Trade Database

The Arizona Cardinals agreed to trade Marvin Harrison Jr. and a 2027 seventh-round draft pick to the Houston Texans on October 11, 2026. Arizona receives Houston's 2027 second-round and sixth-round picks. The trade reunites Harrison with former Ohio State quarterback C.J. Stroud while giving Arizona additional draft capital for a player who had just five receptions in four games this season.

Baltimore acquired two-time Pro Bowl center Cam Jurgens and a 2027 seventh-round pick from Philadelphia for a 2027 fifth-round pick and a 2028 second-round pick. The Ravens add a proven, versatile interior starter under contract through 2029, but the second-round price is substantial and makes this a win-now bet that Jurgens can stabilize the middle of the line.

Dallas acquired cornerback Joey Porter Jr. from Pittsburgh for a 2028 second-round pick and a 2027 sixth-round pick on September 30, 2026. The Cowboys add a starting-caliber outside corner to an injury-hit secondary, but they also inherit the contract question that helped drive the standoff in Pittsburgh. The Steelers turn a player who had not appeared in the first three games into a premium future pick plus extra Day 3 capital, giving Pittsburgh the stronger current-read value.

New York acquired quarterback J.J. McCarthy from Minnesota for a 2027 fifth-round pick on September 28, 2026. The Giants get a 23-year-old former No. 10 overall pick for a Day 3 selection, giving them inexpensive quarterback upside after injuries hit the position. Minnesota converts a displaced backup into future draft capital, but the current-read value edge goes to New York because a fifth-round pick is a modest price for a recent first-round quarterback with starting experience.

Indianapolis acquired center Sedrick Van Pran-Granger and Buffalo's 2027 seventh-round pick for the Colts' 2027 sixth-round selection. Van Pran-Granger arrived with 31 NFL appearances and two starts at age 24, giving Indianapolis experienced interior depth for a small move down the draft board. The cost is limited, while the Colts gain a young player who can compete for backup or starting work.

Atlanta acquired defensive tackle Gervon Dexter Sr. from Chicago for cornerback Clark Phillips III and a 2027 fifth-round pick. Dexter brought 49 games, 33 starts and 13.5 sacks into the final year of his rookie contract, giving the Falcons an established interior defender with immediate starting value. Atlanta paid a young reserve corner and Day 3 capital rather than an early draft choice.

Houston acquired offensive tackle Nathan Thomas from Dallas for a 2027 seventh-round pick on August 30, 2026. Thomas had already appeared in all 17 games in 2025 and made four starts, giving the Texans inexpensive swing-tackle experience for the cost of a late Day 3 selection. Houston gets the current-read edge because usable offensive-line depth is difficult to find this late in the preseason.

Green Bay sent quarterback Kyle McCord to Miami for a sixth-round selection in the 2028 NFL Draft. With Jordan Love established and other options competing behind him, the Packers turned surplus quarterback depth into a future asset rather than risk receiving nothing from a roster decision. The pick remains years from producing value, but Green Bay secured tangible compensation at a position where McCord was not needed to start.

San Francisco acquired interior offensive lineman Jarrett Patterson from Houston for a 2027 seventh-round pick on August 30, 2026. Patterson brought starting experience at center and guard at a moment when the 49ers were searching for interior depth. Houston recovered a late pick while reshaping its line, but San Francisco gets the current-read edge because a seventh is a small price for an experienced, versatile blocker.

Arizona acquired tight end Hunter Long and a 2028 seventh-round pick from Jacksonville on August 30, 2026 for a 2028 sixth-round selection, pending a physical. The Cardinals address an immediate tight-end need while Jacksonville moves up one round in a distant draft for a player near the back of its depth chart. With modest cost and modest return on both sides, the current verdict is even.

Seattle acquired rookie cornerback Avery Smith from the Chargers for a 2027 sixth-round pick on August 30, 2026, pending physicals. Smith was an undrafted rookie who impressed during the preseason and made Seattle’s initial roster, giving the Seahawks a young system fit at nickel and outside corner. The Chargers still win the first valuation because turning an undrafted rookie into a sixth-round pick before he plays a regular-season snap is exceptional asset conversion.

Carolina acquired defensive tackle TeRah Edwards from the Chargers for a 2028 sixth-round pick on August 30, 2026, pending physicals when the teams announced the deal. Edwards had not appeared in a regular-season game but produced a strong 2026 preseason and gave the Panthers another young interior defender. The price is meaningful for an unproven player, so Carolina gets credit for addressing depth while accepting real projection risk.

New England acquired Walter Rouse and Minnesota’s 2027 seventh-round pick for a 2027 sixth-round pick on August 30, 2026. Rouse, a 2024 sixth-rounder with eight NFL appearances, gives the Patriots tackle-guard depth after an injury weakened their reserve line. Minnesota improves its draft slot while moving surplus depth, but New England gets the slight edge because the pick downgrade buys a young, experienced lineman at a position of need.

Green Bay acquired running back Kaleb Johnson from Pittsburgh for a 2028 sixth-round pick on August 30, 2026, pending a physical. Johnson was the 83rd pick in the 2025 draft but had a limited rookie season, while Green Bay suddenly needed more backfield insurance. The Packers get a narrow current-read edge because they bought recent third-round pedigree and multiple years of team control for a future sixth.

The Jets acquired offensive lineman Jordan Meredith and a 2029 seventh-round pick from Las Vegas for a 2027 sixth-round pick on August 30, 2026. Meredith had starting experience and addressed a clear New York depth need, while the later seventh softens the cost. Las Vegas gets useful nearer-term draft capital, but the Jets earn the slight edge because they obtained a playable lineman without surrendering a premium asset.

Green Bay acquired tight end Mark Redman from the Rams for a 2028 seventh-round pick on August 30, 2026, pending a physical. Redman spent 2025 on Los Angeles’ practice squad and had not played a regular-season game, but Green Bay needed tight-end depth and liked his preseason. The Packers make a sensible low-cost roster bet; the Rams get the edge for turning likely surplus into a draft asset.

Arizona traded Corey Kiner to New England for a 2028 seventh-round pick. The Cardinals turned a crowded-backfield extra into future draft capital, which is reasonable roster management, but the return is still light for a 24-year-old runner who flashed throughout the preseason. Arizona gets something instead of risking a waiver loss, yet the stronger current value sits with New England.

The Giants acquired defensive lineman C.J. Okoye from Baltimore for a 2028 seventh-round pick, with the deal finalized during roster cutdowns. Okoye appeared in 13 games for the Ravens in 2025 and reunites with head coach John Harbaugh and defensive line coach Dennis Johnson. New York gets the current-read edge because a distant seventh is a small price for a young developmental lineman with real NFL snaps and direct scheme familiarity.

Baltimore sent undrafted rookie tackle Diego Pounds to Kansas City on August 29, 2026 and received a conditional Day 3 selection whose year depends on the Chiefs' available draft inventory. The Ravens turned a player who was not certain to make their final roster into future draft capital. The exact selection remains conditional, so Baltimore's return is valuable but not yet fully defined.

Miami traded quarterback Quinn Ewers to Jacksonville on August 29, 2026 for a sixth-round selection in the 2028 NFL Draft, pending a physical. Ewers had already made three rookie starts, giving Jacksonville inexpensive quarterback depth with actual regular-season experience. Miami converted a former seventh-round investment into a higher future pick while reshaping its quarterback room.

Dallas acquired offensive tackle Broderick Jones and a 2027 fourth-round pick from Pittsburgh on August 29, 2026. The Steelers received Dallas' 2027 third- and sixth-round selections. Jones gives Dallas a former first-round tackle with starting experience, while Pittsburgh moved a player who had slipped down its depth chart and improved its position in the future draft.

Miami’s slight edge vanished three days after the trade when the Dolphins waived Jarquez Hunter on August 30, while Tutu Atwell made the Rams’ initial 53-man roster. Miami sent Atwell to Los Angeles for Hunter and ended cutdown day without the player it acquired. The Rams reacquired a receiver they know and kept him, making Los Angeles the clear current-read winner before either side has played a regular-season game.

Kansas City acquired offensive lineman Joshua Ezeudu from the New York Giants on August 26, 2026 for a 2028 seventh-round pick. Ezeudu brings 33 games and 10 starts of NFL experience at guard, tackle and as an extra lineman, giving the Chiefs inexpensive versatility for a distant late-round selection. Kansas City gets the stronger current grade because the acquisition cost is minimal and the player can help immediately, while New York still deserves credit for converting a roster-bubble lineman into future draft capital.

San Francisco acquired linebacker Deion Jones from New Orleans for running back Zamir White in a late-August player-for-player exchange. The 49ers released Jones on August 30 before he made the initial 53-man roster, while New Orleans terminated White's contract the same day. No draft capital was reported in the swap, and neither acquiring club received regular-season roster value from the player it obtained.

Houston acquired Kayshon Boutte from New England on August 24, 2026 for safety Jaylen Reed and a 2028 seventh-round pick. The Texans moved quickly after Jayden Higgins suffered a season-ending ACL tear, adding a 24-year-old outside receiver who caught 33 passes for 551 yards and six touchdowns in 2025 and averaged 16.7 yards per reception.

The Giants traded veteran offensive lineman Daniel Faalele to Jacksonville on August 19, 2026 for the Jaguars' 2027 sixth-round pick. Faalele arrived with 66 regular-season appearances and 35 starts, including 34 consecutive starts at right guard over the prior two seasons. Jacksonville gets the slight early edge for buying experienced line help cheaply, but the unresolved 2027 pick keeps the grades close.

Miami acquired offensive lineman Caedan Wallace plus a 2029 seventh-round pick from New England for a 2028 sixth-round selection. The Dolphins bought a young tackle with starting experience at a modest future cost, but New England moved a player from a crowded line room and improved the timing and round of its draft capital.

Atlanta acquired tackle Wanya Morris and Kansas City's 2027 seventh-round pick on June 11, 2026, in exchange for Atlanta's 2027 sixth-rounder. Morris was competing for offensive-line depth but did not make the Falcons' initial 53-man roster after an injury-limited preseason. Kansas City therefore moved up a round in the 2027 draft while giving up a player Atlanta did not retain, creating a clear early edge.

New England acquired A.J. Brown from Philadelphia for a 2028 first-round pick and a 2027 fifth-round pick, adding an established No. 1 receiver to its offense. Brown had topped 1,000 receiving yards in each of his four Eagles seasons, including 1,003 in 2025. The Patriots paid a major future asset, but the immediate roster upgrade supports a B+ while Philadelphia receives a C+ for choosing long-term draft value.

Los Angeles acquired reigning Defensive Player of the Year Myles Garrett in June 2026, sending Cleveland young edge rusher Jared Verse plus first-, second- and third-round picks across the next three drafts. Garrett arrived after setting the NFL single-season sack record with 23 in 2025. The Rams get the present-day edge for landing the proven superstar, while Cleveland's enormous return keeps the long-term verdict open.

Atlanta moved down 12 spots in the fourth round of the 2026 draft, sending No. 122 to Las Vegas for No. 134 and No. 208. The Falcons used those selections on Oklahoma linebacker Kendal Daniels and Washington defensive tackle Anterio Thompson. Atlanta turned one fourth-round choice into two defensive prospects while remaining in the same round.

Buffalo moved down only one spot from No. 101 to No. 102 in the 2026 fourth round and received an additional 2027 seventh-round pick. The Bills selected Boston College lineman Jude Bowry at No. 102. By accepting minimal movement on the board, Buffalo gained a future asset without materially changing its draft position, an efficient exchange whose player outcomes remain unknown.

Buffalo Bills received two seventh-round rookies who both made Buffalo's initial 53-man roster: punter Tommy Doman at No. 239 and guard Ar'maj Reed-Adams at No. 241. The team earns a C, compared with C for Chicago Bears, and the hindsight verdict is Even Trade. That judgment reflects the concrete team-specific production, role and tenure created by the assets in this deal.

Carolina sent picks No. 124 and No. 166 to Chicago in the 2026 draft and received Nos. 129 and 144. The Panthers used the new selections on Will Lee and Sam Hecht, improving their fifth-round position by 22 spots while sliding only five places in the fourth. With the players still early in their careers, the exchange remains a balanced Day 3 reshuffling rather than a settled long-term result.

Denver moved up to No. 152 in the 2026 draft and selected NC State tight end Justin Joly. The Broncos sent Cleveland picks No. 170 and No. 182 to make the move. Joly gave Denver a targeted pass-catching prospect, but the deal required two later selections for one fifth-round choice and no regular-season results are available yet. The current C grade reflects a defensible bet rather than a proven win.

Carolina received Nos. 124 and 166 and subsequently moved both selections through later draft activity. The Panthers' side preserved more flexible capital and is supportable as the slightly stronger return, although the difference is modest. That outcome supports a B- grade within the Carolina Panthers Win verdict. The grade reflects realized football value rather than the size of the original package.

Jacksonville Jaguars received Josh Cameron at No. 191; the rookie made Jacksonville's roster and opened 2026 with two catches for 20 yards and a touchdown, plus a 23-yard kick return. The team earns a C, compared with C for New England Patriots, and the hindsight verdict is Even Trade. That judgment reflects the concrete team-specific production, role and tenure created by the assets in this deal.

Houston Texans received 2026 4th round pick (123rd overall, Wade Woodaz) and 2026 6th round pick (204th overall, Lewis Bond) in the 2026-04-25 exchange with Los Angeles Chargers. Wade Woodaz and Lewis Bond likewise remain at the beginning of their NFL careers, so Houston's return is still unresolved in performance terms. The direct package, rather than later movement of any acquired asset, is the basis for the hindsight judgment. Against what Houston Texans surrendered, the result supports Even Trade.

Minnesota sent New England the 234th pick in the 2026 draft plus a 2027 sixth-round choice to move up to No. 198 for running back Demond Claiborne. The Patriots used No. 234 on quarterback Behren Morton. Both rookies made their clubs' initial 53-man rosters, while the future sixth remains unresolved, making an even grade appropriate.

Las Vegas moved former No. 7 overall pick Tyree Wilson and seventh-round selection No. 219 to New Orleans for pick No. 150 in the 2026 draft. The Raiders immediately used No. 150 on defensive back Dalton Johnson, while the Saints selected T.J. Hall at No. 219 and added Wilson. Both sides exchanged uncertain future value, so the early result remains balanced.

Pittsburgh sent Kansas City picks No. 161 and No. 249 in the 2026 draft and received No. 169 plus No. 210. The Steelers used those incoming selections on Riley Nowakowski and Gabriel Rubio. Pittsburgh moved down eight spots in the fifth round to add a sixth-round choice, a reasonable two-for-two reshaping of late capital. With no regular-season results yet, the prior Steelers-win label is too early and an Even Trade fits better.

Los Angeles moved from No. 207 to No. 197 in the 2026 draft to select Miami receiver CJ Daniels, sending Philadelphia two seventh-round choices with its sixth-rounder. The Rams concentrated three opportunities into one preferred receiver. His professional career is too young to establish whether that concentration produced better value than the alternatives.

Cleveland received Seattle's 2027 fourth-round pick, while Seattle moved to No. 148 in the 2026 draft and selected Iowa guard Beau Stephens. Stephens' NFL career is only beginning, and Cleveland's acquired selection remains a future asset. With neither side yet holding a mature outcome, the trade is graded C/C and Even Trade.

Green Bay moved to No. 216 and selected kicker Trey Smack. By the end of the 2026 preseason, Smack had won the Packers' kicking job, giving Green Bay an immediate roster return from the trade. Because the regular season had not yet begun, the grade remains deliberately restrained, but current roster value favors the Packers over Seattle's two later selections.

Baltimore moved up to No. 133 for Matthew Hibner, giving up No. 154 and a 2027 sixth-round pick. Hibner made the Ravens' initial 53-man roster, which gives Baltimore a real developmental asset but not yet an established regular-season return. With the 2026 season only beginning, there is not enough completed NFL production to assign Baltimore a meaningful advantage.

Las Vegas moved down ten spots in the sixth round of the 2026 draft, sending No. 185 to Tampa Bay and receiving Nos. 195 and 229. The Raiders used those selections on wide receiver Malik Benson and defensive lineman Brandon Cleveland. Because both rookies are only beginning their NFL careers, the extra selection is attractive but the long-term value of the return remains unsettled.

Chicago moved down from No. 60 to No. 69 in the 2026 draft and added No. 144. The Bears selected Stanford tight end Sam Roush at No. 69, while the later fifth-round choice was subsequently moved. The trade let Chicago gain an additional asset while still landing a player it valued, but the regular-season results are not yet available.

Cleveland sent the No. 74 pick to New York on April 24, 2026 for Giants selections No. 105 and No. 145 plus a 2027 fourth-round choice. Cleveland then packaged Nos. 105 and 145 with its own No. 206 pick to move up to No. 86 for offensive tackle Austin Barber. The future fourth-rounder remains an additional Browns asset, so the trade cannot yet be judged solely by the players selected in 2026.

Buffalo moved from No. 66 to No. 62 in the 2026 draft, sending Denver the 66th pick and No. 182 to make the jump. The Bills used No. 62 on Ohio State cornerback Davison Igbinosun. That is a modest price for targeting a preferred second-round defender, but the rookie has not yet supplied regular-season evidence. Buffalo's C+ reflects a reasonable move whose long-term value remains unsettled.

Houston moved from No. 38 to No. 36 in the 2026 draft and selected Ohio State defensive tackle Kayden McDonald, while also receiving No. 117. Las Vegas dropped only two spots, still landed safety Treydan Stukes, and gained No. 91 for guard Trey Zuhn III. Before regular-season results exist, both teams can reasonably like the value they created.

Los Angeles moved down from No. 55 to No. 63 in the 2026 draft and added Nos. 131 and 202. Those selections became Jake Slaughter, Genesis Smith and Logan Taylor, while New England used No. 55 on Gabe Jacas. The Chargers gained three swings for one, but none of the players has completed an NFL regular season, leaving the long-term result appropriately even for now.

Cleveland moved up to No. 86 in the 2026 draft and selected Austin Barber, sending the Chargers Nos. 105, 145 and 206. Los Angeles used those picks on Brenen Thompson, Nick Barrett and Alex Harkey. The Browns concentrated three later selections into one third-round target, while the Chargers chose volume. With no completed NFL season from the class, an Even Trade remains the sound result.

Minnesota moved down two spots in the second round of the 2026 draft, sending Nos. 49 and 196 to Carolina for Nos. 51 and 159. The Panthers used No. 49 on Lee Hunter, while the Vikings selected Jake Golday at No. 51 and Max Bredeson at No. 159. Minnesota preserved access to a second-round target while improving from the sixth to the fifth round, supporting a B- versus Carolina's C.

Philadelphia acquired Jonathan Greenard and pick No. 244 from Minnesota for pick No. 98 and a 2027 third-round selection, then committed a major extension to the veteran edge defender. Greenard brought a Pro Bowl résumé but entered 2026 after an injury-limited 2025 season, and a pectoral issue later threatened his availability for the start of the season. The upside still supports a B for Philadelphia, while Minnesota's two third-round assets earn a C.

New York sent 2026 selections No. 105 and No. 145 plus a 2027 fourth-round pick to Cleveland for No. 74, then used the acquired third-round choice on Notre Dame receiver Malachi Fields. The Giants' official account dates the move to April 24. With Fields still early in his NFL career, New York's return is best understood as certainty on a targeted receiver rather than established professional production.

Detroit traded up from No. 50 to No. 44 in the 2026 second round and selected Michigan edge rusher Derrick Moore. The Lions paid No. 50 plus No. 128, a straightforward premium to secure a pass-rushing prospect they valued. Because Moore has not yet played a regular-season NFL game, Detroit's side is best judged as a reasonable targeted move rather than a proven win.

Pittsburgh moved from No. 53 to No. 47 in the 2026 second round and selected receiver Germie Bernard, also receiving pick No. 249. Indianapolis received Nos. 53, 135 and 237, using them on CJ Allen, Bryce Boettcher and Seth McGowan. The Steelers paid two later selections to secure their preferred receiver, while the Colts added volume without leaving the second round; that balance supports an Even Trade and C grades.

San Francisco exchanged picks fifty-eight and 152 for Cleveland's selections seventy and 107 in the 2026 draft. The 49ers selected Romello Height and Gracen Halton, while Cleveland used its second-round choice on Emmanuel McNeil-Warren. The transaction exchanged draft position for a stronger later selection. With little NFL history established, an even preliminary assessment is more defensible than a career-based winner.

Tampa Bay traded down seven spots in the third round on April 24, 2026, sending No. 77 to Green Bay for Nos. 84 and 160. The Buccaneers used No. 84 on wide receiver Ted Hurst III and No. 160 on guard Billy Schrauth. Hurst opened his rookie season as a starter and had five catches for 63 yards through Tampa Bay's first two games, while Schrauth had not yet recorded a regular-season appearance on the club's official stat page.

Houston moved from No. 28 to No. 26 in the 2026 first round, sending Buffalo picks 28, 69 and 167 for picks 26 and 91. The Texans used No. 26 on guard Keylan Rutledge, while Buffalo quickly moved No. 28 again and continued reshaping its draft capital. With the rookie class still awaiting regular-season results, neither side has earned a meaningful historical edge.

Buffalo moved down three spots from No. 28 to No. 31 in the 2026 first round and added pick 125, while New England climbed to No. 28 for Utah tackle Caleb Lomu. The Bills later moved No. 31 again and kept No. 125, using it on UConn receiver Skyler Bell. With both rookies still before their first regular season, the exchange remains appropriately even.

Buffalo and Tennessee swapped six 2026 draft choices when the Titans moved back into the first round for edge defender Keldric Faulk. Tennessee received Nos. 31, 69 and 165, while Buffalo received Nos. 35, 66 and 101. With no regular-season results yet from the rookies and several picks subsequently moved again, the fairest August 2026 judgment remains even and provisional.

Houston moved from No. 28 to No. 26 and also received No. 91, sending Buffalo picks 28, 69 and 167. The Texans used No. 26 on Keylan Rutledge, prioritizing a specific first-round target, while Buffalo accumulated extra Day 2 and Day 3 value. Houston gets the slight early edge only because it secured its preferred player; the broader draft-value exchange gave Buffalo several chances to outperform it.

Kansas City moved from No. 9 to No. 6 in the 2026 draft to select LSU cornerback Mansoor Delane, sending Cleveland picks 74 and 148 for the three-slot jump. Cleveland stayed in the top 10 and selected Utah tackle Spencer Fano at No. 9 while gaining two additional choices. Before the rookies have established NFL careers, the exchange remains balanced.

Dallas moved down three spots from No. 20 to No. 23 and added two fourth-round selections, No. 114 and No. 137, while sending Philadelphia a 2027 seventh. The Cowboys used the incoming choices on Malachi Lawrence, Devin Moore and LT Overton. Dallas increased its number of prospects without dropping far in the first round, creating a strong value case on draft night.

Cincinnati acquired three-time Pro Bowl defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence for the No. 10 pick and extended him, paying premium draft capital for an immediate centerpiece. New York turned an unhappy contract situation into a second top-ten selection in the 2026 draft. The Bengals received the proven difference-maker, while the Giants gained a major rebuilding asset. The early verdict leans Cincinnati but remains tied to the No. 10 pick's development.

On 2026-04-17, Atlanta Falcons received Maason Smith, while Jacksonville Jaguars received Ruke Orhorhoro. The hindsight verdict is Even Trade, with Atlanta Falcons graded C and Jacksonville Jaguars graded C. The evaluation credits only the consideration that can be traced confidently and keeps uncertain pick details out of the final judgment.

Philadelphia acquired Dontayvion Wicks from Green Bay for a 2026 fifth-round pick, No. 153 overall, and a 2027 sixth-round pick. Wicks arrived after producing 108 catches, 1,328 yards and 11 touchdowns over three Packers seasons, giving the Eagles another proven receiving option. The price was modest enough to support a B for Philadelphia, while Green Bay receives a C+ for turning depth into two selections.

Houston acquired Marte Mapu and a 2027 seventh-round pick from New England for a 2027 sixth-round pick. Mapu's Texans tenure is only beginning, and neither future selection has been used yet. That leaves both sides with identifiable but largely unrealized value. With the player sample and both draft branches still unresolved, Houston and New England each receive C+ and the trade is Even.

Atlanta acquired safety Sydney Brown plus picks No. 122 and No. 215 from Philadelphia, while the Eagles received Nos. 114 and 197. The earlier row duplicated Atlanta's return; the clean package is Brown, a fourth-round pick and a sixth-round pick for an earlier fourth and sixth. Atlanta gained a veteran while moving back eight spots in Round 4 and 18 spots in Round 6, supporting an Even Trade with C grades.

Carolina Panthers received a 2027 7th round pick, while Philadelphia Eagles received Andy Dalton. Carolina agreed on March 18, 2026 to send veteran quarterback Andy Dalton to Philadelphia for a 2027 seventh-round pick, with the transaction becoming official after Dalton completed his physical on March 24. Because the pick and Dalton's Eagles tenure remain unresolved, the long-term result is still open. That outcome supports a C+ grade for Carolina Panthers, a C+ for Philadelphia Eagles, and a Even Trade verdict.

Denver acquired Jaylen Waddle and the 111th pick in the 2026 draft from Miami for picks 30, 94 and 130. Waddle arrived as a proven field-stretching receiver with three 1,000-yard seasons in five years, giving the Broncos an immediate veteran weapon while Miami converted an established star into three selections across the first four rounds.

Kansas City acquired Justin Fields from the Jets for a 2027 sixth-round pick after New York moved in a different direction at quarterback. Fields had started nine games for the Jets in 2025, throwing for 1,259 yards with seven touchdowns and one interception while adding 383 rushing yards and four scores. For only a late future choice, the Chiefs gained experienced quarterback depth and earn a B; New York receives a C.

Indianapolis traded Michael Pittman Jr. and the No. 230 pick to Pittsburgh for No. 214. The Colts used No. 214 on Ohio State edge defender Caden Curry, who made the regular-season roster and appeared in each of Indianapolis' first three games.

Pittsburgh acquired Michael Pittman Jr. and the No. 230 selection for the No. 214 pick, moving back only sixteen draft slots to add a proven starting receiver. Indianapolis gained a modest upgrade in draft position and moved on from a veteran entering a new roster phase. The low acquisition cost gives Pittsburgh the early edge before Pittman has played a regular-season game for the Steelers.

Buffalo officially traded Taron Johnson and pick No. 228 to Las Vegas on March 11, 2026 for pick No. 182. The Bills later packaged No. 182 with No. 66 to move up four spots to No. 62, where they selected Ohio State cornerback Davison Igbinosun. Through two games, Igbinosun had seven tackles and one pass defended. Because Buffalo also spent No. 66, the rookie cannot be credited wholly to this trade, but No. 182 clearly helped fund the move.

New Orleans traded punter Kai Kroeger and its 2028 seventh-round pick to Houston for the Texans' 2028 sixth-round pick in March 2026. Kroeger had punted in all 17 Saints games as a rookie, averaging 44.8 yards with 18 punts inside the 20. New Orleans moved up one late round while Houston filled a specialist vacancy at a modest cost.

Las Vegas sent Geno Smith and pick No. 228 to New York for pick No. 208. The Raiders gained only a twenty-slot improvement from the seventh into the sixth round while moving on from a veteran quarterback after one season. The transaction helped reset the position and salary structure, but the draft return was limited compared with the established quarterback value New York acquired.

Dallas acquired edge rusher Rashan Gary from Green Bay for a 2027 fourth-round pick, a modest draft price for a veteran with 46.5 sacks over seven Packers seasons. Gary had 7.5 sacks and 20 quarterback hits in 2025 before the move. The Cowboys receive an A- for adding established pass-rush help without surrendering an early pick; Green Bay receives a C for accepting future mid-round value.

New York acquired Minkah Fitzpatrick from Miami for only the No. 238 pick and then committed to the veteran safety on a new multi-year contract. The Jets added a five-time Pro Bowler and three-time first-team All-Pro at a position of need for seventh-round cost. Miami gained a late selection and financial flexibility, but the known talent exchange strongly favors New York before the 2026 season.

Green Bay acquired veteran linebacker Zaire Franklin from Indianapolis in a straight player-for-player exchange for defensive lineman Colby Wooden. Franklin arrived with 132 games, 82 starts, a 2024 second-team All-Pro selection, and a Pro Bowl appearance, giving the Packers a proven middle-of-the-defense option. Wooden is younger and had become a starter, so the long-term result remains open, but Green Bay received the stronger established résumé at the time of the trade.

Chicago agreed on March 6, 2026 to send a 2027 fifth-round pick to New England for center Garrett Bradbury, a deal that became official with the new league year on March 11. The Bears moved quickly after Drew Dalman's retirement, adding a veteran who had started all 105 of his NFL games and every game of New England's 2025 run to Super Bowl LX.

Buffalo paid the No. 60 pick for D.J. Moore and Chicago's No. 165 selection, giving Josh Allen an established receiver while preserving a later draft asset. Chicago converted a veteran contract into a second-rounder. With Moore yet to play a regular-season game for Buffalo, the exchange remains balanced between immediate offensive help and meaningful young-cost-controlled capital.

Kansas City sent All-Pro cornerback Trent McDuffie to Los Angeles and received the No. 29 pick in the 2026 draft, 2026 fifth- and sixth-round picks, and a 2027 third-round choice. The first-rounder became Peter Woods, while the later 2026 picks were subsequently moved to Pittsburgh. The Chiefs obtained substantial draft capital, but no regular-season results from the new assets exist yet, so the current grade remains provisional.

Cleveland acquired veteran tackle Tytus Howard for the 2026 fifth-round pick Houston used at No. 141 on safety Kamari Ramsey. One regular-season game has been played since the trade: Howard started at right tackle for the Browns, while Ramsey appeared for Houston without a start and logged only a minimal defensive role. Both assets are active and the sample is far too small for settled hindsight, so this checkpoint is graded Even Trade at C-plus.

New York agreed to acquire defensive tackle T'Vondre Sweat from Tennessee on February 26, 2026, in exchange for edge rusher Jermaine Johnson, with the deal formally processed in March. Sweat brought two seasons of starting interior production to the Jets. Because the 2026 regular season has not begun, the football return remains unresolved and an even preliminary grade is most appropriate.

Baltimore acquired Dre'Mont Jones from Tennessee on November 4, 2025 for a conditional 2026 fifth-round pick that settled at No. 142 and became Fernando Carmona. Jones produced 2.5 sacks in nine Ravens games, giving Baltimore useful veteran pass-rush snaps without a premium cost. Tennessee converted a short-term veteran into a young draft asset.

Cincinnati traded linebacker Logan Wilson to Dallas on November 4, 2025, for a 2026 seventh-round pick that became No. 221 overall. The Bengals used it on tight end Jack Endries, who made Cincinnati's initial 53-man roster in 2026. Dallas received seven games and one start from Wilson before waiving him in February, giving Cincinnati a slight early value edge.

Chicago got eight games, 13 tackles and no sacks from Joe Tryon-Shoyinka in 2025, then used the acquired No. 239 pick with another seventh-rounder to move up for Jordan van den Berg, who made his 2026 debut in Week 1. Cleveland used No. 206 as one of three picks to move up for Austin Barber, now a rookie starter. Both draft branches are still too early for a stronger hindsight call, so C/C remains even.

Dallas made a deadline-level investment for Quinnen Williams, sending Mazi Smith, a 2026 second-round pick and the better of its two 2027 first-rounders to New York. Williams immediately became a centerpiece of the Cowboys' front and earned another Pro Bowl selection in 2025. The Jets accumulated major future capital, but the unresolved 2027 first keeps their ultimate return open.

Indianapolis acquired All-Pro cornerback Sauce Gardner from the Jets for wide receiver Adonai Mitchell and first-round picks in 2026 and 2027. Gardner played only three Colts games in 2025 before a calf strain ended his season, while New York used the 2026 choice at No. 16 on tight end Kenyon Sadiq. With the 2027 first still outstanding, the trade remains unfinished.

Jacksonville acquired Jakobi Meyers from Las Vegas at the 2025 deadline for 2026 fourth- and sixth-round picks. Meyers quickly became a reliable target, produced for a winning Jaguars stretch and then agreed to a long-term extension. The price was meaningful, but Jacksonville did not rent him for only a few games; it added an established receiver who became part of the club's continuing plan.

Los Angeles Chargers received Trevor Penning in the exchange with New Orleans Saints. Trevor Penning gave Los Angeles immediate offensive-line depth and starts after the 2025 trade, so the Chargers have already realized usable player value. Against New Orleans Saints' return of a 2027 6th round pick, that outcome supports a C+ grade. The transaction is judged as Even Trade, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Seattle acquired Rashid Shaheed at the 2025 deadline for 2026 fourth- and fifth-round picks. Shaheed immediately added explosive receiving and return value, scored major special-teams touchdowns during the stretch run and postseason, and helped Seattle win Super Bowl LX before re-signing. New Orleans converted the picks into Jeremiah Wright and Lorenzo Styles Jr., leaving useful future upside but less proven value so far.

Philadelphia acquired Jaire Alexander and a 2027 seventh-round pick from Baltimore for a 2026 sixth-rounder, but Alexander never played a snap for the Eagles after the trade and was placed on the Reserve/Retired list less than two weeks later. Baltimore still secured pick No. 211, later used on Ryan Eckley. Philadelphia later recovered money and cap credit, softening the damage, but the football return clearly favors the Ravens.

Philadelphia traded John Metchie III and a 2027 sixth-round pick to the Jets in October 2025 for cornerback Michael Carter II and a 2027 seventh-rounder. Metchie became an immediate receiving contributor in New York, while Carter gave Philadelphia secondary depth and remained with the Eagles. The Jets also improved their future draft position by one round.

Pittsburgh acquired veteran safety Kyle Dugger and a 2026 seventh-round pick from New England in October 2025 for a 2026 sixth-round pick. Dugger arrived with 81 career games, 69 starts, nine interceptions and extensive starting experience. The late-round pick swap narrowed the acquisition cost, making this a veteran-for-draft-position transaction rather than a pure player sale.

New England converted the acquired No. 198 pick into rookie quarterback Behren Morton at No. 234 plus a 2027 sixth-rounder, leaving that branch too early for a final grade. San Francisco got nine 2025 games, two starts and 1.5 sacks from Keion White, then another Week 1 start and fumble recovery in 2026. The conditional seventh reverted to New England. San Francisco keeps a narrow B- to C+ win.

The Rams acquired Roger McCreary and a 2026 sixth-round pick from Tennessee for a 2026 fifth-rounder. McCreary's Los Angeles tenure was interrupted almost immediately by injury and produced only a modest statistical return after he came back. Tennessee, meanwhile, improved its draft position from the sixth-round asset it sent to the fifth-round asset it received. The round upgrade gives the Titans the stronger outcome so far.

Jacksonville acquired Greg Newsome II and a 2026 sixth-round pick from Cleveland for Tyson Campbell and a 2026 seventh. Newsome recorded 29 tackles, six passes defensed and an interception in 12 Jaguars games. Campbell produced 53 tackles, 12 passes defensed, an interception touchdown and a forced fumble for Cleveland, while Jacksonville also improved the attached draft choice by one round.

Cincinnati received nine games and six starts from Joe Flacco in 2025, with 1,664 passing yards, 13 touchdowns and four interceptions. The acquired No. 199 pick later became one piece of a trade that yielded rookies Connor Lew and Colbie Young. Cleveland used No. 149 on linebacker Justin Jefferson, who made the 53-man roster but was inactive in Week 1. The Bengals lead B- to C.

Los Angeles acquired edge rusher Odafe Oweh and a 2027 seventh-round selection from Baltimore for safety Alohi Gilman and a 2026 fifth-round pick. Oweh produced 7.5 sacks in 12 games for the Chargers, supplying immediate pressure at a premium defensive position. Baltimore received Gilman and used pick No. 162 on Chandler Rivers, preserving two roster assets in the exchange.

Cleveland acquired tackle Cam Robinson and Houston's 2027 seventh-round pick on September 29, 2025 for a 2027 sixth-round pick. Robinson immediately filled an injury-created need and appeared in 13 games with 12 starts for the Browns, logging 696 offensive snaps and four Approximate Value. With the two draft choices still unresolved until 2027, Cleveland holds the current-read advantage because it already received a season of starting tackle play while moving down only one late round.

New Orleans acquired Ja'Lynn Polk and a 2028 seventh-round pick from New England for a 2027 sixth. Polk was already unavailable for the 2025 season because of a shoulder injury and never played a regular-season snap for the Saints; he was placed on the Reserve/Retired list in August 2026. New England therefore improved from a future seventh to a sixth while moving a player who produced no Saints on-field return.

Jacksonville sent Tank Bigsby to Philadelphia in September 2025 for a 2026 fifth-round pick and a 2026 sixth-round pick. The Eagles added a proven young runner and kick-return option behind Saquon Barkley, while the Jaguars converted a crowded backfield asset into two future selections that later carried identifiable draft value.

Green Bay acquired Micah Parsons from Dallas in August 2025 for Kenny Clark and first-round picks in 2026 and 2027. Parsons immediately recorded 12.5 sacks in 14 games for the Packers, giving Green Bay elite production from the centerpiece it targeted. Dallas received substantial veteran and draft value, but one future first remains unresolved and the 2026 choice was later moved again.

Minnesota brought Adam Thielen home along with a 2026 seventh-round pick and a 2027 fifth-rounder, while Carolina received a 2026 fifth and a 2027 fourth. Thielen produced only eight catches for 69 yards in 11 Vikings games before his Minnesota return ended. Carolina therefore converted an aging receiver into the two more valuable selections, creating a clear value advantage for the Panthers.

Cleveland received the 2026 fifth-round pick that became No. 141 for Kenny Pickett. The Browns later moved No. 141 again rather than selecting Kamari Ramsey, so Cleveland's return must be measured through that downstream transaction rather than Ramsey's career. Las Vegas acquired Pickett in August 2025, and both sides remain too recent for a stronger conclusion. The current result is C/C Even Trade.

Houston moved Austin Deculus to Los Angeles for a conditional 2027 seventh-round pick that ultimately conveyed. Deculus gave the Chargers 13 games and five starts in 2025, then departed for Tennessee in free agency. Houston now owns a real seventh-round asset, but its football outcome cannot be judged before the 2027 draft. With tangible but limited value on one side and unresolved future value on the other, the deal remains even for now.

New Orleans acquired offensive lineman Asim Richards and a 2028 seventh-round pick from Dallas on August 26, 2025, sending the Cowboys a 2028 sixth-round selection. Richards was a 2023 fifth-round pick who had appeared in 25 games with one start for Dallas. The Saints bought young line depth while moving down only one round in a draft three years away.

Los Angeles traded offensive tackle KT Leveston to Cleveland on August 26, 2025 for a 2028 seventh-round draft choice. Leveston, a 2024 seventh-round pick who had missed his entire rookie season on injured reserve, became useful line depth for the Browns and appeared in 16 regular-season games with seven starts in 2025.

Seattle traded offensive tackle Michael Jerrell to Atlanta on August 26, 2025, for a conditional seventh-round choice in the 2027 draft. The transaction gave Seattle a chance to recover future capital from a depth lineman, but the condition remains the defining uncertainty. Until the selection is finally realized, the Seahawks’ return is best treated as limited and provisional.

Indianapolis acquired Mekhi Blackmon from Minnesota for a 2026 sixth-round pick shortly before roster cuts, betting on a corner returning from a torn ACL. Blackmon responded by playing all 17 games, starting 11 and recording 64 tackles, seven passes defensed, two interceptions and a sack. Minnesota moved the sixth-rounder again, leaving the Colts with the clearly stronger direct football return.

Minnesota sent Sam Howell and a 2026 sixth-round pick to Philadelphia for a 2026 fifth and a 2027 seventh. Howell did not record a regular-season pass for the Eagles in 2025, serving as quarterback depth rather than creating measurable game production. Minnesota's fifth became pick No. 163, Charles Demmings, while the Vikings also retained the future seventh. The stronger draft position gives Minnesota the early advantage.

