Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
Cleveland Browns acquired 2026 4th round pick (105th overall subsequently traded, Brenen Thompson), 2026 5th round pick (145th overall subsequently traded, Nick Barrett) and a 2027 4th round pick from New York Giants for 2026 3rd round pick (74th overall, Malachi Fields). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 2026 4th round pick (105th overall subsequently traded, Brenen Thompson), 2026 5th round pick (145th overall subsequently traded, Nick Barrett) and a 2027 4th round pick
- Pick 2026 3rd round pick (74th overall, Malachi Fields)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Los Angeles Chargers acquired 2026 4th round pick (105th overall, Brenen Thompson), 2026 5th round pick (145th overall, Nick Barrett) and 2026 6th round pick (206th overall, Alex Harkey) from Cleveland Browns for 2026 3rd round pick (86th overall, Austin Barber). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 2026 4th round pick (105th overall, Brenen Thompson), 2026 5th round pick (145th overall, Nick Barrett) and 2026 6th round pick (206th overall, Alex Harkey)
- Pick 2026 3rd round pick (86th overall, Austin Barber)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ New York Giants Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: medium
New York Giants acquired 2026 3rd round pick (74th overall, Malachi Fields) from Cleveland Browns for 2026 4th round pick (105th overall subsequently traded, Brenen Thompson), 2026 5th round pick (145th overall subsequently traded, Nick Barrett) and a 2027 4th round pick. New York Giants received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New York Giants Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2026 3rd round pick (74th overall, Malachi Fields)
- Pick 2026 4th round pick (105th overall subsequently traded, Brenen Thompson), 2026 5th round pick (145th overall subsequently traded, Nick Barrett) and a 2027 4th round pick
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports New York Giants: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Los Angeles Chargers acquired Taylor Heinicke from Atlanta Falcons for 2025 7th round pick (218th overall, Jack Nelson). The overall result favors Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers over Los Angeles Chargers.
Assets Received
- Pick 2025 7th round pick (218th overall, Jack Nelson)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Los Angeles/San Diego Chargers: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
Seattle acquired 2026 6th round pick (188th overall subsequently traded, Anez Cooper) from Cleveland Browns on 2024-08-11, sending Nick Harris; 2026 7th round pick (248th overall, Carsen Ryan) in return. The value case for Seattle comes down to the direct asset exchange: 2026 6th round pick (188th overall subsequently traded, Anez Cooper) for Nick Harris; 2026 7th round pick (248th overall, Carsen Ryan). There is no clear evidence of a major downstream swing, so the grade stays modest rather than inflated. For TradeVerdicts, this row matters because it preserves the transaction trail without overstating the long-term Seahawks impact.
Assets Received
- Pick 2026 6th round pick (188th overall subsequently traded, Anez Cooper)
- Player Nick Harris
- Pick 2026 7th round pick (248th overall, Carsen Ryan)
Trade Analysis
Cleveland Browns received Nick Harris; 2026 7th round pick (248th overall, Carsen Ryan) while sending 2026 6th round pick (188th overall subsequently traded, Anez Cooper) to Seattle.
View the full trade verdict
→ San Francisco 49ers Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: medium
Philadelphia Eagles acquired 2024 3rd round pick (94th overall, Jalyx Hunt) and 2024 4th round pick (132nd overall subsequently traded) from San Francisco 49ers for 2024 3rd round pick (86th overall, Dominick Puni).
Assets Received
- Pick 2024 3rd round pick (94th overall, Jalyx Hunt)
- Pick 2024 4th round pick (132nd overall subsequently traded)
- Pick 2024 3rd round pick (86th overall, Dominick Puni)
Trade Analysis
San Francisco 49ers received 2024 3rd round pick (86th overall, Dominick Puni) and sent 2024 3rd round pick (94th overall, Jalyx Hunt) and 2024 4th round pick (132nd overall subsequently traded).
View the full trade verdict
→ New York Jets Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Denver Broncos acquired Zach Wilson; 2024 7th round pick (256th overall, Nick Gargiulo) from New York Jets for 2024 6th round pick (203rd overall subsequently traded, Will Reichard). The stronger recorded return sits with New York Jets, matching the New York Jets Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Player Zach Wilson
- Pick 2024 7th round pick (256th overall, Nick Gargiulo)
- Pick 2024 6th round pick (203rd overall subsequently traded, Will Reichard)
Trade Analysis
New York Jets gets the edge because the recorded return is stronger than what it gave up.
View the full trade verdict
→ New England Patriots Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
New England Patriots acquired 2025 7th round pick (217th overall subsequently traded, Jay Toia) from Tennessee Titans for Nick Folk. New England Patriots received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New England Patriots Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2025 7th round pick (217th overall subsequently traded, Jay Toia)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports New England Patriots: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Houston Texans Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Houston Texans acquired 2023 6th round pick (205th overall, Xavier Hutchinson) from Buffalo Bills for 2023 7th round pick (230th overall, Nick Broeker) and 2024 6th round pick (200th overall subsequently traded, Jaden Crumedy). Houston Texans received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Houston Texans Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 6th round pick (205th overall, Xavier Hutchinson)
- Pick 2023 7th round pick (230th overall, Nick Broeker)
- Pick 2024 6th round pick (200th overall subsequently traded, Jaden Crumedy)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Houston Texans: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Chicago Bears Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
New Orleans Saints acquired 2023 4th round pick (103rd overall, Nick Saldiveri) from Chicago Bears for 2023 4th round pick (115th overall, Roschon Johnson) and 2023 5th round pick (165th overall, Terell Smith). The overall result favors Chicago Bears over New Orleans Saints.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 4th round pick (103rd overall, Nick Saldiveri)
- Pick 2023 4th round pick (115th overall, Roschon Johnson)
- Pick 2023 5th round pick (165th overall, Terell Smith)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Chicago Bears: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Philadelphia acquired 2023 4th round pick (105th overall, Kelee Ringo) and 2023 6th round pick (191st overall subsequently traded, Trey Palmer) from Houston for 2024 3rd round pick (86th overall subsequently traded, Dominick Puni), 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded, Nick Broeker) and 2023 7th round pick (248th overall, Brandon Hill). The bundled asset stack stays close enough for an Even Trade verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 4th round pick (105th overall, Kelee Ringo)
- Pick 2023 6th round pick (191st overall subsequently traded, Trey Palmer)
- Pick 2024 3rd round pick (86th overall subsequently traded, Dominick Puni)
- Pick 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded, Nick Broeker)
- Pick 2023 7th round pick (248th overall, Brandon Hill)
Trade Analysis
The combined Philadelphia-Houston pick exchange stays in Even Trade territory because both sides received usable draft value without decisive separation.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Philadelphia acquired 2023 3rd round pick (65th overall, Tyler Steen), 2023 6th round pick (188th overall, Tanner McKee) and 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded, Nick Broeker) from Houston Texans for 2023 2nd round pick (62nd overall, Juice Scruggs).
