New York gave Washington a 2017 fourth-round pick to acquire…
New York gave Washington a 2017 fourth-round pick to acquire No. 158 in 2016 and drafted tackle Brandon Shell. Shell became a four-year Jets contributor with 40 starts. Washington used the future pick on Samaje Perine, who rushed for 603 yards as a rookie but had a much smaller role the next season. Perine had value, but New York received more sustained starting production.
Washington Commanders Received
- pick 2017 4th round pick (114th overall, Samaje Perine)
New York Jets Received
- pick 2016 5th round pick (158th overall, Brandon Shell)
Trade Analysis
What Changed Hands
The Jets acquired pick No. 158 in the 2016 fifth round from Washington for a 2017 fourth-round selection. New York used No. 158 on South Carolina tackle Brandon Shell. One year later, Washington used the acquired pick, No. 114, on Oklahoma running back Samaje Perine.
Why New York Has the Edge
Shell became a regular part of the Jets' offensive line. He appeared in 49 games for New York and started 40 over four seasons, including extended stretches at right tackle. That is strong realized value from a fifth-round selection, even if he never became an elite lineman. Washington moved the pick into a higher future round, but Perine's most productive season for the club came immediately as a rookie, when he rushed for 603 yards. His role then diminished.
How the Return Aged
Perine was not a wasted selection. He gave Washington useful backfield depth and started eight games over two seasons before his career continued elsewhere. The comparison favors New York because Shell's contribution was steadier and lasted twice as long with the acquiring team. The Jets also gained that production one year earlier, avoiding the wait attached to sending a future pick. Washington's higher nominal round did not translate into higher retained value. Shell also filled a premium offensive-line position, increasing the practical importance of those starts.
Final Verdict
New York earns a B+ and Washington a C+. Shell's 40 starts represent a meaningful fifth-round hit and a more durable return than Washington received from Perine. New York Jets Win.