Green Bay acquired Darian Kinnard from Philadelphia for a 2027 sixth-round pick and immediately received useful offensive-line depth. Kinnard played all 17 regular-season games for the Packers in 2025 and started four. Philadelphia’s compensation remains a legitimate future asset, but the sixth-round pick has not yet been exercised. The Packers therefore hold the stronger realized value today, with the final margin still capable of changing.

San Francisco acquired Brian Robinson for a 2026 sixth-round pick and received immediate production in 2025. Robinson played all 17 games, carried 92 times for 400 yards and two touchdowns, then moved on to Atlanta for 2026. The 49ers received a useful one-season backfield return from a modest draft cost.

The Jets acquired defensive tackle Harrison Phillips and a 2027 seventh-round pick from Minnesota on August 21, 2025, sending the Vikings 2026 and 2027 sixth-round selections. Phillips then started all 17 games for New York and recorded 60 tackles, adding dependable interior snaps immediately. Minnesota gained two draft assets for a veteran it was prepared to move, but the Jets received the stronger proven return.

Cleveland's acquired No. 182 pick later joined Greg Newsome in the package for Tyson Campbell, who started 12 Browns games in 2025 and remained a starter in Week 1 of 2026. New York received 17 games, eight starts and four sacks from Jowon Briggs, then used No. 242 with another pick to move up for Anez Cooper. The Jets' direct production creates a narrow B- to C+ win.

Denver traded receiver Devaughn Vele to New Orleans for a 2026 fourth-round pick and a 2027 seventh-rounder. Vele caught 25 passes for 293 yards and two touchdowns in 13 games for the Saints in 2025, while Denver's fourth-round asset became pick No. 108 and Jonah Coleman. Turning a former seventh-round receiver into a fourth plus a future seventh gives Denver a B; New Orleans receives a C+.

Kansas City sent wide receiver Skyy Moore and a 2027 seventh-round pick to San Francisco for a 2027 sixth-round pick. The future selections remain unresolved, but the 49ers already received a full season of special-teams production from Moore, including 907 kickoff-return yards and 291 punt-return yards before he moved on in 2026.

Houston traded John Metchie III and a 2026 sixth-rounder to Philadelphia for Harrison Bryant and a 2026 fifth-rounder. The teams were effectively returning draft choices they had exchanged in an earlier deal. Houston improved its draft position and added an experienced tight end, while Philadelphia gained receiver depth and later recycled Metchie in the Michael Carter II trade.

Philadelphia acquired cornerback Jakorian Bennett from Las Vegas on August 4, 2025 in a straight player-for-player trade for defensive tackle Thomas Booker IV. Bennett appeared in 11 regular-season games with one start for the Eagles, recording seven tackles and one pass defensed. Booker became a much larger part of the Raiders' defense, playing all 17 games with 13 starts.

The Giants turned the rights to retired tight end Darren Waller, while also sending a conditional 2027 seventh-rounder, into Miami's 2026 sixth-round pick. That selection became No. 192 and New York used it on Illinois offensive lineman J.C. Davis. The deal created draft value from a player who had not played in 2024, although Davis remains too early in his career for a complete long-term judgment.

Pittsburgh acquired Jalen Ramsey, Jonnu Smith and a 2027 seventh-round pick from Miami for Minkah Fitzpatrick and a 2027 fifth. Ramsey immediately became a full-time defensive starter, while Smith’s Pittsburgh stay lasted only one season. Miami received 14 starts from Fitzpatrick before moving him again in 2026, leaving the still-unresolved 2027 pick swap as an important part of the final value.

Dallas acquired George Pickens and a 2027 sixth-round pick from Pittsburgh for a 2026 third-rounder and a 2027 fifth. Pickens immediately delivered 93 catches, 1,429 yards and nine touchdowns in 2025, earning Pro Bowl and second-team All-Pro recognition. Pittsburgh used the third-round choice, No. 76, on quarterback Drew Allar, leaving its long-term return dependent on a rookie passer and a future pick.

Arizona moved down from pick No. 152 to No. 174 and added No. 211, turning those selections into Denzel Burke and Hayden Conner. Dallas used No. 152 on Shemar James. James delivered 84 tackles in 14 games, but Burke countered with 48 tackles, 11 passes defensed and three interceptions while Conner added line depth. The extra contributor gives Arizona a narrow early edge.

Baltimore traded Nos. 136 and 183 to Tennessee in the 2025 draft for Nos. 141 and 178, turning the exchange into Carson Vinson and Bilhal Kone. The Ravens stayed in roughly the same portion of the board and added two developmental players. After one completed season, though, their pair has produced less realized value than Tennessee's Elic Ayomanor and Marcus Harris, putting Baltimore behind for now.

Buffalo moved back up to No. 109 in the 2025 fourth round to select Kentucky defensive tackle Deone Walker, sending Chicago Nos. 132 and 169. The Bills had previously sent No. 109 to the Bears in their larger Day 2 trade, then decided Walker was worth reacquiring the pick. Buffalo's return is one high-upside defensive lineman whose career remains in its early stages.

Denver moved down in the 2025 sixth round, sending pick 197 to Houston for picks 216 and 241. The Texans selected quarterback Graham Mertz at 197, while Denver chose punter Jeremy Crawshaw at 216 and tight end Caleb Lohner at 241. With only a limited professional sample available from these players, the exchange remains too young for a meaningful hindsight winner and is best graded evenly.

Detroit moved up from No. 182 to No. 171 in the 2025 draft by also sending pick No. 228 to New England. The Lions selected guard Miles Frazier, while the Patriots took kicker Andy Borregales at 182 and later recycled 228 into additional seventh-round capital. Borregales' record-setting 134-point rookie season gives New England the clear early edge.

Houston moved up with Miami on April 26, 2025, receiving No. 116, used on running back Woody Marks, and No. 224, used on defensive tackle Kyonte Hamilton. Miami received No. 179, used on Ollie Gordon II, plus Houston's 2026 third-rounder. Marks immediately delivered the strongest rookie production in the package, giving Houston the early edge.

Kansas City moved from picks No. 251 and No. 257 to No. 228 and selected Brashard Smith. Smith contributed 151 rushing yards and 172 receiving yards as a rookie. New England used No. 251 on long snapper Julian Ashby, who handled every regular-season game and all four postseason contests, while Kobee Minor supplied depth from No. 257. Both clubs found useful late-round roles, making the exchange remarkably balanced.

Los Angeles moved up for Oronde Gadsden II and received immediate offensive production. As a rookie, Gadsden caught 49 passes for 664 yards and three touchdowns in 15 games, including seven starts. That early contribution established meaningful value quickly and gives the Chargers a substantial advantage over Philadelphia's two acquired selections, whose players did not produce comparable Eagles regular-season impact.

Minnesota sent pick 142 to Seattle for quarterback Sam Howell and pick 172, then converted No. 172 into picks 201 and 202 for Kobe King and Gavin Bartholomew. Howell did not make the regular-season roster, but Minnesota later packaged him and a 2026 sixth to Philadelphia for 2026 fifth- and 2027 seventh-round picks. Seattle used 142 on Rylie Mills, leaving a modest Vikings edge.

Minnesota sent pick No. 172 to the Rams during the 2025 draft and received Nos. 201 and 202, selecting Kobe King and Gavin Bartholomew. Los Angeles used No. 172 on Chris Paul Jr., who did not make the Rams' regular-season roster. Both Vikings selections reached the NFL roster picture, giving Minnesota the stronger early return.

The Jets received pick No. 176 in the 2025 draft and a 2026 sixth-rounder from Baltimore for pick No. 186 and a 2026 fifth-rounder. New York used No. 176 on Tyler Baron, while Baltimore used No. 186 on Tyler Loop; the future selections later became part of additional draft movement. The exchange paired a ten-slot current move with a one-round future adjustment, supporting an Even Trade and matching C grades.

New York traded picks No. 145 and No. 207 to Philadelphia to move up to No. 130 in the 2025 fourth round, where it selected safety Malachi Moore. Moore quickly earned a substantial role and started regularly as a rookie. That early playing time gives the Jets the best realized value so far, though Philadelphia received two legitimate developmental prospects in return.

Kansas City moved from No. 164 to No. 156 in the 2025 fifth round and selected linebacker Jeffrey Bassa, giving Pittsburgh No. 164 and No. 226. Bassa played all 17 games as a rookie and recorded 15 combined tackles with a forced fumble. That is a useful first season, but Pittsburgh received two contributors and more defensive production from Yahya Black, so the early returns favor the Steelers.

Chicago received Luke Newman, who has appeared in 10 regular-season games through Week 1 of 2026, plus the 2026 No. 129 pick that later helped the Bears trade for Nos. 124 and 166. Los Angeles used No. 148 on Ty Hamilton, now at 15 games with no starts and 12 tackles. The Bears retain a narrow hindsight edge, B- to C+.

New England Patriots received Joshua Farmer at No. 137; he played 13 games with three starts as a rookie, making 15 tackles with a pass defensed and a fumble recovery before landing on injured reserve. The team earns a C+, compared with B- for Seattle Seahawks, and the hindsight verdict is Seattle Seahawks Win. That judgment reflects the concrete team-specific production, role and tenure created by the assets in this deal.

Cleveland received 2025 5th round pick (144th overall, Shedeur Sanders), while Seattle received 2025 5th round pick (166th overall, Tory Horton), 2025 6th round pick (192nd overall, Bryce Cabeldue). The hindsight grades are C for Cleveland and C for Seattle. The Even Trade verdict is grounded in the actual starts, production, tenure and downstream draft results produced by those assets.

Atlanta moved from pick No. 101 to No. 96 to select safety Xavier Watts, sending Philadelphia a 2026 fifth-rounder for the five-slot climb. Watts immediately started all 17 games and produced 91 tackles, 11 passes defensed, five interceptions and a fumble recovery. Philadelphia received two transferable draft assets and later moved both. The Falcons' exceptional rookie production from Watts makes the small move-up cost look highly efficient.

Buffalo jumped from No. 56 to No. 41 in the 2025 draft and came away with T.J. Sanders, while also receiving Nos. 72 and 240. The Bills used those additional selections on Landon Jackson and Kaden Prather. They paid Nos. 56, 62 and 109, making this a substantial consolidation of capital rather than a simple move up fifteen spots.

Carolina moved from pick No. 85 to No. 77 and selected edge defender Princely Umanmielen, sending New England No. 85 and No. 146. Umanmielen appeared in 16 games with 23 tackles and 1.5 sacks as a rookie. New England later moved No. 85 in another deal and used No. 146 on Bradyn Swinson, who had a limited rookie role. Neither side has created enough separation for a winner.

Carolina and Denver exchanged four 2025 draft selections apiece. The Panthers moved to No. 51 for Nic Scourton and also received Nos. 85, 122 and 208; Denver received Nos. 57, 74, 111 and 230. Scourton produced five sacks as a rookie, while Denver used and later moved its acquired capital in several ways. Carolina's immediate hit at a premium defensive position supports a B-, with Denver at C+.

Detroit moved from No. 60 to No. 57 in the 2025 second round and also received No. 230, sending Denver Nos. 60 and 130. The Lions selected Tate Ratledge, who started all 17 games at right guard as a rookie; Denver selected RJ Harvey, who produced 896 scrimmage yards and 12 total touchdowns. Both primary players delivered immediately, so the earlier wide grade gap is narrowed to an Even Trade with B grades.

Denver sent selections No. 111, No. 130 and No. 191 to Philadelphia for picks No. 101 and No. 134 in the 2025 draft. The Broncos selected Sai'vion Jones and Que Robinson, while Philadelphia drafted Ty Robinson and Myles Hinton and later moved No. 130. With each of those players still early in his NFL career, the long-term value remains unresolved.

Houston moved up from No. 58 to No. 48 in the 2025 second round for tackle Aireontae Ersery, sending Las Vegas picks 58 and 99. Ersery immediately started all 16 games he played as a rookie and both playoff games. The Raiders used No. 58 on receiver Jack Bech and No. 99 on tackle Charles Grant, giving both clubs useful young players.

Kansas City moved from No. 95 to No. 85 for cornerback Nohl Williams, sending New England the later third-round pick plus a 2026 fourth. Williams contributed immediately with 44 tackles, seven passes defensed and a sack. New England answered with Jared Wilson, who started 13 regular-season games and all four postseason contests as a rookie, while also retaining the extra fourth as trade capital. That combination gives the Patriots a narrow edge.

Minnesota moved from No. 97 to No. 102 in the 2025 third round and also moved from No. 187 to No. 142, selecting receiver Tai Felton while Houston selected cornerback Jaylin Smith. The two clubs essentially exchanged small pockets of draft position across two rounds. Neither side has created enough separation yet to justify more than an even verdict.

Seattle paid the No. 52 and No. 82 selections to move up to No. 35 for safety Nick Emmanwori. As a rookie, Emmanwori started 11 regular-season games, filled multiple defensive roles, made the PFWA All-Rookie Team and started throughout Seattle's Super Bowl LX run. That immediate high-level contribution gives the Seahawks the early advantage.

New York traded back into the first round on April 24, 2025, sending Houston picks No. 34 and No. 99 plus a 2026 third-round selection for No. 25. The Giants used No. 25 on quarterback Jaxson Dart. Through New York's first two games of 2026, Dart had started 14 of 16 career games, throwing for 2,522 yards and 18 touchdowns with five interceptions while adding 541 rushing yards and nine scores. The early return is substantial, but the trade is still young.

Atlanta traded back into the 2025 first round for James Pearce Jr. and pick 101, sending the Rams picks 46 and 242 plus its 2026 first-rounder. Pearce immediately justified much of the aggression with 10.5 rookie sacks, while Los Angeles turned the deal into Terrance Ferguson, Konata Mumpfield and the 13th pick in 2026. Both sides secured meaningful value.

Cleveland sent three late 2025 selections to Houston for pick No. 166 and a 2027 fifth-round choice. Houston's package eventually included the rights associated with Ollie Gordon, Jeremy Crawshaw and Luke Lachey, while Cleveland's 2025 pick was subsequently moved. The future fifth remains unresolved, preventing a definitive hindsight winner. With both clubs still holding plausible value paths, an even C+/C+ grade is the responsible call.

Jacksonville paid a premium to move from No. 5 to No. 2 in 2025 for two-way star Travis Hunter, also receiving Bhayshul Tuten and Rayuan Lane. Cleveland turned the move down into Mason Graham, Quinshon Judkins, Dylan Sampson and Jacksonville’s 2026 first-rounder, used on KC Concepcion. After one season, Cleveland has already produced more established NFL value, while Hunter’s ceiling keeps Jacksonville’s case very much alive.

Kansas City moved down one spot from No. 31 to No. 32 and added pick No. 164, selecting Josh Simmons at No. 32 while Philadelphia chose Jihaad Campbell at No. 31. Campbell started 10 games and played all 17 as a rookie; Simmons started all eight games he played. Both teams landed first-round contributors, but the Chiefs gained the extra fifth-round asset for almost no movement.

Dallas got four reserve appearances and 183 passing yards from Joe Milton in 2025 plus five games and three tackles from Jay Toia. New England converted No. 171 into Andy Borregales and another pick that became Julian Ashby and Kobee Minor. Borregales scored a Patriots-rookie-record 134 points, while Ashby handled all 17 regular-season games at long snapper. New England wins, B+ to C.

Minnesota acquired Jordan Mason and a 2025 sixth-round pick from San Francisco for a 2025 fifth-rounder and a 2026 sixth-rounder. Mason immediately supplied starting-caliber rushing production, while the 49ers turned the fifth-round slot into safety Marques Sigle and retained another future selection. Both teams found usable value, but Mason's 2025 workload gives Minnesota the modest edge.

Seattle traded Geno Smith to Las Vegas for the No. 92 pick in the 2025 draft and used it on quarterback Jalen Milroe. Through the 2025 season and the opening weeks of 2026, Milroe has appeared in only a small package role, so Seattle has not yet realized substantial on-field value from the pick.

Houston acquired guard Ed Ingram from Minnesota for a 2026 sixth-round pick after he had lost his Vikings starting job. Ingram rebounded to start 14 regular-season games and both Texans playoff games in 2025, then earned a three-year extension. Minnesota moved the acquired sixth-rounder in the Jordan Mason trade and later reacquired the same draft slot at additional cost, strengthening Houston's side.

San Francisco agreed on March 1, 2025 to send Deebo Samuel to Washington for a fifth-round pick, and both clubs list the completed transaction on March 12. Washington received 16 games, 12 starts and 802 scrimmage yards with six touchdowns in 2025. San Francisco's No. 147 pick, Jordan James, produced only limited rookie action.

Buffalo turned its return into rookie defensive back Jordan Hancock and a 2026 seventh-rounder that later helped produce another trade asset. Hancock has played 14 regular-season games through Week 1 of 2026 without a start. Dallas received seven 2025 starts from Kaiir Elam before waiving him and only one appearance from Ajani Cornelius. The Cowboys retain a narrow hindsight edge, C+ to C.

Houston acquired C.J. Gardner-Johnson and a 2026 sixth-round choice from Philadelphia for Kenyon Green and a 2026 fifth-round choice. Gardner-Johnson started the Texans' first three games and made 15 tackles before Houston released him. Green also failed to stick in Philadelphia, so neither veteran became a lasting centerpiece and the one-round draft-position difference keeps the return close.

New Orleans acquired veteran defensive tackle Davon Godchaux from New England in March 2025 for a 2026 seventh-round pick. That Saints choice became No. 224 overall, Robert Spears-Jennings, after New England later included the pick in another trade. The Saints added an experienced interior defender immediately, while the Patriots converted a veteran contract into usable future draft capital.

Cleveland acquired quarterback Kenny Pickett from Philadelphia for Dorian Thompson-Robinson and the 2025 fifth-round pick at No. 164. Pickett spent the 2025 offseason with the Browns before Cleveland traded him to Las Vegas for a 2026 fifth-rounder. Philadelphia gained both a quarterback option and draft capital, while Cleveland effectively rolled its investment forward, leaving the original deal close to even.

Washington acquired five-time Pro Bowl left tackle Laremy Tunsil and a 2025 fourth-round pick from Houston for a third, seventh, 2026 second and 2026 fourth. Tunsil immediately stabilized the left side, earning an 88.9 pass-blocking grade while allowing only a handful of pressures and later signing an extension. Houston received substantial draft capital, keeping the overall exchange close.

Pittsburgh acquired D.K. Metcalf and pick No. 185 from Seattle for picks No. 52 and No. 223 in the 2025 draft. Seattle's earlier row listed No. 52 twice; the clean return is one second-rounder and one seventh-rounder. Metcalf then produced 850 yards and six touchdowns in 15 games for Pittsburgh, giving the Steelers substantial immediate production alongside the sixth-round selection.

Houston acquired veteran receiver Christian Kirk from Jacksonville for a 2026 seventh-round pick. The price was minimal for an experienced target, and Kirk contributed to a Texans offense that needed veteran help around C.J. Stroud. Jacksonville gained cap flexibility and at least converted an expected departure into draft capital, but the realized football value favored Houston.

Chicago acquired Joe Thuney from Kansas City for a 2026 fourth-round pick and received exactly the kind of stabilizing veteran it wanted. Thuney started all 17 games in 2025, earned first-team All-Pro and Pro Bowl honors, won the inaugural NFL Protector of the Year award and helped the Bears win the NFC North. That immediate elite return supports a clear Chicago win.

Chicago acquired Jonah Jackson after his injury-shortened Rams season, while Los Angeles received the 2025 sixth-round pick that became No. 202. The Rams later combined No. 202 with No. 201 in a trade with Minnesota to reach No. 172 and select Chris Paul. Jackson's Bears tenure and the Rams' downstream draft return remain recent, leaving the deal evenly graded at C+ for both teams.

Carolina traded Jonathan Mingo and a 2025 seventh-round pick to Dallas for the Cowboys' 2025 fourth-round pick, later No. 114. Mingo produced only five catches for 46 yards in eight Dallas games in 2024 and one catch for 25 yards in 2025, while Carolina converted the premium pick into additional roster value. The production gap makes the Panthers the clear winner.

Detroit acquired Za'Darius Smith and a 2026 seventh-round pick from Cleveland at the 2024 deadline for 2025 fifth- and 2026 sixth-round selections. Smith gave a contender needed pass-rush help after Aidan Hutchinson's injury, while Cleveland converted a veteran into two future assets. Detroit gets the win for immediate competitive value, but Cleveland's return was meaningful enough to keep the grades close.

New Orleans sent Marshon Lattimore and a 2025 fifth-round pick to Washington for third-, fourth- and sixth-round selections. Those picks became Jonas Sanker, Quincy Riley and Devin Neal, and Sanker quickly emerged as a 16-game starting safety with two interceptions in 2025. Lattimore helped Washington during its 2024 NFC Championship run but played only 11 regular-season games for the Commanders through 2025. The younger, multi-player return now favors New Orleans.

Pittsburgh acquired Mike Williams from the Jets for a 2025 fifth-round pick, hoping a veteran deep threat could strengthen a playoff-bound offense. Williams caught nine passes for 132 yards and one touchdown in nine regular-season games, then added one 37-yard playoff catch. New York used the pick on linebacker Francisco Mauigoa, who started eight games as a rookie. The continuing rookie-contract value now gives the Jets the stronger return.

Pittsburgh acquired veteran edge rusher Preston Smith from Green Bay for a 2025 seventh-round pick. Smith recorded 13 tackles and two sacks in eight regular-season games while working behind T.J. Watt, Alex Highsmith and Nick Herbig, then was released in February 2025. That useful but brief depth contribution gives the Steelers only a narrow advantage.

Baltimore acquired veteran cornerback Tre'Davious White and a 2027 seventh-round pick from the Rams for a 2026 seventh-round pick. White appeared in seven regular-season games for the Ravens and provided experienced secondary depth without requiring meaningful draft capital. Los Angeles recovered a slightly earlier late-round selection for a player outside its plans, but Baltimore received the more useful immediate football value.

Arizona acquired edge rusher Baron Browning from Denver for a 2025 sixth-round pick. Browning immediately joined the Cardinals' rotation, recorded two sacks in eight games after the trade and later re-signed, then added 34 tackles, two sacks and an interception in 2025. Denver recovered a late selection, but Arizona received multiple seasons of usable defensive snaps for a modest price.

Carolina sent Diontae Johnson and a 2025 sixth-round pick to Baltimore for a 2025 fifth-round pick, effectively moving up a round while exiting a short-lived receiver relationship. Johnson caught only one pass for six yards as a Raven, was suspended after refusing to enter a game and was waived in December. The Panthers therefore gained the better draft position while Baltimore received almost no usable return.

Minnesota acquired Cam Robinson at midseason after Christian Darrisaw was injured and received the veteran tackle play it urgently needed during a 14-win season. Jacksonville ultimately secured a 2026 fourth-round pick, a respectable return for a player on an expiring contract. The Jaguars were compensated fairly, but Robinson's immediate role in stabilizing Minnesota's line gives the Vikings the modest edge.

Kansas City acquired edge rusher Josh Uche from New England for a future sixth-round pick, adding low-cost pass-rush depth for a championship run. Uche's role with the Chiefs remained limited, so the Patriots ultimately converted a player nearing free agency into draft capital without surrendering meaningful long-term production. The gap is small, but New England's retained asset gives it the better hindsight result.

Kansas City acquired DeAndre Hopkins from Tennessee for a conditional 2025 fifth-round pick that remained in the fifth round. Hopkins caught 41 passes for 437 yards and four touchdowns in 10 regular-season games with the Chiefs and contributed during another Super Bowl run. Tennessee recovered useful draft capital for a veteran, but Kansas City received meaningful contender-window production at an affordable cost.

Seattle acquired Ernest Jones IV for Jerome Baker and a 2025 fourth-round pick, then watched Jones become a defensive centerpiece. He earned second-team All-Pro honors in 2025, helped Seattle win Super Bowl LX and remained with the club on a new contract. Tennessee still produced useful value through Gunnar Helm, but Jones' impact makes this a clear Seahawks victory.

Buffalo acquired Amari Cooper and a 2025 sixth-round pick from Cleveland for a 2025 third and 2026 seventh. Cooper gave the Bills 20 catches, 297 yards and two touchdowns in nine regular-season games plus modest playoff production before leaving after the season. Cleveland used the third-rounder on quarterback Dillon Gabriel, who appeared in 10 games as a rookie. The lasting rookie-contract value now tilts this trade toward the Browns.

Minnesota reacquired running back Cam Akers from Houston on October 15, 2024, with a conditional 2026 seventh-round pick, sending a conditional 2026 sixth-rounder to the Texans. Akers played 12 regular-season games for Minnesota and rushed for 297 yards while providing needed backfield depth. With the eventual pick movement amounting to a one-round difference, the Vikings received the better practical return.

Las Vegas traded Davante Adams to New York on October 15, 2024 for a conditional 2025 third-round pick that stayed in the third round and became No. 92. The Raiders later sent No. 92 to Seattle for quarterback Geno Smith. Smith started 15 games for Las Vegas in 2025, throwing for 3,025 yards and 19 touchdowns with 17 interceptions. After that season, the Raiders traded Smith and No. 228 to the Jets for No. 208, leaving Las Vegas with one year of starting-quarterback production plus a small retained draft asset.

Seattle acquired defensive tackle Roy Robertson-Harris from Jacksonville in October 2024 for a 2026 sixth-round selection. The Seahawks added an established interior defender during the season without sacrificing premium draft capital. Robertson-Harris immediately strengthened a position of need, giving Seattle useful veteran snaps at a price low enough to make the acquisition efficient even without a long-term star outcome.

New Orleans acquired defensive tackle John Ridgeway and Washington's 2025 seventh-round pick for the Saints' 2025 sixth-round selection. Ridgeway supplied rotational interior-line snaps, while the Saints retained a late-round draft asset. Washington improved by one round in draft order. The exchange gave New Orleans immediate depth at a modest draft cost without surrendering premium capital.

The Chargers acquired Elijah Molden from Tennessee for a 2026 seventh-round pick and immediately received starter-level value. Molden started 12 games in 2024, intercepted three passes, recovered two fumbles and became part of the league's stingiest scoring defense before earning a multi-year extension. Tennessee gained late-round capital, but Los Angeles turned a minimal price into a durable secondary piece.

Atlanta Falcons received 2025 7th round pick (218th overall, Jack Nelson) from Los Angeles Chargers, sending Taylor Heinicke the other way. Heinicke supplied limited backup snaps and Nelson's early return is modest, so the trade is best treated as roughly even. That outcome supports a C+ grade for Atlanta Falcons, and the overall verdict is Even Trade.

Buffalo got 21 regular-season games of return-specialist work from Brandon Codrington, including 681 kick-return yards and 371 punt-return yards, but 2026 seventh-rounder Toriano Pride was released before playing a Bills game. New York converted No. 208 into Geno Smith plus No. 228 VJ Payne. Smith immediately started a 23-10 Week 1 win, throwing for 215 yards without a turnover. The Jets now lead B to C+.

Kansas City acquired edge rusher Cameron Thomas from Arizona for a 2025 seventh-round pick, with the league's transaction list recording the trade on August 27, 2024. Thomas appeared in only four games for the Chiefs, logged no defensive statistics and was waived in November. Arizona eventually held the selection used at No. 225, giving the Cardinals the stronger realized value from a small deal.

Kansas City acquired tight end Peyton Hendershot from Dallas for a conditional 2026 seventh-round pick, a low-risk depth move made during final roster cuts. The condition was reached and Dallas ultimately retained the draft asset, while Hendershot remained a limited-role player for the Chiefs. The difference is modest because the price was only a seventh-rounder, but Dallas converted a player it was prepared to move into usable capital.

The Rams sent Ernest Jones and a 2026 sixth-round pick to Tennessee for a 2026 fifth-round pick. Tennessee then turned Jones into another return less than two months later, receiving linebacker Jerome Baker and a 2025 fourth-round pick from Seattle. That second move transformed a small pick swap into additional veteran help and meaningful draft capital, making Tennessee the clear winner of the original exchange.

Green Bay acquired Malik Willis from Tennessee for a 2025 seventh-round pick, a modest cost that quickly paid off when Jordan Love was injured. Willis threw for 550 yards, three touchdowns and no interceptions with a 124.8 passer rating in 2024, then remained an efficient backup in 2025. Tennessee turned the pick into later draft movement, but the Packers received meaningful quarterback insurance at one of the league’s most valuable positions.

Seattle acquired edge defender Trevis Gipson from Jacksonville on August 26, 2024, for a 2025 sixth-round choice that became No. 194 overall. Gipson appeared in only five games for the Seahawks and logged a limited defensive role before the relationship ended. The brief return did not justify surrendering a draft asset that Jacksonville ultimately retained in the next draft.

Cleveland traded defensive tackle Chris Williams and a 2025 seventh-round pick to Chicago on August 24, 2024 for a 2025 sixth-round pick originally acquired from Miami. Williams played 31 regular-season games for the Bears across 2024-25, recording 37 tackles and four sacks. Chicago later used the seventh-rounder, No. 240, as part of its 2025 draft trade with Buffalo, giving the Bears both direct defensive production and retained draft capital.

Seattle traded edge rusher Darrell Taylor to Chicago on August 23, 2024, for a 2025 sixth-round choice that settled at No. 185 and was later moved again. The Seahawks recovered late-round capital from a player whose role was changing under a new staff. Because Seattle did not turn the pick itself into a major direct return, the value stays modest.

Cleveland traded kicker Cade York to Washington on August 22, 2024 for a conditional 2025 seventh-round pick. The condition required York to remain on Washington's 53-man roster for two games. He was released after Week 1, so the pick was not conveyed and Cleveland ultimately received no draft asset from the transaction.

Washington traded Jahan Dotson and a 2025 fifth-round pick to Philadelphia for a 2025 third-rounder and two 2025 seventh-rounders. Dotson helped the Eagles' championship run but remained a low-volume receiver, posting 216 regular-season yards in 2024 and 262 in 2025. Washington converted a player outside its plans into substantially stronger draft capital, giving the Commanders the long-term value edge.

Atlanta acquired Matthew Judon from New England for a 2025 third-round pick and received one season of veteran edge help. Judon recorded 5.5 sacks for the Falcons in 2024 before the sides separated. New England converted an aging player entering a contract dispute into a valuable Day 2 selection, while Atlanta received useful but short-term pass-rush production.

Dallas received veteran defensive tackle Jordan Phillips plus a separate 2026 seventh-round choice. Phillips provided immediate roster utility, and the extra selection preserved a small amount of future value. The package is properly represented as two assets rather than one combined pick label. That result supports a C+ grade within the Dallas Cowboys Win verdict.

Cleveland reacquired center Nick Harris from Seattle in August 2024 and also received a 2026 seventh-round pick, while the Seahawks received a 2026 sixth-rounder. Harris provided some short-term depth before injury, and the draft choices only recently resolved into later player and trade value. Neither side has produced enough separation to justify a winner, making an even C+/C+ the fairest current grade.

Minnesota and Dallas swapped former second-round cornerbacks Nahshon Wright and Andrew Booth Jr. during the 2024 preseason. Wright appeared in one regular-season game for the Vikings. Booth played seven games and made two starts for Dallas. The Cowboys received more immediate snaps, but neither player became a durable contributor for the acquiring club.

Los Angeles traded wide receiver Ben Skowronek and its 2026 seventh-round pick to Houston for the Texans' 2026 sixth-round pick on May 9, 2024. Houston waived Skowronek before the 2024 regular season, so the Rams moved a player they were reportedly prepared to release and improved their future draft position by one round without surrendering realized on-field production to the Texans.

Chicago traded its 2025 fourth-round pick to Buffalo during the 2024 draft to reacquire No. 144 and select edge defender Austin Booker. That future fourth became No. 109, which Buffalo used on defensive tackle Deone Walker. Both teams turned the exchange into young defensive contributors, but Walker's immediate starting role gives Buffalo a slight edge.

Denver acquired John Franklin-Myers from the Jets for a 2026 sixth-round pick and secured an established defensive-line starter at a bargain price. Franklin-Myers brought durability, interior-outside versatility and immediate pass-rush production to the Broncos, then remained productive into 2025. New York received future draft capital, but a late sixth-round return does not match the multi-season value Denver obtained from a proven defender.

Buffalo moved down five spots in the 2024 fifth round, sending No. 163 to Green Bay for Nos. 168 and 219. The Packers selected Jacob Monk, while Buffalo took edge rusher Javon Solomon and defensive back Daequan Hardy. Solomon has appeared in 31 games across his first two seasons and produced three sacks, giving the Bills the strongest realized return from the exchange.

Philadelphia moved from No. 155 to No. 164 in the 2024 fifth round and sent Indianapolis an additional sixth-round pick, then selected linebacker Jeremiah Trotter Jr. The Colts used their two choices on Jaylin Simpson and Micah Abraham. Trotter has appeared in every regular-season game through two years and contributed on defense and special teams, giving Philadelphia the clearest realized value.

Green Bay traded two later selections to the Jets to move up to No. 111 for safety Evan Williams. New York received Nos. 126 and 190, but Williams quickly became a substantial defensive contributor for the Packers, earning rookie recognition and continuing as a playmaking starter. The Jets gained extra chances, yet Green Bay converted the consolidated pick into the best realized player value.

Houston moved up four spots in the 2024 fourth round, sending No. 127 and a 2025 fifth-rounder to Philadelphia for No. 123. The Texans selected tight end Cade Stover; the Eagles selected running back Will Shipley at No. 127 and later linebacker Smael Mondon at No. 161. All three became roster contributors, giving Philadelphia a modest quantity advantage.

Detroit moved into the fourth round at No. 132 in 2024 and also received No. 210, selecting Sione Vaki and Christian Mahogany. The Lions paid Nos. 164 and 201 plus a 2025 fourth-round choice. Detroit converted later capital into two players who fit its physical roster identity, with Mahogany in particular developing into meaningful offensive-line value.

The Jets traded pick No. 171 to Philadelphia for Nos. 185 and 190, then selected Florida State quarterback Jordan Travis. Travis spent his rookie year rehabilitating a serious leg injury and retired in April 2025 after medical consultations, never appearing in an NFL game. The outcome is unfortunate rather than a scouting indictment, but New York received no on-field return from the selection acquired in the trade.

Atlanta traded up eight spots in the 2024 second round for defensive tackle Ruke Orhorhoro and also received a sixth-round pick used on Jase McClellan. Arizona moved down to No. 43 for cornerback Max Melton and added No. 79, which was later moved. Orhorhoro and Melton have both become useful defenders, leaving the exchange balanced two seasons later.

Carolina moved from No. 52 to No. 46 for Jonathon Brooks, sending Indianapolis two additional fifth-round picks at Nos. 142 and 155. Brooks entered the league recovering from an ACL tear and then tore the same ACL again in his third NFL game, sharply limiting the early return. The Colts collected three selections for six spots of movement, giving Indianapolis the stronger realized value so far.

Carolina traded the 65th pick to the Jets for Nos. 72 and 157, then selected Trevin Wallace and Chau Smith-Wade while New York used No. 65 on Malachi Corley. Wallace and Smith-Wade developed into regular defensive contributors, combining for substantial 2025 playing time and production, while Corley's Jets tenure never gained traction. The Panthers received two useful defenders from one traded selection, creating a clear value edge.

Indianapolis moved up three spots in the 2024 third round for tackle Matt Goncalves, sending Arizona the selections used on tight end Tip Reiman and receiver Tejhaun Palmer. Goncalves appeared in every game as a rookie and started seven times across both tackle spots. Arizona received two players from one pick, but Indianapolis has realized the stronger early value from the deal's most important selection.

Kansas City moved up one spot to No. 63 and added a sixth-round choice, turning the deal into Kingsley Suamataia and Kamal Hadden. San Francisco moved back to No. 64 for Renardo Green while also adding the No. 173 pick. Green became a full-time starter, while Suamataia developed into a starting guard. Both teams found meaningful value, leaving the exchange close to even.

Los Angeles moved up three spots in the 2024 second round for Ladd McConkey and also received fifth-round cornerback Tarheeb Still, while New England took Ja'Lynn Polk and Javon Baker. McConkey has produced 1,938 receiving yards and 13 touchdowns through two seasons, and Still has become a regular starter with four career interceptions. The Patriots’ two receivers have not approached that impact, making this a clear Chargers win.

New Orleans moved from No. 45 to No. 41 for Kool-Aid McKinstry, sending Green Bay additional selections at Nos. 168 and 190. McKinstry developed into a high-level Saints starter with 17 pass breakups and three interceptions in 2025. Green Bay selected Edgerrin Cooper at No. 45 and retained two extra draft opportunities, creating substantial value on both sides.

San Francisco moved from No. 94 to No. 86 in the 2024 third round and selected guard Dominick Puni, sending Philadelphia No. 94 and No. 132. Puni started immediately and became a dependable 49ers lineman. Philadelphia used No. 94 on edge defender Jalyx Hunt, whose 2025 breakout included 6.5 sacks and three interceptions, giving both clubs strong young starters from the swap.

Los Angeles paid Carolina a substantial package to move up for defensive tackle Braden Fiske at No. 39, sending the Panthers a 2024 second-rounder, a 2024 fifth-rounder and a 2025 second-rounder. Fiske has already produced 11.5 regular-season sacks in two years and became a full-time starter. Carolina received strong draft capital, but Fiske's performance has erased the case for a lopsided Panthers win.

Philadelphia moved from No. 50 to No. 40 by sending Washington picks No. 50, 53 and 161 for Nos. 40, 78 and 152. The Eagles selected Cooper DeJean, who became a Super Bowl playmaker and first-team All-Pro. Washington used No. 50 on Mike Sainristil and also added Ben Sinnott and Dominique Hampton, leaving both clubs with substantial young talent from the exchange.

Buffalo moved from No. 28 to No. 32 in the 2024 first round and added picks 95 and 221, while Kansas City moved up for Xavier Worthy and also received picks 133 and 248. Worthy became an immediate postseason weapon and Jaden Hicks developed into a useful safety. Buffalo later traded No. 32 again, so Xavier Legette was not a direct Bills return. Kansas City has clearly produced more value from this exchange.

Carolina moved from No. 33 to No. 32 for Xavier Legette and also received No. 200, used on Jaden Crumedy. Buffalo took Keon Coleman at No. 33 and Sedrick Van Pran-Granger at No. 141. Coleman has 960 receiving yards and eight touchdowns through two seasons, slightly outproducing Legette’s 860 yards and seven scores, while Van Pran-Granger has provided useful line depth and Crumedy was waived in 2025.

Dallas moved down from No. 24 to No. 29 in 2024 and added the 73rd pick, turning the deal into Tyler Guyton and Cooper Beebe. Detroit moved up for cornerback Terrion Arnold and also received a 2025 seventh-round pick. Beebe became an immediate starting center, while Guyton’s first two seasons were interrupted by penalties and injuries. Arnold has started when healthy, making the trade closer than the original grade spread suggests.

Minnesota moved from No. 23 to No. 17 in 2024 for edge rusher Dallas Turner, sending Jacksonville four selections. Turner developed from a rookie reserve into a 10-game starter with eight sacks and four forced fumbles in 2025. Jacksonville still owns the stronger return because No. 23 became Brian Thomas Jr., who posted a 1,282-yard Pro Bowl rookie season, while the additional Jaguars assets provided extra value around him.

Minnesota moved from No. 11 to No. 10 in 2024 for quarterback J.J. McCarthy and also received No. 203, used on kicker Will Reichard. New York drafted left tackle Olu Fashanu and moved the additional picks in later deals. Fashanu became a 17-game starter in 2025, while McCarthy’s first playing season produced 1,632 yards, 11 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. Reichard’s First-Team All-Pro season keeps Minnesota’s return competitive despite the quarterback uncertainty.

Denver acquired Zach Wilson and pick No. 256 from the Jets for pick No. 203, with the transaction formally recorded by the Broncos on April 23, 2024. Wilson spent the 2024 regular season as Denver's third quarterback and did not take a regular-season snap, while New York converted its former starter into a higher draft slot. The value difference is small, but the Jets captured the better return.