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 3rd round pick (65th overall, Tyler Steen), 2023 6th round pick (188th overall, Tanner McKee) and 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded, Nick Broeker)
- Pick 2023 2nd round pick (62nd overall, Juice Scruggs)
Trade Analysis
Houston Texans received 2023 2nd round pick (62nd overall, Juice Scruggs) and sent 2023 3rd round pick (65th overall, Tyler Steen), 2023 6th round pick (188th overall, Tanner McKee) and 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded, Nick Broeker).
View the full trade verdict
→ Pittsburgh Steelers Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Pittsburgh Steelers acquired 2023 3rd round pick (93rd overall, Darnell Washington) and 2023 4th round pick (132nd overall, Nick Herbig) from Carolina Panthers for 2023 3rd round pick (80th overall, DJ Johnson). Pittsburgh Steelers received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Pittsburgh Steelers Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 3rd round pick (93rd overall, Darnell Washington)
- Pick 2023 4th round pick (132nd overall, Nick Herbig)
- Pick 2023 3rd round pick (80th overall, DJ Johnson)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Pittsburgh Steelers: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
Los Angeles Rams acquired 2023 3rd round pick (73rd overall subsequently traded, Jalin Hyatt) and 2023 5th round pick (161st overall, Nick Hampton) from Houston Texans for 2023 3rd round pick (69th overall, Tank Dell). The overall result favors Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams over Los Angeles Rams.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 3rd round pick (73rd overall subsequently traded, Jalin Hyatt)
- Pick 2023 5th round pick (161st overall, Nick Hampton)
- Pick 2023 3rd round pick (69th overall, Tank Dell)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Dallas Cowboys Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Dallas Cowboys acquired Brandin Cooks from Houston Texans for 2023 5th round pick (161st overall subsequently traded, Nick Hampton) and 2024 6th round pick (200th overall subsequently traded, Jaden Crumedy). Dallas Cowboys received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Dallas Cowboys Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 5th round pick (161st overall subsequently traded, Nick Hampton)
- Pick 2024 6th round pick (200th overall subsequently traded, Jaden Crumedy)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Dallas Cowboys: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Houston Texans Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired 2023 6th round pick (179th overall subsequently traded; Karl Brooks); 2023 6th round pick (179th overall subsequently traded, Karl Brooks) from Houston Texans for Shaq Mason; 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded; Nick Broe; additional player details unavailable from source data; Draft-pick compensation details unavailable from source data. The overall result favors Houston Texans over Tampa Bay Buccaneers.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 6th round pick (179th overall subsequently traded, Karl Brooks)
- Player Karl Brooks)
- Player Shaq Mason
- Pick 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded
- Player Nick Broe; additional
- Pick Draft-pick compensation
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Houston Texans: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ New York Jets Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
New York Jets acquired Chuck Clark from Baltimore Ravens for 2024 7th round pick (228th overall, Nick Samac). New York Jets received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New York Jets Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2024 7th round pick (228th overall, Nick Samac)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports New York Jets: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ San Francisco 49ers Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
San Francisco's trade for Christian McCaffrey became one of the clearest modern examples of a running back being worth the price. The 49ers paid a strong draft-pick package, but McCaffrey immediately became the engine of Kyle Shanahan's offense. Carolina received volume, yet San Francisco acquired the player who changed its ceiling. The deal worked because the player, coach, scheme, and roster timeline all matched.
Assets Received
- Pick 2023 2nd round pick (61st overall subsequently traded, Brenton Strange), 2023 3rd round pick (93rd overall subsequently traded, Darnell Washington), 2023 4th round pick (132nd overall subsequently traded, Nick Herbig) and 2024 5th round pick (166th overall subsequently traded, Tyrone Tracy)
- Player Christian McCaffrey
Trade Analysis
Why the 49ers Made the Trade
San Francisco made the trade because Christian McCaffrey was not a normal running back. He was a complete offensive weapon who could carry the ball, run routes, punish linebackers in space, and give Kyle Shanahan a matchup advantage on almost every snap.
That fit mattered as much as the talent. McCaffrey joined an offense already built around motion, spacing, timing, and yards after the catch. The 49ers were not asking him to save a broken system. They were adding him to one of the best-designed attacks in football.
What Carolina Actually Received
Carolina received a second-round pick, a third-round pick, a fourth-round pick, and a future fifth-round pick. That is a real package for a running back, especially in a league where the position is often treated as replaceable.
The Panthers were not wrong to consider a reset. McCaffrey had major value, but Carolina was not positioned to maximize him the way San Francisco could. Moving him gave the Panthers draft capital and flexibility.
Why the Trade Still Favors San Francisco
The 49ers get the edge because McCaffrey gave them exactly what they were buying. He became the focal point of the offense, elevated the quarterback situation, and made an already difficult scheme even harder to defend.
This is the rare running back trade that breaks the usual rule. Most teams should be careful about spending major assets at the position. McCaffrey's receiving value and schematic versatility made him different. He was not just a ball-carrier. He was a formation-changing offensive centerpiece.
How McCaffrey Changed the Offense
McCaffrey allowed San Francisco to disguise intentions without changing personnel. The 49ers could line him up in the backfield, move him into the slot, attack the flats, run between the tackles, or use him as a decoy to create space elsewhere.
That kind of versatility stresses a defense before the snap. It also gave San Francisco a reliable pressure valve in high-leverage situations. The offense became less predictable and more explosive.
The Long-Term Legacy
This trade will remain one of the best arguments for paying up when the player is truly special and the fit is exact. It did not prove every running back is worth a premium package. It proved McCaffrey was.
Carolina received useful draft value, but San Francisco received the player who made the trade memorable.
Why This Trade Still Matters
This trade still matters because it pushed back against the easy idea that running backs are never worth a major package. Most backs are not. McCaffrey was different because his receiving value, route flexibility, and open-field skill made him more than a traditional runner.
