johnny Carson and Dale Atkeson in August 1954. Paul later earned Pro Bowl selections in 1956 and 1957, giving the Browns the best player to emerge from the exchange. Washington did receive real production from Atkeson, who played 26 career games and started 18, so the result is a clear but not overwhelming Cleveland win.

San Francisco 49ers received Johnny Williams from Washington Commanders. Johnny Williams appeared in 11 games for San Francisco during the 1954 season, giving the 49ers an immediate, measurable return from a player who actually joined their lineup. That outcome supports a C+ grade for San Francisco 49ers when the trade is measured by the football value actually realized after the exchange.

Los Angeles acquired Hall Haynes and received immediate starting secondary value. Haynes started 11 games for the Rams in 1954 and recorded an interception, giving the club a clear one-season payoff from the trade. His return was not long-term star value, but it was substantial enough to anchor a modest Rams advantage.

Arizona captured the strongest long-term value in the January 30, 1954 three-team trade. The Cardinals received Night Train Lane, Len Teeuws and Bob Morgan; Lane became a six-year secondary star for the franchise and Teeuws became a four-year starter. Washington also created useful value by later turning Don Paul into Johnny Carson and Dale Atkeson, while the Rams' direct return proved much shorter-lived.

Green Bay Packers received Johnny Papit. Green Bay received Johnny Papit, but his Packers tenure was brief. Papit played four games in 1953, rushing six times for 44 yards and one touchdown. That gave Green Bay some immediate offensive depth, yet the return ended quickly and did not become a long-term asset.

Detroit's two draft choices can be traced to Bill Stits at No. 44 in 1954 and Gordon Malloy at No. 39 in 1955. Stits gave the Lions 36 games, 25 starts and 10 interceptions over three seasons; Malloy never played an NFL game. Washington got an immediate star season from Don Doll: 12 starts, 10 interceptions and a Pro Bowl. Both sides earn B grades and an even verdict.

Los Angeles acquired Washington's 1955 second-round choice and used No. 15 on Ron Waller, while Washington received Sam Baker. Waller became an immediate All-NFL-caliber rookie and played four seasons for the Rams. Baker developed into a valuable Washington kicker, punter and back, including Pro Bowl recognition, giving both clubs substantial return from the exchange.

Arizona Cardinals received 1953 ninth round draft choice (possibly #99-Ed Husmann). The Cardinals received Washington's 1953 ninth-round choice. The current record identifies the downstream selection only as possibly No. 99 Ed Husmann, and that qualification must remain. Arizona therefore received a real draft asset, but its exact player outcome cannot be treated as certain.

Washington acquired halfback Julie Rykovich from the Chicago Bears on September 24, 1952 for a 1953 seventh-round draft choice. Rykovich started 21 games over two Washington seasons and produced 612 rushing yards plus 356 receiving yards.

Pittsburgh Steelers received Bryant Douglas. Pittsburgh acquired Bryant Douglas from Washington. The available research does not show a major or durable Steelers regular-season outcome from Douglas after the trade. His value should therefore be treated as limited rather than inferred from appearances or roles he may have had with other clubs.

Los Angeles received the rights to Nick Bolkovac and a 1953 sixth-round pick that became Paul Miller. Those assets gave the Rams future options, but the documented football return is less substantial than Washington's immediate benefit from Joe Moss. The Rams' side therefore grades as a modest return rather than a clear long-term success.

Green Bay Packers received John Martinkovic. Green Bay acquired John Martinkovic and received a major long-term defensive-line return. Martinkovic played 72 consecutive games for the Packers across six seasons and earned three Pro Bowl selections. His durability, starting-level role, and league recognition turned the deal into one of the clearest value wins in this tranche.

San Francisco 49ers received Howie Livingston. San Francisco acquired Howie Livingston and immediately received starting defensive value. Livingston played seven games and started all seven for the 49ers in 1950, intercepting four passes for 99 yards and a touchdown. That is a concrete half-season of high-impact secondary production from the player San Francisco acquired.

Washington sent tackle Walt Stickel to Philadelphia on August 17, 1950, and received the Eagles’ 1951 second-round selection, later used at No. 21 on Jim Staton. Staton played only eight NFL games for Washington without a start before continuing his career in Canada. Stickel, meanwhile, gave Philadelphia two seasons and started 10 games in 1951, producing the better realized return.

Green Bay received Len Szafaryn plus first choice on any Washington guard placed on waivers. Szafaryn became a useful Packers lineman and supplied multiple seasons of starting work, so this was not an empty return. Even so, Green Bay did not receive a player with the same individual distinction or Washington-specific impact that Paul Lipscomb produced after the exchange.

Detroit acquired guard Joe Soboleski from Washington for George Hekkers in July 1950. Soboleski appeared in 12 games with three starts for the Lions that season, giving Detroit immediate roster and lineup value. Washington released Hekkers and received no regular-season playing contribution from him, so Detroit produced the only measurable on-field return from the exchange.

Chicago Bears received Jim Spavital and John Adams / Tree Adams in the 1950-06-02 exchange, while Washington Redskins received Walt Stickel. Chicago sent Walt Stickel and received Jim Spavital plus John “Tree” Adams. Turning one outgoing player into two roster pieces gave the Bears more ways to extract value and created the stronger overall return.

Detroit sent Hall of Fame back Bill Dudley to Washington for defensive back Dan Sandifer in January 1950. Dudley immediately became a major two-way contributor for Washington, starting every game in both 1950 and 1951 while rushing, receiving, returning kicks and intercepting passes. Sandifer had value as a defensive back, but Detroit surrendered the far more accomplished player and Washington gained the decisive advantage.

Green Bay traded Roy McKay to Washington and received tackle Don Deeks. Deeks appeared in eight games for the 1948 Packers and made one start, giving Green Bay at least a season of direct roster value from the exchange. The return was not transformative, but it materially exceeded Washington's outcome after McKay was released before playing a regular-season game for his new club.

Green Bay acquired Jack Jacobs, who played 36 games and made 17 starts over three Packers seasons, while Washington received Bob Nussbaumer and the rights to John Ferraro. Nussbaumer delivered 22 Washington games, 849 receiving yards and five touchdowns in 1947-48; Ferraro never played in the NFL. Both teams received real value, but Jacobs' multi-year quarterback role gives Green Bay a narrow edge.

The Rams received Steve Bagarus in exchange for Tom Farmer and Ralph Ruthstrom. Bagarus appeared in only two games for Los Angeles before later returning to Washington, limiting the Rams' realized value from the transaction. That outcome supports a C+ grade for Los Angeles Rams within the final Washington Redskins Win verdict.

The Boston/New York Yanks received Frank Akins for Jim Gillette in 1947. Akins' NFL regular-season record ends with Washington in 1946, so there is no Yanks playing value to credit after the trade. Gillette's 1947 NFL service came with Green Bay rather than Washington, leaving both acquiring teams with zero direct regular-season production from the exchange.

Green Bay acquired Cecil Hare from Washington for cash, with the first confirmed Packers acquisition date supported as August 12, 1946. Hare appeared for Green Bay in the preseason before the Giants later secured him from the Packers. That short tenure limited the realized football value of the acquisition, so Green Bay receives a C rather than a winning grade.

The Rams received Bob Hoffman, Jim Hardy, and Walter Ziemba. Hoffman contributed immediately, and the three-player return gave Los Angeles more usable value than Washington obtained from Jack Jacobs, making the Rams the stronger side in hindsight. The B+ grade reflects that realized football value and the complete supported package, while the overall verdict is Los Angeles/St. Louis Rams Win.