Cleveland traded tackle Leroy Watson IV to Tennessee on April 12, 2024 for the 227th pick in the draft. The Browns later used that seventh-round selection on South Dakota cornerback Myles Harden. Tennessee added familiar offensive-line depth, while Cleveland converted a reserve tackle into a young draft asset. The modest exchange still tilts toward the Browns, producing a C+ to C result.

Buffalo traded Stefon Diggs, the 2024 No. 189 pick and a 2025 fifth-round choice to Houston for Minnesota's 2025 second-round pick. That second-rounder became No. 56 overall and was one of three selections Buffalo sent to Chicago to move up for defensive tackle T.J. Sanders while also acquiring picks 72 and 240. The Bills therefore converted Diggs and two later picks into premium 2025 draft capital that helped reshape their defensive class.

Kansas City traded L'Jarius Sneed and pick No. 252 to Tennessee on March 29, 2024 for pick No. 221 and a 2025 third-round selection. The third-rounder became No. 66 Ashton Gillotte, who played all 17 games as a rookie and recorded 37 tackles, 1.5 sacks, a pass defended and an interception. Kansas City later included No. 221 in its larger 2024 first-round trade with Buffalo. Sneed's separate 2026 free-agent return to the Chiefs is not counted as trade compensation.

Philadelphia traded Haason Reddick to the Jets in March 2024 for a conditional 2026 selection. The conditions ultimately left the return as a third-round pick, No. 68 overall, which Philadelphia used on Miami tackle Markel Bell. Reddick’s prolonged Jets holdout and limited return to the field made the Eagles’ decision to secure valuable future capital look especially strong.

Pittsburgh acquired Justin Fields for a conditional 2025 sixth-round pick that remained a sixth and became No. 202 overall. Fields gave the Steelers a useful one-year bridge, going 4-2 in six starts and finishing 2024 with 1,106 passing yards, 289 rushing yards and 10 total touchdowns. Chicago later used the No. 202 pick to acquire guard Jonah Jackson from the Rams. Jackson started all 17 games for the 2025 Bears and remained a starter entering 2026, giving Chicago the stronger realized downstream return to date.

Minnesota acquired Houston's 2024 first-round pick at No. 23 plus No. 232, while Houston received Nos. 42 and 188 in 2024 plus Minnesota's 2025 second-rounder. The Texans turned No. 42 into starting corner Kamari Lassiter, while Minnesota later used No. 23 as the centerpiece of its move up for Dallas Turner and drafted Levi Drake Rodriguez at No. 232. Houston holds the early edge.

Pittsburgh sent Kenny Pickett and pick No. 120 to Philadelphia for No. 98 and two 2025 seventh-rounders. The Steelers used No. 98 on Payton Wilson, who has become a productive linebacker with 181 career tackles and two interceptions through 2025. Pickett served as Jalen Hurts’ backup on a Super Bowl champion and later brought Philadelphia Dorian Thompson-Robinson plus a fifth-round pick. Pittsburgh still leads, but the Eagles’ return deserves more credit.

Atlanta sent quarterback Desmond Ridder to Arizona for wide receiver Rondale Moore in a straight player-for-player swap. Moore suffered a season-ending knee injury before playing a regular-season snap for the Falcons, so Atlanta never received on-field production from its acquisition. Ridder failed to secure Arizona's backup job and later left the Cardinals' practice squad, leaving both original teams without meaningful regular-season value from the exchanged players.

Chicago Bears received Keenan Allen in the 2024-03-14 exchange, while San Diego/Los Angeles Chargers received 2024 4th round pick (110th overall subsequently traded, Javon Baker). Chicago acquired Keenan Allen and immediately added a proven receiving option. Allen gave the Bears direct veteran value from the trade, which is more than the Chargers ultimately realized from the original fourth-round asset in their own roster.

Buffalo traded Ryan Bates to Chicago for the 2024 fifth-round pick that became No. 144. The Bills did not select Austin Booker with it; they traded No. 144 back to Chicago for a 2025 fourth-round pick, which is the proper Buffalo return to trace. Bates played 19 Bears games across 2024-25 but made only two starts. Buffalo wins on preserved draft value and Chicago's limited offensive-line return.

The Giants acquired Brian Burns and pick No. 166 from Carolina for picks No. 39, No. 141 and a 2025 fifth-rounder, then signed Burns long term. Burns developed into a centerpiece, producing 16.5 sacks, 31 quarterback hits and 22 tackles for loss in 2025 while earning second-team All-Pro honors. Carolina received meaningful draft capital, but New York acquired elite performance and another useful pick.

Cincinnati traded running back Joe Mixon to Houston on March 13, 2024, for a seventh-round pick, No. 224 overall, that became safety Daijahn Anthony. Anthony has served primarily as a reserve and special-teams player. Mixon immediately topped 1,000 rushing yards for Houston and scored 12 total touchdowns in 2024, giving the Texans the substantially stronger early return.

Cleveland acquired Jerry Jeudy from Denver for fifth- and sixth-round selections in the 2024 draft. The Broncos later moved those picks, while Jeudy immediately delivered a Pro Bowl season for Cleveland with 90 receptions and 1,229 yards in 2024. Turning two Day 3 selections into a prime-age receiver with that level of production gives the Browns a decisive hindsight advantage.

Jacksonville Jaguars received Mac Jones in the 2024-03-13 exchange, while New England Patriots received 2024 6th round pick (193rd overall, Joe Milton). Jacksonville acquired Mac Jones as a low-cost quarterback addition and gave up a sixth-round pick. The move provided depth and a familiar player for the organization, but the price still became a concrete draft asset for New England.

The Jets acquired veteran tackle Morgan Moses and pick No. 134, used on Braelon Allen, while Baltimore received picks 113 and 218 for Devontez Walker and Devin Leary. Moses started 14 games for New York in 2024 and Allen supplied 482 yards from scrimmage as a rookie. Walker has flashed big-play ability, scoring four touchdowns on seven career catches through 2025, which improves Baltimore’s return but still leaves the Jets ahead.

Pittsburgh sent Diontae Johnson and pick No. 240 to Carolina for Donte Jackson and No. 178, which became Logan Lee. Jackson gave the Steelers immediate starting value and five interceptions in 2024, while Johnson caught 30 passes for 357 yards and three touchdowns in seven Panthers games before Carolina traded him again. The short Carolina stay and Jackson’s defensive production move this from an even trade to a Pittsburgh win.

Tampa Bay traded Carlton Davis plus 2024 and 2025 sixth-round picks to Detroit for No. 92, which became Jalen McMillan. Davis gave the Lions a strong one-year starting corner during their 15-win 2024 season before leaving in free agency. McMillan scored eight touchdowns as a rookie, then lost much of 2025 to injury. Both teams received exactly the kind of value they sought, making an even grade more appropriate now.

Buffalo acquired Rasul Douglas and a 2024 fifth-round pick from Green Bay for a 2024 third-round choice. Douglas made an immediate impact with four interceptions in nine regular-season games in 2023, then started 15 games in 2024 and helped another playoff run before leaving in free agency. Green Bay still received a useful young player in Ty'Ron Hopper, but Douglas gave Buffalo the stronger realized return.

Chicago acquired Montez Sweat for the 2024 second-round pick that became No. 40. Sweat produced 21.5 sacks in 42 regular-season games for the Bears from the trade through 2025 and signed a long-term extension. Washington later packaged No. 40 with two other picks to acquire Nos. 50, 53 and 161, so those three selections cannot be credited solely to the Sweat trade. Both sides created substantial value.

Cleveland Browns received 2025 6th round pick (204th overall subsequently traded, Ajani Cornelius) from Detroit Lions, giving up Donovan Peoples-Jones. The later draft trail identifies Cleveland's selection as No. 204 after another move. The return supports a B grade because the value directly tied to this deal fits that mark. The final verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Minnesota acquired Joshua Dobbs and a conditional 2024 seventh-round pick from Arizona for a sixth after Kirk Cousins tore his Achilles. Dobbs delivered two memorable comeback wins but finished his Vikings stint with 895 passing yards, five touchdowns and five interceptions before losing the job. The seventh-rounder became Michael Jurgens, who made three center starts in 2025. Arizona received a sixth-round asset. Minnesota still won, but the original A- grade was too generous.

Minnesota sent starting guard Ezra Cleveland to Jacksonville at the 2023 deadline for a 2024 sixth-round pick, which became tackle Walter Rouse at No. 177. Cleveland quickly became a Jaguars starter, re-signed in 2024 and started 36 regular-season games for Jacksonville through 2025. Rouse played eight games without a start over his first two Vikings seasons. Jacksonville obtained far more immediate and sustained value.

San Francisco 49ers received Chase Young. San Francisco received Chase Young, who immediately joined the pass rush during the club's run to Super Bowl LVIII. That result supports a B- for San Francisco 49ers. The overall comparison favors San Francisco 49ers, which produced the stronger realized return. The grade reflects the realized player service and draft value tied directly to this transaction, without assigning extra credit for outcomes that cannot be traced confidently to the exchanged assets.

Atlanta Falcons received Kentavius Street and Conditional 2025 7th round pick (not conveyed) in the exchange with Philadelphia Eagles. Kentavius Street gave Atlanta immediate defensive-line help after Grady Jarrett's season-ending injury. He started all five games he played for the Falcons in 2023, recording 14 tackles and one sack before a pectoral injury ended his season. In hindsight, that direct outcome supports a B- grade for Atlanta Falcons. The judgment focuses on what this transaction itself produced rather than unrelated later moves.

Seattle sent the Giants a 2024 second-round pick and 2025 fifth for Leonard Williams, then re-signed him after the season. Williams has become a defensive centerpiece, recording four sacks in 10 games after the trade, 11 sacks in 2024 and seven more in 2025. New York used the picks on safety Tyler Nubin and lineman Marcus Mbow, who have combined for 27 starts. Both sides did well, but Williams’ sustained impact now gives Seattle the edge.

Philadelphia acquired All-Pro safety Kevin Byard from Tennessee for Terrell Edmunds plus 2024 fifth- and sixth-round picks. Byard started 11 games including the playoffs, but the Eagles released him the following March. Tennessee converted the picks into Jarvis Brownlee Jr. and Jha'Quan Jackson while also receiving Edmunds, producing more continuing roster value than Philadelphia obtained from its short rental.

Kansas City reacquired Mecole Hardman from New York in October 2023, receiving the receiver and a 2025 seventh-round pick for a 2025 sixth-rounder. Hardman returned to a familiar offense and delivered the defining payoff months later, catching the overtime touchdown that won Super Bowl LVIII. For a one-round future-pick drop, the Chiefs bought a championship moment and clearly won the exchange.

Los Angeles sent Van Jefferson and a 2025 seventh-round pick to Atlanta for a 2025 sixth-round selection. Jefferson caught only 12 passes for 101 yards in 12 games with the Falcons and left after the season. The Rams cleared a crowded receiver rotation and improved their future draft position by a round, making the modest transaction a clean win for Los Angeles in hindsight.

Chicago traded Chase Claypool and its 2025 seventh-round pick to Miami on October 6, 2023 for the Dolphins' 2025 sixth-rounder. The sixth became No. 192, which the Bears later sent to Cleveland for defensive tackle Chris Williams and pick No. 240. Williams played 31 regular-season games for Chicago across 2024-25 with four sacks, while No. 240 later remained part of a larger 2025 draft trade with Buffalo. Chicago therefore recovered useful multi-year defensive value after moving on from Claypool.

San Francisco acquired Randy Gregory and Denver's 2024 seventh-round choice for the 49ers' 2024 sixth-round pick. Gregory supplied rotational pass-rush snaps during San Francisco's Super Bowl run, but the stint lasted only one season. Denver improved its draft position from the seventh to the sixth round while moving a player no longer central to its plans, giving the Broncos a small but durable value edge.

Los Angeles Chargers received 2025 6th round pick (181st overall; subsequently traded by Los Angeles) in the 2023-10-04 exchange with New England Patriots. Los Angeles moved on from an expensive cornerback situation and gained the better 2025 draft position, creating a modest practical benefit despite dead money. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Los Angeles Chargers surrendered, the result supports Los Angeles Chargers Win and a B- grade for Los Angeles Chargers.

Minnesota acquired Cam Akers from Los Angeles in September 2023 while swapping conditional 2026 late-round picks. Neither conditional pick ultimately conveyed, leaving the Vikings with Akers at no realized draft cost. He produced 138 rushing yards, 70 receiving yards and one touchdown in six games before an Achilles injury ended his season, making Minnesota the modest winner.

Buffalo received the 2025 sixth-round selection used on Dorian Strong. Strong appeared in four rookie games, made one start, and recorded 10 tackles, giving the Bills some direct defensive value. The return remains early in its development, but New York has already accumulated more total service from Boogie Basham and Korie Black, leaving Buffalo slightly behind in realized value.

Carolina acquired Ihmir Smith-Marsette and Kansas City's 2025 seventh-round pick for Carolina's own 2025 seventh-rounder. Smith-Marsette supplied immediate depth, return ability and some offensive touches during the 2023 season, while the eventual pick difference favored Kansas City only modestly. Because the Panthers received a usable player in addition to a late selection, Carolina produced the slightly better total return.

Denver acquired kicker Wil Lutz from New Orleans for a 2024 seventh-round pick that became No. 239, Josiah Ezirim. Lutz immediately stabilized the Broncos' kicking job and gave Denver dependable veteran production for a minimal draft cost. New Orleans recovered a late selection after moving on to Blake Grupe, but the pick carried far less realized value than the proven specialist Denver received.

Denver traded tight end Albert Okwuegbunam and a 2025 seventh-round pick to Philadelphia for the Eagles' 2025 sixth-round selection. Okwuegbunam played a limited role in Philadelphia, while the pick exchange eventually left Denver with the more valuable round of draft capital. Because neither side received a major player outcome, the deal is best viewed as a modest Denver win based on moving up a round while clearing a crowded depth chart.

Miami moved veteran guard Dan Feeney to Chicago for a 2024 sixth-round pick and turned that choice into wide receiver Malik Washington at No. 184. Washington produced 72 catches for 540 yards through his first two seasons while also becoming a significant return specialist. Feeney gave Chicago veteran line depth in 2023, but Miami converted a surplus player into a younger multi-year contributor.

Miami and Dallas swapped former high draft picks at cornerback, with Kelvin Joseph going to the Dolphins and Noah Igbinoghene to the Cowboys. Joseph appeared in four games for Miami before being waived in November 2023. Igbinoghene played five games for Dallas without a start and left after the season. Neither club found a durable solution, so the one-for-one reclamation swap produced no meaningful winner.

New England Patriots received 2025 7th round pick (217th overall subsequently traded, Jay Toia) from Tennessee Titans. New England received a 2025 seventh-round choice and later moved that selection in a separate package. The Patriots did not realize a comparable direct football return from this transaction itself. That outcome supports a C grade for New England Patriots. The final verdict is Tennessee Titans Win, based on the football value the club actually realized from the assets it controlled after the exchange.

Houston Texans received Kendrick Green in the exchange with Pittsburgh Steelers. Kendrick Green gave Houston 21 games and four starts, providing real but modest offensive-line value after the trade. Against Pittsburgh Steelers' return of 2025 6th round pick (202nd overall subsequently traded, Gavin Bartholomew), that outcome supports a C+ grade. The transaction is judged as Pittsburgh Steelers Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Kansas City acquired defensive tackle Neil Farrell from Las Vegas, but he appeared in only three 2023 games for the Chiefs and recorded one tackle before his tenure ended. The Chiefs therefore received very little realized defensive value from the veteran acquisition, leaving the sixth-round cost difficult to justify in hindsight.

Minnesota traded tackle Vederian Lowe to New England on August 28, 2023, for a 2024 sixth-round pick, No. 188. The Vikings later moved that selection as part of subsequent draft maneuvering; Jamal Hill was eventually chosen at No. 188 by another club. Lowe provided New England some tackle starts, but Minnesota's recovery of useful draft capital for a reserve gives the Vikings a slight edge.

Cleveland Browns received Dustin Hopkins from Los Angeles Chargers. Hopkins immediately became Cleveland's starting kicker and delivered a productive 2023 season, solving a position the Browns needed to stabilize. The A- grade reflects the direct value Cleveland Browns realized from the transaction, with the final Cleveland Browns Win call based on actual service and clearly traceable draft outcomes rather than projected value.

Cleveland Browns received Pierre Strong in the exchange with New England Patriots. Pierre Strong Jr. appeared in every Browns game in 2023 and 14 more in 2024, contributing as a runner, receiver, and returner. Against New England Patriots' return of Tyrone Wheatley Jr., that outcome supports a B grade. The transaction is judged as Cleveland Browns Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Los Angeles acquired Kevin Dotson plus Pittsburgh's 2024 fifth- and 2025 sixth-round picks for the Rams' 2024 fourth- and 2025 fifth-round choices. Dotson immediately became a starting guard, then re-signed on a three-year deal and started 45 regular-season games for Los Angeles from 2023 through 2025. Pittsburgh gained better draft positions, but the Rams found a high-level long-term starter at a manageable trade price.

Dallas sent a 2024 fourth-round pick to San Francisco for Trey Lance, hoping the former No. 3 selection could develop behind Dak Prescott. Lance attempted only 41 regular-season passes for Dallas before leaving, while San Francisco used pick No. 124 on safety Malik Mustapha. Mustapha has started 22 games, recorded 148 tackles and intercepted two passes through two seasons. The 49ers converted a discarded quarterback into a starting defender and won decisively.

Arizona traded reserve tackle Josh Jones and a 2024 seventh-round pick to Houston for a 2024 fifth-round selection. The Cardinals used No. 162 on tackle Christian Jones, improving their draft position while moving a veteran outside their long-term plans. Houston received immediate offensive-line depth from Josh Jones and also retained the seventh-round component of the exchange.

Arizona acquired quarterback Joshua Dobbs plus a 2024 seventh-round pick. Dobbs immediately started eight games for the Cardinals in 2023, throwing for 1,569 yards and eight touchdowns before Arizona later traded him. The seventh-round asset added retained transaction value. Even though Dobbs was a short-term solution, eight starts at quarterback provided meaningful immediate value and gave Arizona the stronger realized return.

New York acquired Isaiah Simmons from Arizona for a 2024 seventh-round pick after the Cardinals declined his fifth-year option. Simmons played all 17 games for the Giants in 2023, recording 50 tackles, a sack, a forced fumble and a pick-six, then re-signed for 2024. Arizona used the resulting No. 226 selection on Jaden Davis. The Giants received useful veteran snaps for a minimal draft cost.

Detroit Lions received Denzel Mims and conditional 2025 7th round pick from New York Jets (did not convey) in the 2023-07-19 exchange with New York Jets. Mims was waived before the regular season and played no regular-season game for Detroit, while the conditional seventh never conveyed. The realized value remains close enough to support an even result.

Detroit Lions received Riley Patterson in the 2023-05-25 exchange, while Jacksonville Jaguars received 2026 7th round pick (233rd overall, Zach Durfee). Detroit acquired kicker Riley Patterson and received immediate roster value from the move. The price was a conditional 2026 seventh-round choice, which later met its condition and became a real selection for Jacksonville.

Cleveland acquired Za'Darius Smith plus 2025 sixth- and seventh-round picks from Minnesota for fifth-round selections in 2024 and 2025. Smith produced 10.5 sacks across 25 Browns games, then Cleveland traded him to Detroit and recovered a 2025 fifth plus a 2026 sixth. Minnesota used the 2024 fifth in its move up for J.J. McCarthy and the 2025 fifth on Tyrion Ingram-Dawkins. Cleveland extracted the stronger overall return.

Buffalo moved down in the 2023 fifth round and came away with No. 150 Justin Shorter plus No. 215. Shorter spent his rookie year on injured reserve and did not become an immediate Bills regular, but the additional sixth-round asset preserved value and was moved again. The two-piece return offsets Washington's quicker on-field contribution enough to keep Buffalo near even.

Baltimore Ravens received 2023 7th round pick (229th overall, Andrew Vorhees). Baltimore used the 2023 No. 229 selection on Andrew Vorhees. After recovering from the knee injury that affected his draft position, Vorhees developed into a multi-season starter and made 17 starts in 2025. Vorhees developed into a materially more valuable original-team return than Watson's early Cleveland contribution, so Baltimore owns the stronger result. That outcome supports an A- grade for Baltimore Ravens.

Denver sent the 195th pick in the 2023 draft to New Orleans for tight end Adam Trautman and pick No. 257. The Saints used No. 195 on receiver A.T. Perry, while Denver selected center Alex Forsyth at 257. Trautman became a regular part of Denver's offense and Forsyth added line depth. Perry flashed receiving ability but had a shorter Saints tenure, giving Denver the broader practical return.

Houston moved from picks Nos. 174 and 259 to No. 167 and selected linebacker Henry To'oTo'o. He became a regular starter, reaching 35 starts and roughly 250 tackles through his first three seasons. The Rams used the acquired selections on Warren McClendon and Desjuan Johnson, who both supplied useful depth. Los Angeles received two contributors, but To'oTo'o's sustained starting role gives Houston the modest win.

Buffalo received No. 230 in 2023 plus a 2024 sixth-round selection. Nick Broeker did not create lasting Bills value, and the future sixth was later moved again before another club used it. Buffalo preserved draft capital in the exchange, but the direct return did not produce a contributor comparable to the player Houston selected after moving up.

Jacksonville received No. 227 in 2023 and a 2024 fourth-round pick. Raymond Vohasek did not create meaningful regular-season value, while Jordan Jefferson provided rotational defensive-line snaps for Jacksonville in 2024. The Jaguars therefore extracted some usable depth from the package, but not enough high-impact production to create clear separation from the reserve-quarterback value New Orleans received.

Kansas City exchanged the 178th pick in 2023 for Dallas' 2024 fifth-rounder, which became No. 159 and center Hunter Nourzad. Nourzad appeared in all 17 games as a rookie and made his first start in 2025, while Eric Scott never played a regular-season game for Dallas before being waived in 2024. The delayed pick produced the more durable return for Kansas City.

Kansas City moved up fifteen spots in the fourth round of the 2023 draft for defensive back Chamarri Conner, sending Minnesota pick No. 134 and a 2024 fifth-round choice. The Vikings selected Jay Ward at No. 134 and later moved the future pick. Conner has become the strongest individual contributor, while Minnesota received the larger asset package.

Minnesota moved up from No. 158 to No. 141 in the 2023 draft and selected defensive tackle Jaquelin Roy. Indianapolis received No. 158, used on Daniel Scott, and No. 211, used on Titus Leo. Roy produced regular-season snaps and sacks, while the Colts' two selections yielded limited early playing time, giving Minnesota the edge.

New Orleans moved up to pick No. 103 in the 2023 draft and selected guard Nick Saldiveri, sending Chicago picks No. 115 and No. 165. The Bears turned those selections into running back Roschon Johnson and cornerback Terell Smith. Both Chicago players supplied more sustained regular-season value than Saldiveri through the first three seasons, giving the Bears the stronger two-player return.

New England Patriots received 2023 4th round pick (112th overall, Chad Ryland) in the 2023-04-29 exchange with New York Jets. Chad Ryland lasted one season in New England, and his later work elsewhere does not add Patriots value. The direct package, rather than later movement of any acquired asset, is the basis for the hindsight judgment. Against what New England Patriots surrendered, the result supports New York Jets Win.

Philadelphia sent Houston a 2024 third-round pick for No. 105 in the 2023 draft and selected cornerback Kelee Ringo. Ringo played all 51 regular-season games over his first three seasons with eight starts, an interception and five passes defensed. Houston preserved the higher future draft asset, which became pick No. 86 before another trade. The direct exchange produced legitimate value for both sides and remains essentially even.

Detroit Lions received 2023 7th round pick (219th overall, Antoine Green); 2025 4th round pick (134th overall; subsequently traded by Detroit) in the 2023-04-29 exchange with Philadelphia Eagles. Antoine Green produced little offensive value, and the future fourth-round selection later moved again rather than becoming a comparable direct Lions contributor. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Detroit Lions surrendered, the result supports Philadelphia Eagles Win and a C+ grade for Detroit Lions.

Las Vegas moved up five spots to No. 104 and also received No. 203, selecting Jakorian Bennett and Amari Burney. Houston used No. 109 on Dylan Horton and later moved the No. 174 pick in another draft trade. Bennett started 11 games for the Raiders, while Horton developed into a regular rotational defender. Both teams extracted useful but non-premium value, making the exchange essentially balanced.

Las Vegas acquired pick No. 135 from New England and selected Aidan O'Connell, while the Patriots received picks Nos. 144 and 214 for Atonio Mafi and Ameer Speed. O'Connell made 17 starts over his first two seasons and threw for more than 3,900 career yards through 2025. New England's two players provided depth but less impact, giving the Raiders a modest win.

Las Vegas moved up to No. 170 and selected Christopher Smith II. Smith did not become a major starter, but he appeared in 36 Raiders games from 2023 through 2025 and supplied the longest sustained direct service produced by the deal. For a late-round exchange, three seasons of usable roster and secondary value gave Las Vegas the stronger realized return.

Los Angeles traded down four spots in the fifth round on April 29, 2023, sending No. 171 to Tampa Bay for Nos. 175 and 252. The Rams selected tight end Davis Allen at No. 175, and by early 2026 he had appeared in 49 games with 12 starts, 42 catches, 362 yards and four touchdowns. Los Angeles later used No. 252 as part of another trade-up, so both pieces of the return retained value.

Los Angeles traded pick No. 252 and a 2024 sixth-rounder to Buffalo on April 29, 2023 for pick No. 215. The Rams selected running back Zach Evans, who appeared in 10 regular-season games as a rookie, rushing nine times for 19 yards without a touchdown, and never played another regular-season game for Los Angeles. The move-up therefore produced only a brief reserve contribution.

Tampa Bay sent its 2024 fifth-round pick to Philadelphia on April 29, 2023 for the 2023 sixth-round selection at No. 191 and used that pick on Trey Palmer. Palmer gave the Buccaneers 32 regular-season games, 11 starts, 51 catches, 557 yards and four touchdowns over 2023-24 before Tampa Bay waived him in August 2025. Philadelphia later included the 2024 pick, No. 161, in a larger trade-up package with Washington.

Arizona moved from No. 33 to No. 41 in 2023, exchanged third-round positions and added Tennessee's 2024 third-rounder. The Titans selected Will Levis and Tyjae Spears; Arizona's return became BJ Ojulari, Garrett Williams and Isaiah Adams. Spears has been productive, but Levis did not establish himself as Tennessee's long-term quarterback, while Williams and Adams developed into regular Arizona starters. The broader return favors the Cardinals.

Atlanta moved up six spots for Matthew Bergeron, who became an immediate fixture at left guard and started 49 games over his first three seasons. Indianapolis turned the move down into Julius Brents and Adetomiwa Adebawore; Adebawore developed into a useful rotational defender, but Brents' Colts tenure was limited by injuries. Bergeron's steady starting value gives Atlanta the clearer return.

Denver acquired picks No. 63 and 183, selecting Marvin Mims Jr. and JL Skinner, while Detroit received No. 68 and a fifth-round pick later moved to Arizona. Mims became a two-time All-Pro returner in his first two seasons and added more than 1,200 receiving yards through 2025. Detroit's Hendon Hooker barely played before leaving the organization, giving Denver a clear win.

Detroit moved up to No. 96 for Brodric Martin and sent Arizona picks Nos. 122, 139 and 168. Martin appeared in only six games with one start over his first two active seasons. Arizona's return produced guard Jon Gaines II, quarterback Clayton Tune and linebacker Owen Pappoe, giving the Cardinals several roster contributors. The package was not spectacular, but it clearly outperformed Detroit's limited result.

Detroit moved up three spots for Brian Branch, who became one of the league's most productive young defensive backs. Green Bay moved down, added pick No. 159 for Dontayvion Wicks, then flipped No. 48 to Tampa Bay for the choices used on Jayden Reed and Karl Brooks. Branch is the best single player, but Green Bay created three productive contributors. Both sides earned an excellent return.

Chicago moved up for Tyrique Stevenson, who quickly became a starting cornerback and a substantial part of the Bears' secondary. His career is still developing, but the early return includes meaningful starting snaps and legitimate defensive value at a premium position. That makes Chicago's side productive, though not clearly superior to Jacksonville's two-player return while all three players remain relatively early in their careers.

Kansas City moved from No. 63 to No. 55 in 2023 for Rashee Rice and also received pick 194, used on Keondre Coburn. Rice has 156 catches for 1,797 yards and 14 touchdowns in 28 regular-season games and was a major contributor to the Chiefs’ Super Bowl LVIII run. Detroit received three picks and moved them again in later transactions, but Kansas City obtained the clear impact player from the exchange.

Kansas City moved up three spots in the 2023 third round for tackle Wanya Morris, sending Cincinnati pick No. 95 and a sixth-rounder. Morris supplied 16 starts across three Chiefs seasons, but the Bengals used No. 95 on safety Jordan Battle, who became a full-time starter and recorded four interceptions and 125 tackles in 2025. Cincinnati also received the extra pick, creating the stronger return.

Minnesota traded pick No. 87 to San Francisco in the 2023 draft for Nos. 102, 164 and 222. The Vikings selected Mekhi Blackmon, Jaren Hall and DeWayne McBride, while the 49ers used No. 87 on safety Ji'Ayir Brown. Brown became the most durable starter in the deal, reaching 31 starts and five interceptions through 2025. San Francisco therefore produced the stronger concentrated return.

The Giants traded picks No. 89 and No. 128 to the Rams on April 28, 2023, moving up to No. 73 for wide receiver Jalin Hyatt. Los Angeles used the return on defensive tackle Kobie Turner and quarterback Stetson Bennett. Hyatt produced limited receiving output through 2025, while Turner became a high-volume defensive starter, giving the Rams the best player and another draft asset.

Philadelphia sent pick No. 62 to Houston for Nos. 65, 188 and 230. Houston selected center Juice Scruggs, who made 20 starts over his first three seasons. Philadelphia used No. 65 on Tyler Steen and No. 188 on Tanner McKee; Steen became a 17-game starter in 2025 and McKee provided credible backup-quarterback play. Both teams found useful players, but Philadelphia's two enduring pieces create the stronger aggregate return.

Pittsburgh moved down from No. 80 to No. 93 and added pick No. 132, selecting Darnell Washington and Nick Herbig. Washington became a regular tight end, while Herbig produced 16 sacks and nine forced fumbles through his first three seasons. Carolina used No. 80 on DJ Johnson, whose defensive impact was far smaller. Turning one third-round slot into two contributors makes Pittsburgh the clear winner.

Las Vegas sent picks 38 and 141 to Indianapolis to move three spots for tight end Michael Mayer. Mayer has started 32 games and produced 83 catches for 788 yards and three touchdowns through three seasons, useful production but below the expectations attached to the move. Indianapolis immediately traded No. 38 again and later moved No. 141, multiplying its draft capital. The Colts’ flexibility and Mayer’s modest output give Indianapolis the better side.

Los Angeles sent picks No. 69 and No. 191 to Houston on April 28, 2023 for Nos. 73 and 161. The Rams then flipped No. 73 to New York for Nos. 89 and 128, selecting Kobie Turner and Stetson Bennett, while No. 161 became Nick Hampton. Turner had 24 sacks through Week 2 of 2026 and is the centerpiece of a strong Rams return.

The Rams traded pick No. 73 to the Giants for Nos. 89 and 128, then selected Kobie Turner and Stetson Bennett. Turner became the centerpiece of the deal, producing 24 sacks through his first three seasons and establishing himself as a starting defensive lineman. New York used No. 73 on Jalin Hyatt, whose early production remained limited. Turner's impact makes this a decisive Rams win.

Tampa Bay moved up two spots in the second round on April 28, 2023, sending picks No. 50 and No. 179 to Green Bay for No. 48. The Buccaneers selected North Dakota State guard Cody Mauch, who immediately became a full-time starter and started all 34 regular-season games over his first two NFL seasons before an injury-shortened 2025. Tampa Bay obtained a legitimate starting lineman, but Green Bay turned the trade-down into two productive players.

Houston paid a premium to move from No. 12 to No. 3 for Will Anderson Jr., sending Arizona additional 2023 and 2024 premium picks. Anderson has 30 sacks in three seasons, won 2023 Defensive Rookie of the Year, earned 2025 first-team All-Pro honors and received a major extension. Arizona converted its return into several young pieces, including Darius Robinson, but none has matched Anderson’s impact. Hindsight now favors Houston despite the original price.

Detroit moved down from No. 6 to No. 12 in 2023 and came away with Jahmyr Gibbs, Sam LaPorta and additional draft capital, while Arizona moved up for tackle Paris Johnson Jr. Gibbs has made three Pro Bowls, scored an NFL-record 49 touchdowns through three seasons and surpassed 5,000 scrimmage yards; LaPorta has 2,104 receiving yards and 20 touchdowns. Johnson has been a quality starting tackle, but Detroit’s two-star return is exceptional.

Jacksonville moved back one spot from No. 24 to No. 25 and collected picks No. 160 and No. 240 from the Giants. New York used No. 24 on cornerback Deonte Banks, while Jacksonville preserved first-round flexibility and added the selection used on safety Antonio Johnson. The Jaguars soon traded No. 25 again, so that later move should be judged separately. This direct exchange gave both teams what they wanted without an obvious loser.

Jacksonville sent the 25th pick in the 2023 draft to Buffalo for Nos. 27 and 130. Buffalo used No. 25 on tight end Dalton Kincaid, while Jacksonville selected tackle Anton Harrison at No. 27 and defensive lineman Tyler Lacy at No. 130. Kincaid and Harrison both became meaningful young starters, leaving a balanced value exchange with additional depth value flowing to Jacksonville.

Arizona moved down from No. 66, selected Michael Wilson at No. 94, and also received a future fifth-round pick. Wilson became a core Cardinals receiver, totaling 163 catches, 2,119 yards, and 14 touchdowns through 2025 before agreeing to a major extension in September 2026. His established offensive role gives Arizona the strongest realized value in the deal by a wide margin.

Philadelphia moved from No. 10 to No. 9 and selected Jalen Carter, while Chicago received the No. 10 pick used on Darnell Wright plus the 2024 fourth-round pick used on Tory Taylor. Carter became a disruptive interior cornerstone for the Eagles, and Wright developed into a high-end right tackle for the Bears. Both teams converted a one-slot draft move into premium long-term value.

Pittsburgh sent picks 17 and 120 to New England for No. 14, using the move up on tackle Broderick Jones. Jones has started 38 games through three seasons but missed the final six games of 2025 with injury. New England stayed in the first round and drafted Christian Gonzalez, a 2024 second-team All-Pro and 2025 Pro Bowler. The fourth-round asset was later moved, and Gonzalez’s elite cornerback play now gives New England a clear win.

The Jets acquired Aaron Rodgers plus 2023 first- and fifth-round picks, while Green Bay received picks that became Lukas Van Ness, Luke Musgrave, Anders Carlson and a 2024 second-rounder later moved for additional capital. Rodgers tore his Achilles four snaps into 2023, then went 5-12 in 2024 despite 3,897 yards and 28 touchdowns. Green Bay received multiple young contributors and moved on cleanly to Jordan Love, making this an overwhelming Packers win.

Pittsburgh acquired Allen Robinson and the 251st pick in 2023 from the Rams for No. 234. Robinson started all 17 games and caught 34 passes for 280 yards in his lone Steelers season, while No. 251 became Spencer Anderson, who developed into a useful lineman with 42 games and 11 starts through 2025. That combined return gives Pittsburgh the narrow hindsight edge.

Atlanta acquired former No. 3 pick Jeff Okudah from Detroit for a 2023 fifth-round choice. Okudah started nine games for the Falcons, recording 44 tackles and three passes defensed, but left after one season. Detroit gained pick No. 159 and moved on from a player outside its long-term plan while also creating roster and cap flexibility. Atlanta received a functional one-year starter, but Detroit's low-risk reset aged better.

Carolina Panthers received 2025 conditional seventh round pick (not conveyed), while San Francisco 49ers received Zane Gonzalez and 2025 conditional seventh round pick (not conveyed). Carolina sent kicker Zane Gonzalez to San Francisco in a conditional swap of 2025 seventh-round selections. Neither conditional pick was conveyed, and Gonzalez was placed on injured reserve and later released by San Francisco without appearing in a regular-season game for the club. That outcome supports a C grade for Carolina Panthers, a C for San Francisco 49ers, and a Even Trade verdict.

Cleveland acquired Elijah Moore and pick No. 74 from the Jets for pick No. 42 in March 2023. Moore gave the Browns two seasons of regular receiving work, and Cleveland used No. 74 on Cedric Tillman, who developed into another useful receiver. The Jets converted No. 42 into later value, but Cleveland's two-player production gives the Browns the stronger realized return.

Dallas acquired Brandin Cooks from Houston for a 2023 fifth-round pick and a 2024 sixth-rounder. Over two Cowboys seasons, Cooks caught 80 passes for 916 yards and 11 touchdowns in 26 games, including eight scores in 2023. He left for New Orleans in 2025, but Dallas still received useful veteran production for two late picks while Houston gained rebuilding flexibility.

Dallas acquired veteran cornerback Stephon Gilmore from Indianapolis for a 2023 fifth-round pick that became running back Evan Hull. Gilmore immediately started all 17 regular-season games for a 12-win Cowboys team, intercepted two passes and strengthened a secondary that needed veteran stability. Indianapolis received little lasting production from Hull, making the one-year Gilmore rental easily worth the modest price.

Las Vegas sent Darren Waller to the Giants for pick No. 100 and used the selection on Tre Tucker. Waller produced 552 receiving yards in his lone Giants season before retiring, while Tucker developed into a regular Raiders receiver with 123 catches, 1,566 yards and 10 touchdowns through 2025. Converting a veteran nearing the end of his career into a multi-year contributor gives Las Vegas the win.

Houston acquired veteran guard Shaq Mason and a 2023 seventh-round pick from Tampa Bay for the 179th selection. Mason immediately started all 17 games in 2023 and ultimately made 32 starts for the Texans across two seasons. Tampa Bay later sent pick No. 179 to Green Bay while moving up for Cody Mauch. The Buccaneers preserved draft value, but Mason's two seasons of starting play give Houston the win.

Atlanta acquired tight end Jonnu Smith from New England for a 2023 seventh-round pick. Smith responded with 50 receptions for 582 yards and three touchdowns in 2023, all career highs or near-career highs at the time, before Atlanta released him the next offseason. New England used No. 245 on Isaiah Bolden, who later appeared in 14 games without a start in 2024. One strong season for a seventh-rounder favors Atlanta.

Miami acquired Jalen Ramsey from the Rams for tight end Hunter Long and pick No. 77, used on edge rusher Byron Young. Ramsey started 27 games for Miami across 2023-24, intercepted five passes and extended his Pro Bowl streak before being traded again in 2025. Young has become a three-year Rams starter with 27.5 sacks, including 12 in 2025. The long-term pass-rush return now gives Los Angeles a slight edge.

Carolina sent Chicago D.J. Moore, the 2023 No. 9 pick, a 2023 second, a 2024 first and a 2025 second to move to No. 1 for Bryce Young. Young improved to 3,011 yards and 23 touchdowns in 2025, but Chicago’s return became Caleb Williams, Moore and additional premium players including Luther Burden III. Williams has 7,483 passing yards through two seasons. Carolina’s quarterback progress does not erase the enormous value gap.

The Jets sent Baltimore a 2024 seventh-round pick for veteran safety Chuck Clark. Clark tore his ACL before playing in 2023, but New York re-signed him and received 12 starts, 69 tackles, a sack and an interception in 2024. Baltimore used No. 228 on center Nick Samac and also gained cap space. The injury delayed New York's payoff, yet one starting season for a seventh-rounder still gives the Jets a slight edge.

Denver sent New Orleans a 2023 first-round pick and a 2024 second for the rights to hire Sean Payton, receiving Payton and a 2024 third in return. After an 8-9 debut, Payton led Denver to consecutive playoff berths, a 14-3 record, the 2025 AFC West title and an AFC Championship Game appearance. New Orleans used the first-rounder on Bryan Bresee and leveraged the second-rounder in another trade. Both sides gained value, but Denver’s franchise turnaround now wins.