The lesson is not that every team should trade heavily for a running back. The lesson is that a special player in the perfect system can justify a premium price. San Francisco had the coach, roster, and offensive structure to use every part of McCaffrey's skill set.
Final Verdict
The 49ers won because they acquired a rare offensive weapon who matched their system perfectly. Carolina received assets, but San Francisco received the immediate and elite impact. 49ers grade: A. Panthers grade: D+.
View the full trade verdict
→ Vikings Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Minnesota Vikings acquired Nick Mullens from Las Vegas Raiders for 2024 7th round pick (229th overall, M.J. Devonshire). The overall result favors Vikings over Minnesota Vikings.
Assets Received
- Pick 2024 7th round pick (229th overall, M.J. Devonshire)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Vikings: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Las Vegas Raiders Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Minnesota Vikings acquired 2022 4th round pick (126th overall subsequently traded, Neil Farrell) and 2022 7th round pick (227th overall, Nick Muse) from Las Vegas Raiders for 2022 4th round pick (122nd overall, Zamir White) and 2022 7th round pick (250th overall, Brittain Brown). The stronger recorded return sits with Las Vegas Raiders, matching the Las Vegas Raiders Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2022 4th round pick (126th overall subsequently traded, Neil Farrell)
- Pick 2022 7th round pick (227th overall, Nick Muse)
- Pick 2022 4th round pick (122nd overall, Zamir White)
- Pick 2022 7th round pick (250th overall, Brittain Brown)
Trade Analysis
The edge goes to Las Vegas Raiders because the recorded return is stronger than what it gave up.
View the full trade verdict
→ Indianapolis Colts Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Denver Broncos acquired 2022 5th round pick (179th overall subsequently traded, Kingsley Enagbare) and 2023 3rd round pick (67th overall, Drew Sanders) from Indianapolis Colts for 2022 3rd round pick (96th overall, Nick Cross). The stronger recorded return sits with Indianapolis Colts, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2022 5th round pick (179th overall subsequently traded, Kingsley Enagbare)
- Pick 2023 3rd round pick (67th overall, Drew Sanders)
- Pick 2022 3rd round pick (96th overall, Nick Cross)
Trade Analysis
The edge goes to Indianapolis Colts because the recorded return is stronger than what it gave up.
View the full trade verdict
→ Las Vegas Raiders Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Las Vegas Raiders acquired Rock Ya-Sin from Indianapolis Colts for Yannick Ngakoue. Las Vegas Raiders received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Las Vegas Raiders Win verdict.
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Las Vegas Raiders: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Los Angeles Rams Win
Tier: landmark
Confidence: high
The Rams acquired Von Miller from Denver for a 2022 second-round pick and a 2022 third-round pick, then watched him become a finishing piece on a Super Bowl champion. Denver received meaningful draft capital, but Los Angeles got exactly what contenders hope to buy: immediate championship impact.
Assets Received
- Pick 2022 2nd round pick (64th overall, Nik Bonitto)
- Pick 2022 3rd round pick (96th overall subsequently traded, Nick Cross)
Trade Analysis
This is a Rams win, not a Broncos failure. Denver handled the situation well and received real draft capital. Los Angeles paid for a short-term title piece, and Miller helped deliver the championship result the Rams wanted.
View the full trade verdict
→ Denver Broncos Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Denver Broncos acquired Jonas Griffith and 2022 7th round pick (250th overall subsequently traded, Brittain Brown) from San Francisco 49ers for 2022 6th round pick (187th overall, Nick Zakelj) and 2023 7th round pick (222nd overall subsequently traded, DeWayne McBride). The stronger recorded return sits with Denver Broncos, matching the Denver Broncos Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Player Jonas Griffith
- Pick 2022 7th round pick (250th overall subsequently traded, Brittain Brown)
- Pick 2022 6th round pick (187th overall, Nick Zakelj)
- Pick 2023 7th round pick (222nd overall subsequently traded, DeWayne McBride)
Trade Analysis
The edge goes to Denver Broncos because the recorded return is stronger than what it gave up.
View the full trade verdict
→ Las Vegas Raiders Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Carolina Panthers acquired 2022 6th round pick (199th overall, Cade Mays) from Las Vegas Raiders for Denzel Perryman and 2022 7th round pick (227th overall subsequently traded, Nick Muse). The overall result favors Las Vegas Raiders over Carolina Panthers.
Assets Received
- Pick 2022 6th round pick (199th overall, Cade Mays)
- Pick Denzel Perryman and 2022 7th round pick (227th overall subsequently traded, Nick Muse)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Las Vegas Raiders: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Kansas City Chiefs Win
Tier: landmark
Confidence: high
Kansas City acquired Orlando Brown Jr., a second-round pick that became Nick Bolton, and later pick value from Baltimore for a package built around the No. 31 pick. Brown gave the Chiefs immediate left tackle help, started on a Super Bowl champion, and Bolton became a major defensive piece. Baltimore got useful value with Odafe Oweh, but Kansas City landed the stronger championship-era return.
Assets Received
- Pick Orlando Brown Jr., 2021 2nd round pick (58th overall, Nick Bolton) and 2022 6th round pick (191st overall subsequently traded, Jalen Nailor)
- Pick 2021 1st round pick (31st overall, Odafe Oweh), 2021 3rd round pick (94th overall, Ben Cleveland), 2021 4th round pick (136th overall subsequently traded, Marco Wilson) and 2022 5th round pick (173rd overall subsequently traded, Marcus McKethan)
Trade Analysis
Why the Chiefs Made the Trade
Kansas City made this move because protecting Patrick Mahomes had become urgent. The Chiefs had just watched their offensive line collapse on the biggest stage, and Orlando Brown Jr. gave them a proven tackle with the size, pedigree, and experience to stabilize the edge.
That mattered because the Chiefs were not rebuilding. They were managing a championship window around the best quarterback in football. When a team has Mahomes, every offensive line decision carries extra weight. Kansas City needed a real solution, not a developmental guess.
What Baltimore Actually Received
Baltimore received a first-round pick that became Odafe Oweh, along with additional draft value. The Ravens were also responding to Brown's desire to play left tackle, which made the situation more complicated than a normal player sale.
That is why Baltimore should not be graded like it got nothing. Oweh became a useful edge defender, and the Ravens turned a looming contract and role issue into real draft capital. The return was respectable, even if it did not match Kansas City's final payoff.