Atlanta Falcons Atlanta received Buffalo's 2023 seventh-round pick. The Falcons later used No. 245 as a direct trade asset in the Jonnu Smith deal, converting modest draft capital into a useful veteran tight end. The supported hindsight grade is B-. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against Buffalo Bills, the final verdict is Atlanta Falcons Win.

Atlanta Falcons received Rashad Fenton in the 2022-11-01 exchange, while Kansas City Chiefs received conditional 2023 7th round pick (not conveyed). Atlanta acquired cornerback Rashad Fenton at the 2022 deadline. The Falcons agreed to a conditional 2023 seventh-round pick, but the condition was not met and the selection never conveyed, limiting the cost while also reflecting the deal’s modest impact.

Buffalo Bills received Nyheim Hines from Indianapolis, giving up Zack Moss and the 2023 fifth-round selection that became Will Mallory. Hines provided immediate return-game value, including two kickoff-return touchdowns in the 2022 playoffs, but his Buffalo tenure was interrupted before 2023. That useful but short contribution supports a C+ for Buffalo rather than a stronger long-term grade.

Denver sent Bradley Chubb and a 2025 fifth-round pick to Miami on November 1, 2022, for running back Chase Edmonds, a 2023 first-round pick, and a 2024 fourth-round pick. Miami acquired an established edge rusher and extended him shortly after the trade. Denver converted a player approaching a new contract into a veteran plus two draft assets. Chubb contributed when available, but injuries limited the continuity of Miami’s return.

Denver received edge defender Jacob Martin plus the future fifth-round selection that became Kris Abrams-Draine. Martin gave Denver a short rotational contribution before moving on, while Abrams-Draine developed into useful young secondary depth and earned starting opportunities. That combination gave the Broncos both immediate roster help and a later young contributor from the same package.

Jacksonville acquired suspended receiver Calvin Ridley from Atlanta in 2022 for conditional draft compensation that ultimately became a 2023 fifth-rounder and a 2024 third-rounder. Ridley returned in 2023 and gave the Jaguars a productive season, but he left in free agency after one year on the field. Atlanta converted an unavailable player into two picks, including Day 2 capital, giving the Falcons the stronger lasting value.

Miami acquired running back Jeff Wilson from San Francisco at the 2022 deadline for a 2023 fifth-round pick. Wilson immediately gave the Dolphins familiar, dependable backfield depth and stayed with the club beyond the initial season. San Francisco used the pick on cornerback Darrell Luter Jr., adding a younger, cost-controlled defender. Both teams received useful depth, but the 49ers get a narrow edge for converting a surplus veteran into a multi-year draft asset.

Minnesota acquired T.J. Hockenson plus two later picks from Detroit for a 2023 second and 2024 third. Hockenson became a central target, setting a Vikings tight end record with 95 catches and 960 yards in 2023 before a severe knee injury reduced his next two seasons. Detroit repeatedly moved the acquired picks, with the assets helping lead to Hendon Hooker and the 2024 move for Terrion Arnold. Minnesota still holds a narrow edge.

Pittsburgh traded Chase Claypool to Chicago for the Bears' 2023 second-round pick, which finished No. 32 overall and became Joey Porter Jr. Claypool played only 10 games for Chicago, catching 18 passes for 191 yards and one touchdown before the Bears traded him to Miami. Porter has started 41 games through three seasons with 31 passes defensed and three interceptions. The trade became a franchise-level win for Pittsburgh.

Pittsburgh acquired cornerback William Jackson III and a conditional 2025 seventh-round choice from Washington while sending back a conditional 2025 sixth-round choice. Jackson never appeared in a game for the Steelers because of a back injury and was released in March 2023. The playing-time conditions were not met, so neither conditional draft choice changed hands. Pittsburgh therefore received essentially no realized on-field value.

Baltimore acquired Roquan Smith from Chicago at the 2022 deadline for A.J. Klein, a 2023 second-round pick and a 2023 fifth-rounder. Smith quickly became the centerpiece of the Ravens defense and earned top-level honors after the move. Chicago used the premium pick on Gervon Dexter and added Noah Sewell, so the Bears recovered meaningful young talent, but Baltimore obtained the proven star and won the deal.

Kansas City acquired Kadarius Toney from the Giants for a 2023 compensatory third and sixth-round pick. Toney never became a dependable regular-season receiver, but his touchdown and Super Bowl-record 65-yard punt return were pivotal in the Chiefs' Super Bowl LVII victory. New York used the third-round asset to acquire Darren Waller and drafted Tre Hawkins with the sixth. Waller lasted one Giants season. The championship impact shifts the trade toward Kansas City.

Chicago traded veteran pass rusher Robert Quinn to Philadelphia on October 26, 2022 for a 2023 fourth-round pick that became No. 133 overall, Tyler Scott. Quinn was nearing the end of his Bears tenure, and Chicago converted him into a young receiver. Scott did not become an immediate star, but securing a fourth-round asset for a veteran who produced little after the trade gave the Bears the stronger transaction value.

Dallas Cowboys received Johnathan Hankins and 2024 7th round pick (233rd overall, Nathan Thomas). Dallas added veteran defensive tackle Johnathan Hankins for immediate interior-line help and also received a future seventh-round choice. Hankins was the only established NFL player in the package when the deal was made. Dallas obtained the more useful mix of present and future value, so the existing Cowboys advantage remains the best fit. That outcome supports a B+ grade for Dallas Cowboys.

Jacksonville Jaguars traded James Robinson to the New York Jets for a conditional 2023 pick that remained a sixth-rounder and became No. 185, Parker Washington. Robinson's Jets stint lasted only four games, while Washington developed into a useful Jacksonville receiver and return contributor. Turning a departing running back into a productive draft outcome gives the Jaguars an A- and the clear win.

San Francisco's trade for Christian McCaffrey became one of the clearest modern examples of a running back being worth the price. The 49ers paid a strong draft-pick package, but McCaffrey immediately became the engine of Kyle Shanahan's offense. Carolina received volume, yet San Francisco acquired the player who changed its ceiling. The deal worked because the player, coach, scheme, and roster timeline all matched.

Carolina traded Robbie Anderson to Arizona in October 2022 for a 2024 sixth-round pick and a 2025 seventh-rounder. The move ended an unhappy Panthers relationship while recovering two future assets and clearing the receiver from the roster. Anderson produced little for Arizona before the Cardinals moved on, so even modest late-round compensation became meaningful. Carolina won by extracting value from a player it was already prepared to separate from.

Cleveland acquired linebacker Deion Jones and a 2024 seventh-round pick from Atlanta for a 2024 sixth. Jones played 11 games with five starts in 2022, recording 44 tackles, 2.5 sacks, an interception and a forced fumble while injuries hit Cleveland's linebacker room. Atlanta used pick No. 197 on Zion Logue, who was waived before the 2024 regular season. Cleveland received the more useful football return, though the stakes were modest.

Las Vegas received tackle Justin Herron and the future seventh-round pick that became Trey Taylor. Herron appeared in seven Raiders games with one start, while Taylor later supplied special-teams depth in nine regular-season games. Neither asset became a major piece, but the Raiders converted the exchange into two modest forms of usable roster value and therefore hold a slight edge.

Minnesota acquired Jalen Reagor from Philadelphia for a 2023 seventh-round pick and a conditional 2024 fourth that became a fifth. Reagor caught only eight passes for 104 yards in his lone Vikings season and was waived the following summer. Philadelphia did not keep the two picks through their final selections, but converting a player buried on the depth chart into future draft capital was still useful. The Eagles won by selling before Reagor's value disappeared.

Denver traded linebacker Malik Reed and a 2023 seventh-round pick to Pittsburgh for a 2023 sixth-round selection. The Steelers used the seventh on Cory Trice, while Denver's incoming sixth later moved through another deal and became tied to A.T. Perry. Reed spent one season in Pittsburgh and did not become a long-term starter there. Denver's ability to turn a departing depth defender into the higher draft asset gives the Broncos a slight edge.

Minnesota acquired defensive lineman Ross Blacklock and a 2023 seventh-round pick from Houston on August 30, 2022, sending a 2023 sixth-round selection in return. Blacklock played one season for the Vikings before being released. Houston’s acquired pick became No. 201, Jarrett Patterson, while Minnesota later moved the seventh-rounder in another trade.

Minnesota traded Jesse Davis to Pittsburgh after rookie Ed Ingram won the Vikings' right-guard job, receiving a conditional seventh-round pick. Davis appeared in 14 games for the Steelers in 2022 but did not start, serving primarily as experienced depth. The condition attached to the pick did not produce meaningful value for Minnesota in the locked record. Pittsburgh therefore gets a narrow win for obtaining usable veteran depth at essentially no realized draft cost.

Philadelphia acquired C.J. Gardner-Johnson and a seventh-round pick for fifth- and sixth-round selections. Gardner-Johnson tied for the league lead with six interceptions despite missing time and helped the Eagles reach Super Bowl LVII. New Orleans recovered limited draft value while surrendering a versatile defender at the start of his prime.

Arizona Cardinals received Trayvon Mullen in the 2022-08-30 exchange involving Las Vegas/Oakland Raiders. Mullen appeared in eight games for Arizona before the club waived him in December, so the Cardinals received only a short stretch of depth from the acquisition. That realized return supports a D+ grade for Arizona Cardinals. The overall verdict is Las Vegas Raiders Win, with the grade based on direct value created from this transaction.

Indianapolis acquired linebacker Grant Stuard and a 2023 seventh-round pick from Tampa Bay for a 2023 sixth-rounder. The Buccaneers used the sixth on defensive back Josh Hayes, while the Colts' seventh became Jake Witt. Stuard developed into a valuable special-teams player who also handled defensive starts, and Hayes supplied Tampa Bay with special-teams and secondary depth. Both clubs turned late-round value into useful roster pieces.

Carolina sent Dennis Daley and a 2024 seventh-round pick to Tennessee for a 2024 fifth-rounder. Daley became the Titans' emergency starting left tackle and started 15 games in 2022, so Tennessee received real short-term utility. He left after one season, while Carolina upgraded a late-round asset by two rounds and moved a player who had been squeezed by improved offensive-line depth, giving the Panthers the better value.

Carolina Panthers received Laviska Shenault. Carolina received wide receiver Laviska Shenault and used him immediately as an offensive contributor. Shenault supplied touches as both a receiver and runner, giving the Panthers near-term roster value from the deal. Jacksonville received future late-round capital, but Carolina obtained the more useful established player at the time of the exchange. That stronger outcome supports a B- grade for Carolina Panthers.

Philadelphia sent defensive back Ugo Amadi and a 2024 seventh-round pick to Tennessee for a 2024 sixth-rounder, effectively moving up one round in a future draft. Amadi played only two games for the Titans before being waived. Tennessee eventually used the seventh-round choice on James Williams, who appeared in 29 games over his first two seasons, leaving both teams with modest but real value.

Green Bay Packers Green Bay received the 2023 seventh-round pick that became No. 242 Anthony Johnson. The Packers retained draft value, but the direct payoff did not surpass the multi-year line value Jacksonville received. The supported hindsight grade is C. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against Jacksonville Jaguars, the final verdict is Jacksonville Jaguars Win.

Arizona Cardinals received Cody Ford in the exchange with Buffalo Bills. Cody Ford played 11 games with three starts for Arizona in 2022, giving the Cardinals a modest but tangible veteran return. Against Buffalo Bills' return of 2023 5th round pick (137th overall subsequently traded, K.J. Henry), that outcome supports a B- grade. The transaction is judged as Arizona Cardinals Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Minnesota acquired Nick Mullens from Las Vegas for a conditional 2024 seventh-round pick. Mullens became a multi-year Vikings backup and, when injuries struck in 2023, started three games while throwing for 1,306 yards and seven touchdowns across five appearances. Las Vegas eventually used pick No. 229 on M.J. Devonshire. For a seventh-round cost, Minnesota received meaningful quarterback insurance and emergency starting production, making the trade a clear Vikings win.

Las Vegas Raiders received conditional 2024 seventh-round pick (not conveyed). Las Vegas received a conditional 2024 seventh-round pick, but the condition was not met and the choice was never conveyed. That result supports a C- for Las Vegas Raiders. The overall comparison is balanced because neither side created a clear enough edge to separate the grades. The grade reflects the realized player service and draft value tied directly to this transaction, without assigning extra credit for outcomes that cannot be traced confidently to the exchanged assets.

Chicago Bears received N'Keal Harry in the 2022-07-12 exchange, while New England Patriots received 2024 7th round pick (231st overall, Jaheim Bell). Chicago acquired N’Keal Harry for a future seventh-round choice. The cost was low, but Harry did not produce enough value for the Bears to make the acquisition a clear success, keeping Chicago around an average grade.

Carolina acquired Baker Mayfield from Cleveland in July 2022 for a conditional 2024 fifth-round pick. The condition tied to playing time did not rise to a fourth-rounder, but Mayfield still failed to stabilize the Panthers' quarterback situation and was released during the season. Cleveland recovered draft value for a quarterback it had already replaced, while Carolina paid for a short, unsuccessful stint that ended before the year was over.

Atlanta acquired Bryan Edwards and a 2023 seventh-round pick from Las Vegas for a 2023 fifth-rounder. Edwards did not solve the Falcons' receiving need and was released during the season, but the extra seventh eventually became safety DeMarcco Hellams, who supplied useful defensive value. The Raiders gained the better original pick but later moved it, leaving Atlanta with the most tangible contributor directly connected to the exchange.

Las Vegas acquired Jarrett Stidham and a 2023 seventh-round selection that became Nesta Jade Silvera. Stidham appeared in five games and made two starts for the Raiders, throwing for 656 yards and four touchdowns, while Silvera added defensive depth. That combination produced a clearer direct football return than the future sixth-round asset New England received.

Buffalo moved down from No. 60 to No. 63 in 2022, receiving pick 209 and selecting James Cook. Cincinnati moved up for cornerback Cam Taylor-Britt. Cook has become a three-time Pro Bowler, won the 2025 NFL rushing title with 1,621 yards and earned second-team All-Pro honors. Taylor-Britt has supplied several seasons of starting corner play, but Cook's elite production and long-term extension make Buffalo the clear winner.

Buffalo sent picks 168 and 203 to Chicago for No. 148 and selected Khalil Shakir. Shakir developed into Josh Allen's dependable slot target, led Buffalo with 76 catches and 821 receiving yards in 2024 and signed an extension through 2029. Chicago used No. 168 on Braxton Jones, who has started 44 of 46 career games at left tackle and earned PFWA All-Rookie honors. Both teams found long-term starters, making this an excellent even trade.

Carolina moved up for linebacker Brandon Smith at No. 120 and also received pick No. 189, used on edge defender Amare Barno. Washington received two fifth-rounders and selected Sam Howell and Cole Turner. Howell later started all 17 games for the Commanders in 2023 and was traded for additional draft value, while Carolina received only modest returns from Smith and Barno. Washington clearly created the stronger package.

Green Bay moved back eight spots in the fifth round of the 2022 draft and added an extra seventh-rounder, turning the return into Kingsley Enagbare and Jonathan Ford. Denver used No. 171 on Luke Wattenberg. Wattenberg developed into a useful interior lineman, but Enagbare became a regular part of Green Bay's edge rotation and gives the Packers the stronger combined return from the two selections.

Chicago received both No. 166 and No. 207. The Bears later converted No. 166 into additional draft value and used No. 207 on Doug Kramer, so the complete two-pick package gave Chicago the stronger aggregate return. That outcome supports a B grade within the Chicago Bears Win verdict. The grade reflects realized football value rather than the size of the original package.

Jacksonville Jaguars received 2022 5th round pick (154th overall, Snoop Conner) in the 2022-04-30 exchange with Philadelphia Eagles. Snoop Conner produced limited value for Jacksonville after the Jaguars moved up to No. 154. The direct package is the basis for the hindsight grade, with later movement of an acquired selection treated separately. That supports Philadelphia Eagles Win.

Jacksonville sent 2022 picks Nos. 157 and 235 to Tampa Bay for the Buccaneers' 2023 fourth-round selection, which became No. 121 Ventrell Miller. Tampa Bay used No. 157 on cornerback Zyon McCollum and later moved No. 235. Both clubs produced usable players from the exchange, but the Buccaneers received two current picks and turned the higher one into a meaningful defensive contributor, giving Tampa Bay the stronger return.

Chicago received the final two selections of the 2022 draft and used them on Elijah Hicks and Trenton Gill. Hicks became a useful defensive back and special-teams contributor, while Gill handled punting duties before his Bears tenure ended. Getting two players who produced real NFL service from a future sixth gives Chicago the slightly stronger combined return.

Minnesota traded picks No. 122 and No. 250 to Las Vegas for Nos. 126 and 227 in the 2022 draft. The Raiders selected Zamir White and Brittain Brown. Minnesota took Nick Muse at No. 227 and immediately flipped No. 126 for Nos. 165 and 169, adding Esezi Otomewo and Ty Chandler. Chandler's production roughly matched White's, while the Vikings also gained extra depth, creating a narrow Minnesota edge.

Minnesota sent pick No. 156 and a 2023 fourth-rounder to Cleveland to move up for cornerback Akayleb Evans at No. 118. Cleveland used No. 156 on running back Jerome Ford and the future fourth on edge defender Isaiah McGuire. Evans gave Minnesota stretches of starting work, but Ford became a productive backfield contributor and McGuire added defensive rotation value. Two useful Browns for one inconsistent Vikings corner gives Cleveland the edge.

Philadelphia traded picks 188 and 237 to Detroit to move up seven spots to No. 181 for linebacker Kyron Johnson. Detroit stayed in the sixth round and selected Malcolm Rodriguez at No. 188, then used No. 237 on Chase Lucas. Rodriguez quickly became a useful Lions linebacker and special-teams contributor, while Johnson had a limited Eagles tenure. Detroit gained the best player while also adding an extra selection.

Los Angeles moved up 11 spots in the fifth round on April 30, 2022, sending Las Vegas picks No. 175 and No. 238 for No. 164. The Rams selected Notre Dame running back Kyren Williams. Through Week 2 of 2026, Williams had played 57 games with 46 starts, rushing for 3,960 yards and 37 touchdowns while adding 116 catches for 781 yards and nine receiving scores. He surpassed 1,100 rushing yards in each season from 2023 through 2025.

Los Angeles traded pick No. 218 to Tampa Bay on April 30, 2022 for two seventh-round selections, Nos. 235 and 261. The Rams used them on edge defender Daniel Hardy and tackle A.J. Arcuri. Hardy appeared in six regular-season games for Los Angeles in 2022 without a start before later continuing his career elsewhere. Arcuri played 10 Rams games across 2022 and 2024 with one start. The two-pick return produced depth but little sustained role value.

On 2022-04-30, Cleveland Browns received 2023 5th round pick (140th overall, Dorian Thompson-Robinson), while Los Angeles Rams received Troy Hill. The hindsight verdict is Los Angeles Rams Win, with Cleveland Browns graded C- and Los Angeles Rams graded B. The evaluation follows the documented consideration and traceable football value, while leaving unresolved downstream pick identities out of the judgment.

New York moved down two spots on April 29, 2022, sending pick No. 36 to the Jets for Nos. 38 and 146. The Giants then flipped No. 38 to Atlanta for Nos. 43 and 114, selecting Wan'Dale Robinson and Dane Belton, while No. 146 became Micah McFadden. Across four Giants seasons those three selections produced substantial receiving, defensive and starting value, giving the trade-down a broad multi-player return.

New York traded pick No. 38 to Atlanta on April 29, 2022 for picks No. 43 and No. 114. The Giants selected Wan'Dale Robinson and Dane Belton. Robinson produced 268 catches for 2,465 yards and nine receiving touchdowns across four Giants seasons before leaving in 2026, while Belton played all 66 regular-season games for New York from 2022 through 2025 with 22 starts, 240 tackles, six interceptions and four sacks. The two-player return gave New York sustained value on both sides of the ball.

Atlanta traded picks No. 43 and No. 114 to the Giants in the 2022 draft to move up to No. 38 for edge rusher Arnold Ebiketie. New York used the return on wide receiver Wan'Dale Robinson and safety Dane Belton. Ebiketie became a useful rotational pass rusher, but Robinson developed into a high-volume receiver and Belton added four seasons of defensive depth, giving the Giants more combined value.

Tampa Bay moved from No. 60 to No. 57 in the 2022 draft for tackle Luke Goedeke, sending Buffalo pick No. 180 as well. Goedeke became a durable Buccaneers starter, making Tampa's return strong. Buffalo then flipped No. 60 to Cincinnati and landed the pick used on James Cook, who led the NFL with 1,621 rushing yards in 2025. That downstream result gives Buffalo the larger payoff.

Carolina paid a 2022 fourth-round pick and a 2023 third-rounder to move up for Matt Corral at No. 94. Corral missed his rookie season with a foot injury and was waived before ever appearing in a regular-season game for the Panthers. New England used the fourth-rounder on Bailey Zappe and the future third on Marte Mapu, producing substantially more usable NFL value from the exchange.

Cleveland moved out of the 44th pick in the 2022 draft and received Nos. 68, 108 and 124 from Houston. Those selections became Martin Emerson Jr., Perrion Winfrey and Cade York, while Houston used No. 44 on John Metchie III. Emerson developed into the most valuable player produced by the exchange, giving Cleveland the stronger long-term return despite misses elsewhere in the package.

Indianapolis sent pick No. 179 and a 2023 third-rounder to Denver to move back into the 2022 third round for safety Nick Cross at No. 96. Cross grew from a young special-teams contributor into a productive starting safety, giving the Colts a durable defensive payoff. Denver later used the future third on Drew Sanders, but his early return did not match Cross's established role in Indianapolis.

Houston moved up five spots in the 2022 third round, receiving pick No. 75 from Denver and selecting linebacker Christian Harris. The Broncos received Nos. 80 and 162, which became tight end Greg Dulcich and returner Montrell Washington. Harris developed into a regular starter on Houston's defense and contributed during the Texans' return to the playoffs, while Denver received only limited long-term value from its two selections.

New England moved up from No. 54 to No. 50 in the 2022 draft for wide receiver Tyquan Thornton, sending Kansas City the 54th and 158th picks. The Chiefs selected Skyy Moore at No. 54. Neither receiver became a consistent starter for his drafting club, but Moore contributed a crucial touchdown in Kansas City's Super Bowl LVII victory. That championship moment gives the Chiefs a modest edge.

Green Bay sent picks 53 and 59 to Minnesota for No. 34 and selected Christian Watson. Watson has 133 catches for 2,264 yards and 20 receiving touchdowns through four seasons and signed another extension in 2026. Minnesota used No. 59 on Ed Ingram and later packaged No. 53 with other picks to move up for Andrew Booth Jr. Ingram supplied 41 starts, but Watson became the highest-impact player, giving Green Bay the win.

Minnesota moved up in the 2022 second round and came away with cornerback Andrew Booth Jr. at No. 42 plus the No. 122 pick, which was later moved again. Indianapolis turned the return into Alec Pierce, Bernhard Raimann and Andrew Ogletree. Booth never supplied comparable value, while Pierce and especially Raimann became meaningful Colts contributors, giving Indianapolis the clearer long-term return.

The Jets sent picks 38 and 146 to the Giants to move up two spots for Breece Hall at No. 36. Hall became a centerpiece of the Jets offense, recovering from a major rookie knee injury to produce multiple high-volume seasons and eventually top 1,000 rushing yards. The Giants used No. 146 on Micah McFadden and later moved No. 38 in another trade. New York's NFC team received good value, but Hall became the best player.

Tennessee traded picks No. 90 and No. 169 to Las Vegas during the 2022 draft to move up four spots to No. 86, where the Titans selected quarterback Malik Willis. Willis appeared in 11 regular-season games with three starts over two Tennessee seasons before the Titans traded him to Green Bay in 2024 for a seventh-round pick.

Arizona acquired Marquise Brown and pick No. 100 from Baltimore for the 23rd pick in the 2022 draft. Baltimore immediately traded down to No. 25 and added No. 130, turning those selections into Tyler Linderbaum and Jordan Stout. Brown gave Arizona useful receiving production but stayed only two seasons, while Linderbaum became a foundational Ravens center. Baltimore's downstream return makes this a clear Ravens win.

Buffalo sent picks 25 and 130 to Baltimore to move up two spots for cornerback Kaiir Elam. The Ravens stayed in the first round and drafted center Tyler Linderbaum, then used No. 130 on punter Jordan Stout. Linderbaum made three consecutive Pro Bowls from 2023 through 2025, and Stout earned his first in 2025. Elam started only 12 games for Buffalo before being traded to Dallas. Baltimore won overwhelmingly.

Jacksonville moved back into the first round in 2022 for linebacker Devin Lloyd, sending Tampa Bay picks No. 33, No. 106 and No. 180. Lloyd became a productive four-year starter and Pro Bowl player. Tampa Bay countered with defensive lineman Logan Hall and tight end Cade Otton, both durable multi-year contributors, plus another pick. The Buccaneers' depth of return narrowly exceeds Jacksonville's excellent single player.

Kansas City traded picks No. 29, No. 94 and No. 121 to New England to move up to No. 21 for cornerback Trent McDuffie. McDuffie became a championship cornerstone, winning two Super Bowls with Kansas City and earning consecutive All-Pro recognition. New England received Cole Strange and additional draft capital, but none of that return approached McDuffie's elite value at a premium position.

Detroit sent picks 32, 34 and 66 to Minnesota for Nos. 12 and 46, selecting Jameson Williams and Josh Paschal. Williams has surpassed 1,000 receiving yards in consecutive seasons and signed an extension through 2029; Paschal has supplied defensive-line depth. Minnesota drafted Lewis Cine and Brian Asamoah and later moved No. 34 through additional trades. Cine was waived after two seasons, and the Vikings never found comparable value. Detroit won decisively.

New Orleans moved from No. 16 to No. 11 in 2022 for Chris Olave, sending Washington third- and fourth-round picks in the process. Olave has 291 catches for 3,728 yards and 19 touchdowns through four seasons, earned second-team All-Pro honors in 2025 and signed a new extension in 2026. Washington received meaningful value from Jahan Dotson and Brian Robinson Jr., but Olave became the best player in the transaction.

The Jets sent Tennessee picks 35, 69 and 163 for Nos. 26 and 101, selecting Jermaine Johnson and Jeremy Ruckert. Johnson became a 2023 Pro Bowler before an Achilles tear cost him most of 2024, while Ruckert developed into a regular tight end and earned an extension. Tennessee received several starters, led by Roger McCreary and Nicholas Petit-Frere. The Titans gained more total snaps, but the Jets landed the highest-ceiling player, making the result essentially even.

Philadelphia sent picks 15, 124, 162 and 166 to Houston to move up two spots for Georgia defensive tackle Jordan Davis at No. 13. Houston selected guard Kenyon Green at No. 15 and moved the later picks in additional draft-day deals. Davis developed into a durable starting piece on Philadelphia's defensive front, while Green's early career was less stable, giving the Eagles the stronger directly attributable return.

Philadelphia acquired A.J. Brown for the first-round pick used on Treylon Burks and a third-round pick, then turned Brown into an elite centerpiece of a championship offense. He helped the Eagles reach two Super Bowls, scored in their Super Bowl LIX victory, and in 2026 Philadelphia later traded him to New England for a 2028 first-rounder and a 2027 fifth-rounder.

Houston Texans received 2022 5th round pick (170th overall, Teagan Quitoriano) in the 2022-04-25 exchange with New England Patriots. Teagan Quitoriano provided some tight-end snaps for Houston, but not enough to create a clear long-term advantage. The direct package, rather than later movement of any acquired asset, is the basis for the hindsight judgment. Against what Houston Texans surrendered, the result supports Even Trade.

New Orleans acquired two 2022 first-round slots and used one on Trevor Penning, while Philadelphia received a future first, a future second, and additional selections. The 2023 first became the No. 10 pick that Philadelphia used in the move for Jalen Carter. The Eagles converted patience into premium, championship-level roster value.

Miami sent DeVante Parker and a 2022 fifth-round pick to New England for a 2023 third-rounder. Parker gave the Patriots veteran receiving help but never became a difference-making long-term piece, while Miami extracted premium draft position from a player whose role was shrinking after the Tyreek Hill acquisition. The third-round return carried more lasting roster value than New England received from Parker and the accompanying fifth-round selection.

Miami sent Kansas City five draft picks for Tyreek Hill and received an immediate superstar: 340 catches, 4,733 yards and 27 touchdowns through four Dolphins seasons, including consecutive 1,700-yard campaigns. Kansas City used Hill-related capital in several moves, including the trade up for Trent McDuffie, a two-time champion and All-Pro who later brought four more picks in 2026. Both sides prospered, but Kansas City's continuing asset tree earns a slight edge.

Atlanta traded longtime quarterback Matt Ryan to Indianapolis for pick No. 82 in 2022, ending a 14-year era and beginning a roster reset. The Falcons used the pick on DeAngelo Malone, who became primarily a rotational defender and special-teams contributor. Ryan started 12 games for the Colts, throwing for 3,057 yards, 14 touchdowns and 13 interceptions before being released after one season. Atlanta won because Indianapolis received no lasting quarterback solution.

Buffalo Bills received Case Keenum in the exchange with Cleveland Browns. Its C grade reflects the practical value of that return relative to the package surrendered and the hindsight result. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Los Angeles Rams received 2023 sixth-round pick No. 189, Ochaun Mathis; Tennessee Titans received Robert Woods. Mathis appeared in eight Rams games as a rookie reserve, made two tackles and recorded no sacks. Woods started 15 of 17 games for Tennessee in 2022 and led the Titans with 53 receptions for 527 yards and two touchdowns. The realized returns support Tennessee Titans Win, with Los Angeles Rams graded C and Tennessee Titans graded B-.

Cleveland's trade for Deshaun Watson became one of the most damaging modern blockbuster deals. The Browns surrendered a massive pick package and handed Watson a fully guaranteed contract, while Houston escaped the situation and rebuilt with premium assets. The Texans won decisively because Cleveland absorbed nearly all of the risk. It is one of the clearest modern examples of a team paying franchise-quarterback prices without receiving franchise-quarterback stability.

Las Vegas sent Green Bay first- and second-round picks for Davante Adams, then gave him a major extension. Adams produced 221 catches, 2,869 yards and 23 touchdowns for the Raiders before being traded to the Jets in 2024 for a third-round pick later used in the Geno Smith deal. Green Bay drafted Quay Walker at No. 22 and used No. 53 in the move for Christian Watson. Both sides gained value, but Green Bay built the stronger long-term return.

Indianapolis traded Carson Wentz plus picks No. 47 and No. 240 to Washington on March 16, 2022 for picks No. 42 and No. 73 plus a conditional 2023 third-round pick. The Colts later used No. 73 on Jelani Woods and the 2023 pick became No. 79 Josh Downs, while No. 42 was included in a trade-down that helped produce three additional selections. Downs alone had 207 catches for 2,249 yards and 11 touchdowns through Week 2 of 2026, giving Indianapolis the strongest direct long-term return.

Cleveland acquired Amari Cooper and a sixth-round pick for late-round compensation. Cooper delivered consecutive 1,000-yard seasons and gave the Browns a true No. 1 receiver before Cleveland later recovered additional value in another trade. Dallas created salary flexibility but received limited on-field return from Matt Waletzko and Devin Harper.

Cleveland received Chase Winovich for Mack Wilson in a linebacker-for-edge swap that became official on March 16, 2022. Winovich gave the Browns eight games, 18 tackles and one sack before leaving after the season. Wilson became a useful two-year Patriots contributor, playing all 34 regular-season games and producing five sacks. New England extracted the longer and more productive return, giving the Patriots the clear hindsight win.

Houston acquired linebacker Blake Cashman from the Jets in March 2022 for a 2023 sixth-round pick. Cashman became a useful Texans defender and eventually a full-time starter, delivering a strong final season in Houston before leaving in free agency. New York received modest late-round capital for a player who had struggled to stay healthy, but Houston extracted starting-caliber production from a very small acquisition cost.

Indianapolis and Las Vegas exchanged Yannick Ngakoue and Rock Ya-Sin in March 2022. Both incoming players became one-year starters and then left their new clubs. Ngakoue started 15 games for the Colts and led the team with 9.5 sacks; Ya-Sin started nine of 11 games for the Raiders and defended seven passes. Because each team received useful short-term production without a lasting asset, the trade grades evenly.

Tampa Bay acquired veteran guard Shaq Mason from New England for the 170th pick in the 2022 draft. Mason started all 17 games for the Buccaneers during Tom Brady's final season and gave them needed stability after Ali Marpet retired. Tampa then traded Mason to Houston in 2023 and moved up from the seventh to the sixth round in the process. One strong starting season for a fifth-rounder makes the Buccaneers the winner.

The Chargers acquired Khalil Mack from Chicago for a 2022 second-round pick and a 2023 sixth-rounder. Mack delivered multiple seasons of high-end edge play in Los Angeles, including a major 2023 pass-rushing season. Chicago used the second-round selection on safety Jaquan Brisker, who immediately became a full-time starter, leaving both organizations with substantial direct value from very different roster-building approaches.

Seattle's Russell Wilson trade became one of the clearest modern examples of selling a star at the perfect time. Denver paid a massive price for a quarterback solution that quickly collapsed, while the Seahawks turned the return into the start of a roster reset and avoided the steep downside of Wilson's decline. The deal remains a defining warning about paying peak price for a player whose best version may already be gone.

The Rams acquired Von Miller from Denver for second- and third-round picks in the 2022 draft, adding a proven edge rusher for a championship run. Miller became a major part of Los Angeles' Super Bowl LVI defense, while Denver eventually turned the second-rounder into Nik Bonitto, who developed into a Pro Bowl pass rusher of his own.

Kansas City sent guard Laurent Duvernay-Tardif to the New York Jets on November 2, 2021 for tight end Daniel Brown. Brown never appeared in a regular-season game for the Chiefs; he was waived later that month and returned to the Jets' practice squad. Kansas City cleared a veteran from its offensive-line depth chart, but the player return itself produced no game-day value for the Chiefs.

Kansas City Chiefs received Melvin Ingram from Pittsburgh Steelers. Kansas City received Melvin Ingram and used him as a veteran pass rusher during a playoff run. The Chiefs gained useful short-term help at a position of need. That outcome supports a C+ grade for Kansas City Chiefs. The final verdict is Pittsburgh Steelers Win, based on the football value the club actually realized from the assets it controlled after the exchange.

Houston sent Charles Omenihu to San Francisco at the 2021 trade deadline for a 2023 sixth-round pick that became No. 207. The Texans secured future draft capital for a player they were willing to move, but they later traded that selection, so Anders Carlson was not Houston's direct return. Omenihu's useful 49ers production gives San Francisco the stronger hindsight result.

New Orleans reacquired Mark Ingram from Houston for a future seventh-round pick, bringing back a franchise favorite at minimal cost. Ingram rushed for 260 yards and caught 20 passes for 138 yards in seven Saints games in 2021 while becoming the franchise's career rushing leader. Houston eventually used the 2024 pick on Solomon Byrd, who appeared in one game as a rookie. The Saints received more useful football value.

New York reacquired Joe Flacco for a conditional 2022 sixth-rounder and got a small but useful quarterback return: two appearances, one start, 338 passing yards, three touchdowns, and no interceptions in 2021. Philadelphia did not use the eventual No. 206 selection on Matt Henningsen; it moved that pick to Denver for Kary Vincent Jr., who played two Eagles games with one start. New York produced the stronger direct football return.

Denver acquired linebacker Kenny Young and a 2024 seventh-round pick from the Rams for a 2024 sixth-rounder during the 2021 season. Young immediately stepped into Denver's lineup and supplied short-term starting help, while Los Angeles improved its future draft position and opened snaps for other linebackers during a Super Bowl run. Neither side created a major long-term advantage, making the exchange a sensible even trade.

Denver acquired Stephen Weatherly and Minnesota's 2023 seventh-round pick for a 2022 seventh-rounder. Weatherly supplied immediate rotational snaps for an injury-hit defense, and the Broncos also replaced much of the draft capital they spent by taking back a later seventh. With both picks eventually moving again, Weatherly's actual games in Denver provide the clearest realized value and give the Broncos the stronger return.

Arizona Cardinals received Zach Ertz. Zach Ertz became an immediate and meaningful receiving option for Arizona and continued producing across subsequent Cardinals seasons, giving the club the strongest direct return. That result supports a B+ grade for Arizona Cardinals. The final verdict is Arizona Cardinals Win, based on the documented service, durability, and value each club actually obtained from this exchange.

Carolina acquired cornerback Stephon Gilmore from New England for a 2023 sixth-round pick. Gilmore gave the Panthers eight games, two interceptions and a Pro Bowl selection before leaving after the season. New England eventually used the pick on receiver Kayshon Boutte, who developed into a productive asset and later carried additional trade value. Carolina received a quality rental, but the Patriots captured the better long-term return.

Chicago acquired receiver and return specialist Jakeem Grant from Miami for a 2023 sixth-round pick. Grant gave the Bears an immediate return-game and offensive option for the remainder of the 2021 season, but his stay was brief. Miami later moved the No. 178 selection in another transaction, and the downstream path did not create enough value to establish a clear advantage.

Jacksonville sent cornerback C.J. Henderson and a 2022 fifth-round pick to Carolina for tight end Dan Arnold and a 2022 third-round choice. The Jaguars used the higher selection, No. 70, on linebacker Chad Muma, giving them both immediate tight end help and materially stronger draft capital. Henderson's Carolina tenure did not produce enough value to offset that combined return.

New Orleans acquired cornerback Bradley Roby from Houston in September 2021, sending the Texans a 2022 third-round pick and a 2023 sixth-rounder. Roby gave the Saints experienced secondary help, but the stay was relatively short. Houston recovered two future selections, including a day-two pick, for a veteran on a rebuilding roster. The amount and flexibility of that draft return give the Texans the edge.

Pittsburgh acquired cornerback Ahkello Witherspoon from Seattle for a 2023 fifth-round pick. Witherspoon supplied meaningful defensive snaps and interceptions during his Steelers tenure, giving Pittsburgh useful present value at a contained cost. Seattle later used the selection on Mike Morris, but his early production did not match what Pittsburgh received. The Steelers therefore hold a slight edge in an otherwise modest trade.

Minnesota acquired Chris Herndon plus a 2022 sixth-round pick from the Jets for a 2022 fourth after Irv Smith Jr. suffered a season-ending injury. Herndon played all 16 games but caught only four passes for 40 yards and one touchdown. The sixth-rounder became Vederian Lowe, whom Minnesota later traded to New England for another sixth. New York used pick No. 117 on Micheal Clemons, who has 8.5 sacks and 24 starts through four seasons. The Jets won decisively.

Denver traded wide receiver Trinity Benson and a 2023 sixth-round pick to Detroit for a 2022 fifth-rounder and a conditional 2022 seventh. The seventh did not convey, but the fifth-round asset still gave Denver meaningful draft value. Benson produced only 10 receptions for 103 yards across nine Lions games, so Detroit paid a future pick for limited on-field return and lost the exchange decisively.

Denver acquired linebacker Jonas Griffith and a 2022 seventh-round pick from San Francisco for a 2022 sixth-rounder and a 2023 seventh-rounder. Griffith became a useful short-term starter, appearing in 22 games with 12 starts for the Broncos before injuries interrupted his momentum. San Francisco retained usable draft value, but Denver received the most immediate NFL contribution, producing a modest Broncos edge.

Green Bay acquired punter Corey Bojorquez and a 2023 seventh-round pick from the Rams for a 2023 sixth-round selection. Bojorquez gave the Packers useful punting for one season, and Green Bay eventually used pick No. 235 on running back Lew Nichols. The return had practical value, but the Rams received the stronger draft asset and preserved more flexibility with the sixth-rounder.

Indianapolis acquired offensive lineman Matt Pryor and a 2022 seventh-round pick from Philadelphia for a 2022 sixth-round pick. Pryor immediately supplied useful, inexpensive depth, appearing in all 17 games with five starts in 2021 before earning another Colts contract. Philadelphia recovered a modest draft asset, but Indianapolis received the more substantial on-field return from a small late-round pick downgrade.