Why the Trade Still Favors Kansas City
The trade still favors Kansas City because the Chiefs got immediate left tackle value and another major player through the pick structure. Brown helped protect Mahomes during a key stretch, and Nick Bolton became an important defensive piece.
That combination pushes the trade beyond a simple rental or short-term offensive line fix. Kansas City got help at a premium protection spot, then also landed a linebacker who mattered to the next championship version of the roster.
The Mahomes Window Factor
This trade is really about the Mahomes window. Kansas City could not treat left tackle like an ordinary position after the Super Bowl LV protection problems. The Chiefs had to act like a contender with a generational quarterback.
That context makes the price easier to defend. Brown did not stay in Kansas City forever, but he filled a need at the right time. Contenders do not need every trade to last ten years. They need the move to fit the window.
The Long-Term Legacy
Baltimore's side aged better than a D. Oweh gave the Ravens something real, and the organization did not get trapped by a player who wanted a different role and a major future payday.
Kansas City's side still aged better. The Chiefs got the stronger immediate value, kept Mahomes protected, and came away with Bolton as part of the total exchange. That gives Kansas City the cleaner historical win.
Why This Trade Still Matters
This trade still matters because it shows how contenders should treat premium protection. Kansas City paid aggressively, but the Chiefs were solving a real problem tied directly to their franchise quarterback.
It also belongs in the GSC priority group because the Orlando Brown Jr. trade connects Mahomes, left tackle value, Ravens draft discipline, and a Super Bowl-era Chiefs roster. That gives the page lasting search value.
Final Verdict
This should stay as a Chiefs win, but Baltimore should not be buried with a D. Kansas City won the championship-window and player-value arguments. Chiefs grade: A. Ravens grade: C+.
View the full trade verdict
→ Tennessee Titans Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Los Angeles Chargers acquired 2021 6th round pick (185th overall, Nick Niemann) from Tennessee Titans for Desmond King. The overall result favors Tennessee Titans over Los Angeles Chargers.
Assets Received
- Pick 2021 6th round pick (185th overall, Nick Niemann)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Tennessee Titans: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Minnesota Vikings Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Minnesota Vikings acquired 2021 3rd round pick (90th overall, Patrick Jones) and 2022 5th round pick (156th overall subsequently traded, Jerome Ford) from Baltimore Ravens for Yannick Ngakoue. Minnesota Vikings received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Minnesota Vikings Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2021 3rd round pick (90th overall, Patrick Jones)
- Pick 2022 5th round pick (156th overall subsequently traded, Jerome Ford)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Minnesota Vikings: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Tampa Bay Buccaneers Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired Steve McLendon and 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded, Nick Broeker) from New York Jets for 2022 6th round pick (206th overall subsequently traded, Matt Henningsen). The stronger recorded return sits with Tampa Bay Buccaneers, matching the Tampa Bay Buccaneers Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Player Steve McLendon
- Pick 2023 7th round pick (230th overall subsequently traded, Nick Broeker)
- Pick 2022 6th round pick (206th overall subsequently traded, Matt Henningsen)
Trade Analysis
The value edge goes to Tampa Bay Buccaneers because the recorded return is stronger than what it gave up.
View the full trade verdict
→ Jacksonville Jaguars Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Jacksonville Jaguars acquired Kamalei Correa and 2021 7th round pick (249th overall subsequently traded, Ben Skowronek) from Tennessee Titans for 2021 6th round pick (185th overall subsequently traded, Nick Niemann). Jacksonville Jaguars received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Jacksonville Jaguars Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick Kamalei Correa and 2021 7th round pick (249th overall subsequently traded, Ben Skowronek)
- Pick 2021 6th round pick (185th overall subsequently traded, Nick Niemann)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Jacksonville Jaguars: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Minnesota Vikings Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Minnesota Vikings acquired Yannick Ngakoue from Jacksonville Jaguars for 2021 2nd round pick (45th overall, Walker Little) and 2022 5th round pick (157th overall subsequently traded, Zyon McCollum). Minnesota Vikings received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Minnesota Vikings Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2021 2nd round pick (45th overall, Walker Little)
- Pick 2022 5th round pick (157th overall subsequently traded, Zyon McCollum)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Minnesota Vikings: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Indianapolis Colts Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Indianapolis Colts acquired 2020 2nd round pick (41st overall, Jonathan Taylor) from Cleveland Browns for 2020 2nd round pick (44th overall, Grant Delpit) and 2020 5th round pick (160th overall, Nick Harris). Indianapolis Colts received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Indianapolis Colts Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2020 2nd round pick (41st overall, Jonathan Taylor)
- Pick 2020 2nd round pick (44th overall, Grant Delpit)
- Pick 2020 5th round pick (160th overall, Nick Harris)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Indianapolis Colts: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Jacksonville Jaguars Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Jacksonville Jaguars acquired 2020 4th round pick (140th overall, Shaquille Quarterman) from Chicago Bears for Nick Foles. Jacksonville Jaguars received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Jacksonville Jaguars Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2020 4th round pick (140th overall, Shaquille Quarterman)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Jacksonville Jaguars: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: standard
Confidence: medium
Seattle Seahawks acquired 2020 5th round pick (162nd overall subsequently traded, Khaleke Hudson) from Pittsburgh Steelers for Nick Vannett. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 2020 5th round pick (162nd overall subsequently traded, Khaleke Hudson)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Los Angeles Rams acquired 2019 4th round pick (134th overall, Greg Gaines) and 2019 7th round pick (243rd overall, Nick Scott) from New England Patriots for 2019 5th round pick (162nd overall subsequently traded, Cameron Smith) and 2019 5th round pick (167th overall subsequently traded, Clayton Thorson). The overall result favors Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams over Los Angeles Rams.
Assets Received
- Pick 2019 4th round pick (134th overall, Greg Gaines)
- Pick 2019 7th round pick (243rd overall, Nick Scott)
- Pick 2019 5th round pick (162nd overall subsequently traded, Cameron Smith)
- Pick 2019 5th round pick (167th overall subsequently traded, Clayton Thorson)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Cleveland Browns acquired 2019 5th round pick (170th overall, Austin Seibert) from New England Patriots for Josh Gordon and 2019 7th round pick (243rd overall subsequently traded, Nick Scott). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 2019 5th round pick (170th overall, Austin Seibert)
- Pick Josh Gordon and 2019 7th round pick (243rd overall subsequently traded, Nick Scott)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Cleveland Browns Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
San Francisco 49ers acquired Shon Coleman from Cleveland Browns for 2019 7th round pick (243rd overall subsequently traded, Nick Scott). The overall result favors Cleveland Browns over San Francisco 49ers.