Kansas City Chiefs received 2022 7th round pick (243rd overall, Jaylen Watson) from New England Patriots. Watson developed into a meaningful Chiefs defensive back and produced important postseason plays during a championship stretch, far exceeding typical seventh-round expectations. The A grade reflects the direct value Kansas City Chiefs realized from the transaction, with the final Kansas City Chiefs Win call based on actual service and clearly traceable draft outcomes rather than projected value.

Baltimore Ravens received 2022 4th round pick (110th overall, Daniel Faalele) in the 2021-08-31 exchange with New York Giants. Daniel Faalele developed into a substantial Ravens offensive-line contributor and starter from the No. 110 selection. The realized value remains close enough to support an even result.

Seattle acquired cornerback Sidney Jones from Jacksonville at the 2021 roster deadline for a 2022 sixth-round selection, No. 188 overall. Jones moved into a meaningful role in the Seahawks secondary and gave the team starting-caliber snaps for a very small draft cost. That immediate defensive value made the trade worthwhile even though his Seattle tenure was not especially long.

Carolina acquired defensive end Darryl Johnson from Buffalo for a 2022 sixth-round pick, hoping to add size and special-teams help before the 2021 season. Buffalo used that selection at No. 185 on cornerback Christian Benford. Benford developed into a starting-caliber defensive back and later earned a four-year extension, turning a depth-player sale into a major long-term return for the Bills.

Cincinnati acquired defensive tackle B.J. Hill and a conditional 2022 seventh-round pick from the Giants for center Billy Price. Hill developed into a long-term defensive contributor, earned a contract extension, and supplied years of starting-caliber play. The late draft component was secondary; the central value came from turning a former first-round center the Bengals were prepared to move into a durable defensive starter.

Houston Texans received 2022 6th round pick (207th overall subsequently traded, Doug Kramer) in the exchange with New York Jets. The return is graded C+ after weighing the transaction cost and the practical value visible in hindsight. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Jacksonville traded Gardner Minshew to Philadelphia for a conditional 2022 sixth-round pick. The condition was not met at a level that improved the compensation, and the Jaguars ultimately held pick No. 197, which they used on defensive back Gregory Junior. Jacksonville converted a reserve quarterback into a young, inexpensive defender, but the return remained modest enough to keep the deal close.

Miami acquired offensive lineman Greg Mancz and a 2022 seventh-round pick from Baltimore for a 2022 sixth-round selection. Mancz supplied immediate depth, and Miami later used pick No. 224 on Cameron Goode. Baltimore used the higher No. 196 choice on Tyler Badie. The modest player and draft returns on both sides never created enough separation for a clear winner.

Carolina Panthers received Ryan Santoso from the New York Giants for a conditional 2022 seventh-round pick. The condition required Santoso to remain on Carolina's regular-season roster for two games, but he was waived after one, so the choice was never conveyed. Carolina therefore got a short kicker trial without surrendering draft capital, enough for a modest B- result.

Carolina sent linebacker Denzel Perryman and a 2022 seventh-round pick to Las Vegas for a 2022 sixth-rounder. The Panthers eventually used that sixth on offensive lineman Cade Mays, but Perryman immediately became a centerpiece of the Raiders' defense, posting a career season and earning Pro Bowl recognition in 2021. That immediate high-level production gives Las Vegas the stronger return despite Carolina landing a useful later pick.

Baltimore received a 2022 seventh-round choice and a 2023 fifth-round choice. The Ravens later moved both selections through additional transactions, preserving flexibility and extracting continued value from two pieces of draft capital rather than relying on one player to develop. That result supports a B grade within the Baltimore Ravens Win verdict.

The Rams acquired running back Sony Michel from New England for draft compensation that became a 2022 sixth-round pick and a 2023 fourth-round pick. Michel rushed for 845 yards in 2021, stabilized the backfield through injuries and contributed to a Super Bowl LVI championship season. New England received legitimate future capital, but the Rams bought exactly the short-term production and postseason relevance they needed.

Houston traded cornerback John Reid to Seattle on August 24, 2021, for a conditional 2023 seventh-round selection. The condition was not met, so Houston never received the pick. Reid nevertheless appeared in eleven games and made two starts for Seattle that season, leaving the Texans without compensation while the Seahawks obtained usable secondary depth at no realized draft cost.

Green Bay Packers received 2022 7th round pick (228th overall, Tariq Carpenter). Green Bay used the seventh-round choice on Tariq Carpenter, who appeared in 14 games as a rookie and contributed on special teams. That result supports a C+ grade for Green Bay Packers. The final verdict is Green Bay Packers Win, based on the documented service, durability, and value each club actually obtained from this exchange.

Carolina sent tackle Greg Little to Miami for a 2022 seventh-round pick and later used the resulting No. 242 selection on cornerback Kalon Barnes. Barnes did not provide regular-season value for the Panthers, but Carolina still recovered an asset for a player it was ready to move. Miami received some offensive-line starts from Little, yet he did not become a long-term answer, leaving Carolina with the narrow advantage.

Green Bay received Isaac Yiadom in the August 2021 cornerback swap and got the more useful short-term return. Yiadom appeared in all 16 games for the Packers and made a start, providing workable depth during the season. That is modest value rather than a major win, but it clearly exceeded what New York received, supporting a C+ grade for Green Bay.

Houston Texans received 2023 6th round pick (203rd overall subsequently traded, Amari Burney) in the 2021-08-16 exchange involving New York Giants. Houston retained a sixth-round draft asset for a depth player, giving the Texans future roster-building flexibility without surrendering a core contributor. That realized return supports a C+ grade for Houston Texans. The overall verdict is Even Trade, with the grade based on direct value created from this transaction.

Jacksonville Jaguars Jacksonville received the 2022 sixth-round pick at No. 198 and later used it as part of additional draft movement. The pick preserved some value, but the direct return was less substantial than Pittsburgh's season of starting linebacker production. The supported hindsight grade is C. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against Pittsburgh Steelers, the final verdict is Pittsburgh Steelers Win.

Green Bay reacquired Randall Cobb from Houston for a 2022 sixth-round pick at Aaron Rodgers' urging. Cobb caught 28 passes for 375 yards and five touchdowns in 2021, then 34 for 417 yards in 2022, contributing to a 13-win season and another playoff appearance. Houston used pick No. 205 on tackle Austin Deculus, who became depth rather than a long-term starter. For a sixth-round cost, the Packers received two useful veteran seasons and won comfortably.

Chicago sent Anthony Miller and a 2022 seventh-round pick to Houston for a 2022 fifth-round selection. The Bears later traded that No. 148 pick to Buffalo for Nos. 168 and 203, using No. 168 on tackle Braxton Jones. Jones became the most meaningful downstream asset from the transaction, giving Chicago the stronger long-term return from moving Miller.

Atlanta sent Julio Jones and a 2023 sixth-round pick to Tennessee for a 2022 second and conditional 2023 fourth. Jones played only 10 regular-season games for the Titans, catching 31 passes for 434 yards and one touchdown before being released after one season. Atlanta used the second-rounder on Troy Andersen and later moved the fourth-round asset. Andersen's injuries limited his ceiling, but the Falcons still recovered far more durable value than Tennessee received.

Jacksonville Jaguars received Jameson Houston and 2023 6th round pick (208th overall, Erick Hallett) from Philadelphia Eagles in the 2021-05-18 exchange. Jameson Houston was waived by Jacksonville before the 2021 season and Erick Hallett remained a practice-squad player there, while Josiah Scott played 33 Eagles games with four starts and two interceptions. Measured by what Jacksonville Jaguars actually realized after the deal, the return supports a D+ grade and represents the weaker realized return. The overall judgment is Philadelphia Eagles Win.

Minnesota traded cornerback Mike Hughes and a 2022 seventh-round choice to Kansas City for a 2022 sixth-round pick. Hughes gave the Chiefs one useful season, but Minnesota used No. 191 on Jalen Nailor, who developed into a productive receiver with 1,066 receiving yards and 11 touchdowns through 2025. Nailor's multi-year contribution gives the Vikings the better return.

Arizona sent picks 160 and a 2022 fourth to Baltimore for Nos. 136 and 210, selecting Marco Wilson and Victor Dimukeje. Wilson started extensively over his first three seasons and intercepted three passes in 2022 before being released late in 2023; Dimukeje developed into a useful rotational edge defender. Baltimore's Shaun Wade was traded before his rookie season, while Charlie Kolar became a reserve tight end with 30 catches for 409 yards through 2025. Arizona received more total defensive value.

Tennessee traded up to No. 109 in the 2021 draft for receiver Dez Fitzpatrick, sending Carolina picks 126, 166 and 232. The Panthers used those selections on Chuba Hubbard, Keith Taylor and Phil Hoskins. Hubbard developed into a productive starting running back and earned a long-term extension, while Fitzpatrick made only a limited NFL impact. Carolina's move-down produced the clear long-term winner.

Cleveland moved down in the 2021 draft and received No. 153 Tony Fields plus a 2022 fourth-round pick that became No. 107. The Browns later traded No. 107, so Dameon Pierce was not Cleveland's direct selection from this exchange. Fields provided useful depth, but Derrick Barnes became the most impactful direct player, leaving Cleveland on the weaker side of the hindsight result.

Buffalo Bills received 2021 6th round pick (203rd overall, Marquez Stevenson) and 2021 6th round pick (212th overall, Damar Hamlin) from Houston Texans. Buffalo turned its two sixth-round selections into Marquez Stevenson and Damar Hamlin. Hamlin developed into a multi-year safety contributor, creating the strongest durable return produced by the original pick swap. That outcome supports a B+ grade for Buffalo Bills when the trade is measured by the football value actually realized after the exchange.

Indianapolis traded pick No. 206 for Nos. 218 and 229, selecting quarterback Sam Ehlinger and receiver Mike Strachan. Ehlinger appeared in eight games and made three starts for the Colts, while Strachan played 23 games and caught six passes for 130 yards. The Colts created two roster chances, but neither player became a sustained starter, leaving the return useful mainly as depth.

Kansas City sent picks No. 175 and No. 207 to the Jets for Nos. 162 and 226. The Chiefs used those selections on Noah Gray and Trey Smith, both of whom became meaningful contributors. New York used its return on Jason Pinnock and Jonathan Marshall, but the Jets did not receive comparable team-specific value from those selections.

Miami moved pick No. 156 in the 2021 draft to Pittsburgh and received the Steelers' 2022 fourth-round pick, No. 125, which the Dolphins used on wide receiver Erik Ezukanma. The trade gave Miami a higher-value future selection, but Ezukanma did not produce enough on-field value to create a large advantage. The draft-capital gain still leaves Miami slightly ahead in a modest exchange.

Las Vegas moved from picks No. 162 and No. 200 to No. 143 and selected safety Tyree Gillespie. The Raiders got the player they wanted, but New York retained multiple pieces of draft capital and preserved more flexibility. Those assets later fed into additional transactions and player selections, giving the Jets a broader set of downstream returns than Las Vegas received from Gillespie.

Jacksonville moved up from No. 130 to No. 121 in the 2021 draft and added No. 209, selecting Jordan Smith and Jalen Camp. The Rams received Nos. 130, 170 and 249, using the package on Robert Rochell, later trade capital, and Ben Skowronek. Los Angeles extracted more usable depth and optionality from the exchange, earning a B to Jacksonville's C-.

Los Angeles moved down four spots in the fifth round on May 1, 2021, sending Houston pick No. 170 for Nos. 174 and 233. The Rams selected defensive lineman Earnest Brown IV and running back Jake Funk. Brown appeared in 12 Rams regular-season games with three starts and 14 tackles across 2022-23, while Funk appeared in 15 Rams games across 2021-22 and had two carries for five yards, contributing mainly on special teams. The two-player return produced modest depth rather than a long-term starter.

Seattle moved up nine spots in the 2021 sixth round, sending picks 217 and 250 to Chicago for No. 208. The Seahawks selected tackle Stone Forsythe, while the Bears landed running back Khalil Herbert and defensive tackle Khyiris Tonga. Forsythe became a useful starter, but the combined production of Herbert and Tonga gives Chicago the stronger overall return.

Philadelphia sent 2021 picks No. 225 and No. 240 to Washington for a 2022 fifth-round selection. The Eagles preserved future draft flexibility and later moved that fifth-rounder in another sequence of transactions rather than making the selection themselves. That future asset had value, but Washington received multiple seasons from the specialist it targeted, leaving Philadelphia with the smaller realized return.

New York moved from No. 76 to No. 71 on April 30, 2021, sending Denver picks No. 76 and No. 164 to draft UCF cornerback Aaron Robinson. Robinson appeared in 11 games for the Giants across 2021-22, recording 28 tackles and four passes defended before injuries derailed his tenure. The trade-up therefore produced only a brief defensive contribution from a third-round selection.

Chicago moved up from No. 52 to No. 39 in the 2021 draft and selected offensive lineman Teven Jenkins, while Carolina received Nos. 52, 83 and 204 and also sent No. 151 to the Bears. The Panthers converted the move-down into Tommy Tremble, Shi Smith and additional trade flexibility. Chicago got useful linemen in Jenkins and Larry Borom, but Carolina extracted the broader package.

Cleveland moved from No. 59 to No. 52 in the 2021 draft to select linebacker Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah, sending Carolina Nos. 52 and 113 for Nos. 59 and 89. Carolina selected Terrace Marshall at 59 and later moved the 89th pick, while Cleveland landed a high-impact linebacker who reached the Pro Bowl. Both sides created value, but Owusu-Koramoah gives Cleveland the narrow edge.

Carolina moved from No. 73 to No. 70 in the 2021 draft and selected offensive lineman Brady Christensen, sending Philadelphia pick 191 as part of the swap. Christensen became a versatile multi-year Panthers starter, so Carolina received legitimate value. Philadelphia selected defensive tackle Milton Williams at 73 and Tarron Jackson at 191; Williams later became a major championship contributor, giving the Eagles the stronger overall return.

Houston traded up to No. 89 in the 2021 draft and selected wide receiver Nico Collins, sending Carolina picks 109, 158 and a 2022 fourth-rounder. Carolina gained three bites at the apple and used or moved each piece, but Collins developed into a high-volume, 1,000-yard-caliber receiver and a central part of Houston's offense. That star-level outcome overwhelms Carolina's respectable quantity return.

New England sent picks 46, 122 and 139 to Cincinnati to move up to No. 38 for Christian Barmore. Barmore has 15.5 sacks through five seasons, including an 8.5-sack breakout in 2023, and returned to start 16 games in 2025 after a serious medical issue limited 2024. Cincinnati's Jackson Carman, Tyler Shelvin and D'Ante Smith never produced comparable long-term value. The Patriots turned a three-for-one move into the only clear impact player.

Denver traded picks 40 and 114 to Atlanta for No. 35 and No. 219, then selected running back Javonte Williams and receiver Seth Williams. Atlanta turned its return into safety Richie Grant and center Drew Dalman. Javonte Williams delivered productive seasons despite a major knee injury, but Dalman became a multi-year starting center and Grant also supplied defensive snaps. The Falcons received two useful starters from the premium Denver paid to move up.

Denver sent pick No. 71 to the Giants for No. 76 and No. 164. New York used No. 71 on cornerback Aaron Robinson, whose career was derailed by injuries after limited playing time. Denver used No. 164 on safety Jamar Johnson and, more importantly, retained No. 76 as valuable currency for a second trade later that night. Even without crediting the later players directly here, Denver preserved far more value than New York realized from Robinson.

Denver traded pick No. 76 to New Orleans for picks 98 and 105, selecting Quinn Meinerz and Baron Browning. Meinerz became a first-team All-Pro guard and signed a long-term extension, while Browning developed into a useful edge defender before Denver later traded him. New Orleans used No. 76 on Paulson Adebo, who started 51 games in four seasons and became a coveted free agent. Both teams hit, but Meinerz makes Denver's two-player return exceptional.

Green Bay sent picks No. 92 and No. 135 to Tennessee to move up seven spots for Amari Rodgers at No. 85. Rodgers appeared in 26 games with one start before the Packers released him in November 2022, and problems in the return game shortened his opportunity. The move-up therefore produced little lasting offensive or special-teams value for Green Bay.

Miami sent pick No. 50 and a 2022 third-rounder to the Giants to move up eight spots for Liam Eichenberg at No. 42. Eichenberg became a versatile multi-position starter for the Dolphins, so Miami received real value. New York used No. 50 on edge defender Azeez Ojulari and the future third on cornerback Cordale Flott. Injuries limited Ojulari, but Flott and Ojulari together produced enough defensive contribution to give the Giants the stronger return.

Miami moved from No. 50 to No. 42 in the 2021 second round for tackle Liam Eichenberg, sending New York a 2022 third-round pick as the premium. The Giants selected Azeez Ojulari at No. 50 and later used the future third on Cordale Flott. Eichenberg became a versatile Dolphins starter, while Ojulari supplied pass-rush production and Flott added secondary snaps, giving New York a modest edge through two useful players.

Las Vegas moved from No. 48 to No. 43 in 2021 for safety Tre'von Moehrig and also received a seventh-round pick. San Francisco took guard Aaron Banks at No. 48 and later moved the fourth-round selection. Moehrig started 64 games in four Raiders seasons with six interceptions, while Banks started 43 games for three strong 49ers offenses before leaving in free agency. Both teams found quality multi-year starters, making this an even trade.

San Francisco sent picks 117 and 121 to the Rams to move up to No. 88 for running back Trey Sermon. Sermon rushed for 167 yards as a rookie and was waived before his second season. Los Angeles used No. 117 on defensive tackle Bobby Brown III and later moved No. 121. Brown developed into a regular contributor and starter on the Rams' defensive line. The Rams received the only lasting player value and clearly won the deal.

Chicago moved from No. 20 to No. 11 on April 29, 2021 by sending New York picks No. 20 and No. 164 plus first- and fourth-round selections in 2022. The Bears used No. 11 on quarterback Justin Fields, who started 38 games over three Chicago seasons, threw for 6,674 yards and 40 touchdowns, rushed for 2,220 yards and 14 scores, and was later traded to Pittsburgh. He delivered real starting-quarterback value but did not become Chicago's long-term answer.

Philadelphia moved from No. 12 to No. 10 in the 2021 draft and selected DeVonta Smith, while Dallas moved back and chose Micah Parsons before adding Chauncey Golston with the extra third-round pick. Smith became a foundational Eagles receiver and championship contributor. Parsons developed into an elite pass rusher, giving Dallas the strongest individual asset while both teams received major value.

Minnesota moved from No. 14 to No. 23 in 2021 and received two third-round picks, selecting Christian Darrisaw, Kellen Mond and Wyatt Davis. Darrisaw became a high-level starting left tackle and earned an extension through 2029; Mond and Davis failed to stick. New York used No. 14 on Alijah Vera-Tucker, a versatile starting lineman whose career has been repeatedly interrupted by major injuries. Darrisaw plus the additional opportunities keep Minnesota ahead.

Chicago moved from No. 20 to No. 11 in the 2021 draft for Justin Fields, sending New York pick 164 plus first- and fourth-rounders in 2022. Fields gave the Bears three seasons of starting quarterback play but never became their long-term answer. New York's haul included Kadarius Toney, Evan Neal and Daniel Bellinger; uneven results kept the package from becoming a windfall, but the Giants retained more aggregate value.

Denver acquired quarterback Teddy Bridgewater from Carolina for a 2021 sixth-round pick, with the Panthers also absorbing part of his salary. Bridgewater became the Broncos' primary starter in 2021 and delivered credible veteran quarterback play at a minimal acquisition cost. Carolina recovered only a late pick after moving on from him. Denver did not find a permanent solution, but the one-season return easily justified the price.

Kansas City acquired Orlando Brown Jr., a second-round pick that became Nick Bolton, and later pick value from Baltimore for a package built around the No. 31 pick. Brown gave the Chiefs immediate left tackle help, started on a Super Bowl champion, and Bolton became a major defensive piece. Baltimore got useful value with Odafe Oweh, but Kansas City landed the stronger championship-era return.

Miami sent guard Ereck Flowers and the 2021 seventh-round pick at No. 258 to Washington, receiving the No. 244 selection in return. The Dolphins gained modest draft position and moved Flowers' contract, but the pick used on Gerrid Doaks did not create value comparable to Flowers' immediate starting role in Washington. Miami's practical return was limited, supporting a C grade.

Carolina acquired quarterback Sam Darnold from the Jets for a 2021 sixth-round pick plus second- and fourth-round selections in 2022. The Panthers also exercised Darnold's fifth-year option, increasing the commitment to a quarterback who never became their long-term answer. New York converted a player it was replacing into substantial draft capital, including a premium second-rounder, making the Jets the decisive winner.

San Francisco sent Miami the No. 12 pick in 2021, first-round picks in 2022 and 2023, and a 2022 third-rounder to move up to No. 3 for Trey Lance. Lance started only four games for the 49ers before they traded him to Dallas for a 2024 fourth. Miami immediately recycled No. 12 in another trade and retained enormous additional capital. The quarterback gamble failed, making the Dolphins the overwhelming winner.

Miami moved from No. 12 to No. 6 and selected Jaylen Waddle, who immediately became a premier offensive weapon. Philadelphia moved down, added a future first-round pick, and retained enough flexibility to move back up for DeVonta Smith before using the broader asset chain in later roster-building moves. Both teams converted the deal into cornerstone value.

Minnesota acquired interior lineman Mason Cole from Arizona for the 223rd pick in the 2021 draft. Cole appeared in 14 games and started seven for the Vikings, providing useful center and guard depth. Arizona selected Tay Gowan at No. 223 and later included him in the Zach Ertz trade, giving both clubs some value.

Cincinnati received No. 202 and selected Chris Evans. Evans provided the Bengals a direct roster return from the sixth-round choice, giving Cincinnati useful value from a relatively small exchange. That outcome supports a B grade within the Cincinnati Bengals Win verdict. The grade reflects realized football value rather than the size of the original package.

Baltimore Ravens received Josh Oliver in the exchange with Jacksonville Jaguars. Josh Oliver became a useful Baltimore tight end and started nine games in 2022 while contributing 149 receiving yards and two touchdowns. Against Jacksonville Jaguars' return of 2022 7th round pick (235th overall subsequently traded, Daniel Hardy), that outcome supports a B grade. The transaction is judged as Baltimore Ravens Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Houston Texans received Ryan Izzo in the 2021-03-18 exchange involving New England Patriots. Izzo did not make Houston's regular-season roster in 2021 and was waived at the final cutdown, leaving the Texans without regular-season production from the player they acquired. That realized return supports a D grade for Houston Texans. The overall verdict is New England Patriots Win, with the grade based on direct value created from this transaction.

The Matthew Stafford-Jared Goff trade is one of the rare NFL blockbusters where both teams can claim victory. The Rams got a Super Bowl quarterback. The Lions got Jared Goff, major draft value, and the foundation for a new competitive era. Los Angeles won the immediate bet, while Detroit won the broader reset. It stands out because the Rams got the championship payoff and the Lions still turned the return into lasting roster value.

Seattle acquired veteran guard Gabe Jackson from Las Vegas in March 2021 for the 167th selection in that year’s draft. Jackson immediately filled a starting-line need and gave the Seahawks experienced interior protection. Seattle received legitimate short-term value, but the player chosen with the outgoing pick, Nate Hobbs, developed into a much more valuable long-term asset for the Raiders.

Atlanta Falcons received Lee Smith from Buffalo Bills. Smith filled a short-term role, appearing in 16 games with six starts during the 2021 season and giving Atlanta the veteran blocking presence it sought. The C+ grade reflects the direct value Atlanta Falcons realized from the transaction, with the final Buffalo Bills Win call based on actual service and clearly traceable draft outcomes rather than projected value.

Detroit Lions received Michael Brockers from Los Angeles Rams. Brockers played 22 regular-season games with 21 starts over two Detroit seasons, giving the Lions substantial immediate veteran service for a minimal acquisition cost. The B grade reflects the direct value Detroit Lions realized from the transaction, with the final Detroit Lions Win call based on actual service and clearly traceable draft outcomes rather than projected value.

Philadelphia turned a deteriorated Carson Wentz situation into a 2021 third-round pick and a conditional 2022 selection that became a first-rounder after Wentz met the playing-time threshold in Indianapolis. The Eagles escaped the quarterback relationship, gained valuable draft flexibility and avoided needing Wentz to rebound for the transaction to work. Extracting a first-round return after his disastrous 2020 season made the outcome especially favorable.

Jacksonville Jaguars received Malcom Brown from New Orleans Saints, giving up 2021 7th round pick (229th overall subsequently traded, Mike Strachan). Jacksonville's March 17 acquisition date is supportable, and the pick can be followed to No. 229. The return supports a B grade because the value directly tied to this deal fits that mark. The final verdict is Jacksonville Jaguars Win.

Miami acquired Isaiah Wilson and a 2022 seventh-round selection that ultimately became Skylar Thompson. Wilson was waived only three days after the trade, but Thompson later started NFL games for Miami and gave the club meaningful value from the future pick. The B- grade reflects that mixed package and a modest edge in realized return over Tennessee.

Miami acquired linebacker Benardrick McKinney and pick No. 231 from Houston for edge defender Shaq Lawson and pick No. 203. Neither veteran produced regular-season value for his new club, leaving the late-round selections to carry much of the comparison. Miami eventually used No. 231 on tackle Larnel Coleman, giving the Dolphins at least one realized player return from the exchange.

Houston acquired Marcus Cannon plus 2021 picks No. 158 and No. 195 from New England for picks No. 122 and No. 188. Cannon is a separate direct player asset, and later pick movement must remain downstream provenance. The Texans gained a veteran tackle and draft capital, while New England retained meaningful selections, leaving the trade close to balanced in hindsight.

Las Vegas Raiders received 2022 5th round pick (164th overall; subsequently traded by Las Vegas) in the 2021-03-17 exchange with New England Patriots. Las Vegas received a fifth-round asset but did not turn that return into value comparable to the starting tackle it sent away. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Las Vegas Raiders surrendered, the result supports New England Patriots Win and a C grade for Las Vegas Raiders.

Arizona acquired veteran center Rodney Hudson and a seventh-round pick from Las Vegas for the 79th selection in the 2021 draft. Hudson gave the Cardinals two seasons of experienced center play but missed time and retired after 2022. The Raiders used No. 79 on Malcolm Koonce, who developed into an eight-sack edge defender in 2023, later returned from injury, and re-signed with Las Vegas. The younger, longer-lasting return gives the Raiders the win.

Miami acquired running back DeAndre Washington and a 2021 seventh-round pick from Kansas City for a 2021 sixth-round selection. Washington served only a brief depth role for the Dolphins. Kansas City improved its draft position by one round, while Miami gained immediate backfield insurance and retained a late selection, leaving modest realized value on each side.

Miami traded receiver Isaiah Ford to New England at the 2020 deadline for a conditional 2022 sixth-round pick. Ford caught only a handful of passes for the Patriots and was waived roughly a month later, after which Miami reclaimed him. The Dolphins therefore recovered the player while also retaining the draft compensation that was ultimately conveyed, turning a short-term roster move into a clear value gain.

Los Angeles traded Desmond King to Tennessee for the 2021 sixth-round pick later used on Nick Niemann. King helped the Titans only for the remainder of 2020 before leaving, while Niemann gave the Chargers four seasons of regular special-teams service. The pick produced the longer club return, so Los Angeles earns the moderate hindsight win.

New York sent Avery Williamson and a 2022 seventh-round pick to Pittsburgh for a 2022 fifth-rounder. The Jets later moved that fifth-round selection again, so the return was primarily extra draft flexibility during a rebuilding season rather than a player who directly became part of the roster. Moving a veteran on an expiring deal made sense, but the eventual value was modest.

San Francisco traded Kwon Alexander to New Orleans for Kiko Alonso and a conditional fifth-round pick that became Deommodore Lenoir in 2021. Alonso supplied no playing return, but Lenoir developed into a long-term member of the secondary and earned a major extension. That direct draft outcome gives the 49ers the stronger lasting value from the exchange.

Dallas Cowboys Dallas acquired defensive lineman Eli Ankou as short-term depth. His contribution was limited, but he gave the Cowboys an immediate roster option during the 2020 season. The supported hindsight grade is C. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against Houston Texans, the final verdict is Even Trade.

Seattle acquired Carlos Dunlap from Cincinnati for lineman B.J. Finney and a 2021 seventh-round pick. Dunlap immediately helped revive the Seahawks' pass rush, posting five sacks after the trade and 8.5 more in 2021 for 13.5 sacks across 25 games. Cincinnati received little from Finney and used the pick on Wyatt Hubert, who never played after a pectoral injury and later retired. Seattle won decisively at a very small cost.

Dallas Cowboys received 2021 6th round pick (192nd overall, Quinton Bohanna) in the exchange with Detroit Lions. Its D+ grade reflects the practical value of that return relative to the package surrendered and the hindsight result. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Arizona Cardinals received Markus Golden in the 2020-10-23 exchange, while New York Giants received 2021 6th round pick (201st overall, Rodarius Williams). Arizona reacquired Markus Golden and received useful pass-rush production after bringing him back. The Cardinals paid a 2021 sixth-round pick, but Golden’s on-field contribution made the veteran acquisition worthwhile and supports the strongest grade in this wave.

Minnesota sent Yannick Ngakoue to Baltimore after only six games, receiving a 2021 third-round pick and a conditional 2022 fifth. The Ravens got three sacks in nine regular-season games before Ngakoue left in free agency. Minnesota used the third-rounder on Patrick Jones II, who recorded 12 sacks across four Vikings seasons, including seven in 2024, while the fifth became part of later draft movement. The Vikings clearly recovered more value.

New York Jets received the 2022 No. 207 pick, which New York traded to Houston for Shaq Lawson; Lawson played 14 games with seven starts for the Jets in 2021, recording 23 tackles, one sack and one interception. The return earns a C+, versus B for San Francisco 49ers, with a hindsight verdict of San Francisco 49ers Win. Concrete team-specific production and downstream results drive the grade.

Tampa Bay acquired veteran nose tackle Steve McLendon and a 2023 seventh-round pick from the Jets for a 2022 sixth-round selection. McLendon immediately joined a Buccaneers defense that finished the 2020 season by winning Super Bowl LV, giving Tampa useful veteran depth during a championship run. New York improved the timing and round of its draft asset, but the title-season contribution gives the Buccaneers the edge.

Jacksonville received linebacker Kamalei Correa plus Tennessee's 2021 seventh-round pick while surrendering a 2021 sixth-rounder. Correa's Jaguars stay was brief, but the club added a veteran and still retained later draft capital. Moving down only one round for that combination gave Jacksonville the slightly stronger practical return.

Miami acquired rookie Lynn Bowden Jr. and a 2021 sixth-round pick from Las Vegas for a 2021 fourth-round selection only months after the Raiders drafted Bowden in the third round. Bowden produced 211 receiving yards and 32 rushing yards for Miami in 2020 but did not become a long-term Dolphin. Las Vegas recouped the more valuable future pick, giving the Raiders a modest win.

Cincinnati acquired defensive lineman Christian Covington from Denver for linebacker Austin Calitro on September 4, 2020. The trade contained no picks, cash, or additional players. Covington gave the Bengals a more useful short-term defensive return than Denver received from Calitro, creating a clear but limited Cincinnati edge in a low-cost swap between depth players.

Cleveland Browns received Ronnie Harrison from Jacksonville Jaguars, giving up 2021 5th round pick (170th overall subsequently traded, Garret Wallow). The fifth-round return can be followed to No. 170 before a later move. The return supports a B- grade because the value directly tied to this deal fits that mark. The final verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Denver received a 2021 seventh-round pick that became No. 239 Jonathon Cooper. Cooper developed into a multi-year Broncos starter and productive pass rusher, turning a late-round selection into substantial roster value well beyond the usual expectation for that draft slot. That outcome supports an A- grade for Denver Broncos within the final Denver Broncos Win verdict.

Las Vegas received Washington's 2021 sixth-round selection, No. 203, after sending David Sharpe and a seventh-rounder to Washington. The Raiders later moved that sixth in another transaction, so that later return is separate from this deal. The direct asset had value, but it did not create a clear Raiders contribution that outweighed Washington's immediate tackle depth plus the extra pick.

Buffalo Bills and Carolina Panthers completed this transaction on 2020-08-31, with Buffalo Bills receiving Andre Smith and Carolina Panthers receiving a conditional 2023 pick (7th round and not conveyed). The cited historical sources support the basic exchange and its compensation. In hindsight, Buffalo Bills gets the better grade because its return produced the clearer practical value from this modest exchange.

Minnesota acquired Yannick Ngakoue from Jacksonville for a 2021 second-round pick and conditional 2022 fifth, but the experiment lasted only six games. Ngakoue recorded five sacks before the Vikings traded him to Baltimore for a third and conditional fifth, recovering much of the cost. Jacksonville used the second-rounder on Walker Little, who developed into a starting tackle and earned an extension in 2024. The Jaguars won, though Minnesota's successful salvage keeps the loss from being severe.

Las Vegas acquired linebacker Raekwon McMillan and a 2021 fifth-round pick from Miami for a 2021 fourth-round selection. McMillan played one season for the Raiders, appearing in all 16 games but starting only four before leaving in free agency. Miami improved its draft position by roughly a round while moving a player nearing the end of his rookie deal, giving the Dolphins the better direct return.

Detroit Lions received conditional 2022 seventh-round pick (not conveyed) from New England Patriots. Detroit’s return was a conditional 2022 seventh-round pick, and the condition was never satisfied. The pick was not conveyed, so the Lions received no realized draft value from the transaction. That outcome supports a D grade for Detroit Lions when the trade is measured by the football value actually realized after the exchange.

Chicago Bears received 2021 6th round pick (208th overall subsequently traded, Stone Forsythe) from Miami Dolphins, giving up Adam Shaheen. The conditional choice improved to a sixth-rounder and became No. 208. The return supports a C+ grade because the value directly tied to this deal fits that mark. The final verdict is Miami Dolphins Win.

The Jamal Adams trade became one of the most lopsided modern safety deals. Seattle paid two first-round picks, a third-round pick, and Bradley McDougald for Adams and a fourth-round pick. Adams flashed early, but injuries and positional value crushed the return. The Jets won by turning one safety into premium roster-building power. It is a GSC priority page because the trade remains one of the easiest modern blockbuster losses for fans to search and understand.

Miami traded former first-round edge rusher Charles Harris to Atlanta for a 2021 seventh-round pick. Harris produced three sacks in 13 games for the Falcons in 2020 before leaving in free agency, so Atlanta received a modest one-year contribution. Miami recovered late-round draft capital from a player it no longer planned to keep. Neither side created enough lasting value to establish a meaningful advantage.

Dallas sent Philadelphia the 164th pick and a 2021 fifth-rounder to move up to No. 146 for center Tyler Biadasz. Biadasz became a multi-year starter, started 49 games for the Cowboys, and earned a Pro Bowl selection after the 2022 season. Philadelphia retained useful draft flexibility and moved the returned selections again, but Dallas secured a dependable starting center at a clear position of need.

Houston Texans received 2021 6th round pick (212th overall subsequently traded, Damar Hamlin) from New Orleans Saints, sending 2020 7th round pick (240th overall, Tommy Stevens) the other way. The Texans retained useful follow-on trade value, while New Orleans received little from Stevens, favoring Houston. That outcome supports a B- grade for Houston Texans, and the overall verdict is Houston Texans Win.

Indianapolis traded the 182nd pick to New England for selections 212 and 213, using them on Dezmon Patmon and Jordan Glasgow. The Patriots selected Michael Onwenu at No. 182. Patmon and Glasgow filled limited roles, while Onwenu became one of New England's best offensive linemen, starting at guard and tackle and eventually earning a multi-year contract to remain with the Patriots. New England won decisively.

Miami sent Houston picks No. 136 and No. 141 to move up to No. 111 for guard Solomon Kindley. Kindley started 13 games as a rookie but did not become a long-term Dolphins starter. Houston used No. 141 on John Reid and packaged No. 136 in another trade that moved the Texans to No. 126 for tackle Charlie Heck. That downstream flexibility produced the stronger overall return.

Miami sent the 153rd pick in the 2020 draft to San Francisco for running back Matt Breida. Breida played one Dolphins season, rushing for 254 yards on 59 carries and adding 96 receiving yards. The 49ers used No. 153 on Colton McKivitz, who developed into their starting right tackle and later earned an extension through 2028. That longevity makes San Francisco the clear winner.

Miami moved from No. 173 to No. 164 by sending Philadelphia an additional seventh-round pick at No. 227, then selected edge rusher Curtis Weaver. Weaver was waived before playing a regular-season game for the Dolphins. Philadelphia immediately repackaged picks 173 and 227 to Chicago for three later choices, helping produce multiple roster players. The Eagles therefore extracted more usable value from the exchange.

Minnesota traded picks No. 201 and No. 219 in the 2020 draft to Baltimore for No. 225 and a 2021 fifth-rounder. The Vikings selected Kenny Willekes and later Zach Davidson; Baltimore used its choices on James Proche and Geno Stone. Stone became the difference-maker, developing into a productive safety and recording a seven-interception season for Baltimore in 2023. Minnesota's return never approached that level of impact.

Minnesota turned a future fourth-round pick into safety Camryn Bynum after Chicago used the acquired 2020 fifth-rounder on edge rusher Trevis Gipson. Gipson supplied some pass-rush production during three Bears seasons, but Bynum became a full-time Vikings starter from 2022 through 2024, starting every regular-season game in that span and producing eight interceptions before leaving in free agency.

Indianapolis traded cornerback Quincy Wilson to the Jets during the 2020 draft for pick No. 211 and used the selection on Isaiah Rodgers. Wilson produced only a brief Jets tenure, while Rodgers developed into a multi-season contributor in Indianapolis before his later suspension and release. The Colts received substantially more usable football value from the transaction and earn a B- to D+ win.

Chicago moved up to No. 173 and selected Darnell Mooney, also receiving pick No. 227, while Philadelphia collected three later selections that became Shaun Bradley, Quez Watkins and Casey Toohill. Mooney quickly became a starting receiver and posted a 1,000-yard season in 2021. Philadelphia found role players, but none matched Mooney's sustained offensive production, leaving the Bears with the stronger return.

Las Vegas moved up from No. 121 to No. 109, sending Detroit an additional fifth-round pick at No. 172. The Raiders selected guard John Simpson, who developed into a starting offensive lineman and logged significant snaps before leaving the club. Detroit used the return on Logan Stenberg and Jason Huntley, but neither became a comparable long-term contributor for the Lions. The realized value favors Las Vegas.

Houston moved up 10 spots in the fourth round on April 25, 2020, sending picks No. 136, No. 248 and No. 250 to Los Angeles for No. 126. The Texans selected North Carolina tackle Charlie Heck, who became a four-year Houston contributor with 41 games and 21 starts. The Rams turned their three selections into Brycen Hopkins, Sam Sloman and Tremayne Anchrum, receiving depth across three roster spots and a notable Super Bowl contribution from Hopkins.

Miami gave Seattle the 251st pick in 2020 for Seattle's 2021 sixth-rounder, later identified as No. 208. Seattle selected Stephen Sullivan at 251, while the future pick moved through additional transactions before another team used it. Because neither side created notable direct value from the original assets, later movement should not distort the comparison. The trade grades as a modest, essentially even swap of late draft capital.

San Francisco moved Marquise Goodwin and pick No. 210 to Philadelphia for pick No. 190, then used No. 190 on tight end Charlie Woerner. Goodwin opted out of 2020 and his rights reverted to San Francisco in 2021, triggering an additional 2021 seventh-round pick to Philadelphia. Woerner gave the 49ers four seasons, 65 regular-season games and seven starts. Philadelphia got one regular-season game from No. 210 pick Prince Tega Wanogho, while the later seventh-round adjustment was bundled into subsequent pick trades. The realized franchise value favors San Francisco.