Assets Received
- Pick 2019 7th round pick (243rd overall subsequently traded, Nick Scott)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Cleveland Browns: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Cleveland Browns Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Cleveland Browns acquired Brock Osweiler, 2017 6th round pick (188th overall subsequently traded, Elijah McGuire) and 2018 2nd round pick (35th overall, Nick Chubb) from Houston Texans for 2017 4th round pick (142nd overall, Carlos Watkins). Cleveland Browns received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Cleveland Browns Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick Brock Osweiler, 2017 6th round pick (188th overall subsequently traded, Elijah McGuire) and 2018 2nd round pick (35th overall, Nick Chubb)
- Pick 2017 4th round pick (142nd overall, Carlos Watkins)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Cleveland Browns: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Kansas City Chiefs Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: medium
Kansas City Chiefs acquired 2019 7th round pick (216th overall, Nick Allegretti) from San Francisco 49ers for Rod Streater. Kansas City Chiefs received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Kansas City Chiefs Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2019 7th round pick (216th overall, Nick Allegretti)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Kansas City Chiefs: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
Los Angeles Rams and Chicago Bears land in even-trade territory. The final grade profile (Los Angeles Rams B-, Chicago Bears B-) shows useful value on both sides without enough separation for a clear winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 2016 4th round pick (117th overall, Pharoh Cooper)
- Pick 2016 6th round pick (206th overall, Mike Thomas)
- Pick 2016 4th round pick (113th overall, Nick Kwiatkoski)
Trade Analysis
This final review treats the trade as a low-separation exchange. One side may have preferred the timing, player fit, or draft slot, but the long-term value did not break sharply in either direction. With the grade profile set at Los Angeles Rams B-, Chicago Bears B-, the reviewed TradeVerdicts outcome is Even Trade.
View the full trade verdict
→ Atlanta Falcons Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Atlanta Falcons come out ahead in this trade. The final grade profile (Atlanta Falcons B+, Houston Texans C) supports the existing verdict and gives the winning side the cleaner value result.
Assets Received
- Pick 2016 2nd round pick (52nd overall, Deion Jones)
- Pick 2016 6th round pick (195th overall, Wes Schweitzer)
- Pick 2016 2nd round pick (50th overall, Nick Martin)
Trade Analysis
This trade tilts toward Atlanta Falcons because the recorded return created the better long-term value case. The losing side may have been chasing a roster need, draft-board target, or short-term fit, but the final results favor the team that converted the exchange into more practical value. With the grade profile set at Atlanta Falcons B+, Houston Texans C, the TradeVerdicts read is a clear Atlanta Falcons win.
View the full trade verdict
→ Seattle Seahawks Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Seattle Seahawks come out ahead in this trade. The final grade profile (Seattle Seahawks B, Denver Broncos C) supports the existing verdict and gives the winning side the cleaner value result.
Assets Received
- Pick 2016 1st round pick (31st overall, Germain Ifedi)
- Pick 2016 3rd round pick (94th overall, Nick Vannett)
- Pick 2016 1st round pick (26th overall, Paxton Lynch)
Trade Analysis
This trade tilts toward Seattle Seahawks because the recorded return created the better long-term value case. The losing side may have been chasing a roster need, draft-board target, or short-term fit, but the final results favor the team that converted the exchange into more practical value. With the grade profile set at Seattle Seahawks B, Denver Broncos C, the TradeVerdicts read is a clear Seattle Seahawks win.
View the full trade verdict
→ Tennessee Titans Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Tennessee Titans come out ahead in this trade. The final grade profile (Los Angeles Rams C+, Tennessee Titans A-) supports the existing verdict and gives the winning side the cleaner value result.
Assets Received
- Pick 2016 1st round pick (1st overall, Jared Goff), 2016 4th round pick (113th overall subsequently traded, Nick Kwiatkoski) and 2016 6th round pick (177th overall, Temarrick Hemingway)
- Pick 2016 1st round pick (15th overall subsequently traded, Corey Coleman), 2016 2nd round pick (43rd overall, Austin Johnson), 2016 2nd round pick (45th overall, Derrick Henry), 2016 3rd round pick (76th overall subsequently traded, Shon Coleman), 2017 1st round pick (5th overall, Corey Davis) and 2017 3rd round pick (100th overall, Jonnu Smith)
Trade Analysis
This trade tilts toward Tennessee Titans because the recorded return created the better long-term value case. The losing side may have been chasing a roster need, draft-board target, or short-term fit, but the final results favor the team that converted the exchange into more practical value. With the grade profile set at Los Angeles Rams C+, Tennessee Titans A-, the TradeVerdicts read is a clear Tennessee Titans win.
View the full trade verdict
→ Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Tennessee Titans come out ahead in this trade. The final grade profile (Philadelphia Eagles C-, Tennessee Titans C) supports the existing verdict and gives the winning side the cleaner value result.
Assets Received
- Pick 2016 4th round pick (100th overall subsequently traded, Connor Cook)
- Pick DeMarco Murray and 2016 4th round pick (113th overall subsequently traded, Nick Kwiatkoski)
Trade Analysis
This trade tilts toward Tennessee Titans because the recorded return created the better long-term value case. The losing side may have been chasing a roster need, draft-board target, or short-term fit, but the final results favor the team that converted the exchange into more practical value. With the grade profile set at Philadelphia Eagles C-, Tennessee Titans C, the TradeVerdicts read is a clear Tennessee Titans win.
View the full trade verdict
→ Minnesota Vikings Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Minnesota Vikings acquired Nick Easton and 2016 6th-round pick (#180 Moritz Boehringer) from San Francisco 49ers for Gerald Hodges. Minnesota Vikings received the stronger long-term football value, matching the Minnesota Vikings Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Player Nick Easton
- Pick 2016 6th-round pick (#180 Moritz Boehringer)
Trade Analysis
The grades favor Minnesota Vikings because that side produced the clearer long-term football value. The visible verdict remains Minnesota Vikings Win.
View the full trade verdict
→ Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Los Angeles Rams come out ahead in this trade. The final grade profile (Los Angeles Rams A-, Philadelphia Eagles C-) supports the existing verdict and gives the winning side the cleaner value result.
Assets Received
- Pick Nick Foles, 2015 4th round pick (119th overall, Andrew Donnal) and 2016 2nd round pick (43rd overall subsequently traded, Austin Johnson)
- Pick Sam Bradford, 2015 5th round pick (145th overall subsequently traded, Bobby McCain) and a conditional 2016 pick (not conveyed)
Trade Analysis
This trade tilts toward Los Angeles Rams because the recorded return created the better long-term value case. The losing side may have been chasing a roster need, draft-board target, or short-term fit, but the final results favor the team that converted the exchange into more practical value. With the grade profile set at Los Angeles Rams A-, Philadelphia Eagles C-, the TradeVerdicts read is a clear Los Angeles Rams win.
View the full trade verdict
→ Miami Dolphins Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Miami Dolphins acquired 2012 4th round pick (97th overall, Lamar Miller) from San Francisco 49ers for 2012 4th round pick (103rd overall subsequently traded, Frank Alexander), 2012 6th round pick (196th overall subsequently traded, Jonte Green) and 2013 6th round pick (180th overall, Nick Moody). Miami Dolphins received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Miami Dolphins Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2012 4th round pick (97th overall, Lamar Miller)
- Pick 2012 4th round pick (103rd overall subsequently traded, Frank Alexander), 2012 6th round pick (196th overall subsequently traded, Jonte Green) and 2013 6th round pick (180th overall, Nick Moody)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Miami Dolphins: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Philadelphia acquired DeMeco Ryans and 2012 3rd round pick (88th overall, Nick Foles) from Houston Texans for 2012 3rd round pick (76th overall, Brandon Brooks) and 2012 4th round pick (99th overall, Ben Jones).
Assets Received
- Pick DeMeco Ryans and 2012 3rd round pick (88th overall, Nick Foles)
- Pick 2012 3rd round pick (76th overall, Brandon Brooks)
- Pick 2012 4th round pick (99th overall, Ben Jones)
Trade Analysis
Houston Texans received 2012 3rd round pick (76th overall, Brandon Brooks) and 2012 4th round pick (99th overall, Ben Jones) and sent DeMeco Ryans and 2012 3rd round pick (88th overall, Nick Foles).
View the full trade verdict
→ Philadelphia Eagles Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Tampa Bay Buccaneers acquired 2011 4th round pick (104th overall, Luke Stocker) from Philadelphia Eagles for 2011 4th round pick (116th overall, Casey Matthews) and 2012 4th round pick (99th overall; traded with 2012 pick 76 to Houston for DeMeco Ryans and 2012 pick 88, Nick Foles; Houston later selected Ben Jones at 99). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 2011 4th round pick (104th overall, Luke Stocker)
- Pick 2011 4th round pick (116th overall, Casey Matthews)
- Pick 2012 4th round pick (99th overall; traded with 2012 pick 76 to Houston for DeMeco Ryans and 2012 pick 88, Nick Foles; Houston later selected Ben Jones at 99)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ San Francisco 49ers Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Denver Broncos received 2011 2nd round pick (45th overall, Rahim Moore), 2011 4th round pick (108th overall, Quinton Carter) and 2011 5th round pick (141st overall subsequently traded, D.J. Williams). San Francisco 49ers received 2011 2nd round pick (36th overall, Colin Kaepernick). The final review favors San Francisco 49ers because that return produced stronger practical football value.
Assets Received
- Pick 2011 2nd round pick (45th overall, Rahim Moore), 2011 4th round pick (108th overall, Quinton Carter) and 2011 5th round pick (141st overall subsequently traded, D.J. Williams)
- Pick 2011 2nd round pick (36th overall, Colin Kaepernick)
Trade Analysis
San Francisco 49ers earns the stronger review after comparing actual player outcomes, draft-slot cost, roster usefulness, and retained value from the exchange. The final TradeVerdicts outcome is San Francisco 49ers Win.
View the full trade verdict
→ New England Patriots Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
New Orleans Saints acquired 2008 1st round pick (7th overall, Sedrick Ellis) and 2008 5th round pick (164th overall, Carl Nicks) from New England Patriots for 2008 1st round pick (10th overall, Jerod Mayo) and 2008 3rd round pick (78th overall, Shawn Crable). The overall result favors New England Patriots over New Orleans Saints.
Assets Received
- Pick 2008 1st round pick (7th overall, Sedrick Ellis)
- Pick 2008 5th round pick (164th overall, Carl Nicks)
- Pick 2008 1st round pick (10th overall, Jerod Mayo)
- Pick 2008 3rd round pick (78th overall, Shawn Crable)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports New England Patriots: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ New York Jets Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
New York Jets acquired John Abraham to Falcons. Broncos sent 2006 1st round pick (29th overall, Nick Mangold) from Atlanta Falcons Multi Team for John Abraham. New York Jets received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New York Jets Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick John Abraham to Falcons. Broncos sent 2006 1st round pick (29th overall, Nick Mangold)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports New York Jets: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Green Bay Packers Win
Tier: standard
Confidence: medium
Green Bay Packers acquired J.T. O'Sullivan and 2005 2nd round pick (51st overall, Nick Collins) from New Orleans Saints for Mike McKenzie and an undisclosed 2004 draft pick. Green Bay Packers received the stronger recorded football value, matching the Green Bay Packers Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick J.T. O'Sullivan and 2005 2nd round pick (51st overall, Nick Collins)
- Pick Mike McKenzie and an undisclosed 2004 draft pick
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports Green Bay Packers: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ New England Patriots Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
New England Patriots acquired 2003 5th round pick (164th overall, Dan Koppen), 2003 6th round pick (201st overall, Kliff Kingsbury) and 2003 7th round pick (243rd overall, Ethan Kelley) from Tennessee Titans for 2003 5th round pick (154th overall, Donnie Nickey) and 2003 7th round pick (225th overall, Todd Williams). New England Patriots received the stronger recorded football value, matching the New England Patriots Win verdict.