Tennessee turned Kansas City's 2020 seventh-round choice into the 2021 sixth-round pick used on safety Brady Breeze, who appeared in five games for the Titans before being waived. Kansas City used No. 237 on BoPete Keyes, who played eight games with one start and seven tackles as a rookie. Both returns were small, but Keyes gave the Chiefs the slightly stronger direct contribution.

San Francisco acquired Trent Williams from Washington for a 2020 fifth-round pick and a 2021 third after the seven-time Pro Bowler had missed the entire 2019 season. Williams became even better with the 49ers, earning three straight first-team All-Pro selections from 2021 through 2023 and another All-Pro honor in 2025. Washington received Keith Ismael and Benjamin St-Juste, who supplied starting snaps but nowhere near Williams' value. San Francisco won decisively.

Indianapolis sent picks 44 and 160 to Cleveland to move up three spots for Jonathan Taylor. Taylor has become one of the defining running backs of his era, totaling 7,598 rushing yards and 69 rushing touchdowns through 2025, with a unanimous first-team All-Pro season and NFL rushing title in 2021. Cleveland landed long-term starting safety Grant Delpit and reserve lineman Nick Harris, giving the Browns a strong return but not enough to match Taylor.

Indianapolis moved down from No. 75 to No. 85 in the 2020 draft and received picks No. 149 and No. 182. The Colts selected Julian Blackmon and Danny Pinter before later trading No. 182. Detroit used No. 75 on Jonah Jackson and No. 197 on John Penisini. Jackson became a high-level starting guard, while Blackmon developed into a multi-year starting safety.

Minnesota sent New Orleans pick No. 105, which became tight end Adam Trautman, and received four later selections that became James Lynch, Harrison Hand, Blake Brandel and Nate Stanley. Trautman developed into a useful Saints tight end, but Brandel became a long-term Vikings lineman and eventual starter, while Lynch and Hand added supporting snaps. Minnesota's broader return produced slightly more lasting value.

New England moved up for No. 60 and also received No. 129, sending Baltimore picks No. 71 and No. 98. The Patriots selected Joshua Uche at 60, while the Ravens landed Justin Madubuike at 71 and Malik Harrison at 98. Uche produced a breakout pass-rushing season, but Madubuike became a Pro Bowl and All-Pro defensive tackle and a long-term defensive cornerstone for Baltimore.

New Orleans moved up to No. 74 for linebacker Zack Baun and also received pick No. 244, while Cleveland acquired No. 88 and a 2021 third-rounder. Baun never became a full-time defensive centerpiece during four Saints seasons, and his later All-Pro breakthrough came after he left for Philadelphia. Cleveland received useful snaps from Jordan Elliott, but Anthony Schwartz added little, leaving the direct results close.

New England traded Nos. 125, 129 and a 2021 sixth-round pick to the Jets for No. 101 in the 2020 draft, then selected tight end Dalton Keene. The Patriots consolidated three selections to move up, but Keene never developed into a significant offensive contributor. The Jets gained volume with James Morgan, Cameron Clark and Hamsah Nasirildeen, yet their group also produced little durable value.

Las Vegas sent New England picks No. 91 and No. 159 for Nos. 100, 139 and 172. The Patriots drafted Devin Asiasi and Justin Rohrwasser, while the Raiders selected Tanner Muse and Amik Robertson before moving the 172nd pick. Muse did not last, but Robertson developed into a multi-year defensive contributor and starter. New England received little lasting value from either of its selections.

Seattle traded picks No. 59 and No. 101 to the Jets in the 2020 draft to move up to No. 48 for edge rusher Darrell Taylor. Taylor became a meaningful Seahawks pass-rush contributor, while New York used No. 59 on Denzel Mims and moved No. 101 again. Mims never became the receiver the Jets hoped for, so Seattle received the strongest direct player value. The Seahawks win B to C-.

The Chargers traded picks 37 and 71 to New England for No. 23 in the 2020 draft and selected linebacker Kenneth Murray. Murray became a multi-year starter, but Los Angeles declined his fifth-year option and he left after four seasons. New England selected safety Kyle Dugger at 37 and later moved pick 71. Dugger became a long-term defensive playmaker and earned a four-year extension, giving the Patriots the better return.

Green Bay traded picks No. 30 and No. 136 to Miami for No. 26 and selected quarterback Jordan Love. Miami took cornerback Noah Igbinoghene at No. 30 and later moved the fourth-rounder. Love developed behind Aaron Rodgers, became Green Bay's starter in 2023, led a playoff run, and earned a major extension, while Igbinoghene never became a long-term Dolphins starter.

San Francisco moved from No. 31 to No. 25 and selected Brandon Aiyuk, while Minnesota used the return on Jeff Gladney, D.J. Wonnum and K.J. Osborn. The Vikings extracted multiple useful players, especially Wonnum and Osborn, but Aiyuk became an All-Pro receiver with consecutive 1,000-yard seasons and a major extension. His top-end impact gives the 49ers a narrow but meaningful win.

Tampa Bay traded up one spot from No. 14 to No. 13 in the 2020 draft, sending San Francisco pick 117 and receiving pick 245. The Buccaneers selected tackle Tristan Wirfs, who quickly became an elite offensive lineman and a foundational piece of their championship offense. San Francisco took Javon Kinlaw at 14 and later used the extra fourth-round capital in the move that produced Brandon Aiyuk, but Wirfs remains the defining value.

Tampa Bay acquired Rob Gronkowski and a seventh-round pick from New England for a fourth-round selection after Gronkowski came out of retirement to reunite with Tom Brady. Gronkowski delivered 1,425 receiving yards and 13 touchdowns over two regular seasons and caught two touchdowns in Tampa Bay's Super Bowl LV victory. New England used the fourth-round asset in a larger trade-up that produced Devin Asiasi and Justin Rohrwasser, neither of whom became a comparable contributor. Tampa Bay won overwhelmingly.

Los Angeles sent Brandin Cooks and a 2022 fourth-round pick to Houston for the No. 57 selection in the 2020 draft, which became wide receiver Van Jefferson. Cooks gave the Texans two 1,000-yard seasons before another trade, while Jefferson became a regular contributor for the Rams and topped 800 yards during their Super Bowl LVI championship season. Both clubs realized meaningful value.

Carolina Panthers received 2020 5th round pick (148th overall subsequently traded, Alton Robinson) in the exchange with Washington. Carolina retained and redeployed the acquired fifth-round asset, preserving useful draft value rather than surrendering Kyle Allen without a return. Against Washington's return of Kyle Allen, that outcome supports a B grade. The transaction is judged as Carolina Panthers Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Seattle Seahawks received Quinton Dunbar in the exchange with Washington. Its C+ grade reflects the practical value of that return relative to the package surrendered and the hindsight result. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Pittsburgh sent Baltimore a 2021 fifth-round pick for defensive lineman Chris Wormley and a 2021 seventh-rounder. Wormley became a useful Steelers rotational lineman and produced a career-best seven sacks in 2021, while Pittsburgh used the seventh-round selection on punter Pressley Harvin III. Baltimore moved the fifth-round asset again, but its downstream return did not match the multi-season service Pittsburgh received from both incoming pieces.

Philadelphia acquired Darius Slay for third- and fifth-round picks. Slay became a multi-year No. 1 cornerback, earned additional Pro Bowl recognition, and helped lead a defense that reached the Super Bowl. Detroit received pick value that did not develop into comparable impact, making the modest acquisition cost especially favorable for the Eagles.

Denver acquired five-time Pro Bowler Jurrell Casey from Tennessee for a seventh-round pick, but the veteran played only three games for the Broncos before a season-ending biceps injury and was released the following February. Tennessee received very little draft value, yet it also moved an expensive veteran contract. With neither side realizing major on-field gains, the deal finishes much closer to even than Denver's acquisition-day bargain suggested.

Detroit acquired Duron Harmon plus No. 235, later used on Jashon Cornell. Harmon immediately became a full-time starter in 2020, starting all 16 games, playing nearly every defensive snap, making 73 tackles, and intercepting two passes. Cornell added only one Detroit appearance, but Harmon's one-season workload alone supplied substantial direct value and made the Lions' side productive.

Jacksonville traded Nick Foles to Chicago for the 140th pick in the 2020 draft, which became linebacker Shaquille Quarterman. The Jaguars escaped a quarterback situation that had collapsed after one injury-marred season and recovered a fourth-round asset. Chicago received a veteran challenger to Mitchell Trubisky, but Foles went 2-5 as a Bears starter in 2020 and never solved the franchise's quarterback problem.

Cleveland Browns Cleveland acquired fullback Andy Janovich, who played 27 games with six starts across two Browns seasons and supplied useful blocking, special-teams work, and offensive role value. The supported hindsight grade is B-. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against Denver Broncos, the final verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Arizona's trade for DeAndre Hopkins became one of the most lopsided modern NFL deals. The Cardinals acquired an elite wide receiver and a fourth-round pick while sending David Johnson and draft compensation to Houston. Hopkins immediately gave Arizona a true No. 1 target. Houston's return never came close. The trade still stands out because Arizona landed the best player in the deal without paying anything close to a normal superstar price.

Atlanta sent picks No. 55 and No. 157 to Baltimore for tight end Hayden Hurst and pick No. 134, which the Falcons used on Jaylinn Hawkins. Hurst gave Atlanta two productive seasons, but Baltimore used No. 55 on J.K. Dobbins and converted the fifth-rounder into additional trade value. The Ravens gained the stronger long-term return while Atlanta received a useful short-term starter.

Minnesota turned an unhappy-star situation into the No. 22 pick in 2020 and used it on Justin Jefferson, immediately replacing elite receiver production with a younger centerpiece on a rookie contract. The additional fifth-, sixth-, and future fourth-round assets deepened the return. Because Jefferson became a franchise-level receiver rather than merely a serviceable replacement, Minnesota achieved the rare outcome of trading away a star without losing the long-term talent battle.

Indianapolis sent the 13th pick in the 2020 draft to San Francisco for DeForest Buckner and immediately signed him long term. Buckner became a first-team All-Pro in his first Colts season, added Pro Bowl selections and recorded 43 sacks for Indianapolis through 2025. San Francisco moved from No. 13 to No. 14 for Javon Kinlaw and gained another pick used in later movement. Kinlaw never approached Buckner's impact, making this a clear Colts win.

Baltimore acquired Calais Campbell from Jacksonville for the 157th pick in the 2020 draft. Campbell spent three seasons with the Ravens, appearing in 41 games with 113 tackles, 11 sacks and 36 quarterback hits while making the 2020 Pro Bowl and serving as a defensive leader. Jacksonville used the fifth-round pick on safety Daniel Thomas, who became a durable special-teams contributor but only a spot defensive starter. Baltimore received considerably more impact.

Carolina and the Chargers agreed on a straight Russell Okung-for-Trai Turner swap on March 4, 2020, with the move processed when the league year opened on March 18. Both veterans provided limited one-season value for their new clubs. Neither side created a durable advantage, so the fairest hindsight result is an even trade with matching lower grades.

Denver Broncos received A.J. Bouye in the 2020-03-03 exchange, while Jacksonville Jaguars received 2020 4th round pick (137th overall, Josiah Scott). Denver acquired veteran cornerback A.J. Bouye for a 2020 fourth-round pick. The move addressed an immediate roster need, but the Broncos did not receive enough long-term value from Bouye to create a clear advantage.

Los Angeles sent injured cornerback Aqib Talib and a 2020 fifth-round pick to Miami for a 2022 seventh-rounder. The football purpose was largely financial: Talib was on injured reserve and the Rams wanted salary relief while reshaping the roster around Jalen Ramsey. Miami had abundant cap room and effectively accepted Talib’s contract to move from a distant seventh-round asset into a much more valuable fifth-round selection.

Arizona acquired Kenyan Drake for a conditional 2020 pick that became a fifth-rounder. Drake immediately erupted for 643 rushing yards and eight touchdowns in eight games, then added 955 rushing yards and 10 touchdowns in 2020. Miami later used the acquired pick in the Matt Breida trade, but Drake's two-season production gave Arizona the stronger direct football payoff.

The Giants acquired Leonard Williams from the Jets at the 2019 deadline for a 2020 third-round pick and a conditional 2021 fifth-rounder that became No. 154. Williams broke out with 11.5 sacks in 2020, signed a long-term extension and remained a major defensive-line presence for several seasons. The Jets used the selections on Ashtyn Davis and Michael Carter.

Philadelphia acquired edge defender Genard Avery from Cleveland on October 28, 2019 for the Eagles' 2021 fourth-round pick. Avery played 35 regular-season games for Philadelphia over the rest of 2019 through 2021, including 12 starts in 2021. Cleveland ultimately used the acquired pick, No. 110 overall, to draft offensive tackle James Hudson III.

Dallas Cowboys received Michael Bennett from New England Patriots, giving up 2021 6th round pick (195th overall subsequently traded, Roy Lopez). The conditional late-round return ultimately became 2021 sixth-round selection No. 195. The return supports a C+ grade because the value directly tied to this deal fits that mark. The final verdict is New England Patriots Win.

Atlanta traded Mohamed Sanu to New England for a 2020 second-round pick that settled at No. 55. The Falcons later packaged that selection in the Hayden Hurst trade and received Hurst plus a fourth-rounder. Sanu's Patriots tenure lasted only eight regular-season games and one playoff appearance before he was released the next year, making Atlanta's premium draft return clearly more valuable.

Denver sent Emmanuel Sanders and a 2020 fifth-round pick to San Francisco for third- and fourth-round selections. The Broncos used No. 95 on McTelvin Agim and later moved the fourth-rounder, but the resulting value never matched Sanders' immediate impact on a 49ers team that reached Super Bowl LIV. Denver gained useful rebuilding capital, yet San Francisco got the more consequential football return.

Houston acquired Gareon Conley for a 2020 third-round pick during a 2019 playoff push. Conley immediately started in an injury-hit secondary and appeared in the postseason, but his Texans tenure was short and injuries prevented a lasting return. The Raiders later used the acquired pick as part of a trade-down that generated three selections, giving Las Vegas more durable roster value.

The Rams acquired Jalen Ramsey from Jacksonville for first-round picks in 2020 and 2021 plus a 2021 fourth-rounder. Ramsey became an All-Pro centerpiece of Los Angeles' secondary and helped the Rams win Super Bowl LVI. Jacksonville turned the first-rounders into K'Lavon Chaisson and Travis Etienne, giving the Jaguars useful talent but not an equivalent defensive star.

The Rams traded cornerback Marcus Peters to Baltimore in October 2019 for linebacker Kenny Young and a 2020 fifth-round pick. Peters immediately strengthened a contending Ravens defense, intercepting five passes in nine regular-season games and earning first-team All-Pro recognition. Young developed into a useful Rams linebacker, including six starts in 2020, but his Los Angeles impact remained much smaller.

Los Angeles acquired guard Austin Corbett from Cleveland on October 15, 2019 for a 2021 fifth-round draft choice that became No. 169 overall, safety Richard LeCounte. Corbett quickly became a Rams starter, opening 40 of 41 regular-season games for Los Angeles from 2019 through 2021 and starting all four postseason games during the Rams' 2021 Super Bowl championship run.

Buffalo Bills traded Zay Jones to the Raiders for the 2021 fifth-round pick that became No. 161, Tommy Doyle. Doyle appeared in 12 regular-season games for Buffalo without a start, giving the Bills only modest depth value from the selection. Because Jones became a much larger contributor for the Raiders, Buffalo's return falls to a C in hindsight.

Atlanta acquired Johnathan Cyprien plus the 2020 seventh-round pick used on Sterling Hofrichter. Cyprien appeared in only one Falcons game before going to injured reserve, while Hofrichter handled the punting job for the full 2020 season. That gave Atlanta some direct roster value, but the package did not produce the same multi-season defensive contribution Philadelphia received from Duke Riley.

Seattle traded tight end Nick Vannett to Pittsburgh on September 25, 2019 for a 2020 fifth-round pick. Vannett supplied the Steelers with 13 games, six starts, 13 receptions and 128 yards that season, then left after the year. Seattle later used the acquired No. 162 selection in the trade for cornerback Quinton Dunbar, preserving additional transaction value from a departing depth player.

Green Bay Packers traded Trevor Davis to the Raiders for the 2020 sixth-round pick that became No. 192, Jon Runyan. Davis lasted only part of the 2019 season in Oakland, while Runyan developed into a durable Green Bay guard and started 50 games from 2021 through 2023. Converting a fringe return specialist into a multi-year starter earns Green Bay an A-.

Pittsburgh traded a 2020 first-rounder and smaller draft pieces for 22-year-old Minkah Fitzpatrick, receiving a 2020 fourth-rounder and 2021 seventh-rounder in return. Fitzpatrick immediately became the centerpiece of the secondary, earning first-team All-Pro honors and repeatedly delivering game-changing takeaways. The Steelers paid premium capital, but they acquired a proven young defensive star rather than merely hoping to draft one with the pick.

New England Patriots received 2021 6th round pick (186th overall subsequently traded, Hamsah Nasirildeen) in the deal with New York Jets. New England retained value by later including the sixth-round asset in the package used to move up for Dalton Keene. The pick therefore remained useful, though only as one component of a later move. That outcome supports a C+ for New England Patriots. The New York Jets Win verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Jacksonville Jaguars acquired Joshua Dobbs from Pittsburgh in 2019 for a 2020 fifth-round pick. Dobbs did not appear in a regular-season game for Jacksonville before returning to the Steelers the following year, so the Jaguars gained almost no direct on-field value. Giving up useful fifth-round capital for a backup quarterback who never played leaves Jacksonville with a D+.

Miami acquired linebacker Vince Biegel from New Orleans in a straight player swap for Kiko Alonso immediately after the 2019 roster cutdown. Biegel played 15 games, started 10, recorded 59 combined tackles, 2.5 sacks and an interception. Alonso played 13 games with four starts for the Saints before a serious postseason knee injury ended his season.

Green Bay Packers received B.J. Goodson, conditional 2020 7th round pick (not conveyed) from New York Giants in the 2019-09-02 trade. Green Bay acquired B.J. Goodson, who played 15 games and started nine for the 2019 Packers. New York Giants's return was conditional 2020 7th round pick (not conveyed). The conditional seventh-round picks on both sides were not conveyed, leaving New York without a realized draft asset from the swap. Those realized outcomes, rather than the labels on the assets alone, drive the hindsight grade.

Miami's Laremy Tunsil trade became one of the most valuable asset hauls of the modern era. Houston acquired a legitimate franchise left tackle and protected Deshaun Watson, so the Texans' side was not empty. But Miami extracted a massive premium, gained roster-building flexibility, and turned one elite tackle into the kind of pick package that can reshape a franchise. The verdict remains clear.

Seattle acquired Jadeveon Clowney from Houston for Jacob Martin, Barkevious Mingo and a 2020 third-round pick. Clowney played one season for the Seahawks, recording only three regular-season sacks but creating disruption beyond the sack total and producing a dominant playoff performance in Philadelphia. He left in free agency the next offseason. The short rental helped an 11-win playoff team, but Houston received more usable value than the original C grade implies.

Cleveland acquired wide receiver Taywan Taylor from Tennessee on August 31, 2019 for the Browns' 2020 seventh-round pick at No. 224. Taylor appeared in six regular-season games over two Cleveland seasons, including one start, and returned three kickoffs for 53 yards but did not record a reception.

Cleveland Browns received Justin McCray and 2020 7th round pick (244th overall subsequently traded, Nate Stanley) from Green Bay Packers, sending 2020 7th round pick (236th overall, Vernon Scott) the other way. Cleveland received useful 2019 starts, while Green Bay drafted Vernon Scott. That outcome supports a B- grade for Cleveland Browns, and the overall verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Houston acquired running back Carlos Hyde from Kansas City for offensive lineman Martinas Rankin just before the 2019 season. Hyde responded with the first 1,000-yard rushing season of his career, carrying 245 times for 1,070 yards and six touchdowns. Rankin supplied Kansas City with useful line depth and five starts during the Chiefs' championship season, but Houston received the larger immediate football return.

Miami acquired interior lineman Evan Boehm and a 2020 seventh-round pick from Indianapolis for a 2020 sixth-round selection shortly before the 2019 season. Boehm appeared in 13 games and started eight for the Dolphins, giving a rebuilding offensive line immediate veteran help. Indianapolis improved its draft position, but Miami received the more substantial direct football contribution.

Minnesota acquired cornerback Mark Fields from Kansas City on August 31, 2019, for a conditional 2021 seventh-round selection. The condition was never met, so the pick did not convey and the Chiefs ultimately received no draft asset. Fields provided the Vikings with short-term secondary depth, enough tangible value at zero realized draft cost to give Minnesota the edge.

Houston Texans received Keion Crossen. Keion Crossen gave Houston two full seasons of defensive and special-teams work, including multiple starts in 2020, producing the more durable contribution. That result supports a B- grade for Houston Texans. The final verdict is Houston Texans Win, based on the documented service, durability, and value each club actually obtained from this exchange.

Pittsburgh sent Jerald Hawkins and a 2021 seventh-round pick to Tampa Bay for a 2021 sixth-round pick. The selections became Quincy Roche at No. 216 for Pittsburgh and Chris Wilcox at No. 251 for Tampa Bay. None of the principal returns produced enough sustained value to create meaningful separation, leaving the deal close to even.

New York traded cornerback Parry Nickerson to Seattle on August 31, 2019, for a conditional 2021 seventh-round pick. The condition was not met, so the Jets did not receive the selection. Nickerson lasted only briefly on Seattle's active roster and did not create meaningful regular-season value, leaving both clubs with little to show from the exchange.

Buffalo Bills traded center Russell Bodine to New England for the 2020 sixth-round pick that became No. 207, Isaiah Hodgins. The Patriots released Bodine only days later and he never played a regular-season snap for them. Hodgins had a limited Buffalo role but still gave the Bills roster value from an asset they acquired for a player New England immediately discarded, earning Buffalo a B-.

Cleveland ultimately received the 2022 seventh-round selection at No. 223 and used it on Isaiah Thomas. Thomas appeared in 10 Browns games in 2022, recorded one sack, and made no starts. That gave Cleveland some reserve defensive-line value, but the contribution was limited and did not match the quarterback starts Detroit received from David Blough.

Denver Broncos received Duke Dawson; 2020 7th round pick (237th overall subsequently traded, Thakarius Keyes) in the exchange with New England Patriots. Duke Dawson appeared in 26 Denver games with four starts, and the Broncos also received a seventh-round selection that retained some downstream value. Against New England Patriots' return of 2020 6th round pick (195th overall, Justin Herron), that outcome supports a C+ grade. The transaction is judged as New England Patriots Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Miami acquired guard Danny Isidora from Minnesota on the eve of 2019 final roster cuts for a 2020 seventh-round selection. Isidora gave the Dolphins inexpensive interior-line depth and saw meaningful action during the season. Minnesota recovered a future late-round asset for a player outside its core plans and later moved that selection again, but Miami received the clearer direct playing contribution from the original exchange.

Buffalo traded Wyatt Teller and a 2021 seventh-round pick to Cleveland for 2020 fifth- and sixth-round selections. Teller became an elite guard for the Browns, earning repeated Pro Bowl and All-Pro recognition. Buffalo’s return was far better than the original grade suggests, however: the fifth-rounder was included in the Stefon Diggs package and the sixth-rounder became kicker Tyler Bass. Cleveland still landed the best direct player, but both teams created major value.

Green Bay received the 2020 sixth-round pick at No. 208 and selected Jake Hanson. Green Bay turned the compensation into the 208th pick in the 2020 draft and selected Jake Hanson. Hanson gave the Packers only limited playing time, so the choice never became a meaningful long-term return. A sixth-round pick still carried useful optionality, but the realized football value remained modest. In hindsight, that result supports a C grade for Green Bay Packers in a deal ultimately judged as Houston Oilers/Tennessee Titans Win.

Indianapolis sent cornerback Nate Hairston to New York for a conditional 2020 sixth-round pick. The condition was not satisfied, so the draft choice was never conveyed and the Colts ultimately received no draft asset from the transaction. The New York Jets produced the stronger realized return, supporting the New York Jets Win verdict.

Baltimore received New England's 2020 fourth-round choice, which ultimately became the No. 129 slot before being moved again. That was the most valuable single piece in the transaction and gave the Ravens stronger draft capital to work with. That result supports a B- grade within the Baltimore Ravens Win verdict.

Arizona received the 2020 sixth-round pick at No. 202 and selected Evan Weaver. Arizona received the 2020 sixth-round pick at No. 202 and used it on Evan Weaver. Weaver did not produce regular-season value for the Cardinals, so the draft return never translated into an on-field payoff. The pick had theoretical value on the day of the trade, but its realized return was minimal. In hindsight, that result supports a D+ grade for Arizona Cardinals in a deal ultimately judged as New England Patriots Win.

Philadelphia acquired safety Rudy Ford from Arizona for defensive tackle Bruce Hector on August 22, 2019. Ford became a useful Eagles reserve and special-teams player, while Hector's stay with Arizona was brief. In hindsight, the grades are C for Arizona Cardinals and B- for Philadelphia Eagles, producing a Philadelphia Eagles Win verdict. The modest scoring reflects the limited scale of the transaction.

Minnesota sent Baltimore a 2020 fifth-round pick for kicker-punter Kaare Vedvik after his strong 2019 preseason. Vedvik struggled after the trade and was waived before the regular season, so he never appeared in a game for the Vikings. Baltimore converted a specialist unlikely to make its roster into draft capital that later became defensive tackle Broderick Washington.

Buffalo received Ryan Bates; Philadelphia received Eli Harold. Buffalo acquired Ryan Bates in the preseason swap and developed him into a versatile lineman who eventually started meaningful games and earned a four-year contract. Philadelphia released Eli Harold before he delivered regular-season value for the Eagles. The hindsight grades are B+ for Buffalo Bills and D for Philadelphia Eagles, producing a Buffalo Bills Win verdict.

Cleveland Browns received 2020 3rd round pick (97th overall, Jacob Phillips) in the 2019-08-08 exchange, while Houston Texans received Duke Johnson. Cleveland received a conditional 2020 selection that escalated to the third round and ultimately became No. 97, Jacob Phillips. The pick was meaningful capital, but Phillips had a limited Browns career and did not match Houston’s realized player value.

Baltimore Ravens received 2020 7th round pick (225th overall subsequently traded, Kenny Willekes) in the 2019-08-05 exchange involving New York Jets. Baltimore received late-round draft capital for a player it was ready to move, but the return stayed at the low end of the draft-value spectrum. That realized return supports a C grade for Baltimore Ravens. The overall verdict is New York Jets Win, with the grade based on direct value created from this transaction.

Kansas City acquired linebacker Darron Lee from the New York Jets in May 2019 for a 2020 sixth-round pick. Lee appeared in all 16 regular-season games for the Chiefs and played a rotational defensive and special-teams role on the Super Bowl LIV championship team. New York converted a former first-round pick who was no longer in its plans into late-round draft capital.

Chicago Bears received Eddy Pineiro in the 2019-05-06 exchange involving Las Vegas/Oakland Raiders. Pineiro handled Chicago's kicking job throughout 2019, making 23 of 28 field goals and 27 of 29 extra points and giving the Bears a usable starter for the season. That realized return supports a C+ grade for Chicago Bears. The overall verdict is Chicago Bears Win, with the grade based on direct value created from this transaction.

Seattle acquired tight end Jacob Hollister from New England on April 29, 2019 for a 2020 seventh-round pick. Hollister became a useful receiving option, catching 66 passes for 558 yards and six touchdowns across the next two Seahawks seasons. New England later included pick No. 241 with Rob Gronkowski’s rights in the 2020 Tampa Bay trade, so the Patriots did recover transactional value from the selection.

Atlanta moved up to No. 111 and selected Kendall Sheffield. Sheffield gave the Falcons real defensive-back snaps and some useful service, so the trade was not a failure for Atlanta. The issue is that the single higher selection did not ultimately outproduce Detroit's two-player return. That result supports a C- grade within the Detroit Lions Win verdict.

Cincinnati sent picks No. 149 and No. 213 to Dallas to move up for guard Michael Jordan at No. 136. Jordan made starts during two Bengals seasons but did not become a long-term fixture. Dallas used No. 213 on Donovan Wilson and later turned No. 149 into additional draft capital, giving the Cowboys a multiyear starting safety and the stronger overall return.

Dallas sent 2019 fifth-round No. 149 to Oakland, which used the pick on Hunter Renfrow, for fifth-round No. 158 Michael Jackson and seventh-round No. 218 Mike Weber. Renfrow became a productive Raiders slot receiver and Pro Bowl-level contributor, while Dallas received far less lasting value from its two selections. Oakland clearly won the exchange.

Denver Broncos received Dekoda Watson; 2019 6th round pick (212th overall subsequently traded, Dennis Daley) from San Francisco 49ers, giving up 2019 5th round pick (148th overall, Dre Greenlaw). Denver received Dekoda Watson and a late sixth-round choice. The return proved limited compared with the value San Francisco created from No. 148, so the Broncos receive an F on this specific exchange. That return supports a F grade for Denver Broncos. The final verdict is San Francisco 49ers Win.

Carolina Panthers received the 2019 sixth- and seventh-round picks that became Dennis Daley and Terry Godwin after Denver moved up for Juwann Winfree. Daley supplied 34 games and 21 starts for Carolina, giving the Panthers a tangible multi-season return from a modest draft-day move. That useful starting experience is enough for a B grade and the winning side.

Indianapolis traded defensive tackle Hassan Ridgeway to Philadelphia during the 2019 draft for the No. 246 selection. The Colts used that seventh-round pick on offensive lineman Javon Patterson, who spent his rookie season on injured reserve and never appeared in a regular-season game for Indianapolis. Patterson later played one NFL game for Cleveland, leaving the Colts with virtually no realized return.

Minnesota moved up six spots in the fourth round of the 2019 draft, sending Seattle picks No. 120 and No. 204 for No. 114 and selecting guard Dru Samia. Samia never secured a lasting Vikings role. Seattle got little from Gary Jennings, but Travis Homer became a useful reserve running back and core special-teams contributor over four seasons.

Minnesota moved from pick No. 159 to No. 162 in the 2019 draft and added No. 239, selecting Cameron Smith and Dillon Mitchell. New England used No. 159 on defensive tackle Byron Cowart. Cowart played 19 games for the Patriots and started 14 in 2020, while Minnesota received limited football value from its two selections. New England won the small draft-day exchange.

New England Patriots received 2019 5th round pick (163rd overall, Jake Bailey) in the 2019-04-27 exchange with Philadelphia Eagles. Jake Bailey became a Pro Bowl and first-team All-Pro punter for New England, giving the Patriots unusually strong realized value from a fifth-round selection. The direct package is the basis for the hindsight grade, with later movement of an acquired selection treated separately. That supports New England Patriots Win.

New Orleans moved from No. 116 to No. 105 in the fourth round of the 2019 draft, sending the Jets picks No. 116 and No. 168. The Saints selected C.J. Gardner-Johnson, who developed into a versatile slot defender and safety and gave New Orleans three productive seasons before a later trade sent him to Philadelphia. That impact comfortably exceeded the modest cost of moving up eleven spots.

New York received picks No. 121 and No. 157 from Tennessee and selected Trevon Wesco and Blake Cashman. Wesco filled a blocking and special-teams role, while Cashman's Jets tenure was repeatedly interrupted before he later found greater success elsewhere. Tennessee used No. 116 on Amani Hooker, who became a multiyear starting safety, giving the Titans the stronger team-specific return.

Indianapolis sent picks No. 129 and No. 135 to Oakland to move up for safety Khari Willis at No. 109. Willis started regularly for three seasons and gave the Colts solid defensive value before retiring in 2022. Oakland's two picks ultimately produced Isaiah Johnson plus the trade capital that became Foster Moreau and Quinton Bell, keeping the overall return competitive.

Atlanta sent picks No. 137 and No. 230 to Oakland to move up two spots for John Cominsky at No. 135. Cominsky showed useful versatility but never became a major Falcons starter and later found a larger role after leaving Atlanta. Oakland selected Foster Moreau at No. 137, and his four productive Raiders seasons make the trade-down side more valuable.

Las Vegas Raiders received 2019 5th round pick (149th overall, Hunter Renfrow) in the 2019-04-27 exchange with Dallas Cowboys. Hunter Renfrow became a Pro Bowl receiver, topped 1,000 receiving yards in a season, and developed into one of the Raiders' most productive later-round selections of the era. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Las Vegas Raiders surrendered, the result supports Las Vegas Raiders Win and a A- grade for Las Vegas Raiders.

Los Angeles sent two fifth-round picks to New England for No. 134 and No. 243, selecting Greg Gaines and Nick Scott. Both became meaningful contributors, and each played a role on the Rams' Super Bowl LVI championship team. New England moved the two fifth-rounders onward, but the Rams' direct conversion of the acquired picks into two useful defenders creates a clear advantage.

Cincinnati Bengals received 2019 4th round pick (104th overall, Ryan Finley) in the 2019-04-27 exchange with San Francisco 49ers. Ryan Finley had only a brief run as a Bengals quarterback and did not create sustained value from the move up. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Cincinnati Bengals surrendered, the result supports San Francisco 49ers Win and a D+ grade for Cincinnati Bengals.

Buffalo moved up two spots in the 2019 second round for offensive lineman Cody Ford, sending the Raiders No. 40 and No. 158. Ford started 29 games for Buffalo before being traded away. The Raiders selected cornerback Trayvon Mullen at No. 40 and used No. 158 as part of the move that produced receiver Hunter Renfrow.

Buffalo sent two fourth-round picks to Washington to move up for tight end Dawson Knox at No. 96. Knox became a long-term starter in the Bills' Josh Allen offense and earned a multiyear extension after developing into a reliable receiving and red-zone option. Washington selected Bryce Love and Wes Martin, but neither produced comparable sustained value for the franchise.

Chicago moved from No. 87 to No. 73 in the 2019 draft for David Montgomery and also received pick No. 205, used on Duke Shelley. Montgomery became the Bears’ lead back for four seasons, topping 800 rushing yards every year and producing more than 4,800 yards from scrimmage in Chicago. New England received Damien Harris plus additional draft capital, making the price meaningful but still worthwhile for the Bears.

Denver traded picks No. 52, No. 125 and No. 182 to Cincinnati to move up to No. 42 for quarterback Drew Lock. Lock started 21 games for the Broncos but never secured the franchise job and later became part of the Russell Wilson trade. Cincinnati turned the return into Drew Sample, Renell Wren and Trayveon Williams, getting longer aggregate service despite no star outcome.

Jacksonville moved from No. 38 to No. 35 in the 2019 draft and added later picks, selecting tackle Jawaan Taylor at No. 35, Ryquell Armstead at No. 140 and Dontavius Russell at No. 235. The Raiders received Nos. 38 and 109 and moved those choices again. Taylor became a four-year starting right tackle for Jacksonville, giving the Jaguars the clearest realized value.

Miami traded down from No. 48 and received No. 62, No. 202 and a 2020 second-rounder. The Dolphins later used No. 62 in the Josh Rosen deal, drafted Isaiah Prince at 202 and selected Raekwon Davis at No. 56 in 2020. Those returns produced some value, but they did not match New Orleans' long-term payoff from Erik McCoy.

Miami traded the 62nd pick in 2019 and a 2020 fifth-rounder to Arizona for quarterback Josh Rosen, betting that the previous year’s No. 10 pick could rebound in a new setting. Rosen started only three games for the Dolphins, threw one touchdown against five interceptions and was waived before the 2020 season. Arizona used No. 62 on Andy Isabella and later recycled the fifth-round asset in the Kenyan Drake trade.

Seattle moved up from No. 92 to No. 88 in the third round of the 2019 draft and also received No. 209. Minnesota received No. 92 and fifth-rounder No. 159. The Seahawks selected linebacker Cody Barton at 88 and defensive tackle Demarcus Christmas at 209. The Minnesota Vikings produced the stronger realized return, supporting the Minnesota Vikings Win verdict.

Minnesota sent pick No. 93 to Baltimore and received Nos. 102, 191 and 193. The Vikings selected Alexander Mattison, Marcus Epps and Oli Udoh, extracting several seasons of useful roster value from the three selections. Mattison served as Dalvin Cook’s primary backup before becoming the starter in 2023, while Udoh provided multi-position offensive-line depth. Baltimore used No. 93 on Miles Boykin, whose receiving impact remained limited.

Detroit moved from No. 88 to No. 81 in the third round of the 2019 draft, sending Minnesota pick No. 88 and sixth-rounder No. 204. The Lions used No. 81 on Boston College safety Will Harris, while Minnesota subsequently used the incoming selections as ammunition in additional draft-day trades. The Detroit Lions produced the stronger realized return, supporting the Detroit Lions Win verdict.

The Jets moved up one spot from No. 93 to No. 92 in the 2019 third round and selected tackle Chuma Edoga. Minnesota received No. 93 plus seventh-round pick No. 217, then continued trading: No. 93 went to Baltimore for Nos. 102, 191 and 193, while No. 217 became cornerback Kris Boyd. The Minnesota Vikings produced the stronger realized return, supporting the Minnesota Vikings Win verdict.

New England sent picks No. 56 and No. 101 to the Rams to move up to No. 45 for cornerback Joejuan Williams. Los Angeles immediately moved No. 56 to Kansas City and ultimately turned the trade chain into additional selections, including safety Taylor Rapp, who became a starter on the Super Bowl LVI champions. Williams never became a comparable Patriots starter, giving the Rams the stronger return.

Kansas City moved up five spots for Mecole Hardman, giving the Rams pick No. 61 and a fifth-rounder. Hardman became a useful speed weapon and return option across multiple championship runs, while Los Angeles turned No. 61 into Taylor Rapp, a starting safety on its Super Bowl LVI team. Both clubs extracted meaningful value from the exchange.

Los Angeles sent picks No. 94 and No. 99 to Tampa Bay to climb to No. 70 for running back Darrell Henderson. Henderson became part of the Rams' backfield rotation and contributed during their Super Bowl LVI season, but the Buccaneers converted the two picks into Jamel Dean and Mike Edwards, two defenders who played meaningful roles on a championship roster.

New England traded pick No. 64 to Seattle for Nos. 77 and 118, which became Chase Winovich and Hjalte Froholdt. Winovich supplied some early pass-rush production and Froholdt later developed elsewhere, but neither became a lasting Patriots fixture. The player Seattle selected at No. 64, D.K. Metcalf, became a franchise-level receiver and creates a wide value gap.

Atlanta traded picks 45 and 79 to the Rams for No. 31 and No. 203, using the first-rounder on tackle Kaleb McGary. McGary developed into a long-term Falcons starter and eventually earned a second contract, giving Atlanta stability at right tackle. Los Angeles used No. 79 on David Long and moved No. 45 in another trade, gaining flexibility and secondary depth but no player with McGary's sustained Atlanta role.

Pittsburgh traded up from No. 20 to No. 10 for linebacker Devin Bush, sending Denver pick No. 52 and a 2020 third-rounder as part of the price. Denver selected Noah Fant at No. 20 and later turned the additional capital into more roster value, including center Lloyd Cushenberry. Bush flashed early but never regained his trajectory after a 2020 knee injury, giving Denver the stronger package.

Indianapolis traded the 26th pick in 2019 to Washington for No. 46 and a 2020 second-rounder. The Colts then moved No. 46 again, turning it into Ben Banogu and Marvell Tell, while the future choice became Michael Pittman Jr. Pittman developed into a long-term starting receiver and multiple-time 1,000-yard producer, giving Indianapolis the strongest piece of its eventual return despite Montez Sweat’s success in Washington.

The Giants sent picks 37, 132 and 142 to Seattle to move into the end of the 2019 first round for cornerback Deandre Baker. Baker started 15 games as a rookie but was waived before his second season and never provided the long-term value New York expected. Seattle used the return to continue trading down and also selected Ugo Amadi and Ben Burr-Kirven, producing much more roster value from the package.

Baltimore Ravens received 2019 1st round pick (25th overall, Marquise Brown); 2019 4th round pick (127th overall, Iman Marshall); 2019 6th round pick (197th overall, Trace McSorley) in the 2019-04-25 exchange with Philadelphia Eagles. Marquise Brown supplied the strongest sustained direct value from the exchange, while Iman Marshall and Trace McSorley gave Baltimore two additional selections from the move down. The direct package is the basis for the hindsight grade, with later movement of an acquired selection treated separately. That supports Baltimore Ravens Win.

Seattle traded the 21st pick in 2019 to Green Bay for Nos. 30, 114 and 118. Green Bay selected Darnell Savage, who started 69 regular-season games over five seasons and intercepted nine passes. Seattle repeatedly moved the acquired selections, and two branches of the deal ultimately combined to acquire the pick used on DK Metcalf, who produced 6,324 receiving yards and 48 touchdowns in six Seahawks seasons. Seattle's asset tree became far more valuable.

Kansas City sent premium draft capital to Seattle for Frank Clark and a third-round pick. Clark's regular-season production did not always match his contract, but he delivered repeated postseason pressure and helped the Chiefs win two Super Bowls. Seattle's return was led by L.J. Collier, whose limited impact prevented the Seahawks from converting the valuable package.

Kansas City traded safety Eric Murray to Cleveland for defensive end Emmanuel Ogbah in April 2019. Ogbah became useful rotation help for the Chiefs, recording 5.5 sacks in 10 games before a season-ending injury during a Super Bowl championship season. Murray appeared in nine games with four starts for Cleveland, giving the Browns secondary depth but a smaller direct contribution.

Dallas acquired Robert Quinn for a future sixth-round pick and received 11.5 sacks in one season. Quinn left in free agency after the year, but the Cowboys bought premium pass-rush production at a minimal draft cost. Miami was clearing salary during a rebuild and recovered a late pick, making the Dolphins' side weak rather than valueless.

Chicago moved Jordan Howard for a conditional 2020 selection that became sixth-round pick No. 200. The Bears did not simply draft Quez Watkins with it; they later bundled No. 200 in a multi-pick exchange with Philadelphia. Howard, meanwhile, produced 525 rushing yards and seven total touchdowns in 10 Eagles games during 2019. Chicago retained useful draft-trade leverage, but Philadelphia received the stronger directly traceable football return and wins the deal in hindsight.

Miami sent Ryan Tannehill and a 2019 sixth-round pick to Tennessee for a 2019 seventh-rounder and a 2020 fourth-round pick. The Dolphins were resetting their roster and moved on from an expensive veteran quarterback, but Tannehill immediately revived his career with the Titans, winning Comeback Player of the Year and helping Tennessee reach the 2019 AFC Championship Game. Miami’s draft return never approached that level of impact.

Denver Broncos and Washington completed this transaction on 2019-03-13, with Denver Broncos receiving 2020 6th round pick (181st overall, Netane Muti) and Washington receiving Case Keenum and 2020 7th round pick (229th overall, James Smith-Williams). The cited historical sources support the basic exchange and its compensation. In hindsight, Washington gets the better grade because its return produced the clearer practical value from this modest exchange.

Denver sent the 113th pick in the 2019 draft to Baltimore for Joe Flacco, hoping the veteran quarterback could stabilize the position. Flacco started only eight games for the Broncos, throwing for 1,822 yards with seven touchdowns and six interceptions before his season ended. Baltimore used the pick on Justice Hill, who became a long-running Ravens back and special-teams contributor. The durability and retained value make Baltimore the clear winner.

Kansas City traded franchise-tagged edge rusher Dee Ford to San Francisco for a 2020 second-round pick, avoiding a major long-term commitment after his career-best 2018 season. The Chiefs used pick No. 63 on linebacker Willie Gay Jr., who became a multi-year starter and contributed to championship defenses. Ford helped the 49ers reach Super Bowl LIV in his first season, but persistent injuries made his five-year contract far less valuable than expected.

Cleveland acquired Odell Beckham Jr. from the Giants in exchange for Jabrill Peppers, the 17th pick in the 2019 draft and a third-round pick. Beckham produced one 1,000-yard season for the Browns but never became the transformational piece Cleveland expected. The Giants used the first-rounder on Dexter Lawrence, who developed into a multiple-time Pro Bowl defensive tackle.

The Giants and Browns completed a veteran-for-veteran swap centered on guard Kevin Zeitler and edge defender Olivier Vernon. Zeitler became a dependable New York starter, opening 31 games across two seasons and stabilizing the interior line. Vernon also delivered meaningful Cleveland pass-rush production when healthy, including nine sacks in 2020. Their team-specific returns remained close in both duration and impact.

Philadelphia sent veteran defensive end Michael Bennett and a 2020 seventh-round pick to New England for a 2020 fifth-round selection. The Eagles eventually used the fifth-rounder on wide receiver John Hightower, who provided limited NFL production. Philadelphia improved its draft position while moving an older, relatively expensive defender, but the resulting player return remained modest rather than developing into a major long-term asset.

Arizona Cardinals received Marcus Gilbert from Pittsburgh Steelers. Marcus Gilbert tore his ACL before the 2019 opener, never played a regular-season game for Arizona, and later opted out of the 2020 season. The F grade reflects the direct value Arizona Cardinals realized from the transaction, with the final Pittsburgh Steelers Win call based on actual service and clearly traceable draft outcomes rather than projected value.

Oakland received No. 140 in the 2019 draft but moved that selection onward during the draft. Ryquell Armstead therefore belongs to the later transaction chain rather than to the Raiders' direct realized return here. The acquired pick retained market value, yet Oakland did not turn this particular exchange into comparable on-field service before moving the asset again.

Pittsburgh salvaged meaningful value from a relationship with Antonio Brown that had become untenable, receiving 2019 third- and fifth-round picks from Oakland. The third-rounder became Diontae Johnson and the fifth became Zach Gentry, while Brown never played a regular-season snap for the Raiders. The Steelers did not receive peak-market value for an elite receiver, but converting a collapsing situation into two useful players became a decisive win.

Philadelphia reacquired DeSean Jackson and a 2020 seventh-round pick for a sixth-round selection. Jackson delivered explosive moments, including a huge opening game in 2019, but injuries limited his availability during both seasons of the reunion. Tampa Bay used the pick on Scotty Miller, who became a low-cost contributor on a championship team, giving the Buccaneers the slightly stronger realized return.

Denver sent Demaryius Thomas and a 2019 seventh-round pick to Houston for a 2019 fourth-round pick and another seventh-round pick. Houston acquired Demaryius Thomas during an 11-win season, but he played only seven regular-season games for the Texans before an Achilles injury ended his year; the club released him the following February. Denver obtained a fourth-round pick while only exchanging seventh-round positions. For an aging receiver nearing the end of his contract, that return was strong and gives Denver the clear value edge.

Baltimore Ravens received Ty Montgomery. Baltimore received Ty Montgomery, whose Ravens tenure was brief and did not create a lasting role. That result supports a C- for Baltimore Ravens. The overall comparison favors Green Bay Packers, leaving Baltimore Ravens on the weaker side of the exchange. The grade reflects the realized player service and draft value tied directly to this transaction, without assigning extra credit for outcomes that cannot be traced confidently to the exchanged assets.

Los Angeles acquired edge rusher Dante Fowler from Jacksonville at the 2018 trade deadline for a 2019 third-round pick and a 2020 fifth-round pick. The Rams acquired Dante Fowler at the 2018 deadline and received immediate pass-rush help for a Super Bowl run, then re-signed him for 2019 when he produced a career-high 11.5 sacks. Jacksonville turned the picks into Quincy Williams and Collin Johnson, but neither delivered comparable value for the Jaguars. Fowler's postseason impact and strong 2019 season make Los Angeles the winner.

Detroit Lions received 2019 3rd round pick (88th overall subsequently traded, Cody Barton) in the exchange with Philadelphia Eagles. Detroit used the acquired third-round slot in a move up for Will Harris, who went on to appear in 81 Lions games with 40 starts. Against Philadelphia Eagles' return of Golden Tate, that outcome supports a B+ grade. The transaction is judged as Detroit Lions Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Green Bay Packers received 2019 4th round pick (118th overall subsequently traded, Hjalte Froholdt) in the deal with Washington Commanders. Green Bay later included pick 118 with pick 30 and another fourth-rounder to move up for Darnell Savage. The acquired pick therefore preserved meaningful draft-day leverage for the Packers. That outcome supports a B+ for Green Bay Packers. The Green Bay Packers Win verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Detroit paid a 2019 fifth-round pick for Damon Harrison during the 2018 season and immediately added one of football's premier interior run defenders. Harrison stepped into the starting lineup and helped a defense that badly needed strength in the middle. The Giants later used the incoming pick as part of their move for Deandre Baker, but Detroit received the clearer direct football payoff.

New Orleans acquired cornerback Eli Apple from the Giants for a 2019 fourth-round pick and a 2020 seventh-round pick. Apple became a starter immediately and remained in the lineup through the 2019 season, including the Saints' 2018 run to the NFC Championship Game. The Giants gained reasonable draft capital, but New Orleans received more direct on-field value from the exchange.

Dallas sent a 2019 first-round pick to Oakland for Amari Cooper and immediately transformed a passing game that had lacked a true No. 1 target. Cooper helped spark a 2018 division-title run, produced multiple Pro Bowl seasons in Dallas and gave Dak Prescott a polished separator in his prime. The cost was significant, but the Cowboys received several years of top-level production from the exact position they needed.

Cleveland Browns received 2019 5th round pick (144th overall). Cleveland retained the future fifth-round value and later folded that asset into the draft movement associated with Greedy Williams, preserving more usable roster-building value than Jacksonville received from Hyde. Compared with Jacksonville Jaguars' return, the result supports a B+ grade and fits the Cleveland Browns Win verdict.

Buffalo sent veteran tackle Marshall Newhouse to Carolina for a future conditional seventh-round pick that became No. 236 in 2021. The Bills eventually used that selection on Jack Anderson, but he did not become a meaningful Buffalo regular-season contributor. Newhouse gave Carolina immediate offensive-line insurance during an injury-hit season, so the Panthers received slightly more realized value.

Cleveland received the 2019 fifth-round pick at No. 170 and selected kicker Austin Seibert. Seibert gave the Browns a solid rookie season in 2019, but his Cleveland tenure lasted only one full year before he was waived early in 2020. The return was useful but short-lived, leaving Cleveland behind New England's more substantial receiving production from Josh Gordon.

Buffalo Bills received 2019 5th round pick (158th overall subsequently traded, Michael Jackson) in the deal with Las Vegas Raiders. The Bills retained a meaningful fifth-round asset that remained useful in later draft movement. Turning a reserve quarterback into that level of draft capital created a strong return. That outcome supports a B+ for Buffalo Bills. The Buffalo Bills Win verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Carolina Panthers received Corey Robinson in the 2018-09-01 exchange, while Detroit Lions received conditional 2020 7th round pick (not conveyed). Carolina acquired tackle Corey Robinson for a conditional 2020 seventh-round pick. Because the condition was not satisfied, that choice never conveyed, so the Panthers obtained the player without ultimately surrendering a realized draft selection.

Indianapolis acquired wide receiver Marcus Johnson from Seattle in exchange for tight end Darrell Daniels at the 2018 roster deadline. Johnson grew into useful receiver depth for the Colts, including 277 receiving yards and two touchdowns in 2019 and another 255 yards in 2020. Daniels gave Seattle only a brief role before moving on, so Indianapolis realized the stronger return.

Cleveland acquired defensive tackle Devaroe Lawrence from New Orleans for a 2019 seventh-round pick. Lawrence gave the Browns 12 regular-season appearances across 2018 and 2019, including two starts, eight tackles and a fumble recovery in 2019. The surrendered pick became No. 231 and New Orleans used it on Alize Mack, who never produced a regular-season appearance for the Saints. Cleveland realized the clearer return.

Chicago sent defensive back Deiondre' Hall to Philadelphia on September 1, 2018 for a conditional 2019 seventh-round pick. The condition was satisfied and the selection became No. 222 overall, which Chicago used on running back Kerrith Whyte. Whyte did not appear in a regular-season game for the Bears before being waived in September 2019, so the pick produced little direct return for Chicago.

Chicago's trade for Khalil Mack gave the Bears an instant superstar and briefly turned their defense into one of the league's defining units. The Raiders received a major draft package, but the return never matched the value of an elite pass rusher in his prime. Chicago paid heavily, yet still acquired the best player. The deal remains a strong Bears win because Mack delivered superstar impact immediately, even if Chicago did not turn the window into a championship.

Seattle acquired defensive back Shalom Luani from the Raiders for a 2019 seventh-round pick just before the 2018 season. Luani appeared in 12 games for the Seahawks, contributing primarily on special teams and in reserve defensive work, but he never developed into a significant starter. The Raiders later used pick No. 235 as part of a draft-day move rather than turning it directly into a lasting core player.

Atlanta acquired safety Jordan Richards from New England for a 2020 seventh-round pick. Atlanta acquired safety Jordan Richards and immediately received meaningful short-term usage. Richards appeared in fifteen games and started twelve for the Falcons in 2018, giving the club a substantial amount of playable depth from a modest acquisition. For a seventh-round-equivalent cost, that single season of starts was a useful return. In hindsight, that result supports a B- grade for Atlanta Falcons in a deal ultimately judged as Atlanta Falcons Win.

Kansas City acquired safety Jordan Lucas from Miami for a 2020 seventh-round pick. Lucas appeared in all 16 games with four starts in 2018, contributed on defense and special teams, and remained with the Chiefs through their 2019 championship season. Miami used the pick on Malcolm Perry, who supplied a small one-season offensive role. Kansas City received the stronger club-specific return.

San Francisco acquired tackle Shon Coleman from Cleveland for a 2019 seventh-round pick. Coleman was inactive for all 16 games in 2018, spent 2019 on injured reserve and never appeared in a 49ers regular-season game. Cleveland retained the No. 243 draft asset and later included it in the Josh Gordon trade with New England.

Kansas City acquired Charvarius Ward from Dallas for Parker Ehinger at the end of the 2018 preseason. Ward became a full-time Chiefs corner, started 41 regular-season games from 2019 through 2021 and started every postseason game during Kansas City’s Super Bowl LIV championship run. Ehinger never produced comparable Dallas value. Turning expendable line depth into a championship starter makes this one of the clearest wins in the batch.

New Orleans acquired Teddy Bridgewater and a 2019 sixth-round pick from the Jets for a 2019 third-rounder. Bridgewater became Drew Brees' backup and delivered the trade's defining value in 2019, going 5-0 as the starter while Brees recovered from a thumb injury. The Saints also retained the sixth-round selection, while New York later used the incoming third-round capital in another draft-day move.

Green Bay traded backup quarterback Brett Hundley to Seattle for a 2019 sixth-round pick that became No. 194 and Dexter Williams. Williams produced only a small rushing role for the Packers, but Green Bay still converted a quarterback it no longer needed into a draft asset. Seattle carried Hundley as veteran insurance without receiving regular-season quarterback production, leaving the realized value nearly even.

Baltimore Ravens traded Kamalei Correa to Tennessee for a 2019 sixth-round pick that Baltimore later moved and that ultimately became No. 191, Marcus Epps. Because the Ravens did not directly turn the choice into a comparable long-term contributor, their realized return was limited. Correa became a useful Titans defender, so Baltimore receives a C in the final comparison.

Minnesota acquired center Brett Jones from the Giants for a 2019 seventh-round pick and immediately used him as injury insurance. Jones started the first three games of 2018 while Pat Elflein recovered, returned for additional seasons, and later remained useful interior-line depth. New York's pick became George Asafo-Adjei, who did not create comparable Giants value, giving Minnesota the edge.

The Raiders received Pittsburgh's 2019 fifth-round pick and converted that asset into A.J. McCarron in a separate trade days later. McCarron appeared in only two Raiders games and completed one of three passes. Because the acquired fifth-rounder was itself moved onward, Oakland's direct realized value from this exchange remained limited despite preserving short-term quarterback depth.

Green Bay acquired linebacker Antonio Morrison from Indianapolis for cornerback Lenzy Pipkins just before the 2018 season. Morrison played all 16 games for the Packers, recorded 47 tackles and added a sack, giving Green Bay immediate defensive and special-teams utility. Pipkins did not establish a comparable Colts role, so the Packers received the more meaningful original-team return from the straight player swap.

Detroit acquired linebacker Eli Harold before the 2018 season for a conditional 2020 seventh-round pick. Harold gave the Lions immediate veteran depth and a season of defensive snaps, so the move was not empty. The pick eventually became No. 217, however, and San Francisco used it on Jauan Jennings, whose long-term receiving and postseason value created a much larger return.

Buffalo Bills received Corey Coleman in the exchange with Cleveland Browns. Buffalo released Corey Coleman before the 2018 regular season, so the Bills received no regular-season production from the acquisition. Against Cleveland Browns' return of 2020 7th round pick (236th overall subsequently traded, Vernon Scott), that outcome supports an F grade. The transaction is judged as Cleveland Browns Win, with the mark based on the football value that actually followed from the deal.

Las Vegas Raiders acquired Christian Hackenberg from the New York Jets for a conditional 2019 seventh-round pick. Oakland waived Hackenberg less than a month later, he never appeared in a regular-season game for the club, and the condition was not met, so the pick stayed with the Raiders. With essentially no realized value or cost, Las Vegas earns a C-.

Arizona Cardinals received Jamar Taylor in the exchange with Cleveland Browns. Taylor appeared in 10 games with three starts for Arizona in 2018, then moved on after the season. His stay gave the Cardinals short-term secondary depth but no extended return. The D grade reflects the direct value Arizona Cardinals realized from the deal, while the Cleveland Browns Win call weighs actual regular-season service and clearly connected draft value rather than name recognition alone.

Detroit traded defensive tackle Akeem Spence to Miami for a 2019 seventh-round pick, eventually No. 229 and P.J. Johnson. The Lions created cap and roster flexibility and recovered a draft asset, but Johnson did not provide comparable Detroit production. Spence immediately started all 16 games for Miami, making the Dolphins' inexpensive veteran acquisition the more valuable side.

Atlanta sent the Rams picks No. 244 and No. 256 to move up to No. 194 and select wide receiver Russell Gage. Atlanta moved up for Russell Gage, who developed from a sixth-round special-teams prospect into a productive receiver and eventually posted consecutive 700-yard seasons. The Rams selected Justin Lawler at No. 244 and moved No. 256 in another trade. Lawler provided depth, but Gage generated far more offensive production and became a meaningful part of Atlanta's passing game.

Baltimore moved down from No. 152 and received Nos. 162 and 215. Jordan Lasley provided little, but Bradley Bozeman became a four-year Ravens contributor who played 62 games and started 49, including 16 starts in each of his final three Baltimore seasons. Bozeman's sustained offensive-line role gave the Ravens a strong return from the move down.

Carolina moved up eleven spots in the 2018 fourth round to select edge rusher Marquis Haynes at No. 136, sending the Rams picks No. 147 and No. 197. Haynes became a durable rotational pass rusher for the Panthers, appearing across seven seasons and producing 14 sacks. Los Angeles landed linebacker Micah Kiser at No. 147, but Carolina received the stronger long-term contribution from the deal.

Cleveland Browns received 2018 4th round pick (105th overall, Antonio Callaway) in the 2018-04-28 exchange with New England Patriots. Antonio Callaway gave Cleveland immediate receiving production as a rookie, but his Browns tenure was brief and did not develop into durable long-term value. The direct package is the basis for the hindsight grade, with later movement of an acquired selection treated separately. That supports Even Trade.

Dallas acquired Tavon Austin from the Rams for the 192nd pick in the 2018 draft. Dallas acquired Tavon Austin and got two seasons of offensive and return-game work from him. Austin produced multiple touchdowns and gave the Cowboys a flexible speed option who could contribute in several roles. The impact was not star-level, but Dallas extracted useful snaps and scoring value from a very modest acquisition cost. In hindsight, that result supports a B- grade for Dallas Cowboys in a deal ultimately judged as Dallas Cowboys Win.

Denver Broncos and Rams completed this transaction on 2018-04-28, with Denver Broncos receiving 2018 6th round pick (183rd overall, Sam Jones) and 2018 6th round pick (217th overall, Keishawn Bierria) and Rams receiving 2018 5th round pick (160th overall, Ogbonnia Okoronkwo). The cited historical sources support the recorded exchange and compensation. The Denver Broncos grade of C+ and the Rams grade of B reflect the relative football value visible in hindsight, with the stronger side matching the Los Angeles/St. Louis Rams Win verdict.

Detroit sent New England a 2019 third-round pick in exchange for the No. 114 pick in the 2018 draft, which the Lions used on defensive lineman Da'Shawn Hand. Detroit used No. 114 on Da'Shawn Hand, who had a promising rookie season but struggled to stay healthy and never became a long-term fixture. New England received a 2019 third-round pick, preserving future draft value but ultimately moving that selection again. Neither side converted the exchange into a lasting cornerstone, leaving the realized return close enough for an even verdict.

Indianapolis sent defensive lineman Henry Anderson to the Jets for pick No. 235, then used that seventh-round selection on linebacker Zaire Franklin. Anderson immediately produced seven sacks in New York and earned a multi-year extension, so the Jets received legitimate value. Franklin nevertheless became the superior long-term asset, growing from special-teams contributor into Colts captain, tackle leader and 2024 second-team All-Pro linebacker.

Kansas City sent New England picks No. 233 and No. 243 to move up to No. 198 and select Kahlil McKenzie. Kansas City surrendered two seventh-round picks to move up for Kahlil McKenzie, a college defensive lineman the Chiefs converted to guard. McKenzie never became a regular-season contributor for Kansas City. New England used one acquired pick on Keion Crossen, who contributed on special teams and later brought additional value in a trade, while the other pick was moved again. The Patriots realized more.

Minnesota moved up for kicker Daniel Carlson and also acquired Devante Downs, but Carlson was waived after two games and his later All-Pro success came entirely with Las Vegas. New York used Minnesota’s selections on Folorunso Fatukasi and Trenton Cannon. Fatukasi became a useful Jets starter, giving New York far more team-specific value from the exchange.

New England sent the 233rd pick in the 2018 draft to Philadelphia for pick No. 250 and a 2019 seventh-rounder. The Patriots received two late lottery tickets and used the 2018 choice on Ryan Izzo, but the Eagles used No. 233 on Jordan Mailata. Mailata's development into a long-term starting left tackle creates an enormous hindsight gap in Philadelphia's favor.

Indianapolis turned the acquired choices into Daurice Fountain and Deon Cain. Both players reached the NFL, but neither delivered a sustained Colts role comparable to the defensive snaps Maurice Hurst supplied for the Raiders. The Colts gained two chances from the move down, yet the direct on-field return from those selections remained limited during their time with the franchise.

Dallas sent Ryan Switzer to the Raiders and received defensive lineman Jihad Ward in a straight player-for-player swap during the 2018 draft weekend. Neither acquisition became a major long-term piece for the new club, and neither side created a meaningful downstream asset advantage. The deal produced limited depth value on both sides, leaving the exchange essentially even.

Washington sent the Rams picks No. 205 and No. 231 for picks No. 197 and No. 256, selecting Shaun Dion Hamilton and Trey Quinn. Washington moved up for Shaun Dion Hamilton and Trey Quinn, receiving several seasons of linebacker and receiver depth. Los Angeles moved back for Trevon Young and Travin Howard. Howard developed into a useful linebacker and made a decisive interception during the Rams' 2021 NFC Championship run, giving the Rams the most consequential contribution from the four players involved.

Carolina sent pick No. 88 to Green Bay for Nos. 101 and 147. The Panthers selected tight end Ian Thomas at No. 101 and later used No. 147 in another trade that helped them reach No. 136 for edge rusher Marquis Haynes. Thomas and Haynes both supplied multi-year Carolina roles, giving the Panthers broader realized value than Green Bay received from Oren Burks.

Chicago Bears received 2018 2nd round pick (51st overall, Anthony Miller) in the 2018-04-27 exchange with New England Patriots. Anthony Miller became a useful receiving option in Chicago, but he never developed into the kind of long-term difference-maker that would erase the cost of moving both a current fourth-rounder and a future second-rounder. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Chicago Bears surrendered, the result supports New England Patriots Win and a C grade for Chicago Bears.

Cleveland received 2018 3rd round pick (67th overall, Chad Thomas), 2018 6th round pick (178th overall subsequently traded, Christian Sam), while Indianapolis received 2018 2nd round pick (64th overall, Tyquan Lewis). The hindsight grades are C- for Cleveland and B for Indianapolis. The verdict is grounded in the actual starts, production, tenure and downstream draft results produced by those assets.

Detroit moved from No. 51 to No. 43 in the 2018 second round, sending New England picks No. 51 and No. 117 to select running back Kerryon Johnson. Kerryon Johnson flashed as a rookie and topped 1,000 scrimmage yards in 2018, but injuries limited his Detroit tenure and he was gone after three seasons. New England turned the two selections into additional draft capital rather than one long-term star, giving the Patriots broader value and the better risk-adjusted return.

Philadelphia sent picks No. 52 and No. 169 to Indianapolis to move up three spots to No. 49 and select tight end Dallas Goedert. Philadelphia used No. 49 on Dallas Goedert, who developed into a long-term starting tight end and major postseason contributor. Indianapolis received Kemoko Turay and Jordan Wilkins; both supplied useful stretches, but neither approached Goedert's sustained impact. The Eagles paid a fifth-round pick to move only three spots, and the player they targeted justified the premium.

Kansas City moved from No. 54 to No. 46 and also received No. 100, while Cincinnati received picks No. 54 and No. 78 in the 2018 draft. Cincinnati converted the move down into Jessie Bates III and Malik Jefferson, while Kansas City selected Breeland Speaks at No. 46 and Dorian O'Daniel at No. 100. Bates became an elite safety and a foundational defender during his Bengals tenure; Speaks never became a regular Chiefs contributor. That gap makes this one of the clearest wins in the wave.

Kansas City sent Baltimore picks No. 86 and No. 122 to move up to No. 75 and select defensive tackle Derrick Nnadi. Kansas City moved up for Derrick Nnadi, a durable interior defender who became part of multiple championship teams. Baltimore moved back and landed Mark Andrews plus Kenny Young. Andrews became a first-team All-Pro, multi-time Pro Bowler and one of the most productive receivers in Ravens history. Nnadi made the deal worthwhile for Kansas City, but Andrews creates the decisive edge.

Minnesota sent pick No. 94 to Tampa Bay for Nos. 102 and 180. The Buccaneers used No. 94 on Alex Cappa, who developed into a starting right guard and played on the 2020 Super Bowl championship team. Minnesota drafted Jalyn Holmes at No. 102 and later moved No. 180 in another trade, but the resulting branch produced far less Vikings value than Cappa delivered in Tampa Bay.

Tennessee sent picks 57 and 89 to Oakland to move up to No. 41 for edge rusher Harold Landry. Landry became a long-term Titans starter, double-digit sack producer and Pro Bowler, while Oakland used No. 57 on P.J. Hall and later moved No. 89. Hall lasted only two seasons with the Raiders. Tennessee paid a real premium, but it secured by far the best player in the exchange.

Oakland sent Baltimore picks No. 75, No. 152 and No. 212 to move up to No. 65 and select tackle Brandon Parker. Oakland traded three picks to move to No. 65 for Brandon Parker, who became a useful swing tackle and made 33 starts for the Raiders. Baltimore turned the package into a chain that included Mark Andrews and Bradley Bozeman, with Andrews becoming a first-team All-Pro and one of the franchise's leading receivers. The Ravens extracted dramatically more long-term value.

Oakland sent the Rams picks No. 89 and No. 217 to move up two spots to No. 87 and select edge rusher Arden Key. The Raiders moved up two spots for Arden Key, who showed pass-rush flashes but never established himself as a long-term Oakland starter. The Rams moved back and selected Joseph Noteboom, who stayed with the organization for years as a starter and versatile offensive lineman, while the extra sixth-round selection also retained trade value. Los Angeles got the more durable return.

Pittsburgh Steelers received 2018 3rd round pick (76th overall, Mason Rudolph) in the 2018-04-27 exchange with Seattle Seahawks. Mason Rudolph supplied useful backup and spot-starting quarterback value, making Pittsburgh's side respectable rather than empty. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Pittsburgh Steelers surrendered, the result supports Seattle Seahawks Win and a C+ grade for Pittsburgh Steelers.

San Francisco sent tackle Trent Brown and 2018 fifth-round No. 143 to New England for 2018 third-round No. 95. The 49ers used No. 95 on Tarvarius Moore, while New England gained a starting left tackle for its Super Bowl LIII run and selected Ja'Whaun Bentley at No. 143. The Patriots received the stronger combined return.

Tampa Bay moved down seven spots in the second round, sending No. 56 to New England for Nos. 63 and 117. The Buccaneers selected Carlton Davis and Jordan Whitehead, two defensive starters who later played major roles on the 2020 Super Bowl championship team. New England used No. 56 on Duke Dawson, who never played a regular-season game for the Patriots before being traded to Denver.

San Francisco sent picks No. 59 and No. 74 to Washington for picks No. 44 and No. 142, then used them on Dante Pettis and D.J. Reed. Washington moved down and selected Derrius Guice and Geron Christian, but Guice's career was derailed before he could deliver meaningful value and Christian became a limited starter. San Francisco's Dante Pettis also failed to last, yet fifth-rounder D.J. Reed developed into a quality NFL corner after leaving the 49ers. San Francisco's side produced the stronger overall football value.

Baltimore moved from No. 22 to No. 25 in 2018, sending Tennessee a sixth-rounder and receiving a fourth-round pick. The Ravens selected Hayden Hurst at No. 25 and later used the acquired fourth-round asset in the package that brought back the 32nd pick for Lamar Jackson. Hurst himself was eventually traded to Atlanta for valuable draft capital. Tennessee selected Rashaan Evans, a four-year starting linebacker, producing a solid but less expansive return.

Buffalo's trade up for Josh Allen became the move that ended the Bills' long quarterback search. The Buccaneers received a useful package and added real defensive talent, but Buffalo landed the franchise quarterback who turned the team into a perennial contender. That makes the Bills the clear winner. Tampa Bay got real value, but Buffalo got the quarterback who changed the franchise's ceiling.

Buffalo moved from No. 22 to No. 16 for linebacker Tremaine Edmunds, sending Baltimore a third-round pick and swapping a fifth-rounder into the deal. Edmunds became an immediate starter, made two Pro Bowls and spent five seasons directing the Bills’ defense. Baltimore’s return became even larger through subsequent moves, helping create the picks used on Hayden Hurst, Mark Andrews, Kenny Young and other players while also feeding the later Lamar Jackson trade package.

New Orleans paid picks No. 27 and 147 plus its 2019 first-rounder to jump to No. 14 for Marcus Davenport. Davenport flashed high-end ability and totaled 21.5 sacks in five Saints seasons, including nine in 2021, but injuries repeatedly limited his availability. Green Bay used the return as flexible capital in moves that helped produce Jaire Alexander in 2018 and Darnell Savage in 2019, giving the Packers the stronger long-term value.

Baltimore's trade up for Lamar Jackson gave the Ravens a two-time MVP without paying a massive draft price. Philadelphia received useful value that became real contributors, but Baltimore landed the rare quarterback who changed the shape of the franchise. The Ravens won because Jackson became a unique offensive centerpiece. Philadelphia made a defensible pick-value move, but Baltimore acquired the player who remade its offense.

Arizona jumped from No. 15 to No. 10 in the 2018 draft for quarterback Josh Rosen, sending Oakland third- and fifth-round picks. Rosen lasted one season with the Cardinals before Arizona drafted Kyler Murray and traded him away. Oakland used No. 15 on tackle Kolton Miller, who developed into a long-term starter and Pro Bowler, making the Raiders the overwhelming winner even before accounting for the additional picks.

Oakland sent Pittsburgh the 79th pick in the 2018 draft for wide receiver Martavis Bryant. Bryant's Raiders tenure was turbulent and brief: he was released before Week 1, re-signed, then finished 2018 with 19 catches for 266 yards and no touchdowns in eight games. The third-round cost was too high for that return, giving Pittsburgh a clear advantage.

Seattle traded pick No. 18 and a seventh-rounder to Green Bay for Nos. 27, 76 and 186. The Seahawks selected Rashaad Penny at 27, later turned No. 76 into Rasheem Green and another pick, and used No. 186 on Jacob Martin, who became part of the Jadeveon Clowney trade. Green Bay used No. 18 on Jaire Alexander, an All-Pro cornerback, giving the Packers the best individual player from a deal that still produced several useful Seattle assets.

Denver Broncos received 2019 7th round pick (220th overall subsequently traded, Cullen Gillaspia) from New York Giants in the 2018-04-23 trade. Denver received the conditional 2019 seventh-round pick at No. 220 and later moved that asset in downstream trade activity. New York Giants's return was Riley Dixon. New York acquired Riley Dixon, who punted every game for the Giants from 2018 through 2021. Those realized outcomes, rather than the labels on the assets alone, drive the hindsight grade.

Los Angeles sent first- and sixth-round picks to New England for Brandin Cooks and a fourth-rounder. Cooks immediately delivered 1,204 receiving yards for a Rams team that reached Super Bowl LIII, then was traded to Houston two years later for a second-round pick. New England used No. 23 on Isaiah Wynn, a capable but injury-limited lineman. Both clubs extracted meaningful value, making an even grade more fitting than a Patriots win.

Denver Broncos received Su'a Cravens, the 2018 fourth-round pick used on DaeSean Hamilton, and an additional 2018 fifth-round selection from Washington Commanders. Cravens played only five Denver games, while Hamilton supplied some receiving value. The B- grade reflects a useful but limited return, with the final Washington Commanders Win call based on the broader value Washington created from its package.

Tampa Bay acquired Jason Pierre-Paul and pick No. 102 from the Giants for Nos. 69 and 108. Pierre-Paul immediately posted 12.5 sacks, later re-signed and became a central pass rusher on the 2020 Super Bowl champions. New York used No. 69 on B.J. Hill, who contributed for three seasons before being traded to Cincinnati, while Kyle Lauletta provided little. The Buccaneers received the clear premium impact.

Dallas acquired fullback Jamize Olawale plus the sixth-round selection at No. 192. Olawale appeared in 32 Cowboys games across 2018 and 2019, contributing as a fullback, reserve runner, and special-teams player. The draft pick was later moved again, so it is best treated as retained transaction value rather than direct player production. Olawale's two seasons still gave Dallas the steadier realized return.

Oakland received No. 159 in the 2018 draft and subsequently moved that selection again. Daurice Fountain was chosen only after the pick left Oakland, so his career does not count as direct Raiders value from this deal. The Raiders retained a tradable draft asset, but they did not realize a player contribution from the original exchange comparable to New England's return.

Indianapolis turned the third pick in the 2018 draft into a four-pick package that became Quenton Nelson, Braden Smith, additional 2018 draft capital and the 2019 selection used on Rock Ya-Sin. Nelson became one of the league’s defining guards and Smith a long-term starting tackle. New York used No. 3 on Sam Darnold, whose Jets tenure lasted three seasons before he was traded to Carolina.

Cleveland traded Jason McCourty and 2018 seventh-round No. 219 to New England for 2018 sixth-round No. 205. The Patriots used No. 219 on Danny Etling, but McCourty was the decisive asset, becoming an important starter on the Super Bowl LIII championship team. Cleveland's incoming pick moved again later, leaving New England with the clear hindsight advantage.

Buffalo traded Tyrod Taylor to Cleveland for the first pick of the third round, No. 65, creating valuable draft flexibility while moving on at quarterback. The Bills later packaged No. 65 with No. 22 to climb to No. 16 for linebacker Tremaine Edmunds. Taylor opened 2018 as Cleveland’s starter but made only three starts before Baker Mayfield took over, leaving Buffalo with the stronger long-term return.

Buffalo traded Cordy Glenn, pick No. 21 and a fifth-rounder to Cincinnati for No. 12 and a sixth-round pick. The move cleared Glenn’s contract and, more importantly, moved the Bills into position to make their later jump to No. 7 for Josh Allen. Cincinnati gained a starting left tackle and selected Billy Price at No. 21, but neither became a long-term foundation piece. Buffalo’s draft-board leverage proved far more valuable in hindsight.

Carolina acquired veteran receiver Torrey Smith from Philadelphia for cornerback Daryl Worley in March 2018. Smith played 11 games for the Panthers that season, catching 17 passes for 190 yards and two touchdowns while providing veteran depth. Philadelphia released Worley in April after an arrest, before he played a regular-season snap for the Eagles. Even modest production made Carolina the clear winner of the direct exchange.

Cleveland Browns received Damarious Randall plus the lower fourth- and fifth-round selections, while sending DeShone Kizer and the higher corresponding picks to Green Bay. Cleveland also turned No. 150 into Genard Avery, giving the Browns a stronger mix of immediate secondary help and draft value. That return supports a B grade. The final verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Cleveland Browns and New England Patriots completed this exchange on 2018-03-14. Cleveland received a future third-round pick, while New England received Danny Shelton and a fifth-round selection. Both teams realized usable value, but Cleveland's stronger future draft asset creates the slight hindsight edge. The final grades are C+ for Cleveland and C for New England, producing a Cleveland Browns Win verdict.

Denver traded cornerback Aqib Talib to the Rams for the No. 160 pick in the 2018 draft. Los Angeles paid a fifth-round pick for Aqib Talib, reuniting the veteran corner with Wade Phillips and adding him to a defense built for an immediate championship run. Talib started for the Rams when healthy and helped the club reach Super Bowl LIII. Denver created cap room and later recycled the pick, but the direct football impact favored Los Angeles.

Miami acquired edge rusher Robert Quinn and pick No. 209 from the Rams for picks No. 111 and No. 183 in 2018. Quinn started all 16 games for the Dolphins and recorded 6.5 sacks before Miami traded him to Dallas the next offseason. Los Angeles used No. 111 on center Brian Allen, who became a multi-year starter and started throughout the Rams' Super Bowl LVI championship run.

Cleveland acquired wide receiver Jarvis Landry from Miami for the No. 123 pick in 2018 and a 2019 seventh-round selection. Cleveland acquired Jarvis Landry and immediately extended him. Landry became a central part of the Browns' offensive rebuild and delivered four seasons of high-volume receiving and leadership. Miami turned the picks into Durham Smythe and Myles Gaskin, both useful contributors, so the Dolphins did receive real value. Landry's sustained impact and role in Cleveland's turnaround still give the Browns the edge.

Minnesota acquired quarterback Trevor Siemian and the 225th pick in the 2018 draft from Denver for a 2019 fifth-round selection. Siemian served as Kirk Cousins' backup for one season and did not make a regular-season start for the Vikings. Denver eventually used the fifth-round return on linebacker Justin Hollins, who appeared in 15 games as a rookie. The Broncos gained the slightly cleaner direct return.

Los Angeles sent Alec Ogletree and a 2019 seventh-round pick to New York for 2018 fourth- and sixth-round selections. The Rams drafted John Franklin-Myers and John Kelly, but neither became a long-term Rams fixture. New York received 26 starts, 173 tackles and six interceptions from Ogletree across two seasons, giving the Giants the stronger original-team football return.

Kansas City traded Marcus Peters and a 2018 sixth-round pick to the Rams for a 2018 fourth-rounder and a 2019 second-rounder. Those picks became Armani Watts and Juan Thornhill. Peters helped Los Angeles reach Super Bowl LIII, but Thornhill developed into a multi-year Chiefs starter and championship contributor, giving Kansas City stronger long-term value from the package.

Kansas City traded Alex Smith to Washington for cornerback Kendall Fuller and the 78th pick in the 2018 draft. Fuller gave the Chiefs two seasons of secondary play and was part of the Super Bowl LIV roster, while the draft capital added another valuable asset. The move also cleared the starting job for Patrick Mahomes, making Kansas City's return unusually strong even before considering the quarterback succession.

Carolina sold Kelvin Benjamin at the right moment, sending the former first-round receiver to Buffalo for 2018 third- and seventh-round picks. Benjamin never regained his early Carolina production and was released by Buffalo the following season. The Panthers turned a declining veteran into two draft assets, later using those selections on Rashaan Gaulden and Andre Smith, and avoided carrying the receiver through the rest of his downturn.