Assets Received
- Pick 2003 5th round pick (164th overall, Dan Koppen), 2003 6th round pick (201st overall, Kliff Kingsbury) and 2003 7th round pick (243rd overall, Ethan Kelley)
- Pick 2003 5th round pick (154th overall, Donnie Nickey)
- Pick 2003 7th round pick (225th overall, Todd Williams)
Trade Analysis
The grade spread supports New England Patriots: that side earned the higher mark because it produced the clearer recorded football value.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
New England Patriots acquired 2003 5th round pick (154th overall subsequently traded, Donnie Nickey) from Houston Texans for Greg Randall. The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 2003 5th round pick (154th overall subsequently traded, Donnie Nickey)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: standard
Confidence: medium
New Orleans Saints acquired 1997 4th round pick (116th overall, Keith Poole) and 1997 6th round pick (165th overall, Nick Savoie) from Tennessee Titans for 1997 4th round pick (107th overall, Pratt Lyons). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 1997 4th round pick (116th overall, Keith Poole)
- Pick 1997 6th round pick (165th overall, Nick Savoie)
- Pick 1997 4th round pick (107th overall, Pratt Lyons)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Atlanta Falcons acquired Chris Chandler from Tennessee Titans for 1997 4th round pick (98th overall, Derrick Mason); 1997 6th round pick (165th overall subsequently traded, Nick Savoie). Atlanta got Chris Chandler's Super Bowl-era value, while Tennessee turned the return into Derrick Mason value. Both sides can justify strong grades.
Assets Received
- Pick 1997 4th round pick (98th overall, Derrick Mason)
- Pick 1997 6th round pick (165th overall subsequently traded, Nick Savoie)
Trade Analysis
Atlanta got Chris Chandler's Super Bowl-era value, while Tennessee turned the return into Derrick Mason value. Both sides can justify strong grades. The final grades stay aligned with the neutral verdict rather than preserving conflicting source-perspective grades.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Seattle moved down from No. 43 to No. 51 in the 1991 draft and added a fourth-round pick, while the Raiders moved up for Nick Bell. John Kasay became useful value from the added pick, but the exchange still lands near neutral.
Assets Received
- Pick 1991 second round pick (#51-Doug Thomas (Savoy))
- Pick 1991 fourth round pick (#98-John Kasay)
- Pick 1991 second round pick (#43-Nick Bell)
Trade Analysis
This was a modest draft-capital exchange between Seattle and the Raiders. Seattle gained extra pick volume, while the Raiders moved up for a targeted second-round player. The long-term value does not create enough separation to force a winner.
View the full trade verdict
→ New England Patriots Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Washington received Ricky Smith (b) from New England Patriots for 1985 seventh round pick (#192-Nick Haden). The recorded outcome favors New England Patriots.
Assets Received
- Pick 1985 seventh round pick (#192-Nick Haden)
Trade Analysis
New England Patriots received 1985 seventh round pick (#192-Nick Haden), while Washington received Ricky Smith (b). The recorded outcomes support the existing C+/C grades and New England Patriots Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Las Vegas Raiders Win
Tier: landmark
Confidence: high
The Raiders acquired Hall of Fame cornerback Mike Haynes and a late pick from New England for a 1984 first-round pick and a 1985 second-round pick. Haynes immediately strengthened an elite roster, helped the Raiders win Super Bowl XVIII, made three more Pro Bowls, and reached Canton. New England's return became Brian Blados and Jim Bowman, which never approached Haynes' impact.
Assets Received
- Pick 1984 first round pick (#28-Brian Blados)
- Pick 1985 second round pick (#52-Jim Bowman (Edwin))
- Player Mike Haynes
- Pick 1985 seventh round pick (possibly #192-Nick Haden)
Trade Analysis
Why the Raiders Made the Trade
The Raiders made this move because Mike Haynes was a rare chance to add a Hall of Fame-level cornerback to a roster that was already built to win. This was not a speculative trade. Haynes had already proven he could play at an elite level, and the Raiders had a championship window ready for him.
That mattered because elite cornerback play is one of the hardest things to find. The Raiders were not buying an average veteran. They were adding a true difference-maker to a defense that could immediately use him against top passing games.
What New England Actually Received
New England received a 1984 first-round pick and a 1985 second-round pick. Those picks became Brian Blados and Jim Bowman. On paper, a first and a second is real compensation.
The problem is that the players selected did not come close to replacing Haynes. Draft value only matters if it turns into comparable football value. The Patriots moved a Hall of Fame defensive back and did not land anything near that level in return.
Why the Trade Still Favors the Raiders
The trade still favors the Raiders because Haynes gave them exactly what they were trying to buy. He helped Los Angeles win Super Bowl XVIII, made three more Pro Bowls, and remained part of the historical memory of one of the franchise's great defenses.
That is the difference between asset value and player value. New England received premium picks. The Raiders received the premium player. When the premium player helps win a Super Bowl and later reaches Canton, the verdict becomes clear.
The Championship Window Factor
This trade is a textbook championship-window move. The Raiders did not need to win an abstract draft-value chart. They needed to make an already dangerous team harder to beat.
Haynes did that. His arrival gave the secondary another elite piece and helped the Raiders maximize a roster that was ready right then. The timing made the price easier to justify, because the player directly contributed to the goal.
The Long-Term Legacy
New England's side aged poorly because the return became ordinary. The Patriots can defend the idea of getting a first and a second, but the final player outcomes did not match the Hall of Famer they gave away.
The Raiders' side aged cleanly. They acquired a star, won a Super Bowl with him, and added a Canton-level player to the franchise story. That is the kind of trade a contender hopes to make.
Why This Trade Still Matters
This trade still matters because it shows why contenders sometimes should prefer the known elite player over future picks. The Raiders paid real draft capital, but they bought immediate championship value.
It also belongs in the GSC priority group because the Mike Haynes trade connects Hall of Fame movement, Super Bowl impact, and a clean winner-loser verdict. It is one of the clearest Raiders trade wins.
Final Verdict This belongs as a clear Raiders win. The Raiders got the Hall of Fame player and the championship impact. Raiders grade: A. Patriots grade: D.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Minnesota Vikings acquired Nick Bebout from Seattle Seahawks for 1981 ninth round pick (#237-Jim Whatley). The available record does not show enough separation to call a clear long-term winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 1981 ninth round pick (#237-Jim Whatley)
Trade Analysis
This remains a low-separation transaction. The recorded value does not create enough distance to move either side above an Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received 1976 13th round pick (#367-Craig Crnick) and 1976 17th round pick (#478-Buddy Tate) from Indianapolis Colts for 1975 16th round pick (#416-Robert Smith (b)) and 1975 17th round pick (#440-Frank Russell). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 1976 13th round pick (#367-Craig Crnick)
- Pick 1976 17th round pick (#478-Buddy Tate)
- Pick 1975 16th round pick (#416-Robert Smith (b))
- Pick 1975 17th round pick (#440-Frank Russell)
Trade Analysis
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received 1976 13th round pick (#367-Craig Crnick) and 1976 17th round pick (#478-Buddy Tate), while Indianapolis Colts received 1975 16th round pick (#416-Robert Smith (b)) and 1975 17th round pick (#440-Frank Russell). The available outcome record supports the existing C/C grades and Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Cleveland Browns Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
New York Giants received undisclosed consideration, Ron Johnson (Adolphis), Wayne Meyland / Wayne Meylan and Jim Kanicki from Cleveland Browns for undisclosed consideration and Homer Jones. The recorded outcome favors Cleveland Browns.