Philadelphia acquired Jay Ajayi for a fourth-round pick during the 2017 championship season. Ajayi immediately strengthened the backfield, produced important playoff carries, and helped the Eagles win their first Super Bowl. Miami used the pick on Kalen Ballage, whose limited production never matched the direct championship value Philadelphia received.

Seattle sent a 2018 third-rounder and 2019 second-rounder to Houston for Duane Brown and a 2018 fifth-round pick. Brown immediately stabilized left tackle, earned All-Pro recognition in 2018 and remained Seattle’s starter through 2021; the fifth-rounder became Shaquem Griffin. Houston used the picks on Martinas Rankin and Lonnie Johnson, but neither became a comparable long-term Texans cornerstone. Brown’s premium-position longevity makes this a decisive Seahawks win.

New England Patriots New England received the 2018 second-round pick at No. 43. The Patriots multiplied that asset through later draft-day movement, preserving meaningful value even though the original selection was not used directly on one player. The supported hindsight grade is B-. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against San Francisco 49ers, the final verdict is San Francisco 49ers Win.

New York Jets received Rashard Robinson; San Francisco 49ers received 2018 fifth-round pick No. 143. Robinson played 16 Jets games with two starts and no interceptions. San Francisco later used No. 143 with Trent Brown to acquire No. 95, which became Tarvarius Moore. The realized outcomes support San Francisco 49ers Win, with New York Jets graded C and San Francisco 49ers graded C+.

Jacksonville acquired Marcell Dareus from Buffalo during the 2017 season for a conditional draft pick that became a 2018 fifth-rounder. Dareus helped fix a struggling run defense and contributed to the Jaguars' AFC Championship Game run. Buffalo cleared a massive contract, selected Wyatt Teller with the eventual No. 166 pick and later traded Teller in a package that produced more draft value, including the selection used on kicker Tyler Bass.

Chicago acquired Dontrelle Inman for a conditional 2018 seventh-round pick tied to his receiving production. Inman caught 23 passes for 334 yards and a touchdown for the Bears in 2017, falling short of the reported 25-reception threshold. The condition therefore did not produce a pick for Los Angeles. Chicago received eight games of useful receiver production without surrendering the draft asset, while the Chargers received no realized return from the condition.

New Orleans moved Adrian Peterson after four games in a crowded backfield and received a conditional 2018 sixth-round pick that became No. 189, used on Kamrin Moore. Arizona needed a runner after David Johnson's injury and got six starts, 448 rushing yards and two touchdowns from Peterson. The Cardinals received the more useful direct return, although the short stay keeps the margin modest.

Carolina acquired cornerback Kevon Seymour from Buffalo for receiver Kaelin Clay and a 2019 seventh-round pick. Seymour gave the Panthers useful secondary depth, appearing in 29 games over two seasons and making several starts. Buffalo quickly moved on from Clay, who was reclaimed by Carolina, but kept the future pick and eventually selected tight end Tommy Sweeney at No. 228. The pick's multi-year roster value gives Buffalo a narrow edge.

Dallas acquired cornerback Bene Benwikere from Cincinnati for a conditional 2019 sixth-round pick that ultimately conveyed at No. 198. Benwikere appeared in 12 games for the Cowboys in 2017 but did not start and recorded only two tackles. Cincinnati later included No. 198 in the package used to move up for quarterback Ryan Finley, giving the Bengals modest but more durable draft flexibility from a player they were willing to move.

Detroit Lions received 2019 6th round pick (204th overall subsequently traded, Travis Homer) in the deal with New England Patriots. Detroit later packaged pick 204 with pick 88 to move to No. 81 for Will Harris. The late-round asset therefore helped the Lions reach a substantially higher draft slot with longer roster utility. That outcome supports a B+ for Detroit Lions. The Detroit Lions Win verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Indianapolis and New England swapped former high draft picks at roster cuts in 2017, with Jacoby Brissett going to the Colts and Phillip Dorsett to the Patriots. Brissett became Indianapolis' emergency starter almost immediately and ultimately made 30 starts across four seasons. Dorsett contributed as a rotational receiver for three New England seasons and earned a Super Bowl LIII ring, but Brissett delivered the larger team-specific role.

Baltimore Ravens Baltimore acquired Luke Bowanko for veteran offensive-line depth in 2017. His role was limited, but he supplied immediate roster utility to a team seeking interior line options. The supported hindsight grade is B-. That mark weighs only value tied directly to this transaction and keeps the result proportional to the deal's cost. Against Jacksonville Jaguars, the final verdict is Even Trade.

New York acquired Ross Cockrell for a 2018 seventh-round pick and immediately received starting-caliber cornerback play. Cockrell appeared in all 16 games, started nine, intercepted three passes, and broke up 11 in 2017. Pittsburgh later packaged the No. 220 pick with No. 79 to move up to No. 76, where it drafted Mason Rudolph. The pick had real trade-up utility, but Rudolph's entire career cannot be credited solely to that seventh-rounder, leaving the Giants with the clearer direct return.

Pittsburgh sent Sammie Coates and a 2019 seventh-round pick to Cleveland on September 2, 2017 for Cleveland's 2018 sixth-round pick, the same selection Pittsburgh had previously sent away in the Justin Gilbert deal. Coates produced only 70 receiving yards for Cleveland in 2017, while the exchanged draft choices were later moved again before other clubs used them.

Kansas City sent offensive tackle Isaiah Battle to Seattle at the 2017 roster deadline for a conditional 2018 seventh-round pick. The condition was not met, so the Chiefs did not receive the selection. Battle never produced regular-season value for Seattle and was waived on November 1, leaving Kansas City with no return but no meaningful lost production.

Seattle sent defensive end Cassius Marsh to New England on September 2, 2017 for 2018 fifth- and seventh-round picks. The fifth became tackle Jamarco Jones, while Seattle later included the seventh, No. 250, in the Michael Bennett trade with Philadelphia. Marsh lasted only nine games with New England before being waived in November, giving Seattle both the longer-lived asset value and the cleaner result.

Los Angeles Rams received Derek Carrier from Washington Commanders. The Rams received Derek Carrier and used him in a modest tight end role for one season. He provided real but limited short-term service after the exchange. That outcome supports a C grade for Los Angeles Rams. The final verdict is Even Trade, based on the football value the club actually realized from the assets it controlled after the exchange.

Arizona traded offensive lineman Tony Bergstrom to Baltimore in September 2017 for a conditional 2018 seventh-round pick. The condition was not met, so no draft selection ultimately moved to the Cardinals. Bergstrom appeared in four games for Baltimore before being released later that season. The deal therefore produced little lasting value for either club, and the historical record should preserve the conditional right without falsely treating pick No. 238 as conveyed.

Atlanta acquired Ty Sambrailo for a 2018 fifth-round pick and received enough utility to sign him to a three-year extension in 2019. Denver recovered No. 163 overall and later used that selection as part of the package for Su’a Cravens rather than making the pick itself. Both clubs turned an expendable asset into practical roster value, making the exchange much closer to even than the original Denver-win grade suggested.

New York Jets received Jermaine Kearse, 2018 2nd round pick (49th overall subsequently traded, Dallas Goedert), 2018 7th round pick (235th overall subsequently traded, Zaire Franklin) in the 2017-09-01 exchange with Seattle Seahawks. Seattle acquired Sheldon Richardson and a seventh-round choice from the Jets for Jermaine Kearse, a 2018 second-round choice and a 2018 seventh-round choice. The supported outcome gives New York Jets a B grade. The overall verdict is New York Jets Win, based on the direct football and draft value actually realized after the trade.

San Francisco acquired guard Laken Tomlinson from Detroit for a 2019 fifth-round pick and received five seasons of durable starting line play. Tomlinson started 80 regular-season games for the 49ers, helped the club reach Super Bowl LIV and earned a Pro Bowl selection in 2021. Detroit later used the acquired fifth-round asset in the trade for Damon Harrison, so the Lions generated real value, but Tomlinson's sustained tenure was stronger.

Cleveland traded former first-round offensive lineman Cam Erving to Kansas City on August 30, 2017 for a 2018 fifth-round pick. That selection became No. 159 and was later included in the Browns' Danny Shelton trade with New England rather than used directly by Cleveland. The Browns recovered movable draft value from a player who had not justified his original draft status.

Cincinnati traded linebacker Marquis Flowers to New England at the end of the 2017 preseason for a 2018 seventh-round pick. Flowers immediately became a useful Patriots reserve, playing all 16 games and recording 3.5 sacks before contributing during the team's run to Super Bowl LII. Cincinnati used pick No. 249 on quarterback Logan Woodside, but he never appeared in a regular-season game for the Bengals.

Kansas City acquired Reggie Ragland from Buffalo for a 2019 fourth-round pick. Ragland became a regular Chiefs linebacker, starting 32 games over three seasons and remaining on the roster for the Super Bowl LIV championship year. Buffalo later packaged the acquired No. 131 selection with pick No. 112 to move up for Dawson Knox, who became a long-term starting tight end and Pro Bowler. Both sides created meaningful value.

Indianapolis chose Luke Rhodes as its long snapper and dealt Thomas Hennessy to New York for safety Ronald Martin. Martin was waived at final cuts, later returned to the Colts' practice squad and never became a meaningful Indianapolis regular. Hennessy, by contrast, won the Jets' snapping job and remained a fixture for years, turning a fringe-roster exchange into a quietly excellent New York acquisition.

Philadelphia acquired cornerback Dexter McDougle from the Jets on August 27, 2017 for safety Terrence Brooks. McDougle appeared in eight regular-season games for the Eagles in 2017 and two more in 2018, with one start and no interceptions.

Pittsburgh Steelers received Dashaun Phillips in the exchange with Washington. Its C grade reflects the practical value of that return relative to the package surrendered and the hindsight result. The grade remains tied to documented value for the acquiring club, without assigning credit for unresolved or hypothetical downstream consideration.

Los Angeles added Sammy Watkins and the sixth-round pick that became Sebastian Joseph-Day, while Buffalo received cornerback E.J. Gaines and a 2018 second-rounder. Watkins supplied eight touchdowns during the Rams' 2017 turnaround, and Joseph-Day later became a multi-year starter. Buffalo got one useful season from Gaines and then used the second-round pick as part of the package that moved up for Josh Allen.

Philadelphia acquired Ronald Darby for Jordan Matthews and a 2018 third-round pick that Buffalo used on Harrison Phillips. Darby returned from an early ankle injury to start seven regular-season games and all three postseason games for the Super Bowl LII champions. Phillips became a useful Bills defensive tackle, while Matthews lasted only one season in Buffalo. The championship contribution gives Philadelphia the stronger result.

Buffalo Bills received conditional 2019 seventh-round pick (not conveyed) from Los Angeles Chargers. Buffalo's return was a conditional 2019 seventh-round choice, but the condition was not met and no pick was conveyed. The Bills therefore received no usable draft asset from the exchange. That outcome supports a D grade for Buffalo Bills. The final verdict is Even Trade, based on the football value the club actually realized from the assets it controlled after the exchange.

Denver Broncos acquired veteran lineman Allen Barbre from Philadelphia for a conditional 2019 late-round pick that ultimately traced to No. 222. Barbre supplied experienced line depth, but the return was limited and short-term. Because Philadelphia was preparing to move on from him and still recovered a draft asset, Denver's side is respectable but weaker, meriting a C.

Detroit Lions received Greg Robinson in the exchange with Los Angeles Rams. Robinson played six games for Detroit in 2017 before an injury ended his season. The Lions received emergency tackle help, but the contribution was brief and did not become a longer-term answer. The D+ grade reflects the direct value Detroit Lions realized from the deal, while the Los Angeles Rams Win call weighs actual regular-season service and clearly connected draft value rather than name recognition alone.

New York received DeMario Davis; Cleveland received Calvin Pryor. The Jets reacquired DeMario Davis for Calvin Pryor in June 2017. Davis immediately returned to a full-time role in New York, while Cleveland released Pryor before the regular season after a short and unsuccessful stay. The hindsight grades are D for Cleveland Browns and A for New York Jets, producing a New York Jets Win verdict.

New York moved up seven spots in the sixth round on April 29, 2017, sending picks No. 207 and No. 241 to Tennessee for No. 200. The Giants selected Pittsburgh tackle Adam Bisnowaty, who spent most of his rookie season on the practice squad and made one NFL regular-season appearance and start for New York. The trade-up therefore produced only a one-game on-field return before Bisnowaty left the organization in 2018.

Cleveland Browns received 2017 5th round pick (160th overall, Roderick Johnson), 2017 7th round pick (224th overall, Zane Gonzalez) from New York Jets in the 2017-04-29 trade. Cleveland's package became Roderick Johnson and Zane Gonzalez. New York Jets's return was 2017 5th round pick (181st overall, Dylan Donahue), 2017 6th round pick (188th overall, Elijah McGuire). The Jets' return became Dylan Donahue and Elijah McGuire. Those realized outcomes, rather than the labels on the assets alone, drive the hindsight grade.

Dallas spent a future fifth-round pick to move back into the 2017 draft and select safety Xavier Woods at No. 191. Woods became a four-year Dallas contributor with 60 games, 48 starts and five interceptions. New York later recycled the No. 157 pick through two draft-day trades that produced Folorunso Fatukasi and Trenton Cannon, giving the Jets useful value but not quite the same immediate return.

Denver Broncos received 2018 4th round pick (109th overall subsequently traded, Troy Apke) in the 2017-04-29 exchange, while San Francisco 49ers received Kapri Bibbs and 2017 5th round pick (177th overall, Trent Taylor). Denver received a 2018 fourth-round selection that settled at No. 109 and later became part of another trade chain. That future draft capital gave the Broncos flexibility and enough retained value to support a small edge.

Cleveland Browns received 2017 4th round pick (126th overall, Howard Wilson) and 2017 7th round pick (252nd overall, Matthew Dayes) from Denver Broncos, sending 2017 5th round pick (145th overall, Jake Butt) and 2017 5th round pick (175th overall subsequently traded, DeAngelo Yancey) the other way. With no durable impact gap large enough to separate the sides, an even mid-level grade is the most supportable verdict. That outcome supports a C grade for Cleveland Browns, and the overall verdict is Even Trade.

Denver Broncos received 2017 5th round pick (172nd overall, Isaiah McKenzie) from Green Bay Packers, sending 2017 5th round pick (175th overall, DeAngelo Yancey) and 2017 7th round pick (238th overall, Devante Mays) the other way. Judging only the original clubs, Denver receives a narrow low-end win. That outcome supports a C+ grade for Denver Broncos, and the overall verdict is Denver Broncos Win.

Miami received picks No. 164 and No. 194 from Philadelphia in the 2017 draft, using them on Isaac Asiata and Vincent Taylor. The Eagles received No. 166 and No. 184, selecting Shelton Gibson and Nathan Gerry. Taylor became a useful rotational defensive tackle for Miami, but Gerry developed into a multi-year linebacker starter in Philadelphia. The Eagles' side produced the slightly stronger combined team-specific return.

Miami moved down fourteen spots in the 2017 seventh round, giving Tampa Bay pick No. 223 for No. 237 and a 2018 seventh-round choice. The Dolphins selected Isaiah Ford, who eventually produced 63 NFL receptions and 681 yards, mostly with Miami. Tampa Bay chose defensive tackle Stevie Tu'ikolovatu, who never appeared in a regular-season game, leaving Miami with the clearly better realized return.

Minnesota traded pick No. 139 to Kansas City for picks No. 170 and No. 180 in the 2017 draft. The Vikings selected receiver Rodney Adams and guard Danny Isidora, while the Chiefs chose receiver Jehu Chesson. Adams made little impact, but Isidora appeared in 21 games for Minnesota and made several starts. Chesson caught only two passes for Kansas City before his tenure ended, giving Minnesota the better modest return.

Minnesota moved down two spots late in the 2017 sixth round and also changed seventh-round positions, landing Bucky Hodges at No. 201 and Ifeadi Odenigbo at No. 220. Washington used No. 199 on center Chase Roullier and No. 230 on Josh Harvey-Clemons. Roullier’s long run as a starting center gives Washington the stronger return.

Philadelphia moved from No. 139 to No. 132 in the 2017 fourth round and selected running back Donnel Pumphrey, sending Minnesota No. 139 and No. 230. Pumphrey never appeared in a regular-season game for the Eagles. Minnesota kept trading those selections and eventually turned the chain into several players, including defensive end Ifeadi Odenigbo, who became a productive Vikings rotational pass rusher and 15-game starter in 2020.

Dallas Cowboys received 2017 6th round pick (216th overall, Marquez White); 2017 7th round pick (239th overall, Noah Brown) in the 2017-04-29 exchange with New England Patriots. Noah Brown developed into a long-running NFL receiver with significant starting work and more than 2,000 career receiving yards, creating the clearest value in Dallas' two-pick return. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Dallas Cowboys surrendered, the result supports Dallas Cowboys Win and a B grade for Dallas Cowboys.

Philadelphia received Nos. 164 and 214. The Eagles later moved No. 164 again, so Isaac Asiata belongs to the subsequent transaction chain rather than this return, while Elijah Qualls appeared in only six games for Philadelphia. The package retained draft flexibility, but the direct realized football value was limited and did not approach the sustained defensive production Tennessee obtained.

Arizona Cardinals received 2017 6th round pick (208th overall, Rudy Ford) in the 2017-04-29 exchange with Las Vegas Raiders. Rudy Ford developed into a durable NFL safety and special-teams contributor, giving Arizona real multi-season value from the move down. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Arizona Cardinals surrendered, the result supports Arizona Cardinals Win and a B- grade for Arizona Cardinals.

Los Angeles moved down five spots in the fourth round on April 29, 2017, sending No. 112 to Chicago for Nos. 117 and 197. The Rams selected wide receiver Josh Reynolds at No. 117; over four Los Angeles seasons he played 64 regular-season games with 24 starts, catching 113 passes for 1,450 yards and nine touchdowns. The Rams then combined No. 197 with their own No. 141 to move up for linebacker Samson Ebukam, so the sixth-rounder also retained trade value without being solely responsible for Ebukam's acquisition.

Los Angeles traded up 16 spots in the fourth round on April 29, 2017, sending New York picks No. 141 and No. 197 for No. 125. The Rams selected Eastern Washington edge defender Samson Ebukam, who played all 64 regular-season games over four Los Angeles seasons, starting 35 and recording 14 sacks, six passes defended, an interception returned for a touchdown and six forced fumbles. The move produced a durable defensive contributor and clear multi-year value.

San Francisco traded up with Indianapolis on April 29, 2017, sending picks No. 143 and No. 161 to the Colts for No. 121. The 49ers used No. 121 on running back Joe Williams, who spent his rookie season on injured reserve and never appeared in a San Francisco regular-season game. Indianapolis used the return on Marlon Mack and Anthony Walker Jr., both of whom became multi-year starters and productive contributors.

Tennessee moved down from No. 200 to Nos. 207 and 241, then immediately flipped No. 207 to Cincinnati for Nos. 217 and 227. The downstream package produced Corey Levin, Josh Carraway and Khalfani Muhammad, with Levin becoming the durable return.

Tennessee traded No. 207 to Cincinnati for Nos. 217 and 227, selecting Corey Levin and Josh Carraway. Levin ultimately logged 88 regular-season games and seven starts for the Titans through 2025, while Carraway appeared in one game.

Buffalo sent picks No. 75, No. 149 and No. 156 to Atlanta to move up to No. 63 for offensive tackle Dion Dawkins. The Falcons selected Duke Riley, Damontae Kazee and Brian Hill, receiving useful contributions from Kazee and rotational work from the others. Dawkins became a long-term Bills starter, team leader and five-time Pro Bowler, making him the clear best player produced by the exchange.

Buffalo moved up from No. 44 to No. 37 in the 2017 second round and selected receiver Zay Jones, also receiving pick No. 149. The Rams turned the return into tight end Gerald Everett at No. 44 and safety John Johnson III at No. 91. Jones had a productive 2018 season in Buffalo, but Los Angeles received two multi-year contributors from the trade and ultimately created the stronger direct return.

Carolina paid picks No. 98 and No. 115 to Arizona to move up to No. 77 for defensive end Daeshon Hall. Hall appeared in only one regular-season game for the Panthers before injuries derailed his rookie year and his Carolina tenure ended. Arizona turned the two incoming choices into wide receiver Chad Williams and guard Dorian Johnson, giving the Cardinals more realized roster value from the exchange.

Arizona moved up to 2017 second-round No. 36 for Budda Baker and also received No. 221 Shalom Luani, sending Chicago Nos. 45, 119 and 197 plus a 2018 fourth-round pick. Chicago gained several chances and landed Tarik Cohen among them, but Baker became a perennial Pro Bowl safety, giving Arizona the transaction's highest-value outcome.

Kansas City sent tight end James O'Shaughnessy and pick No. 216 to New England for pick No. 183 in 2017, then selected linebacker Ukeme Eligwe. Eligwe appeared in 14 games with one start as a Chiefs rookie and recorded a sack. New England waived O'Shaughnessy and Conor McDermott, the player it later moved up to select with the pick path involving No. 216, before either played a regular-season snap for the Patriots.

Kansas City sent picks No. 104, 132 and 245 to Minnesota to jump to No. 86 for Kareem Hunt. Hunt immediately led the NFL with 1,327 rushing yards as a rookie and remained an explosive offensive weapon until the Chiefs released him during the 2018 season. Minnesota repeatedly traded the return and ultimately produced players including Jaleel Johnson, Stacy Coley, Rodney Adams, Danny Isidora and Jack Tocho, none matching Hunt’s peak impact.

Minnesota moved from No. 48 to No. 41 in the 2017 second round for Dalvin Cook, sending Cincinnati pick No. 48 and No. 128. Cook became a four-time Pro Bowler and one of the Vikings' most productive modern running backs. Cincinnati selected Joe Mixon at No. 48, and Mixon produced seven strong seasons, a Pro Bowl campaign and major postseason contributions. Both teams found foundational offensive value.

Minnesota traded picks No. 79 and No. 160 to the Jets for No. 70, then selected center Pat Elflein. Elflein became an immediate starter, earned PFWA All-Rookie honors and started 43 games for the Vikings across four seasons. New York selected ArDarius Stewart at No. 79 and later moved the fifth-round asset through additional trades, but its resulting players did not match the sustained starting value Minnesota received.

San Francisco sent picks No. 109 and No. 219 to Minnesota to move back into the 2017 third round for quarterback C.J. Beathard. Beathard made 12 starts and provided several seasons of backup value for the 49ers. Minnesota selected defensive tackle Jaleel Johnson and receiver Stacy Coley; Johnson became a four-year rotational lineman with 20 starts. Neither side found a star, but both received useful depth.

Tennessee moved up to No. 72 in the 2017 draft and also received pick No. 200, sending New England picks No. 83 and No. 124. The Titans selected receiver Taywan Taylor at No. 72, and he produced 53 catches for 697 yards and two touchdowns over his Tennessee tenure. New England chose Derek Rivers at No. 83 and later used No. 124 in another trade, but received little direct on-field value.

New England moved up to No. 85 in the 2017 draft for tackle Antonio Garcia, sending Detroit picks No. 96 and No. 124. Garcia never appeared in a regular-season game for the Patriots. Detroit used the selections on Kenny Golladay and Jalen Reeves-Maybin. Golladay became a Pro Bowl receiver and league touchdown leader, while Reeves-Maybin developed into a long-tenured linebacker and elite special-teams contributor.

New Orleans sent pick No. 229 and a 2018 second-rounder to San Francisco for pick No. 67, then selected Alvin Kamara. Kamara became one of the defining players of the Saints' modern era, earning five straight Pro Bowls to begin his career and setting major franchise rushing marks. San Francisco found some value in Adrian Colbert and later draft maneuvering, but nothing close to Kamara's impact.

Tampa Bay sent picks No. 125 and 204 to the Jets to move up to No. 107 for linebacker Kendell Beckwith. Beckwith started nine games and made 73 tackles as a promising rookie, but a serious ankle injury suffered in a 2018 auto accident ultimately ended his NFL career. New York moved No. 125 again and selected Chad Hansen, Jeremy Clark and Derrick Jones from the resulting capital, receiving little lasting value.

Kansas City's trade up for Patrick Mahomes became one of the most important draft moves in NFL history. The Chiefs paid a first-round pick, a third-round pick, and a future first to move up for their quarterback. Buffalo received real assets, but Kansas City acquired the player who launched a dynasty. Buffalo received useful assets, but Kansas City acquired the defining quarterback of the era.

Houston traded up from No. 25 to No. 12 in 2017 for quarterback Deshaun Watson, sending Cleveland the 25th pick plus its 2018 first-rounder. Cleveland turned those selections into Jabrill Peppers and Denzel Ward, with Ward becoming a perennial Pro Bowl cornerback. Watson became a three-time Pro Bowler in Houston, led the NFL in passing yards in 2020, and later generated an enormous trade return for the Texans.

Cleveland moved up for David Njoku and landed the best player in the transaction. Njoku developed into a long-term Browns starter, a Pro Bowl tight end, and one of the club's most dependable offensive pieces. His sustained receiving production, red-zone value, and years of starting service gave Cleveland exactly the kind of payoff teams seek when sacrificing multiple selections to climb into the first round.

Seattle moved out of pick No. 26 and received Nos. 31, 95 and 249 from Atlanta. The Seahawks kept moving No. 31, eventually building a branch that included Malik McDowell, while No. 95 became Delano Hill and No. 249 became Chris Carson. Carson delivered two 1,100-yard rushing seasons and 3,502 career rushing yards. Atlanta got Takk McKinley, a productive but short-lived pass rusher before waiving him in 2020.

San Francisco moved from No. 34 to No. 31 and selected Reuben Foster. Foster flashed starter-level talent but his 49ers tenure ended after two seasons and did not become the durable linebacker cornerstone the move-up was designed to secure. The 49ers therefore received real short-term ability without enough longevity to justify the concentrated draft investment.

San Francisco moved down only one spot in the 2017 draft and collected Chicago’s third- and fourth-round picks plus a 2018 third-rounder. The 49ers still selected Solomon Thomas at No. 3, while later value from the package connected directly to Fred Warner. Thomas never met his draft billing, but gaining multiple selections for allowing Chicago to move from third to second gave San Francisco a substantial value advantage.

Oakland brought Marshawn Lynch out of retirement and received Seattle's 2018 sixth-round pick while sending back a fifth-rounder. Lynch gave his hometown Raiders 1,267 rushing yards and 10 touchdowns over 21 games. Seattle used the fifth-round pick on cornerback Tre Flowers, who became a multi-year starter. Both clubs received exactly the kind of useful, medium-term value they were seeking, making the exchange remarkably balanced.

Carolina moved down only eight spots, sending Kony Ealy and pick No. 72 to New England for pick No. 64. The Panthers used No. 64 on Taylor Moton, who became a durable long-term starting right tackle. New England released Ealy before the 2017 season and later traded pick No. 72. The Panthers turned a modest move up the board into one of the franchise's most dependable offensive linemen.

New Orleans sent Brandin Cooks and a fourth-round pick to New England for the final first-round pick and a third-rounder. The Saints drafted Ryan Ramczyk and Trey Hendrickson, landing an All-Pro right tackle and a pass rusher who broke out with 13.5 sacks in 2020. New England still received 1,082 yards from Cooks and later flipped him for a first-round pick, making this a strong transaction for both clubs.

Cleveland Browns received Brock Osweiler; 2017 6th round pick (188th overall; subsequently traded by Cleveland); 2018 2nd round pick (35th overall, Nick Chubb) in the 2017-03-09 exchange with Houston Texans. Cleveland absorbed Brock Osweiler's contract and gained premium draft capital, most importantly the 2018 second-round pick used on Nick Chubb. Chubb's elite production transformed the return. The direct return and the football value it produced drive the hindsight judgment. Against the assets Cleveland Browns surrendered, the result supports Cleveland Browns Win and a A- grade for Cleveland Browns.

New England acquired tight end Dwayne Allen and pick No. 200 from Indianapolis for the 137th pick in the 2017 draft. Allen spent two seasons with the Patriots, appearing in 29 regular-season games and serving primarily as a blocking tight end on teams that reached consecutive Super Bowls and won Super Bowl LIII. Indianapolis selected Zach Banner at No. 137 but waived him before he played a regular-season game for the Colts.

Miami moved down only 17 draft slots, sending No. 206 to Los Angeles for veteran defensive end William Hayes and No. 223. Hayes gave the Dolphins useful rotational work across 13 games over two seasons, while Miami later recycled No. 223 into additional draft capital. The Rams used No. 206 on Sam Rogers, whose NFL impact was minimal, leaving Miami with the better return.

Jacksonville Jaguars received Branden Albert from Miami Dolphins, sending conditional 2018 pick (not conveyed) the other way. The current not-conveyed treatment therefore captures the realized transaction correctly. That outcome supports a C- grade for Jacksonville Jaguars, and the overall verdict is Even Trade. The grade stays proportional to the size of the exchange and the direct value created for the original club.

Detroit acquired Johnthan Banks from Tampa Bay for a conditional 2018 seventh-round pick in November 2016, and the condition was not met, so the pick was never conveyed. Banks appeared in only two games for the Lions before being waived, which limits the upside. Still, Detroit received a no-cost roster look while Tampa Bay ultimately received no draft asset, giving the Lions a small but real win.

New England traded Jamie Collins during a championship season rather than carry an approaching free-agent negotiation into the offseason. The Patriots received a 2017 third-round selection and proved they could absorb the football loss, winning Super Bowl LI without him. Collins was a talented and versatile defender, so the move looked risky in real time. In hindsight, New England converted an expiring asset into draft value without damaging its title run.

Denver Broncos received A.J. Derby. Denver received tight end A.J. Derby and used him as an immediate offensive piece after the October 2016 trade. Derby gave the Broncos some short-term receiving value, but he did not become a long-term core player. Denver surrendered a future fifth-round choice, so the direct return was useful without becoming especially valuable in hindsight. That result supports a C+ grade for Denver Broncos.

Detroit traded Kyle Van Noy and a 2017 seventh-round pick to New England for a 2017 sixth-rounder that became Brad Kaaya. Van Noy quickly found a larger role in the Patriots defense, became a multi-year starter and contributed to championship teams. Kaaya never became a Detroit solution, and the Lions received essentially no lasting return. New England's acquisition became a textbook fit-and-development success.

Green Bay acquired Knile Davis for a conditional 2018 pick, but the experiment lasted only two games. Davis carried five times for five yards and caught two passes for four yards before the Packers waived him on October 31. The compensation conditions were not met, so Kansas City received no draft choice. Green Bay therefore gained nine yards of offense at no draft-capital cost, a narrow win rather than the stronger result implied by the old generic copy.

Philadelphia moved Eric Rowe after one season and recovered a 2018 fourth-round pick for a cornerback who had fallen down the new coaching staff's depth chart. The return was respectable for a player whose Eagles role had evaporated. Rowe's immediate usefulness in New England, though, including seven regular-season starts during a Super Bowl championship season, makes the Patriots the better side in hindsight.

Kansas City sent Rod Streater to San Francisco in 2016 and ultimately received the 2019 seventh-round selection at No. 216, used on guard Nick Allegretti. Allegretti became an excellent late-round return, appearing in 74 games with 13 starts for Kansas City from 2019 through 2023 and contributing to three Super Bowl championship teams. The long-term line depth easily surpassed Streater's brief 49ers production.

Philadelphia converted Sam Bradford into a 2017 first-round pick and a 2018 fourth-round pick while clearing the starting job for Carson Wentz. Those selections became Derek Barnett and Josh Sweat, two defensive contributors to the franchise's championship-era rosters. Because Bradford was no longer central to Philadelphia's plan, turning him into premium draft capital was outstanding asset management and gave the Eagles both immediate roster clarity and long-term value.

Seattle acquired safety and special-teams defender Dewey McDonald from Oakland on September 3, 2016, for a 2017 seventh-round selection that became No. 244 overall and Treyvon Hester. McDonald appeared in fourteen games for Seattle in 2016 and three more in 2017. That was legitimate depth value, but not enough to overwhelm the low-cost player Oakland later drafted.

Arizona sent Kansas City a conditional 2018 seventh-round pick for cornerback Marcus Cooper just before the 2016 season. Cooper started 13 games, intercepted four passes and returned one for a touchdown, giving the Cardinals immediate secondary value. Kansas City eventually received No. 233 and packaged it with another seventh-rounder to move up for Kahlil McKenzie. The Chiefs preserved some value, but Arizona got the stronger direct return.

Cleveland Browns received 2018 6th round pick (202nd overall subsequently traded, Jack Cichy) from Pittsburgh Steelers, giving up Justin Gilbert. Gilbert provided very limited value in Pittsburgh, while Cleveland kept the future pick. The return supports a B grade because the value directly tied to this deal fits that mark. The final verdict is Cleveland Browns Win.

Buffalo Bills received Lerentee McCray from Green Bay Packers. Buffalo received Lerentee McCray and used him for one season in reserve and special-teams work. The Bills received immediate roster depth but only a short tenure. That outcome supports a C grade for Buffalo Bills. The final verdict is Green Bay Packers Win, based on the football value the club actually realized from the assets it controlled after the exchange.

New Orleans acquired Chris McCain from Miami for a conditional 2017 seventh-round pick that did not convey. McCain appeared in only two games for the Saints, recording one tackle and no sacks before New Orleans waived him in November. Miami therefore received no draft asset, while the Saints received only brief depth service. New Orleans still holds the narrow hindsight edge because two regular-season appearances are more than the Dolphins realized, but the original B-range framing is too generous.

Carolina acquired veteran punter Andy Lee and a 2017 seventh-round pick for Kasey Redfern and a 2018 fourth. Lee punted well but lasted only nine games before a hamstring injury ended his season, and Carolina released him the next year. The seventh became Harrison Butker, whom the Panthers waived before his NFL success elsewhere, leaving only a short-lived return.

Detroit Lions received Brandon Thomas in the 2016-08-29 exchange with San Francisco 49ers. Brandon Thomas did not deliver comparable regular-season value for Detroit after the straight player swap. The direct package is the basis for the hindsight grade, with later movement of an acquired selection treated separately. That supports San Francisco 49ers Win.

Kansas City acquired cornerback Kenneth Acker from San Francisco on August 27, 2016 for a future seventh-round pick. Acker appeared in nine games for the Chiefs in 2016 and all 16 in 2017, intercepting one pass in his second Kansas City season. He provided useful secondary depth, but the Chiefs received only two seasons before his tenure ended.

Cleveland Browns received 2017 5th round pick (175th overall subsequently traded, DeAngelo Yancey) in the deal with New England Patriots. Cleveland later used pick 175 with another fifth-rounder to move up and also acquire a seventh-rounder. Matthew Dayes then gave the Browns a full season of return and special-teams work. That outcome supports a C+ for Cleveland Browns. The Even Trade verdict weighs documented games, starts, production and connected draft value.

Tennessee received Dennis Kelly; Philadelphia received Dorial Green-Beckham. Tennessee exchanged Dorial Green-Beckham for Dennis Kelly. Green-Beckham caught 36 passes for 392 yards and two touchdowns in his lone Philadelphia season, while Kelly became a multi-year Titans lineman and eventually a 16-game starter. The hindsight grades are C- for Philadelphia Eagles and B+ for Tennessee Titans, producing a Tennessee Titans Win verdict.

Cleveland moved down from No. 100 to No. 114 in the 2016 draft and added No. 154 from Oakland. The Browns used those picks on wide receivers Ricardo Louis and Jordan Payton. Louis gave Cleveland 32 games, 12 starts, 45 receptions and 562 yards over two seasons; Payton appeared in four games. That modest two-player return still exceeded the regular-season value Oakland realized from Connor Cook.

Denver and Tennessee reshuffled late-round draft capital in 2016, with the Broncos receiving No. 176 and a 2017 sixth while the Titans received Nos. 157 and 253. Denver turned No. 176 into fullback Andy Janovich, a useful four-year contributor, while Tennessee used No. 157 on cornerback LeShaun Sims, who played 56 games and made 11 starts for the Titans. The realized value is remarkably balanced.

Miami sent cornerback Jamar Taylor and a late seventh-round pick to Cleveland for a slightly earlier seventh-round selection. The exact pick numbering differs across historical draft references because of forfeited-pick accounting, but the substance is simple: Cleveland acquired Taylor for almost no draft cost. He started 14 games and intercepted three passes in his first Browns season, while Miami gained little from the pick swap.

Miami moved back ten spots in the sixth round and added Jakeem Grant at No. 186, sending Minnesota No. 196 and No. 227. Grant became a dangerous return specialist and useful receiver for the Dolphins. Minnesota turned the two incoming choices into Stephen Weatherly plus part of the package used to move up for tight end David Morgan.

Miami sent No. 147 to New England for Nos. 196, 204 and 250. The Dolphins used No. 204 on Jordan Lucas and recycled the other choices through later moves, including a separate trade that helped them reach Jakeem Grant. New England immediately packaged No. 147 with No. 243 to Seattle and ultimately obtained the future fourth-round pick used on Deatrich Wise Jr., a long-term Patriots defender. New England's downstream return lasted longer.

Minnesota sent Philadelphia picks No. 196 and No. 240 in the 2016 draft to move up to No. 188 for tight end David Morgan. The Eagles selected Blake Countess and Alex McCalister. Morgan played 38 NFL games and became a useful run-game tight end for the Vikings, giving Minnesota the best direct return in the exchange.

New York gave Washington a 2017 fourth-round pick to acquire No. 158 in 2016 and drafted tackle Brandon Shell. Shell became a four-year Jets contributor with 40 starts. Washington used the future pick on Samaje Perine, who rushed for 603 yards as a rookie but had a much smaller role the next season. Perine had value, but New York received more sustained starting production.

the Rams received 2016 4th round pick (117th overall, Pharoh Cooper), 2016 6th round pick (206th overall, Mike Thomas), while Chicago received 2016 4th round pick (113th overall, Nick Kwiatkoski). The hindsight grades are C for the Rams and B for Chicago. The verdict is grounded in the actual starts, production, tenure and downstream draft results produced by those assets.

New England Patriots received 2016 7th round pick (225th overall, Devin Lucien) and 2017 4th round pick (131st overall, Deatrich Wise) in the 2016-04-30 exchange with Seattle Seahawks. Deatrich Wise developed into a long-tenured Patriots defensive lineman with substantial games, sacks and championship-era value. That gives New England Patriots the stronger overall return.

New Orleans sent No. 152 and a 2017 fifth-rounder to Washington for No. 120 and selected David Onyemata. He became a seven-season Saints defensive-line fixture with more than 100 appearances. Washington used the incoming picks on Matthew Ioannidis and Jeremy Sprinkle; Ioannidis developed into a productive interior pass rusher and Sprinkle supplied several years of tight-end depth. Both teams turned modest capital into real contributors.

Atlanta moved down two spots from No. 50 to No. 52 and added Houston's sixth-round pick at No. 195. The Falcons selected linebacker Deion Jones and guard Wes Schweitzer, turning the modest slide into two future starters. Jones became a Pro Bowl defender and a central piece of Atlanta's 2016 Super Bowl team, while Schweitzer developed into a multi-year starter. Houston used No. 50 on center Nick Martin, a solid long-term starter, but Atlanta created more total value.

Buffalo moved up eight spots for Reggie Ragland, sending Chicago No. 49, No. 117 and a 2017 fourth-rounder. Ragland tore his ACL before his rookie season and was traded to Kansas City a year later. Chicago repeatedly moved the acquired picks, with the return helping produce Cody Whitehair, Deon Bush, Nick Kwiatkoski and Eddie Jackson. That depth of value overwhelms Buffalo's brief ownership of Ragland.

Carolina moved up from No. 93 to No. 77 in the 2016 third round and also received pick No. 141, selecting Daryl Worley and Zack Sanchez. Worley became a two-year starter for the Panthers before leaving in 2018, while Sanchez had a small role. The package produced useful but limited value, matching Cleveland's modest return closely enough to keep the deal balanced.