Assets Received
- Player undisclosed consideration
- Player Ron Johnson (Adolphis)
- Player Wayne Meyland / Wayne Meylan
- Player Jim Kanicki
- Player undisclosed consideration
- Player Homer Jones
Trade Analysis
Cleveland Browns received undisclosed consideration and Homer Jones, while New York Giants received undisclosed consideration, Ron Johnson (Adolphis), Wayne Meyland / Wayne Meylan and Jim Kanicki. The recorded results support the existing C+/C grades and Cleveland Browns Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
San Francisco 49ers received Roosevelt Taylor / Rosey Taylor and 1971 fifth round pick (#114-Dean Shaternick) from Chicago Bears for Howard Mudd. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Assets Received
- Player Roosevelt Taylor / Rosey Taylor
- Pick 1971 fifth round pick (#114-Dean Shaternick)
Trade Analysis
San Francisco 49ers received Roosevelt Taylor / Rosey Taylor and 1971 fifth round pick (#114-Dean Shaternick), while Chicago Bears received Howard Mudd. The available outcome record supports the existing C/C grades and Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Miami Dolphins Win
Tier: major
Confidence: high
Miami Dolphins received Nick Buoniconti from New England Patriots for John Bramlett, Kim Hammond, and 1970 fifth round pick (#107-Bob Olson). The recorded outcome favors Miami Dolphins.
Assets Received
- Player John Bramlett
- Player Kim Hammond
- Pick 1970 fifth round pick (#107-Bob Olson)
Trade Analysis
Miami Dolphins received Nick Buoniconti, while New England Patriots received John Bramlett, Kim Hammond, and 1970 fifth round pick (#107-Bob Olson). The recorded outcomes support the existing A/D grades and Miami Dolphins Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: standard
Confidence: high
Miami Dolphins received Mike Hudock from New York Jets for Nick DeFelice. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Trade Analysis
Miami Dolphins received Mike Hudock, while New York Jets received Nick DeFelice. The available outcome record supports the existing C/C grades and Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received Arch Matsos / Archie Matsos from Buffalo Bills for Hank Rivera, Pete Nicklas and George Shirkey. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Assets Received
- Player Arch Matsos / Archie Matsos
- Player Hank Rivera
- Player Pete Nicklas
- Player George Shirkey
Trade Analysis
Oakland/Las Vegas Raiders received Arch Matsos / Archie Matsos, while Buffalo Bills received Hank Rivera, Pete Nicklas and George Shirkey. The available outcome record supports the existing C+/C+ grades and Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
Pittsburgh Steelers received Nick Feher from Los Angeles Rams for draft pick (undisclosed overall/player). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Assets Received
- Pick draft pick (undisclosed overall/player)
Trade Analysis
Pittsburgh Steelers received Nick Feher, while Los Angeles Rams received draft pick (undisclosed overall/player). The available outcome record supports the existing B-/B- grades and Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
Los Angeles Rams received Jim Cason / Jimmy Cason, Nick Feher and 1956 fifth round pick (#51-Jim Freeman) from San Francisco 49ers for Ed Beatty. The recorded outcome favors Los Angeles Rams.
Assets Received
- Player Jim Cason / Jimmy Cason
- Player Nick Feher
- Pick 1956 fifth round pick (#51-Jim Freeman)
Trade Analysis
Los Angeles Rams received Jim Cason / Jimmy Cason, Nick Feher and 1956 fifth round pick (#51-Jim Freeman), while San Francisco 49ers received Ed Beatty. The recorded results support the existing B/C+ grades and Los Angeles/Cleveland/St. Louis Rams Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: medium
Los Angeles Rams received 1954 undisclosed draft pick (possibly #43-Lester McClelland) from Pittsburgh Steelers for George Porter, Bill Hegarty, and Nick Bolkouac. The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Assets Received
- Pick 1954 undisclosed draft pick (possibly #43-Lester McClelland)
- Player George Porter
- Player Bill Hegarty
- Player Nick Bolkouac
Trade Analysis
Los Angeles Rams received 1954 undisclosed draft pick (possibly #43-Lester McClelland), while Pittsburgh Steelers received George Porter, Bill Hegarty, and Nick Bolkouac. The available outcome record supports the existing C/C grades and Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Even Trade
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Washington received Joe Moss from Los Angeles Rams for rights to Nick Bolkovac and 1953 sixth round pick (#64-Paul Miller). The recorded outcome does not show enough separation to identify a clear winner.
Assets Received
- Other rights to Nick Bolkovac
- Pick 1953 sixth round pick (#64-Paul Miller)
Trade Analysis
Washington received Joe Moss, while Los Angeles Rams received rights to Nick Bolkovac and 1953 sixth round pick (#64-Paul Miller). The available outcome record supports the existing C+/C+ grades and Even Trade verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ Green Bay Packers Win
Tier: minor
Confidence: high
Cleveland Browns received rights to Bob Gain and 1952 fourth round pick (#39-Elmer Costa) from Green Bay Packers for Dan Orlich, Bill Schroll / Chuck Schroll / Charley Schroll, Ace Loomis and Dominick Moselle / Dom Moselle. The recorded outcome favors Green Bay Packers.
Assets Received
- Other rights to Bob Gain
- Pick 1952 fourth round pick (#39-Elmer Costa)
- Player Dan Orlich
- Player Bill Schroll / Chuck Schroll / Charley Schroll
- Player Ace Loomis
- Player Dominick Moselle / Dom Moselle
Trade Analysis
Green Bay Packers received Dan Orlich, Bill Schroll / Chuck Schroll / Charley Schroll, Ace Loomis and Dominick Moselle / Dom Moselle, while Cleveland Browns received rights to Bob Gain and 1952 fourth round pick (#39-Elmer Costa). The recorded results support the existing B+/C+ grades and Green Bay Packers Win verdict.
View the full trade verdict
→ 